Introduction
Hemodialysis (HD) is one of the most common treatments for patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) [
1]. Epidemiology studies [
2] report that approximately 84% of all ESRD patients eventually receive hemodialysis treatment. Previous studies have indicated that patients with HD are predisposed to sarcopenia owing to the chronic inflammatory status, metabolic acidosis, malnutrition, and decreased physical activity [
3]. Sarcopenia is characterized by a progressive and systemic loss of muscle mass and strength/function that is typically associated with numerous adverse outcomes [
4,
5]. It has been estimated that 20–50% of all HD patients will develop sarcopenia, which is much higher than the general population [
6‐
9]. Earlier studies have revealed that HD patients with comorbid sarcopenia had an increased risk of falls, fractures, and cardiovascular events as well as a higher likelihood re-hospitalization and death [
10‐
12]. Two recent systematic review and meta-analysis have also corroborated that sarcopenia is associated with a higher risk of death in hemodialysis patients [
13,
14]. Other studies have demonstrated that that early identification and timely intervention can lower the occurrence and development of sarcopenia in hemodialysis patients [
15,
16]. Therefore, the importance of early identification of high-risk groups of sarcopenia in hemodialysis patients cannot be overstated.
The diagnosis of sarcopenia is mainly based on low skeletal muscle mass, skeletal muscle strength, and physical performance [
4]. Several technologies are currently being employed to estimate skeletal muscle mass, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT), dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). Nevertheless, the use of DXA, MRI, and CT is limited in clinical practice by disadvantages such as high cost, complex procedures, and radiation exposure [
17]. On the other hand, even though the BIA is convenient to perform, however, it was not applicable for the HD patients who experienced pacemaker implant and amputation [
18]. The Asian Working Group for Sarcopenia (AWGS)2019 update proposes screening for sarcopenia with either SARC-F or SARC-CalF to facilitate earlier identification of high-risk individuals [
15]. SARC-F is a self-reported questionnaire based on the patient’s perception of limitations in strength, walking ability, rising from a chair, stair climbing, and falls. The SARC-F score ≥ 4 indicates a risk of sarcopenia, however, numerous studies have demonstrated the low sensitivity and high specificity of SARC-F [
19,
20]. SARC-CalF enhanced the sensitivity of SARC-F by the inclusion of calf circumference, with a score ≥ 11 indicates a risk of sarcopenia [
21]. Despite the fact that SARC-F or SAC-CalF is simple to use and cost-free for identifying the risk of sarcopenia in hemodialysis patients, their results have been controversial [
22,
23]. The relatively low sensitivity of these two scales renders a higher risk for miss diagnosis. As a result, the clinical medical staff cannot promptly identify the high-risk groups of sarcopenia in hemodialysis patients and thereby miss the window for early intervention.
To address the aforementioned challenges, we aimed to develop and validate a reliable nomogram model for predicting sarcopenia risk in hemodialysis patients. With this model, we hope to early identification of hemodialysis patients at high risk for sarcopenia and enable timely interventions to prevent or slow development and progression of sarcopenia. Thus improving patients adverse outcomes.
Discussion
Herein, we developed and validated a simple nomogram to predict the risk of developing sarcopenia in HD patients with a total of five clinically relevant variables, including age, C-reactive protein, serum phosphorus, BMI, and MAMC. The AUC, internal validation C-statistic, calibration curve, and DCA curve were constructed to validate the reliability as well as the accuracy of this model. The nomogram model can early identify hemodialysis patients at risk of sarcopenia, and enable timely interventions to prevent or slow development and progression. thus improving patients adverse outcomes.
Nomograms can predict the probability of disease by analyzing and integrating identified disease risk factors, thus providing valuable information for better clinical decisions. It has been extensively used in oncology and chronic diseases worldwide [
24]. For instance, Cheng et al. [
31] designed a nomogram to predict the risk of initiating renal replacement therapy within 3 years in diabetic nephropathy patients, while Jing et al. [
32] developed a nomogram comprising multiple echocardiographic measures to assess 3-year all-cause mortality in hemodialysis patients, both of which showed favorable accuracy and reliability. Ouyang et al. [
33]developed and validated an easy-to-use nomogram that can accurately predict 1-year, 5-year, and 10-year survival in hemodialysis patients. In addition, Mo, et al. [
34] reported the development of nomograms to predict sarcopenia in community older adults. However, to the best of our knowledge, no study has been conducted to construct a nomogram that can predict the risk of developing sarcopenia in HD patients.
In this study, the multivariate logistic regression analysis indicated that age was a risk factor for sarcopenia in HD patients. Aging is a well-known independent risk factor for sarcopenia, With the increase of age, the protein breakdown and anabolic metabolism of patients are gradually unbalanced. In addition, mitochondrial dysfunction and hormonal changes caused by aging are also related to sarcopenia [
5]. Our findings on the relationship between age and sarcopenia are consistent with previous studies [
6,
8,
35]. However,
there are some controversies, Wang et al. [
14] systematic review have shown the age of HD patients was no significant influence on sarcopenia prevalence.
Hyperphosphatemia is a common complication in HD patients and is closely related to an increased risk of vascular calcification and cardiovascular mortality [
36]. Interestingly, our study indicated that lower serum phosphorus level correlated with the development of sarcopenia in HD patients, which was in line with the findings of Ren et al. [
8]. We hypothesized that a high-protein diet is the main source of phosphorus for uremic patients who often suffer from loss of appetite or anorexia. A decrease in food intake will inevitably lead to a decrease in serum phosphorus, malnutrition, and protein-energy expenditure in patients, ultimately resulting in sarcopenia [
37]. Previous studies have shown that shown protein restriction to correlate with increased mortality in patients undergoing HD, restricting dietary protein to help control phosphorus levels in patients undergoing maintenance HD may be more harmful than beneficial [
36]. Balancing Nutrition and Serum Phosphorus in HD patients requires an individualized approach, involving a combination of adequate dietary advice, phosphatebinder use, and adjustments to dialysis prescription.
BMI and MAMC are conventional nutritional assessments for HD patients, and previous studies [
38‐
40] indicated that both are independent predictors of survival. The study conducted by Su et al. [
41] exposed that the decrease in MAC was associated with increased all-cause mortality and cardiac events in HD patients, especially in those with low BMI. Unsurprisingly, the data in our study showed that HD patients with decreased BMI and MAMC were more likely to develop sarcopenia, which is consistent with previous studies [
42,
43].
Consistent with previous studies [
12,
38], This study showed that the level of C-reactive protein was increased in HD patients who developed sarcopenia compared to non-sarcopenia patients. the role of inflammation as a risk factor for malnutrition has been more and more recognized, C-reactive protein is one of the most frequently utilized biochemical indicators to examine inflammation. It has been well established in the field that hemodialysis patients are often under micro inflammatory state for multiple reasons [
44]. Indeed, the close association between inflammation and sarcopenia has been well documented. Inflammatory factors can activate numerous signaling pathways involved in the pathogenesis of sarcopenia, resulting in decreased anabolism and increased catabolism of proteins [
45]. A systematic review shows that exercise training can be beneficial for both the body composition and nutritional status in hemodialysis patients, the MAMC, BMI, Serum albumin increase and C-reactive protein decrease after resistance exercise [
46]. Therefore, attention should be paid to these high-risk patients and early interventions should be taken to improve their outcomes.
Hemodialysis patients often have report significant psychological distress, Depression is common in HD patients [
47]. depression patients are significantly less involved in social, professional, and recreational activities resulting in less physical activity [
48], Infection [
47], these factors are related to the development of sarcopenia. Several previous studies have shown an association between depression and sarcopenia in hemodialysis patients [
49‐
51], there is a higher prevalence of depression in sarcopenia patients. however, we did not find any significant association between depression and sarcopenia. This may be due to differences in study populations and assessment tools.
Currently, commonly used scales for sarcopenia are the SARC-F score and the modified SARC-assisted Cal F score. A meta-analysis [
23] revealed that the sensitivity of SARC-F was low to moderate (28.9% – 55.3%), and so was its specificity (68.9% – 88.9%). Although SARC-CalF is associated with higher specificity (87.7% – 91.3%), its sensitivity is not satisfactory (45.9% – 57.2%). The relatively low sensitivity of these two scales renders a higher risk for misdiagnosis. On the contrary, our novel nomogram provided an alternative method with increased clinical efficacy. The AUC of our constructed nomogram model was 0.869 in the development cohort and 0.832 in the validation cohort with an internal validation C-statistic of 0.783. The validity of this novel model was further verified by calibration and DCA curves. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio of our constructed nomogram model were 77%,83%,45%,93%,4.34,0.418, Accuracy was 82%. More importantly, all five variables included in this model are laboratory and anthropometric measurements that are routinely determined in clinical practice and do not require additional examinations or costs. To make this predictive model more convenient for physicians to use in clinical practice, we modified the nomogram into a scoring system with integer points, the scoring system has ease of visualization. If the total score > 121 points indicates that the patient has a high risk of sarcopenia, should be timely comprehensive interventions, such as exercise training, nutritional interventions to reduce the occurrence of sarcopenia.
However, this study has some limitations that need to be taken into account. First, even though the number of enrollments was relatively large, it was conducted at a single center that might not be representative of the HD patients in other areas. Second, our study was retrospectively constructed and hemodialysis patients level of physical activity, serum bicarbonate, vitamin D level and nutritional status were not included in the analysis, potentially reducing the performance of the model. Third, the constructed nomogram model was not validated using external data. Fourth, this study excluded cases with missing data, which may have led to selection bias. Therefore, this model should be validated through prospective, multicenter clinical studies in the future.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.