Introduction
Basal Ganglia: Pain Processing
Basal Ganglia: Functional Imaging Studies of Pain in Humans
Study Type | Condition | Stimulus | C | Pu | NAc | GP | STN | SN | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Acute Pain
| |||||||||
Thermal Pain | Contact Heat | + |
+
| - |
+
|
+
| [45] | ||
Contact Heat | - | [142] | |||||||
Contact Heat | - | [58] | |||||||
Contact Heat |
+
| [143] | |||||||
Contact Heat | + | [144] | |||||||
Contact Heat | + | [145] | |||||||
Contact Heat | + |
+
| [146] | ||||||
Contact Heat |
+
| [47] | |||||||
Contact Heat |
+
| [147] | |||||||
Laser |
+
| [148] | |||||||
Cold | + | [49] | |||||||
Cold (Prickle) | + | [48] | |||||||
Electrical Pain | Current | + | [51] | ||||||
Current |
+
| [95] | |||||||
Electroacupuncture |
+
| [149] | |||||||
Pressure Pain | + |
+
|
+
| [150] | |||||
Capsaicin Sensitization | Punctate Mechanical |
+
| [91] | ||||||
Punctate Mechanical |
+
|
(+)
|
+
|
+
| [151] | ||||
Visceral Pain | Fundus Distention | + |
+
| [152] | |||||
Esophageal Distention | + |
+
| [143] | ||||||
Chronic Pain
| |||||||||
Neuropathic | Trigeminal (cold allodynia) | - |
+
| [56] | |||||
Trigeminal (mechanical allodynia) | - |
+
|
+
|
+
| [56] | ||||
Post Herpetic (spontaneous pain) |
+
|
(+)
| [153] | ||||||
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome | Pediatric | - | [70] | ||||||
Fibromyalgia | [154] | ||||||||
Pressure |
+
| [150] | |||||||
Catastrophising |
+
|
+
| [155] | ||||||
Back Pain |
+
| [156] | |||||||
Osteoarthritis |
+
| [156] | |||||||
Visceral | Irritable Bowel Syndrome | - |
+
| [157] | |||||
Empathy
| |||||||||
Visual | |||||||||
Pictures | + |
+
| [158] | ||||||
Pictures | + | [159] | |||||||
Virtual Pain (needles) |
+
| [160] | |||||||
Analgesics (phMRI)
| |||||||||
Opioid Agonists | Morphine |
+
|
+
|
+
| [58] | ||||
Remifentanil |
+
|
+
|
+
|
+
| [83] | ||||
Opioid Antagonists | Naloxone |
+
|
+
|
+
|
+
| [82] |
Study Type | Condition | Stimulus | C | Pu | NAc | GP | STN | SN | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Analgesic Effects on Pain
| |||||||||
Acute Pain | |||||||||
Capsaicin | Gabapentin |
(-)
| [91] | ||||||
Heat Pain | Naloxone |
+
|
+
| [82] |
Study Type | Condition | Receptor Binding | C | Pu | NAc | GP | STN | SN | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Acute Pain
| |||||||||
Thermal Pain | Contact Heat (15)O-water |
+
| [161] | ||||||
Contact Heat (15)O-water |
+
| [162] | |||||||
Contact Heat (15)O-water |
+
| [163] | |||||||
Contact Heat (Pain Threshold) | Dopamine receptor binding (11C) Raclopride | Binding - inverse correlation to Heat thershold | [133] | ||||||
Muscle Pain Hypertonic Saline | (15)O-water |
+
| [164] | ||||||
Dopamine Receptor Binding (11C) Raclopride | + | + | + | [135] | |||||
Visceral Pain | Gastric Distenton (15)O-water | + | [165] | ||||||
Placebo | |||||||||
Muscle Pain Hypertonic Saline | Opioid and Dopamine receptor binding Placebo (11C) Raclopride (11C) Carfentanil | Increased opioid and dopamine release | [65] | ||||||
Opioid and Dopamine receptor binding Placebo (11C) Raclopride (11C) Carfentanil | Decrease opioid and dopamine release | [65] | |||||||
Chronic Pain
| |||||||||
Neuropathic Pain (Burning Mouth) | 6-[(18)F]fluorodopa | Decreased presynaptic dopamine function | [72] | ||||||
Neuropathic Pain | Motor Cortex Stimulation (15)O-water |
+
| [141] | ||||||
Atypical Facial Pain | Dopamine receptor binding [11C]raclopride | Increased D2 binding | [73] | ||||||
Fibromyalgia | μ receptor (11C) Carfentanil | Decreased Opioid Binding | [166] | ||||||
Dopamine receptor (11C) Raclopride | Decrease dopamine release | [74] | |||||||
Analgesics
| |||||||||
Fentanyl | Opioid Effects (15)O-water | + | [167] | ||||||
Ketamine
| NMDA Receptor Binding (n-methyl11C)-ketamine | + |
+
| [168] |
Basal Ganglia Activation in Acute Pain (Figure 4, Tables 1, 2 and 3)
Noxious Stimuli
Basal Ganglia Activation in Chronic Pain (Figure 4, Tables 1, 2 and 3)
Basal Ganglia Activation and Analgesics (Figure 4, Tables 1, 2 and 3)
Lessons Learned from Imaging
Putamen (P) shows consistent increase in activation across multiple pain imaging studies
Opposite Signal Changes in Caudate and NAc in Acute vs. Chronic Pain
Smaller Nuclei (ST, SN) are not clearly defined in many fMRI studies
Feed-forward and Feedback Loops - Integrating, Modifying, and Modulating the Pain Experience
Basal Ganglia: Imaging and Improved Understanding of Clinical Applications
Cortical Stimulation and Chronic Pain - Acting via Cortico-Striatal-Thalamic Loops
Anterior Cingulate Lesions and Pain Control
BG and Learned Behaviors
BG and Emergence of Central Pain
Basal Ganglia and Opioid Systems
Dopaminergic Drugs and Pain
BG Deep Brain Stimulation and Strategies for Pain Relief
Conclusions
Region | Putative Role in Pain | Reference |
---|---|---|
Caudate | Involved in avoidance behavior to pain | [169] |
Decrease pain sensitivity following apomorphine injections | [14] | |
Encode noxious stimuli intensity to minimize bodily harm | [9] | |
Behavioral Reinforcement (? Including Pain) | [3] | |
Putamen | Somatotopic modulation of pain | [148] |
Variations in subjective ratings of pain | [135] | |
Nucleus Accumbens | Affective Valence for Reward and Aversive Stimuli | |
Processing of emotional salience of pain | [135] | |
Globus Pallidus | Encoding of behavioral repertoires (? Including pain) | [3] |
Deep brain stimulation inhibits pain | ||
Morphine analgesia | [172] | |
Subthalamic Nucleus | Functional suppression of neural messages | [173] |
Behavioral Inhibition | [174] | |
Regulates level of execution of cortical commands; processing of emotional, cognitive and motor behavior | [3] | |
Substantia Nigra | Heterogeneous response to aversive stimuli | [96] |