Introduction
Methods
Results
Case | Reference | Age (y) | In-hospital (I) 14 Prehospital (P) 8 | Rhythm when resuscitation abandoned | Duration of resuscitation (min) | Signs of life first noticed (min) | Delay before death (s,h,d,m) | CPC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
56 ± 24 (range 0.9–84) | Asystole 12 (55%); VF 4 (18%); PEA 3 (14%); Not stated 3 (14%) | 30 (IQR 25–47.5; range 5–75) | 5.5 (IQR 3.5–10; range 1–20) | CPC 1–2 | ||||
1) | [2] | 68 | I | VF | 75 | 20 | – | 1 |
2) | [34] | 67 | I | “Abnormal” | 30 | 4 | – | 1 |
3) | [35] | 81 | I | Asystole | 5 | 2 | f | 1 |
4) | [36] | 50 | I | Asystole | 30 | 2 | 8 m | 1 |
5) | [59] | 36 | I | PEA | 25 | 3 | – | 1 |
6) | [60] | 84 | P | VF | 15 | 5 | – | 1 |
7) | [61] | 27 | P | Asystole | > 25a | 1 | – | 1 |
8) | [62] | 21 | I | Asystole | 30 | 10 | – | 1 |
9) | [63] | 80 | I | Asystole | 20 | 5 | – | 1 |
10) | [64] | 66 | I | Asystole | 18 | 10 | – | 1 |
11) | [65] | 66 | P | PEA | 45 | 5 | – | 1 |
12) | [66] | 83 | I | NS | 60 | 7 | – | 1 |
13) | [67] | 70 | I | Asystole | 34 | 8 | – | 1 |
14) | [23] | 66 | P | VF | > 30a | NSb | – | 2 (right sided hemiparesis) |
15) | [23] | 71 | I | Asystole | 35 | NSb | – | 1 |
16) | [68] | 63 | P | Asystole | 70 | NS d | – | 1 |
17) | [69] | 51 | I | Asystole | 61 | 3.5 | – | 2 (R arm weakness and partial amnesia) |
18) | [70] | 54 | P | PEA | 50 | NSd | – | 1 |
19) | [71] | 69 | I | Asystole | 25 | 10 | e | 3/Hypoxic brain damage |
20) | [8] | 47 | P | VF | 26 | 15 | 3 m | 3/Hypoxic brain damage |
21) | [72] | 0.92 | I | Asystole | NSc | 15 | 6 weeks | 3/Died progressive cardiomyopathy |
22) | [73] | 1.5 | P | NS | NSa | 6 | – | 3/Severe disability at 1y |
Case | Reference | Age | In-hospital (I) 15Prehospital (P) 26 | Rhythm when resuscitation abandoned | Duration of resuscitation (min) | Signs of life first noticed (min) | Delay before death (s,h,d,m) | CPC (if available)/Outcome or Cause of death |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
64 ± 24 (range 0.75–97) | Asystole 26 (63%); PEA 9 (22%); VF 0 (0%); Not stated 6 (15%) | 30 (IQR 17–40; range 0–90) | 5 (IQR 2.5–10; range 0–220) | |||||
1) | [2] | 84 | P | Asystole | 17 | d | 6d | 3/Hypoxic brain damage |
2) | [2] | 67 | P | Asystole | 20 | c | 15d | 3/Hypoxic brain damage |
3) | [7] | 80 | I | Asystole | 30 | 5 | 2d | 3/Hypoxic brain damage |
4) | [10] | 65 | P | Asystole | 35 | 20 | 5d | 4/Hypoxic brain damage |
5) | [11] | 81 | P | Asystole | 13 | NSc | 20 h | 3/Cardiogenic shock |
6) | [13] | 65 | P | NS | 35 | 20 | 4d | 4/Myocardial infarction |
7) | [13] | 83 | P | Asystole | 23 | 33 | 6.5 h | 4/Myocardial infarction |
8) | [26] | 97 | P | Asystole | 16 | 3 | 2 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
9) | [26] | 30 | P | PEA | 31 | 6 | 88 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
10) | [26] | 63 | P | PEA | 12 | 3 | 26 h | Died without regaining consciousness |
11) | [26] | 91 | P | PEA | 16 | 3 | 15 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
12) | [26] | 61 | P | PEA | 18 | 8 | 3 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
13) | [37] | 53 | I | Asystole | 46 | 2 | 34d | 4/Died (multi-organ failure) |
14) | [74] | 89 | I | Asystole | 18 | 5 | 7 h | Died. Another cardiac event. |
15) | [24] | 0.75 | P | Asystole | NSd | 0.5 | Several days. | Died (WLST). |
16) | [24] | 3 | I | Asystole | 25 | 1 | 40 m | Died (WLST) |
17) | [75] | 64 | I | NS | 20 | 15 | 1 h | Died. Refractory hypotension. |
18) | [76] | 76 | I | Asystole | 30 | 5 | 24 h | 3/Died. Hypoxic brain damage. |
19) | [77] | 44 | P | PEA | 80 | 5 | NSe | 3/Palliative care only |
20) | [78] | 87 | I | Wide complexesg | 15 | Immediately | 12d | 4/Died |
21) | [79] | 63 | I | Asystole | 12 | 3 | 12d | Died. Sepsis. |
22) | [80] | 59 | I | NSb | 15 | 2 | 30 m | Died. |
23) | [81] | 67 | P | PEA | 55 | 2 | 22 h | 1/Died from severe comorbidity. |
24) | [82] | 10 | P | PEA | > 40f | 2 | Short time after | 5 (WLST) |
25) | [83] | 94 | I | PEA | 40 | 2.5 | 18d | 1/Died multi-organ failure |
26) | [84] | 65 | P | Asystole | 55 | 40 | 13d | Died without regaining consciousness |
27) | [85] | 35 | P | NS | 88 | NSc | 50 m | Died. Another cardiac event. |
28) | [86] | 83 | P | Asystole | 90 | 10 | 12d | Died. Pneumonia. |
29) | [87] | 85 | P | Asystole | 34 | 2 | 25 m | Died. Another cardiac event. |
30) | [88] | 62 | I | Idioventricular | 40 | 5 | 34 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
31) | [89] | 55 | P | Asystole | 30 | 7 | 3d | 5/Died. Hypoxic brain damage. |
32) | [25] | 63 | P | Asystole | 40 | 10 | 10 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
33) | [25] | 78 | P | Asystole | 41 | 2 | 20 m | Died without regaining consciousness |
34) | [90] | 78 | P | Asystole | 31 | 220 | 19 h | Died without regaining consciousness |
35) | [91] | 85 | P | Asystole | 0 | 6 | 48 h | 4/Died (WLST) |
36) | [92] | 69 | P | Asystole | 40 | 180 | 10d | Died without regaining consciousness |
37) | [93] | 46 | P | Asystole | 30 | 60 | NS (hours) | 2/Died from cardiogenic shock |
38) | [94] | 83 | I | Asystole | 15 | 10 | 2 h | Died without regaining consciousness |
39) | [95] | 25 | I | NS | 40 | 5–7 | 4 h | Died without regaining consciousness |
40) | [96] | 67 | I | Asystole | 49 | 5 | 9d | 1/Died of massive pulmonary embolism |
41) | [97] | 75 | I | Asystole | 23 | 5 | Several days | Died without regaining consciousness |
Case | Ref | Age | Rhythm when resuscitation abandoned | Duration of resuscitation (min) | Signs of life first noticed (min) | Delay before death | CPC (if available)/Outcome or cause of death |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1) | [98] | 93 | NS | 6 | 5 | NS | Outcome not stated |
2) | [99] | 40 | Asystole | 45 | 30 | NS | Outcome not stated |
Discussion
factor | Proposed Mechanism | Actions that might reduce the Likelihood of Autoresuscitation occurring |
---|---|---|
Poor controlled ventilation techniques | ||
1) Air trapping in the lungs causing hyperinflation | Caused by high tidal volume or rapid ventilation rates with insufficient time for exhalation. Releasing the positive intra-thoracic pressure will enable venous return to resume and restore the circulation [24, 38, 59, 64, 65, 74‐79, 86, 98, 100‐102]. Effect more pronounced in hypovolaemia [37, 64] and pre-existing obstructive airways disease, especially if not managed correctly [9, 59, 103]. | Avoid excessive ventilation (rate, tidal volume, or both) Exclude hyperinflation as a reversible cause of Pulseless Electrical Activity (PEA) by stopping ventilation and disconnecting the bag |
2) High intrathoracic pressure | ||
3) Hyperventilation | Deleterious effects on coronary perfusion pressure (CPP) [104]. | |
Delayed drug effects | ||
CPP as low as 15 mmHg can produce Return of Spontaneous Circulation after asystole | Intrinsic vasomotor function of capacitance and resistance blood vessels may maintain CPP so that even when resuscitation has ceased, CPP may be high enough to restart the heart [105]. | Careful consideration before terminating resuscitation if vasopressor infusions and/or mechanical ventilation are used |
Return of myocardial function following Termination of Resuscitation (TOR) | ||
Premature TOR | Failure to appreciate that transient asystole can occur immediately after defibrillation [23]. | Resuscitation should never be abandoned immediately after defibrillation. |
Resuscitation terminated prematurely before therapeutic measures could have adequate effect. | Careful consideration before terminating resuscitation especially if vasopressor infusions and/or mechanical ventilation are used. | |
Untreated reversible causes e.g. acid-base balance; electrolyte imbalance; hypothermia [68]. | Check for and correct all reversible causes of CA before considering TOR. | |
TOR in the presence of a potentially treatable cardiac rhythm (refractory VF, PEA, broad complexes, bradycardia) and not asystole. | Caution about which cardiac rhythms are acceptable for terminating resuscitation as in 30% of autoresuscitation cases, TOR had occurred in the presence of some cardiac electrical activity (i.e. not asystole) | |
TOR too soon after resuscitation started | Careful consideration of how long CPR has been employed before TOR | |
Procedural | Misdiagnosis of death, perhaps due to failure to fully examine patient prior to declaring death. | A 10 min observation period with ECG is generally more appropriate than 5 min following TOR [2, 7‐11, 14, 26, 60‐64, 66, 76, 79, 81, 94, 95, 106, 107]. After the decision has been made to terminate resuscitation, chest compressions should not be restarted The possibility of autoresuscitation should not affect the decision about when to terminate resuscitation |
Resuscitation may exacerbate acute internal bleeding leading to hypovolaemic arrest | When resuscitation is stopped, the cardiovascular system stabilises [36]. | Observe the patient after TOR for 10 min. |