Depression severity mediates stigma and quality of life in clinically stable people with schizophrenia in rural China

Anomalies in cognition, thought, emotion, and behaviour characterize a collection of extreme mental illnesses known as schizophrenia. It is one of the most debilitating disorders and can often cause extensive disability in daily functioning and cognition [1]. Many clinical studies in the past have focused on the pathological symptoms of schizophrenia [2]. However, with the improvement of patients' psychiatric symptoms, their daily life problems are gradually exposed, including employment, housing, social function, and social relations [3]. Therefore, to provide more comprehensive services for people with schizophrenia (PWS) and help them return to the community as soon as possible, an increasing number of studies are focusing on their quality of life(QOL) [4, 5].

QOL is defined by whether an individual can meet their essential needs and social obligations while utilizing their skills to exploit the opportunities provided by society [6]. QOL is an outcome indicator for evaluating the treatment of PWS [7, 8]. A previous meta-analysis of 18 case–control studies found that the QOL of PWS was significantly lower than that of healthy controls [9]. Additionally, it was discovered in another study that QOL can predict the return of symptoms in schizophrenia patients. According to the study, the likelihood of relapsing after two years of follow-up increases with a decreased QOL [10].

The QOL of PWS is affected by numerous factors, and cross-sectional and longitudinal studies have identified several determinants of QOL in patients with severe mental disorders, such as symptom severity, the presence of depression and anxiety, medication side effects, and treatment adherence [11, 12]. In PWS, lower QOL is associated with the presence of a secondary diagnosis, such as depression [13, 14] or anxiety [15]. PWS frequently experience depressive symptoms (7–65%).Those symptom can be seen in almost all onset stages [16] and are associated with the use of multiple medications, poor psychosocial functioning, low QOL, etc. [17, 18]. Numerous studies have revealed a link between depressive symptoms and poor QOL in PWS [19, 20]. Higher rates of recurrence and readmission have been reported in PWS with depressive symptoms than in non-depressed controls [21]. Furthermore, depression is also a prevalent warning indicator for suicidal thoughts and actions, and many prospective studies have found that depression poses a significant risk of suicidal ideation, conduct, and fatalities [22, 23]. However, because depressive symptoms and the adverse symptoms of schizophrenia frequently coexist, depressive symptoms in schizophrenia are frequently under-recognized and under-diagnosed, which prevents patients from receiving appropriate treatment [24].

Stigma is an internal experience of shame that patients experience as a result of their illness [25]. It can be divided into 'social stigma', which refers to the experience of discriminatory attitudes and unfair treatment by the public, and 'self-stigma', which alludes to the shame that prevents patients from sharing their experiences, asking for help from others, and experiencing the anticipated sentiments of discrimination [26, 27]. In a 2018 cross-sectional study survey, it was found that a significant proportion of PWS are stigmatized, with greater hopelessness, depression and suicidal risk all being linked to stigma [28].

First, many studies have shown that both internal and social stigma significantly affect the QOL of PWS [29, 30]. For example, it can lead to social exclusion, preventing patients from engaging in meaningful life activities [31, 32] and reducing their self-esteem and self-efficacy [33], which are important components of self-concept, and the deterioration of this self-concept may produce a number of negative outcomes that may affect their recovery outcomes. In addition, stigmatization can hinder early treatment and recovery of people with mental illness, leading to prolonged recovery time, which further reduces QOL [34‐36]. Second, stigma can limit the ability of PWS to express their distress and seek help, thereby impairing their social interactions and increasing their risk of depression [37, 38]. The issue of stigma was also found in a longitudinal study to significantly affect PWS, who feared disclosure of their illness, and the results of that study suggested that the more stigmatized the patient was, the more depressed he or she felt [39]. Although the results of the association remain contradictory, according to a meta-analysis of these studies, stigma still has nearly a one-in-three chance of predicting depression [40].Third, many studies have shown that depressive symptoms in PWS can affect social function to varying degrees, reducing the QOL [41]. Yoshimune et al. studied the relationship between QOL and clinical factors in hospitalized schizophrenic patients and found that depressive symptoms significantly affected the QOL of the patients, whereas other symptoms such as positive, negative and pharmacogenetic extrapyramidal symptoms did not have a significant effect on their QOL [42]. Two other studies that included 174 and 67 outpatients with schizophrenia, respectively, reported a significant correlation between QOL and depressed mood but no significant correlation with positive and negative symptoms and extrapyramidal side effects [43, 44].

In summary, we can see that stigma can reduce the QOL of PWS and that stigma can lead to a greater likelihood of depression, and depressive symptoms can further reduce QOL. Therefore, we hypothesized that the severity of depression might be a potential factor for stigma to reduce the QOL of PWS; that is, the severity of depression plays a mediating role between stigma and QOL.

Although depressive symptoms and stigma associated with schizophrenia can affect the QOL, no prior research has studied the connection between the three in this group. The objectives of this study were 1) to assess the demographic and clinical correlates of depressive symptoms associated with schizophrenia; 2) to develop a mediation model to investigate how the severity of depression impacts stigma and living conditions.

To our knowledge, this research is the first to examine how stigma and QOL in rural China are impacted by depressive symptoms associated with schizophrenia. The results showed that PWS with depressive symptoms had greater stigma levels and worse QOL, with the intensity of depression acting as a significant mediating factor between stigma and QOL.

This study indicated that approximately 34% of stable schizophrenia patients had depressive symptoms, which is consistent with other research on depression in schizophrenia patients in various sociocultural situations [60]. Contrary to earlier findings, our analysis revealed that PWS with a spouse were more likely to have depressive symptoms than those without a partner. Many studies have shown that marriage benefits physical and mental health, while divorce can be health-threatening [61]. However, while some people may experience long-lasting "scars" after separation or divorce, most people can quickly regain their health and happiness, and unhappy marriages might put couples in danger of poor intimacy and overall well-being [62].

Consistent with the findings of many studies, PWS who never engaged in physical activity were more likely than those who did to experience depressive symptoms [63, 64]. It has also been documented that appropriate physical activity not only reduces depressive symptoms in patients but also prevents cardiovascular disease [65]. The results of this study also show that PWS who are employed are less likely to experience depression than those who are not. Previous studies have well documented that employment provides productive benefits to patients and improves individual health and lifestyle quality [66, 67].

In recent studies, it was shown that the stronger the intensity of social rejection and social isolation in PWS, the more likely patients were to experience depression. Social exclusion has been linked to depression, which can lead to emotions of sadness and loneliness [68, 69]. Like significant physical sickness and QOL impairment related to despair, social isolation is also thought to be connected with mental health issues, particularly depression [70, 71].In this light, it is crucial to give PWS a social dimension. Research shows that social contact interventions between groups can reduce stigma [72].

The study's key conclusion is that the degree of depression partially mediates the link between stigma and life satisfaction. This finding is important because it has implications for therapies designed to lessen stigma and enhance PWS' living standards. First, in this study, the patient's living standards were significantly negatively correlated with the severity of stigma. Because of the history and understanding of the nature of the disease, people tend to reject PWS, and an interesting phenomenon in psychology is that the public tends to give socially desirable answers to controversial questions to maintain harmony [73]. Previous research has shown that the stigma of mental illness is far greater in Chinese culture than in Western culture [74]. Deeply rooted and specific cultural and philosophical ideas can contribute to stigma and act as barriers to remission and recovery. Traditional cultural values such as Confucianism and Taoism, which have influenced society for more than 2,000 years, also include the issue of "face" [75]. In Chinese society, people are first and foremost seen as living in a strict network of social interactions, and the maintenance of society depends on human interaction. As "face" represents power and status in Chinese society, preserving "face" is part of people's daily lives, and a diagnosis of schizophrenia can lead to a "loss of face", causing the individual to suffer from extreme symptoms of schizophrenia. A diagnosis of schizophrenia can lead to a "loss of face" for the individual, resulting in an extreme sense of shame for the patient [76‐79]. In addition, some Chinese people believe that having a mental illness in this life means that they committed a moral wrong in a previous life, so that people with mental disorders are perceived by the public as being completely uncultivated and incapable of participating in social activities [80]. For example, in a survey of suicides in rural China, PWS were not accounted for, suggesting that people with schizophrenia were not considered morally competent [81].

In a collectivist society, people are more likely to recognize the public's stigmatization of mental illness than to express their values. This phenomenon severely limits and reduces the social status of patients. Schizophrenic patients are often considered different from others and are therefore negatively labelled, making it challenging to integrate into the community [82, 83]. Previous research has also demonstrated that stigmatization can lead to patients imposing negative stereotypes about themselves, resulting in self-discrimination and isolation [84] and a gradual withdrawal from social activities such as learning, working, and socializing, ultimately lowering their QOL [85]. Second, in this study, stigma is positively correlated with the severity of depression, and stigma can also indirectly affect the living standards of patients through the degree of depression (Fig. 1), which means that depression acts as a 'bridge.' Studies have found that stigmatization can result in slower healing rates and psychological issues [86]. For example, a previous cross-sectional survey showed that discrimination could hurt the rehabilitation of people with schizophrenia spectrum disorders through depressive symptoms [87]. In addition, a longitudinal survey also confirmed the hypothesis that stigmatization is a factor leading to higher depressive symptoms [39]. Outpatients with prejudices about mental illness who do not want to believe that their symptoms will improve and thus behave in a more depressed manner [34, 36]. These aggravated depressive symptoms can reduce the patient's ability to work and result in their refusal to enter society, thus reducing their economic income and ultimately worsening their QOL [88]. Based on the above statements, our results may imply that one of the causes of the continued decline in the level of well-being for PWS who experience stigma is the intensity of depression.

Thus, these findings can guide mental health workers to develop effective measures for the rehabilitation of PWS. For example, due to the lack of public knowledge of mental illness, people tend to attribute the symptoms of the disease to patients, so it is essential to educate the public about the aetiology, symptoms, and treatment of schizophrenia [89]. In this era, when social media is widely used, we can educate the public through many platforms, so that patients can be understood, respected, and accepted. Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) can be used to provide multidisciplinary care for patients with mental illness. The team includes psychiatrists, nurses, and social workers who can assist patients with daily life needs such as disease treatment, drug management, work, housing, and transportation [90]. Finally, clinicians in the treatment of schizophrenia also need to pay attention to other interventions, such as cognitive behavioural therapy or social skills training, which may improve symptoms, dysfunctional attitudes, and functions to reduce self-stigma and depressive symptoms, thereby improving the patient's psychological well-being [91, 92].

The scope of this investigation has several limitations. First, as this is a cross-sectional study, it is not possible to elaborate on the causal relationship between variables but only to assess the correlation, so future longitudinal studies are needed for more in-depth exploration. Second, despite the extensive assessment of patient demographic and clinical characteristics, there is evidence that factors such as sleep, diet, and type of antipsychotic medication all influence depressive symptoms in PWS [93‐95], and these factors could be examined in the future.

According to studies, depressive symptoms can occur in up to 34% of PWS, and the intensity of depression may partially influence the link between stigma and life expectancy. To lessen the intensity of depression and further enhance patient QOL, health workers must pay close attention to the depressive symptoms of such patients, come to an agreement on the diagnosis of the illness, and develop efficient treatment and prevention measures. Additionally, more studies are required to validate the efficacy of antidepressant medication for PWS depression symptoms because there are currently few data [96].