Introduction
American Indian and Alaska Native (AIAN) people are disproportionately impacted by many social determinants of health associated with increased COVID-19 infection prevalence and severe morbidity and mortality [
1‐
3]. Food insecurity, in particular, is a complex and important social determinant of health that affects AIAN communities at significantly higher rates than other racial and ethnic groups [
4]. The forced relocation of AIAN communities from traditional lands disrupted their way of life and access to traditional healthy foods. These historical forces contribute to modern AIAN experiences, including inequitable food access, high prevalence of food insecurity, and disparate burden of diet-related health outcomes [
4‐
7]. Food insecurity is defined as having unreliable or limited access to affordable, nutritious food and is associated with higher risk of physical and mental health conditions, including type 2 diabetes, hypertension, chronic stress, anxiety, and depression [
8,
9]. AIAN people experience disparities in these health conditions, which also confer a high risk of severe complications, hospitalization, and death following COVID-19 infection [
10,
11]. Despite these challenges, Tribal entities were quick to design and implement COVID-19 vaccination campaigns, which contributed to high rates of vaccination in AIAN communities early in the pandemic [
12].
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, AIAN communities across the U.S. experienced a higher prevalence of food insecurity (27%) than African American (21%), Asian American and Pacific Islander (6%), Hispanic (17%), and non-Hispanic White populations (9%) [
13]. However, during the COVID-19 pandemic, food insecurity initially sharply increased throughout the U.S. due to job or income loss, school closures, social isolation, and food supply chain disruptions [
14]. Food insecure families living in poverty may be at a greater risk of COVID-19 infection due to increased exposure from work obligations outside the home (particularly for essential workers), more frequent use of public transportation, more interactions with other individuals who are vulnerable due to increased exposure, and lack of healthcare access [
15‐
17]. In addition, food insecurity may be associated with malnutrition, nutrient deficiencies, and a higher risk of chronic disease, which may increase susceptibility to COVID-19 [
18]. Food insecurity during the pandemic was also associated with a high likelihood of COVID-19 infection in older U.S. adults and in counties with large African American or large American Indian or Alaska Native populations [
16,
19]. One study in an Iranian population found that after controlling for confounders, food insecurity increased the risk of COVID-19 threefold [
20]. Data from the 2021 National Health Interview Survey revealed that food insecurity was independently associated with COVID-19 after controlling for sociodemographic and health-related factors [
21]. Food insecurity may also negatively impact vaccination uptake [
22]. Research shows that individuals experiencing food insecurity may be less likely to engage in preventative health behaviors such as vaccinations due to cost (or perceived costs) and vaccine hesitancy, distrust in government, and logistical barriers [
23,
24]. Little research has explored food insecurity among AIAN people during the pandemic, likely in part due to the unique circumstances of research partnerships with AIAN communities during the pandemic, despite their high risk of food insecurity [
25‐
28]. Likewise, individual-level associations among food insecurity, COVID-19 infection, and COVID-19 vaccination have not been examined in any AIAN population.
We conducted a cross-sectional survey in collaboration with 5 geographically dispersed health organizations that serve urban AIAN populations to examine the association between sociodemographic factors and food insecurity. We also evaluated the association between food insecurity and COVID-19 infection, and food insecurity and vaccination uptake mid-pandemic. We hypothesized that food insecurity would be a risk factor for COVID-19 infection and associated with lower rates of vaccination, after adjusting for potential confounding by sociodemographic, cultural, and health-related factors. As an exploratory analysis, we examined the association between persistent food security and COVID-19 infection and vaccination, which is an important area of inquiry within the COVID-19 context where there were newly food insecure households [
29,
30].
Discussion
Food insecurity is an important social determinant of health and increased in many communities because of the pandemic. 38% of study participants experienced food insecurity during the pandemic (2021) without differences in COVID-19 infection or vaccination prevalence by food insecurity status after adjustment.
Observed associations between sociodemographic characteristics and reported food insecurity were similar to those found in previous studies conducted in the U.S. [
36]. Our results add to the literature indicating an increase in food insecurity among urban AIAN populations since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic [
37,
38]. While slightly lower than the 50% food insecurity reported in the February 2021 survey conducted by the Native American Agriculture Fund, the experience of food insecurity was high in the study sample [
39]. Notably, among participants whose food security status likely did not change due to the onset of the pandemic, only 25% of participants reported being food insecure, compared to 38% for the overall sample, suggesting a substantial increase since the onset of the pandemic.
A high prevalence of food insecurity among AIAN families has also been reported prior to the pandemic [
40]. A recent scoping review of pre-pandemic food insecurity in AIAN people found a weighted average prevalence of food insecurity of 46%; however, studies varied widely with food insecurity ranging from 16 − 80% [
4]. Regardless, food insecurity among AIAN communities is likely significantly higher than the nationwide estimate of 10.5% in 2019 [
8]. Most research has focused on food insecurity in rural- and/or reservation-living AIAN households, which experience additional challenges to food access such as restricted transportation options and walkability, and reliable internet and/or phone services [
4]. However, in studies that included urban and rural AIAN households, urban households were more likely to report food insecurity than their rural counterparts [
40,
41]. Higher food insecurity rates in urban areas may be in part due to limited access to traditional foods or food obtained through subsistence activities, exclusion from reservation-based programs for AIAN families (such as the Food Distribution Program on Indian Reservations), and separation from community or family support [
4]. Despite these challenges, many AIAN people have established strong communities within urban settings, and organizations such as Native American LifeLines have found innovative ways to provide access to culturally appropriate food and healthcare for urban AIAN families [
42]. Additional research to elucidate the reasons for food insecurity and novel strategies to reduce food insecurity in both urban and rural areas are needed.
Research among adults in the U.S. indicated significant increases in food insecurity at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic [
43,
44]. However, thus far, research on food insecurity among AIAN communities during the COVID-19 pandemic has been limited, with two studies suggesting increases in food insecurity since the pandemic. One study conducted in the Blackfeet Indian Tribal Community found that 79% of survey respondents indicated some degree of food insecurity over a 4-month period in late 2020 [
37,
38]. Similarly, few studies have examined associations between food insecurity and COVID-19 infection or vaccine uptake. However, our findings that food insecurity was not associated with COVID-19 infection or vaccination, differ from prior research among other populations. Prior studies in older adults and Latinx families suggest higher prevalence of COVID-19 infection in households experiencing food insecurity [
16,
45]. However, in one of the studies, the relationship was no longer significant after adjusting for house size and number of residents [
45].
While research in other communities across the U.S. indicates that people with food insecurity were less likely to receive COVID-19 vaccines, this was not evident in this sample of urban AIAN adults after adjusting for confounders [
46,
47]. Many Tribal organizations responded swiftly to the COVID-19 pandemic and were early adopters of public health vaccination campaigns, with timely distribution of vaccines to Indian Health Service and Tribal healthcare facilities [
12]. Federal data from April 2021 showed that more AIAN people (32%) were fully vaccinated against COVID-19 than Whites (19%), Asian Americans (16%), and African Americans (12%) [
48]. Despite a high prevalence of food insecurity in this sample, the community-led vaccination campaigns across Indian Health Service and Tribal healthcare facilities may have mitigated the negative impacts of food insecurity on COVID-19 preventive behaviors such as vaccination [
12]. However, the unadjusted results suggest that public health strategies that direct resources to food assistance programs may be useful in improving access to COVID-19 vaccinations for families experiencing food insecurity. For example, offering vaccinations at charitable food distribution sites, which faced challenges but were nimble and able to adapt in the face of the public health emergency [
49]. Alternatively, efforts to screen for food security in healthcare settings could be used to simultaneously direct individuals towards food assistance as well as preventive health services [
50]. As these findings differ from prior findings, additional research examining what protective factors and the potential mechanisms that may have occurred is an important next step.
The implementation and scaling up of secondary interventions that address food insecurity among urban AIAN communities is a growing priority. Two interventions have reduced food insecurity among AIAN children [
51,
52]. One intervention with the Navajo Nation included a fruit and vegetable prescription and empowerment program, while the other intervention aimed to foster Indigenous culture and pride, including culturally-based gardening practices. The Indigenous Food Circle described an indigenous-led network to address the immediate needs of food insecurity exacerbated during the pandemic [
53] that highlighted the importance of advocacy, Indigenous-led initiatives, and culturally appropriate frameworks to address the systemic issues of food insecurity in AIAN communities. A study conducted among Alaska Native women receiving the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) assistance showed that intake of traditional foods was associated with improved diet quality [
54]. While an association between food security and traditional food intake was not observed, incorporating efforts to increase access to traditional foods and subsistence practices could strengthen programs and policies aimed at reducing health disparities experienced by AIAN communities.
These studies suggest multiple strategies may reduce food insecurity among Native communities. As the food environment and federal financial interventions (e.g., stimulus checks and child tax credit) are discontinued, understanding the impacts on food insecurity status is integral to reducing food insecurity among AIAN people. Working directly with AIAN populations to contextualize and create standardized measurements of food insecurity among rural and urban AIAN communities is critical to creating appropriate strategies to combat food insecurity and its negative impacts on health [
4]. The U.S. Department of Agriculture food insecurity screening questions focus on the ability to
purchase food, rather than
provide food, and do not ask about subsistence farming or gardening, hunting, or fishing, which are common in many Native communities, though less so in urban areas [
55‐
57]. Furthermore, it is imperative to recognize the importance of food sovereignty within AIAN communities and support ongoing efforts to address inequities within the food system [
58].
Limitations of the present study include a cross-sectional design, which prevents our ability to establish causation, temporality, and proximity between food insecurity and COVID-19 infection or vaccination. Surveys were only sent to individuals who visited the clinic in the year prior to the pandemic, so our sample may have included more people who seek out consistent healthcare. Participants were able to complete the study on paper or online in an attempt to reach the community; however, it is possible that demographic groups may have been missed with this study design. Further, our response rate was low, raising the possibility of unknown selection bias. The study team did not ask participants to differentiate between laboratory-confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis and at-home COVID-19 tests, the latter yielding less accurate results. Additionally, we used the 6-item screener, which may not be a valid measurement of food insecurity for AIAN adults. As experiencing food insecurity likely changed for many households during the pandemic, we developed a variable combining income change and food security as a proxy measure to assess change. While exploratory, this proxy measure may not have accurately assessed change, and additional research exploring food insecurity as a fluctuating (and less stable) variable is necessary. Lastly, we collected data from January to May 2021, about one year after the onset of the pandemic. Access to vaccines varied across the partner sites, and we were not able to distinguish whether participants were not vaccinated due to access or availability. However, our study included a large sample of AIAN adults across the age range from geographically diverse areas, making it the largest and most comprehensive study to date of food insecurity among urban AIAN communities.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.