Background
Methodology
Eligibility criteria
Information source and search strategies
Study selection process
Data collection process
Study quality and risk-of-bias assessment
Outcomes
Subgroup analysis
Data analysis
Trial sequential analysis
Certainty of the evidence
Results
Study selection
Studies and patients’ characteristics
Author, year (country) | N* | Population (number of centre) | EN | PN | Start intervention | Days on intervention | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
High | Low | High | Low | |||||
1. Clifton 1985 [29] (USA) | 20 | Severe head injury (1) | EN only | – | Balance period: ~ 7–14d after injury | Balance period: ~ 7–14d after injury | ~ 7d | ~ 7d |
2. Saffle 1990 [19] (USA) | 49 | Acute burns with % total burn surface area ≥ 25% (1) | EN only | – | After fluid resuscitation and placement of feeding tube | After fluid resuscitation and placement of feeding tube | ~ 22d | ~ 22d |
3. Mesejo 2003 [37] (Spain) | 50 | EN ≥ 5 d, APACHE II 10–25, BMI ≥ 30, no kidney/liver failure (2) | EN only | – | ~ ≤ 48 h of ICU admission | ~ ≤ 48 h of ICU admission | 5d | 5d |
4. Zhou 2006 [30] (China) | 51 | Severe stroke with GCS < 12 (1) | EN only | – | ≤ 5d of acute stroke | ≤ 5 days of acute stroke | – (up to 14d) | – (up to 14d) |
5. Singer 2007 [12] (Israel) | 14 | MV with non-oliguric acute renal failure and required PN (1) | – | PN only | D2 of ICU admission | D2 of ICU admission | 3d | 3d |
6. Rugeles 2013 [33] (Columbia) | 80 | Medical, EN ≥ 96 h (1) | EN only | Exclude patients that need PN | ~ ≤ 48 h of ICU admission | ~ ≤ 48 h of ICU admission | ≥ 96 h (up to 7d) | ≥ 96 h (up to 7d) |
7. Doig 2015 [20] (Australia) | 474 | Mixed, Stay ≥ 2d (16) | Decide by the attending physician | D1-2 of ICU admission | D1-2 of ICU admission | At D7, n = 124 (Until ICU DC: ICU LOS 11.6d) | At D7, n = 120 (Until ICU DC: ICU LOS 10.7d) | |
8. Ferrie 2015 [21] (Australia) | 120 | Mixed, ≥ 3d on PN (1) | – | PN only | 1 (1–2) d in ICU | 1 (1–2) d in ICU | 10.0 (6.8–14.0) d (up to 10d) | 9.5 (7.0–13.5) d (up to 10d) |
9. Jakob 2017 [22] (Switzerland) | 90 | Mixed, EN ≥ 3d, stay ≥ 5d (1) | EN first | PN is only allowed if intolerant to EN | Time to reach full caloric goal: 2.2 (0.8–3.7)d | Time to reach full caloric goal: 2.0 (1.3–2.7)d | 5.0 (3.6–6.4) d (up to 10d) | 7.0 (5.3–8.7) d (up to 10d) |
10. Fetterplace 2018 [23] (Australia) | 60 | Mixed, MV within 48 h and remained ≥ 72 h (1) | EN first | PN is allowed at the discretion of the treating physician | Time EN start: 13 ± 8 h | Time EN start: 20 ± 10 h | At D7, n = 15 (up to 15d) | At D7, n = 12 (up to 15d) |
11. van Zanten 2018 [24] (Netherlands) | 44 | Mixed, MV, BMI ≥ 25, EN ≤ 48 h- > 5d (4) | EN first | SPN is allowed if necessary | D1-2 of ICU admission | D1-2 of ICU admission | At D10, n = 16 (up to 28d) | At D10, n = 13 (up to 28d) |
12. Vega-Alava 2018 [36] (Philippines) | 40 | MV, EN (1) | EN only | – | ~ ≤ 24 h of ICU admission | ~ ≤ 24 h of ICU admission | – | – |
13. Azevedo 2019 [25] (Brazil) | 120 | Mixed, MV, Stay > 2d (1) | EN first | SPN is allowed after 5 d if the caloric goal is not achieved | ~ ≤ 3d in the ICU (IC to adjust caloric intake) | ~ ≤ 3d in the ICU (IC to adjust caloric intake) | – (up to 14d) | – (up to 14d) |
14. Danielis 2019 [26] (Italy) | 40 | Mixed, MV within 12 h, BMI 18.5 to 30 kg/m [2], no acute/chronic renal or hepatic failure (1) | EN first | SPN is allowed to make up the energy shortfall | Once admitted to the ICU and assessed for eligibility | Once admitted to the ICU and assessed for eligibility | – (up to the end of MV, onset of acute renal or hepatic failure, transfer to another hospital or death) | |
15. Bukhari 2020^ [35] (Indonesia) | 33 | ICU patients not contraindicated or intolerant to EN (1) | EN only | – | Within 24–48 h of ICU admission | Within 24–48 h of ICU admission | 3 d | 3 d |
16. Chapple 2020 [27] (Australia) | 116 | Mixed, MV, EN > 2d (6) | EN first | SPN is allowed if deemed necessary by the treating physician | ~ 19 h of ICU admission | ~ 17.6 h of ICU admission | 8.7 ± 7.3d (up to 28d) | 8.1 ± 6.3d (up to 28d) |
17. Nakamura 2020 [28] (Japan) | 117 | Mixed, no lower limb injury, no die or discharge < D10 (1) | EN first | SPN is allowed to reach energy goal within 3d (no IV AA) | Time EN start: < 48 h ICU admission | Time EN start: < 48 h ICU admission | EN: 8 (5–9) d. Oral up to D10 | EN: 8 (5–9) d. Oral up to D10 |
18. Carteron 2021 [31] (France) | 195 | Brain injured (GCS < 8), expected MV > 48 h (1) | EN only | – | Within 36 h of ICU admission | Within 36 h of ICU admission | At D10, n = 52 (up to 10d) | At D10, n = 60 (up to 10d) |
19. Dresen 2021 (Germany) [34] | 42 | Surgical, MV, after stay ≥ 10d, expected stay ≥ 30d (1) | EN first | If the nutrition target was not achieved within 24 h, initiate SPN | After ≥ 10 d in the ICU | After ≥ 10 d in the ICU | At D25, n = 15 (up to 28d) | At D25, n = 12 (up to 28d) |
20. Heyland 2023# [7] (International) | 1301 | Mixed, MV within 96 h of ICU admission and remained ≥ 48 h with a ‘high’ nutrition risk (85) | EN first | TPN or SPN is allowed if deemed necessary by the treating physician | Within 96 h of MV | Within 96 h of MV | Up to 28 d in the ICU | Up to 28 d in the ICU |
Studies with combined high protein and early physical rehabilitation | ||||||||
21. Badjatia 2020 [32] (USA) | 25 | SAH, Stay > 7d, BMI 15 to 40 (1) | EN or oral intake | – | Time EN start: < 24 h of aneurysmal repair | Time EN start: < 24 h of aneurysmal repair | 12 d (range 9–14) | 12 d (range 9–14) |
22. Azevedo 2021 [18] (Brazil) | 181 | Mixed, MV, stay > 3 d (1) | EN first | SPN if protein goal was not reached by day 7–10 | Third day of randomization | Third day of randomization | Up to 14 d | Up to 14 d |
23. Kagan 2022^ [17] (Israel) | 41 | MV for ≥ 48 h and expected MV for a minimum of 7 d (1) | EN only | Exclude patients that need TPN | After 48 h of MV | After 48 h of MV | Up to 28 d | Up to 28 d |
Protein and energy delivery
Early physical rehabilitation delivery
Study quality assessments
Results of the clinical outcomes
Mortality
Infectious complications, ICU, and hospital length of stay and duration of mechanical ventilation
Results of muscle mass and strength, discharge to rehabilitation facilities, self-reported quality of life physical function outcomes, and incidence of diarrhoea
Results of biochemical outcomes
Other subgroup analyses
Trial sequential analysis
Effect size | Incidence, or variance | I2 (%) | D2 (%) | RIS | % of RIS attained | Z-curve passed the conventional boundaries? | Z-curve passed the TSA boundaries? | Z-curve passed the futility boundaries? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Overall mortality (21 studies, n = 3125) | ||||||||
RRR: 10.0% | 25.0% | 0.0 | 0.0 | 12,179 | 25.7 | No | No | No |
Overall mortality in patients with acute kidney injury before protein intervention (3 studies, n = 428) | ||||||||
RRR: 46.0% | 28.0% | 0.0 | 0.0 | 429 | 99.8 | Yes | Yes | No |
Infectious complication (7 studies, n = 462) | ||||||||
RRR 10.0% | 43.7% | 0.0 | 0.0 | 5344 | 8.6 | No | No | No |
Intensive care unit length of stay (16 studies, n = 2516) | ||||||||
MID 1 day | 112.5 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 4730 | 53.2 | No | No | Trending |
Hospital length of stay (11 studies, n = 2130) | ||||||||
MID 1 day | 327.9 | 18.0 | 46.4 | 25,728 | 8.3 | No | No | No |
Mechanical ventilation duration (13 studies, n = 2360) | ||||||||
MID 1 day | 50.8 | 1.0 | 1.8 | 2173 | 108.6 | No | No | Yes |
Incidence of diarrhoea (6 studies, n = 622) | ||||||||
RRR 10.0% | 36.3% | 13.0 | 19.2 | 8915 | 7.0 | No | No | No |
Muscle wasting per week (5 studies, n = 273) | ||||||||
MID 1% | 29.8 | 16.0 | 29.6 | 1780 | 15.3 | Yes | No | No |
Handgrip strength (2 studies, n = 130) | ||||||||
MID 5 kg | 104.5 | 24.0 | 31.4 | 256 | 50.8 | No | No | Trending |
Discharge to rehab (3 studies, n = 173) | ||||||||
RRR 10.0% | 39.1% | 0.0 | 0.0 | UTE | UTE | No | No | No |
GRADE certainty assessments
Certainty assessment | Summary of findings | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Participants (studies) Follow-up | Risk of bias | Inconsistency | Indirectness | Imprecision | Publication bias | Overall certainty of evidence | Study event rates (%) | Relative effect (95% CI) | Anticipated absolute effects | ||
With placebo | With mortality | Risk with placebo | Risk difference with mortality | ||||||||
Overall mortality | |||||||||||
3125 (21 RCTs) | seriousa | not serious | not serious | seriousb | none | ⨁⨁◯◯ Low | 406/1569 (25.9%) | 392/1556 (25.2%) | RR 0.99 (0.88 to 1.11) | 259 per 1,000 | 3 fewer per 1,000 (from 31 fewer to 28 more) |
Mortality (subgroup of patients with acute kidney injury) | |||||||||||
428 (3 RCTs) | not seriousc | not serious | not serious | not seriousd | none | ⨁⨁⨁⨁ High | 62/198 (31.3%) | 102/230 (44.3%) | RR 1.42 (1.11 to 1.82) | 313 per 1,000 | 132 more per 1,000 (from 34 to 257 more) |
Infectious complications | |||||||||||
462 (7 RCTs) | seriouse | not serious | not serious | very seriousf | none | ⨁◯◯◯ Very low | 100/229 (43.7%) | 99/233 (42.5%) | RR 1.05 (0.88 to 1.25) | 437 per 1,000 | 22 more per 1,000 (from 52 fewer to 109 more) |
ICU length of stay | |||||||||||
2516 (16 RCTs) | seriousg | not serious | not serious | serioush | none | ⨁⨁◯◯ Low | 1264 | 1252 | – | The mean ICU length of stay was 0 | MD 0.44 lower (1.27 lower to 0.39 higher) |
Hospital length of stay | |||||||||||
2130 (11 RCTs) | seriousi | seriousj | not serious | very seriousk | none | ⨁◯◯◯ Very low | 1069 | 1061 | – | The mean hospital length of stay was 0 | MD 1.55 higher (0.55 lower to 3.65 higher) |
Duration of mechanical ventilation | |||||||||||
2360 (13 RCTs) | seriousl | not serious | not serious | not serious | Publication bias strongly suspected | ⨁⨁◯◯ Low | 1188 | 1172 | – | The mean duration of mechanical ventilation was 0 | MD 0.42 lower (1 lower to 0.16 higher) |
Incidence of diarrhoea | |||||||||||
622 (6 RCTs) | seriouse | not serious | not serious | very seriousm | none | ⨁◯◯◯ Very low | 111/306 (36.3%) | 113/316 (35.8%) | RR 0.97 (0.79 to 1.19) | 363 per 1,000 | 11 fewer per 1,000 (from 76 fewer to 69 more) |
Attenuation of thigh muscle loss (per week) | |||||||||||
273 (5 RCTs) | seriousn | not serious | not serious | seriouso | none | ⨁⨁◯◯ Low | pdate134 | 139 | – | The mean attenuation of thigh muscle loss (per week) was 0 | MD 3.44 lower (4.99 lower to 1.9 lower) |
Handgrip Strength | |||||||||||
130 (2 RCTs) | very seriousp | not serious | not serious | seriousq | none | ⨁◯◯◯ Very low | 72 | 58 | – | The mean handgrip strength was 0 | MD 2.08 higher (2.16 lower to 6.32 higher) |
Discharge to rehabilitation facilities | |||||||||||
173 (3 RCTs) | not serious | not serious | not serious | very seriousr | none | ⨁⨁◯◯ Low | 34/87 (39.1%) | 36/86 (41.9%) | RR 1.05 (0.74 to 1.50) | 391 per 1,000 | 20 more per 1,000 (from 102 fewer to 195 more) |