Introduction
Infant and young child feeding (IYCF) is a set of recommendations to achieve optimal infant and young child feeding practice for 0-23months of age children [
1]. The main component of IYCF practice includes: early initiation of breastfeeding (EIBF), exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) continued breastfeeding through age of 2yrs years and timely, adequate and safe complementary feeding (CF) and consumption of iron rich foods [
2,
3].
IYCF practice is a cornerstone of care for child development mentally and growth physically, but it is often under estimated. Failure to proper infant and young child feeding practice is associated with increased risks of child health. Such as childhood morbidity, mortality, impaired motor, cognitive and behavioral development, slow physical growth, diminished immunity, reduced learning capacity and under-nutrition [
4]. Poor nutrition leads to ill-health and ill-health contributes to further deterioration in nutritional status. 50 − 70% of the burden of diarrheal diseases, measles, malaria, and lower respiratory infections was attributable to malnutrition [
5,
6].
World Health Organization (WHO) and United Nations International Children’s Fund (UNICEF) have developed the Global Strategy for IYCF practice. It recognizes appropriate infant and child feeding practices to improving nutritional status and decreasing infant mortality in all countries [
3]. . Based on this, Ethiopian ministry of health (MOH) established the national nutrition program (NNP II) and the national guideline on adolescent, maternal, infant, and young child nutrition (AMIYCN) to promote optimal feeding practices. The improvement of infant and young child feeding has been the subject of numerous interventions including national nutrition policies, nutrition specific and sensitive intervention efforts. One of the methods for meeting the fundamental needs of the community is to increase agricultural productivity using irrigation systems to provide food security at the household level [
4,
7‐
10].
The problem of IYCF practice is vast, it is estimated that 50% and 34.8% of infants are EIBF and EBF for the first 6 months of life respectively. Complementary foods are often introduced too early or too late and are often nutritionally inadequate and unsafe [
11‐
13]. Which is surprise, only 18% of children received a minimum acceptable diet (MAD), 28% received diverse food groups and 55% were feed with minimum meal frequency (MMF) [
14]. It is well recognized that the size of the problem is high in Africa, 51%, 37–40% and 40%, EBF, MMF and MDD respectively [
5,
15,
16].
Different literatures, governmental and non-governmental reports argue that, IYCF practice is not well practiced globally and nationally [
3,
17,
18]. Even these realities in Ethiopia, there were some studies were conducted to identify the prevalence and associated factors among children less than 2yrs [
19‐
21]. However, most of those studies were conducted in urban area, which is difficult to generalize the findings to rural area and comparative cross-sectional study designs were not implemented. Important variables like house hold food security and attitude were not included. More over the evidence in irrigated and non-irrigated area is scarce or limited. This indicates that, it has a long way to go to fill these gaps. Therefore, the aim of this study is to compare infant and young child feeding practice among 0–23 months of age in irrigated and non-irrigated area.
Methods and materials
Study setting and period
The study was conducted in Dangila Woreda from Dec 1, 2020 to Jun 1, 2020. Dangila was found in Awi zone located 485 Km from the capital city Addis Ababa and 78 Km from regional city Bahir Dar. In the district there were Amhara and Agew elites with a total projected population of 156,169 in the year 2020. It is further divided into 6 sub clusters and 31 kebeles (Kebele is the lowest administrative unit in Ethiopia). Out of 31 kebeles, 10 kebeles were irrigation practiced and 21 kebeles were non-irrigation practiced. In Dangila district, there are 1 primary hospital (governmental), 6 Health Centers and 31 health posts. The district childbearing age groups were 34,825 of the total female population and under-five age groups were 21,145 among these under-two years were 7808 [
22].
Study design and populations
A Community based comparative cross-sectional study was conducted to assess the magnitude of IYCF practices of mothers who had infant and young children 0–23 months of age its associated factors in both irrigation users and non-irrigation user households. The source populations for the study were all mothers who had infant and young children 0–23 months of age residing in Dangila, Woreda and the study populations were all mothers who had infant and young children 0–23 months of age in the selected kebeles. All selected mothers who had infant and young children 0–23 months of age in each selected kebeles were the study unit and included. Mothers who had infant and young children 0–23 months of age those unable to communicate during data collection were excluded.
Sample size determination
The required sample size of the study was determined by using double population proportion formula by considering the following assumption.95% confidence level,80% power, of the study, P1 and P2 the prevalence IYCF practice in irrigated area and non-irrigated area respectively. The two comparison groups population ratio 1:1, prevalence of infant and young child feeding practice (p2 = 43.4%) was taken from the previous studies done at North Achefer Woreda, Amhara, Ethiopia [
21]. For irrigated area the prevalence of infant and young child feeding (p1 = 58.4%) was taken to detect 10% difference from non-irrigated area.
$$\varvec{n}1=\varvec{n}2=\frac{{({\varvec{z}}_{\frac{\varvec{\alpha }}{2}} \sqrt{2\stackrel{-}{\varvec{p}\varvec{q}}} +\varvec{z}\varvec{\beta }\sqrt{{\varvec{p}}_{1{\varvec{q}}_{1} +{\varvec{p}}_{2{\varvec{q}}_{2}}}})}^{2}}{{\varDelta }^{2}}$$
$$\text{W}\text{h}\text{e}\text{r}\text{e} = \stackrel{-}{\varvec{p}} = \frac{{\varvec{p}}_{1} +{\varvec{p}}_{2}}{2}$$
$$\stackrel{-}{\varvec{q}} = 1- \stackrel{-}{\varvec{p}}$$
= 0.484,
= 0.516, p1= 0.534, p2= 0.434
$$\text{q}1=1-\text{p}1=0.466$$
and
$$\text{q}2=1-\text{p}2=0.566$$
,
$$\varDelta =\text{p}1-\text{p}2$$
=0.15
$$n1=\text{n}2=\frac{\left(1.96\right(\sqrt{2\left(0.484 \text{x} 0.516\right)} +0.84\sqrt{0.534 \text{x} 0.466+0.434 \text{x} 0.566} )2 }{(0.534-0.434)2}$$
Therefore, n1 = n2 = 391, the group sample was 782. Finally, by taking 5% non-response rate the total sample size was 823.
Sampling technique and sampling procedure
A stratified random sampling method was implemented to identify irrigated and non-irrigated kebeles. After stratification, three kebeles from irrigated fields and six kebeles from non-irrigated fields were selected by using a simple random sampling technique (the lottery method). A proportional size allocation was used to determine the required sample size for each kebele. Finally, the sample was drawn from a list of infants and young children registered at the health post using a systematic simple random sampling technique.
Variable and operational definition of terms
Infant and young child feeding practice was the dependent variable and Socio-demographic, Maternal and child health service, Household food security, Knowledge and attitude, Women decision power and social support were the independent variables.
Irrigated area
areas where a practice to river diversion, pumping, and small or large dam’s for agricultural cultivation during non-rainfall seasons in addition to rainfall seasons [
23].
Appropriate IYCF practice/good
defined as early initiation of breast feeding within1hr after delivery, exclusive breast feeding to infant age less than 6 months, continue breast feeding 1yrs and above, timely introduction of solid, semi-solid and soft foods in 6–8 months of age, minimum dietary diversity, minimum meal frequency, minimum acceptable diet and consumption of Iron rich foods. A practice that was appropriate for a specific age group received a score of 1, and a practice that was inappropriate received a score of 0. If summed score of the indicators is equal to 4 or above ( above mean), it was considered as appropriate(good) IYCFP and If summed score of the indicators is equal to 3 or below ( below mean), it was considered as inappropriate(good) IYCFP [
2,
24].
Early initiation of breastfeed
Proportion of children born in the last 23 months who were put to the breast within one hour of birth [
25].
Exclusive breastfeeding (EBF)
means that an infant receives only breast milk from his or her mother or a wet-nurse, or expressed breast milk, and no other liquids or solids, not even water, with the exception of oral rehydration solution, drops or syrups consisting of vitamins, minerals supplements or medicines [
13,
25].
Continued breastfeeding
continue breastfeeding for to 1yrs and above or more along with complementary feeding.
Introduction of complementary feeding
The process of introducing, solid, semi-solid or soft foods along with breast milk 6–8 months, when breast milk is no longer sufficient to meet the nutritional requirements of infants and young children [
13].
Minimum dietary diversity
Proportion of children 6–23 months of age who receive foods from 4 or more food groups among the 7 food groups [
25].
Minimum meal frequency
Proportion of breastfed and non-breastfed children 6–23 months of age who receive solid, semi-solid, or soft foods (but also including milk feeds for non-breastfed children. minimum frequency by age defined as: − 2 times for breastfed infants 6–9 months, 3 times for breastfed children 9–24 months and 4 times for non-breastfed children 6-24months. In this study the maximum value 4 was taken to compute meal frequency [
25].
Minimum acceptable diet
Proportion of children 6–23 months of age who receive a mini- mum dietary diversity and minimum meal frequency (apart from breast milk) [
25].
Consumption iron rich foods
Proportion of children 6–23 months of age who receive iron rich foods [
25].
House hold food security
A state in which “all people at all times have both physical and economic access to sufficient food to meet their dietary needs for a productive and healthy life”. Measured by asking in the past four week’s household food status using yes or no questions. 0 = No (skip to Q—) 1 = Yes (1 = rarely (once or twice in the past four weeks, 2 = Sometimes (three to ten times in the past four weeks, 3 = Often (more than ten times in the past four weeks) Calculate the household food Insecurity access category for each household. 1 = Food Secure, 2 = Mildly Food Insecure Access, 3 = Moderately Food Insecure Access, 4 = Severely Food Insecure Access [
26].
Women’s decision making
Participation of women’s from house hold decision making with their husband. In this study the measurement was by taking three question (No = 0, yes = 1) from Demography Health Information System (DHIS), among these questions the cumulative result = 3 women’s decision and 1,2 = no women’s decision making [
27,
28].
Knowledgeable of IYCF
when the respondents correctly answer above mean of questions about IYCF knowledge [
21].
Positive attitude about IYCF
when the respondents agree to favorable questions to appropriate IYCF [
21].
The questionnaires were prepared after reviewing different literature developed for similar purposes by different authors. It was developed in English then translated into the local language (Amharic) and finally retranslated back to English to check its consistency. The questionnaires contained socio-demographic and economic, household food security, knowledge and attitude, maternal, child health service related factors, as well as information on women’s decision making power. Face-to-face interviews were used to collect data. The data collection was conducted in a calm and private environment to ensure confidentiality. The data collectors were four diploma nurses, with one health officer serving as the supervisor.
Data quality control
In order to ensure the accuracy and consistency of the data collected, standardized data collection tools were developed in English and then translated to Amharic, the local language, for data collection and back to English for consistency. The developed questionnaire was pretested on 5% of the total sample size in other sites to evaluate its effectiveness. Prior to the actual data collection, two-day training was given to data collectors and supervisors on the selection procedure of study participants, the purpose of the study, and the steps to provide necessary information to participants. The supervisor and principal investigator monitored and ensured the completeness and quality of data daily. During data collection, the supervisor and principal investigators reviewed and checked the questionnaires for completeness and provided necessary feedback to the data collectors the following morning.
Data processing and analysis
The collected data was processed using Epi-info data version 7 and exported to SPSS version 23 for further analysis. Descriptive statistics such as frequency, percentage, and mean were calculated for different variables. The chi-square test was used to examine the association between two populations. Bi-variable logistic regression analysis was performed to determine the crude association between each independent variable and the outcome variable, and crude odds ratios were calculated. Variables with a p-value < 0.25 were included in the multivariable logistic regression analysis models if they were associated with the dependent variable in the bi-variable analysis. The Hosmer-Lemeshow test was conducted to assess model fitness in the final model, and a p-value > 0.05 was considered to indicate a good fit. Odds ratios with a 95% confidence interval were estimated to evaluate the level of association, and a p-value less than 0.05 was considered significant.
Ethical consideration
Letter of ethical approval was obtained from the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of Bahir Dar University, College of Medicine and Health Sciences (protocol number 00312/2020) and formal permission letter from Dangila administrative council and health office. Before collecting the data, verbal informed consent was taken from all subjects and their legal guardian(s) and the process of verbal informed consent was approved by the ethics committee (Institutional Review Board (IRB) of Bahir Dar University, College of Medicine and Health Sciences). Each study participants were informed about the purpose of the study and participation was voluntary without payment for their participation. Each study participants also were informed that the right to withdraw at any time during the interview. All gathered information were protected from its confidentiality, anonymity was explaining clearly to participant. Except the principal investigator information is not exposed third person.
Discussions
The overall prevalence of good infant and young child feeding practice in this study was 62.5% (95% CI: 34.2, 41.3) and greater than the studies conducted Shashemene [
24], North Achefer [
21] and South Wollo Zone [
29]. It shows statistically significant variation in irrigated and non-irrigated area among mothers who have 0–23 months of age children. The possible explanation for this significance variation might be due to irrigation can have a significant impact on smallholders’ livelihoods and food security. Because of improved productivity and changes in cropping patterns, irrigation can have a direct impact on food availability. When the productivity is increasing, economical assets and living status of the household becomes improved to feed their child. This an advantage to enhances timely introduction of complementary feeding, increases minimum dietary diversity, minimum mealy frequency and minimum acceptable diet results to improving IYCF practice in irrigated area than in non-irrigated area [
30,
31].
The finding of this study revealed that two-third 75% in irrigated and 68.2% in non- irrigated area of respondent’s had early initiation of breast feeding within one hr. after delivery, which was higher than studies conducted in Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (43%) [
32] and Nigeria 34.7% [
33]. The deference might be low health facility delivery and skill birth attendant leads to missing the opportunity of early initiation of breast feeding by health professionals. It might be also health service performance and socio-cultural barriers. On the other hand, the finding of this study was consistent with EDHS survey analysis in Ethiopia (74.3%) [
34] and study conducted in Assella town 70% [
35]. It could be the focus and commitment of the government for child health and nutrition throughout the country is similar and dramatically increment of skill delivery. This might have the opportunity of initiating breast feeding within 1 h after delivery. More than half of the respondents (63.8%) in irrigated and 57.8% in non- irrigated area were exclusively breast feed for the first six months even without water. It was greater than studies conducted in Somaliland (20.47%) [
36], Bishoftu (34.1%) [
37] and East Gojam at Motta (50.1%) [
38]. The discrepancy for this result might be due to socio-economic difference and cultural practice between study subjects in different part of Ethiopia. But lower than studies conducted in Assella town (86.3%) [
35]. It might be residence, living in urban has an access to health service and media exposure to have information about breast feeding than those living in rural. continued breast feeding to 1yrs and above were (95.6%) in irrigated and 93.4% in non-irrigated area, which is higher than study conducted in Jima (75.6%) [
39]. The probability of the difference might be, the majority of the participants in this study were housewives which could increase the likelihood of breastfeeding to their child, as it cost less when they have a poor economic status and they spend much of their time at home which increases the likelihood of continuing to breastfeed. Beyond this mothers in urban area might have workload, to turn their works mothers stop breast feeding early and use formula milk instead of breast milk. Urban mothers have better economical assets than those living in rural, based on this reality mothers in urban setting use breast milk substitution by commercially produced milk, cow milk and other commercially available foods due to easily accessible and ability of purchasing.
In this study timely introduction of complementary feeding at 6 months and above was found to be (54.7%) in irrigated and 40.3% in non-irrigated area, which was close to the study conducted in two Agro-ecological zone of Ethiopia (50.5%) [
40]. On the contrary it was lower than studies conducted in India (72.7%) [
41], Addis Ababa (81.1%) [
42] and Jima (82.9%) [
39]. This might be the difference between Indian and Ethiopian socio-economic level, cultural practice, accessibility of child foods and nutrition action intervention from ministry of health to health professionals, like health extension program implementation in Ethiopia. The difference between urban, rural and in deferent part of Ethiopia about awareness, economical status, health service accessibility and performance have its own influence on IYCF practice. Like ways minimum dietary diversity was (58.3%) in irrigated and 25.9% in non-irrigated area, it was greater than studies done at Northern India (29.6%) [
43] and in Kenya (32–40%) [
44], in Shashemene16.1% [
24], in two Agro-ecological zone of Ethiopia (22.2%) [
40], EDHS 2016 survey analysis (14.9%) [
42] and Assella town (26.6%) [
35]. This fact might be the study including irrigated area, enabling variety of food groups to be easily accessible and improve or growth of household economic status to feed diversified foods. Another reason might be, optimization of health extension program and community based neonatal care implementation was supported by Path finder from study area. Due to these facts the minimum dietary diversity becomes increased. Minimum meal frequency were (72.8%) in irrigated and 44.1% in non-irrigated area. This might be the level of awareness and media access about the frequency of complementary feeding. Minimum acceptable diet was (44.9%) in irrigated and 24% in non-irrigated, which was lower than as compared to studies conducted in India (45.8) [
41] and Addis Ababa (65.1%) [
42]. The minimum acceptable diet was greater than in India (19.5%) [
41] and two Agro-ecological Zone of Ethiopia (12%) [
40]. This discrepancy might be due irrigation scheme, socio-economic and cultural practice between country and study setting.
A significant association was observed between mothers’ participation on household decision making and good IYCF practice in both irrigated and non-irrigated area. Different studies support this study [
45‐
47]. The prevalence of IYCF practice was significantly higher among those who had women’s decision making as compared to those who do not women’s decision making. The possible explanation might be when the mothers have decision making power on IYCF they can get autonomy to follow the appropriate child feeding practice and care. In addition to this, mothers who had participation on household decision making has freedom to visit health facilities for child health service with IYCF education [
47,
48].
In this study PNC follow up was independently predictor to infant and young child feeding practice among 0-23months of age children. Mothers who had PNC follow up are receiving information to breast feeding, complementary feeding and diversified foods within cooking demonstration. Beside to this, health professionals may show practical demonstrations and role models for breast feeding and complementary feeding. Furthermore, it might be the strength of health extension worker implementation to maternal health service packages including postnatal service. This finding is supported by previous studies conducted in Assella [
35], Shashemene [
24].
Knowledge and attitude were significantly associated to infant and young child feeding practice. Mothers who were knowledgeable and mothers who had positive attitude were more likely practice infant and young child feeding practice. This might be those mothers having information and understanding about the issue of IYCF components can have a better chance of good IYCF practice. The same is true mothers who has positive inclination toward IYCF have a chance to increase IYCF practice. This result is supported by the previous studies conducted in Saudi Arabia [
32], Uganda [
49], in North west Ethiopia [
48] and in Kenya [
44].
Primarily the result of this study helps to improve IYCF feeding practice and child health. In addition to this, the finding of this research can also serve other researchers, educators, policy makers, governmental and nongovernmental organizations as a step point for initiation of activities and strengthening the utilization of available resources in order to decrease the child mortality ratio of our country which is much higher than the target.
Strength and limitation of the study
The strength of this study was completing the on scheduled time bound and doing community based study during the era of covid-19 following prevention principles. The study has limitations. There might be a social desirability bias and a recall bias during answering of questions related to dietary practices and on house hold food security.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.