Intestinal parasitic infections (IPIs) are public health problems widely distributed in the world and cause significant morbidity and mortality; many of which occur among women of reproductive age. IPIs caused by helminthes and protozoan parasites are common among pregnant women. Data on the national pooled prevalence of intestinal parasites and associated factors during pregnancy is not documented well in Ethiopia. This review aims at summarizing evidences on the burden of IPIs and associated factors among pregnant women in Ethiopia.
Methods
Published and unpublished studies were thoroughly searched at MEDLINE/PubMed, EMBASE, Google Scholar, CINAHL, Cochrane library and Science Direct. In addition, repositories of Addis Ababa, Gondar and Jimma Universities were searched. Eligible studies were selected following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guideline. The pooled prevalence of intestinal parasites and summary odds ratios (ORs) were determined with 95 % confidence intervals (CI). Sub-groups analyses were done based on study region, types of parasites, methods of stool examination and study setting. The statistical analyses were performed using STATA version 14.0 software.
Results
Among 168 retrieved studies, 31 studies with a total population of 12,118 pregnant women were included. The estimated pooled prevalence of IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia was 27.32 % (95 % CI: 20.61, 33.87 %). In the subgroup analysis, Oromia and Amhara regions had the highest prevalence with a 29.78 % (95 % CI: 15.97, 43.60) and 29.63 % (95 % CI: 15.37, 43.89); respectively. In addition, studies conducted in the community showed higher prevalence than institution based studies (49.93 % Vs 24.84 %; respectively). The most prevalent type of intestinal parasite identified were Hookworm followed by Ascaris lumbricoides with a pooled prevalence of 11.2 and 10.34 %, respectively. In our analysis; residence, being bare footed, lack of hand washing habit and eating uncooked/raw vegetables were significantly associated with IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia.
Conclusions
Prevalence of IPIs during pregnancy is relatively high in Ethiopia. Poor hygienic practices were identified as risk factors. Based on our finding, targeted preventive measures shall be considered so as to prevent morbidity and mortality due to IPIs.
Hinweise
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Abkürzungen
OR
odds ratio
CI
confidence interval
IPIs
Intestinal parasitic infections
IUGR
Intrautrine growth retardation
STH
soil-transmitted helminths
PC
preventive chemotherapy
PRISMA
preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta analysis
SNNPR
southern national, nationalities and peoples region
ANC
antenatal care
Background
IPIs are public health problems widely distributed throughout the world causing significant morbidity, many of which occur among women of reproductive age. Pregnant women are one of high-risk population for these infections [1]. IPIs caused by helminths and protozoan parasites are common among pregnant women and experience more severe infections [2]. However, the severity depends on different factors, including parasitic load, species, inter-pregnancy intervals, nutritional status, poor hygiene and lack of safe drinking water, climate, poverty, immunity status, and the presence of co-existing infections [2‐8].
Physiological changes during pregnancy modify the maternal immunity that brings tolerance to the growing fetus and susceptibility to different infections. IPIs are common during pregnancy that aggravates the effect leading to “a double burden to carry” and causes serious problems to the mother as well as to the embryo/fetus [1, 9]. Moreover, IPIs might cause anemia; induce deficiencies of iron, total energy, protein, folate and zinc all of which results in low pregnancy weight gain and intrauterine growth retardation (IUGR), greater risks of infection, low birth weight (LBW) and higher perinatal mortality rates [1, 10‐13].
Anzeige
IPIs are reportedly identified as the leading causes of maternal mortality in developing countries especially in the tropics and subtropics [9, 14, 15]. A recent systematic review and Meta-analysis on global prevalence and associated risk factors of IPIs revealed that IPIs in pregnant women is high especially in low and middle income countries [16]. Many other studies were conducted to assess the burden of soil-transmitted helminths (STH) and their effect during pregnancy. Preventive chemotherapy (PC) was introduced as a control program in order to reduce the burden of the infection, but it has been neglected for at-risk women of reproductive ages. The overall coverage of PC was reported as less than 75 % in Ethiopia [17] howing the possibility of the high burden of intestinal parasites. Although it is expected to be high, data on the national pooled prevalence of intestinal parasites and associated factors during pregnancy is not yet documented well in Ethiopia. Therefore; this systematic review and Meta-analysis aims at providing summarized evidence on the burden of IPIs and associated factors among pregnant women in Ethiopia.
Methods
Data Bases and Search strategy
Both Published and unpublished studies regarding the magnitude of IPIs and associated factors among pregnant women in Ethiopia were thoroughly searched by two authors (ZA and AM) at databases of MEDLINE/PubMed, EMBASE, Google Scholar, CINAHL, Cochrane Library and Science Direct. Additionally, repositories of Addis Ababa University, University of Gondar and Jimma University were searched manually to get unpublished student research works related to the topic. Reference lists of eligible studies were checked to maximize the inclusion of relevant studies. The search was not bounded by year of publication. As a result, all articles published and/or reported up to 25th May, 2020 were included. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) checklist was strictly followed to select potential studies (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1
PRISMA chart flow showing article selection process
×
“Prevalence” “Magnitude”, “Epidemiology”, “Intestinal Parasite”, “Intestinal parasitosis”, “Helmenthiasis”, “Hookworm” “ Ascaris lumbricoides OR A. lumbericoids”, “Schistosomia Mansoni OR S. mansoni”, “ Giardia lamblia OR G. lamblia”, “ Strongyloides stercolaris OR S. stercolaris”, “Entamoeba histolytica OR E. hisolytica”, “ Trichuris trichiura OR T. trichiura”, “ Hymenolepis nana OR H. nana”, “Taenia species”, “Enterobius vermicularis OR E. vermicularis”, “Associated Factors”, “Determinants” “Pregnant Women”, “Pregnant Mother” and “Ethiopia” were the key searching terms employed independently and/ or in combination by Boolean operators: “OR” or/and “AND” to bring key concepts together to identify relevant papers. Particularly, studies from MEDLINE/PubMed database were searched by using the following Medical Science Heading (MeSH) terms: (((“parasitic infection“[All Fields] OR “intestinal parasite“[All Fields]) OR (“intestinal diseases, parasitic/epidemiology” [MeSH Terms] OR “intestinal diseases, parasitic“[MeSH Terms])) AND ((((“pregnant women” [All Fields] OR “pregnant mothers“[All Fields]) OR “pregnant mothers attending anc“[All Fields]) AND “pregnant women attending anc“[All Fields]) OR ((“pregnant women“[MeSH Terms] OR “pregnant women/epidemiology“[MeSH Terms]) OR “mothers“[MeSH Terms]))) AND “Ethiopia“[All Fields]. EndNote X7 was also used to manage duplication of articles.
Inclusion criteria
Language of publication/written: English.
Year of publication/report: Up to May 25th of 2020.
Study design: observational studies (cross-sectional, case-control and cohort).
Outcome: magnitude of IPIs and/ or associated factors.
Study population: Pregnant women.
Study setting: At (institution or community based).
Study country: Ethiopia.
Diagnostic modality: Stool examination (either wet mount or concentration or both).
Type of parasite: Either protozoa or helminthes or both
Types of articles: Both published and unpublished.
Types of publication: Peer reviewed, full text articles.
Anzeige
Exclusion criteria
Articles which failed to report the number of study participants and number of cases.
Inaccessible full text articles due to non-responsiveness of the corresponding authors upon frequent inquiry through email by two authors (ZA and AM).
Systematic reviews and meta-analysis.
Articles that did not provide calculable prevalence or ORs for associated factors.
Data extraction
Data pertaining authors' to name with publication year, study period, study design, study setting, study area/region, technique of stool examination, sample size, numbers of pregnant women infected with intestinal parasites and or prevalence of IPIs and species of parasites isolated were extracted from the eligible articles using Microsoft Excel 2013 sheet especially designed for this study. Similarly, a separate data extraction tool was developed for each identified associated factors which contain authors name and publication year. Two by wo tables were also employed to obtain the odds ratio from each study. All associated factors reported by at least two studies were included for pooled analysis.
Quality assessment
Three authors, (ZA, AM and HD), rated the quality of included studies utilizing Newcastle – Ottawa Scale which enables to assess the quality of each article by their methodological merit, comparability caliber and outcome excellence [18]. In due process, arguments between the authors were settled through in-depth discussion and articles were included upon consensus.
Statistical analysis
The extracted data were transferred to STATA software version 14.0 to analyze the pooled prevalence of IPIs and odds ratios of the associated factors. Heterogeneity among included studies was assessed using percentage of variance (I2) and P-values. Random effect model was employed to estimate the pooled prevalence of intestinal parasites and summary odds ratios of factors associated with infections.
Begg’s rank test and Egger’s regression intercept tests were also carried out to indicate the correlation between the effect sizes and sampling variance in order to determine publication bias.
Subgroup analysis was done based on study region, types of parasites (helminthic, protozoa or both species), technique of stool examination (formalin-ether concentration, direct wet mount, or both and others) and study setting (institution or community based).
Protocols and registration
This systematic review and Meta-analysis is registered on PROSPERO under a registration number of CRD42020189115 and can be accessed at https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO.
Results
Characteristics of the included articles
A total of 31 studies were included in this systematic review and meta-analysis. The number of pregnant women participated in the studies ranged from 85 to 783 [19, 20] constituting a total population of 12,118. The reported prevalence of IPIs was ranging from 7.3 % [21, 22] to 76.0 % [20]. Twenty nine studies [4, 5, 10, 12, 19‐43] were cross-sectional while the rest two were case-controls [11, 44]. The studies were published from 2013 up to 2020. Regarding geographical distribution, 10 studies were reported from Amhara region [4, 10, 20, 25, 33, 34, 36‐38, 40], 8 from SNNPR [23, 26‐29, 42‐44], 8 from Oromia [5, 11, 12, 24, 32, 35, 39, 41], 4 from Tigray [19, 22, 30, 31] and One from Addis Ababa [21] (Table 1).
Table 1
General characteristic of the included articles for systematic review and meta-analysis pertaining magnitude and associated factors of IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia
Pooled prevalence of intestinal parasitic infection among pregnant women in Ethiopia
The estimated pooled prevalence of IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia is 27.32 % (95 % CI: 20.61, 33.87; I2 = 98.9 % p = < 0.001) (Fig. 2). Statistically significant heterogeneity was observed in the estimation of this pooled prevalence. Begg’s rank and Egger’s regression tests were carried out to statistically determine publication bias [45]. Based on the results, absence of significant publication bias was declared objectively with P = 0.068 and P = 0.063, consecutively.
Fig. 2
Forest plot of the pooled prevalence of IPIs among pregnant mothers in Ethiopia
×
IPIs and anemia
Among the included articles 16 of them [5, 10‐13, 21, 22, 25, 26, 28, 33, 35, 37, 38, 41, 44] reported that IPIs are significantly associated with anemia during pregnancy while 4 studies [27, 29, 34, 43] revealed that there is no association between occurrence of anemia among pregnant mothers who contracted IPIs. A single study disclosed that IPIs during pregnancy are significantly associated with maternal under-nutrition [36].
Types of intestinal parasite
In this study, the most prevalent type of intestinal parasite identified was Hookworm followed by Ascaris lumbricoides with a prevalence of 11.12 % (95 %CI: 8.21, 14.02) and 10.34 (95 %CI: 7.09, 13.59); respectively. The least reported parasites are Enterobius vermicularis and Taenia species (Table 2).
Table 2
Pattern of Intestinal parasites among pregnant women
Types of parasites
Species of parasite
No of studies
Pooled prevalence
(95 % CI)
I2
P-values
Helminthic
Hookworm
22
11.2 % (8.21, 14.02)
97.3 %
< 0.001
Ascaris lumbricoides
20
10.34 % (7.09, 13.59)
97.9 %
< 0.001
Schistosomia mansoni
10
3.42 % (1.82, 5.01)
95.3 %
< 0.001
Strongyloides stercolaris
5
1.56 % (0.31, 2.82)
91.7 %
< 0.001
Trichuris trichiura
11
2.85 % (1.76, 3.94)
84.3 %
< 0.001
Hymenolepis nana
8
1.09 % (0.56, 1.63)
50.8 %
0.047
Taenia species
7
0.94 % (0.57, 1.31)
65.4 %
0.022
Enterobius vermicularis
4
0.81 % (0.02, 1.63)
58.31
0.031
Protozoa
Giardia lamblia
13
5.25 % (3.41, 7.09)
89.5 %
< 0.001
Entamoeba histolytica
11
6.89 % (4.07, 9.71)
94.0 %
< 0.001
Mixed
Mixed infection
11
7.08 % (4.18, 9.98)
95.6 %
< 0.001
Subgroup analysis
A subgroup analysis based on study regions revealed that Oromia had the highest prevalence estimate accounting 29.78 % (95 % CI: 15.97, 43.60) closely followed by Amhara region 29.63 % (95 % CI: 15.37, 43.89), Tigray region 27.74 % (95 % CI: 6.56, 48.93) and SNNPR 24.23 % (95 % CI: 17.61, 30.85) (Fig. 3). Another subgroup analysis by study setting showed higher prevalence in studies done in the community than studies done institutions with a pooled prevalence of 49.93 % (95 %CI: 20.49, 79.37) and 24.84 % (95 %CI: 19.51, 30.17); respectively (Fig. 4). A similar analysis depending on the technique of stool examination indicates a combination of formalin-ether concentration and direct wet mount reported a higher prevalence of IPIs (35.99 %; 95 % CI: 26.22 ,45.78) than studies that used a single stool examination to diagnose intestinal parasites (Fig. 5).
Fig. 3
Forest plot of subgroup analysis based on regions
Fig. 4
Forest plot of subgroup analysis based on study setting
Fig. 5
Forest plot of subgroup analysis based on techniques of stool examination
×
×
×
Anzeige
Factors associated with intestinal parasitic infection among pregnant women in Ethiopia
Our analysis identified that residence area, being bare footed, hand washing habit and eating uncooked/raw vegetables have significant association with the occurrence of IPIs among pregnant women. Pregnant women from rural areas were 6.3 more likely to develop IPIs when compared to urban dweller pregnant mothers (OR = 6.31; 95 % CI: 20, 32.99; P = 0.002) (Fig. 6 A). Likewise, a barefooted women were 2.79 times more likely to be infected with IPIs than those who wore shoes (OR = 2.79; 95 % CI: 1.82, 9.48; P = 0.01) (Fig. 6B). Similarly; pregnant women who had no hand washing habit and who consumed uncooked/raw vegetables were more likely to be infected with intestinal parasites compared to their counterparts (OR = 3.02 ; 95 % CI: 1.64, 14.33; P < 0.001) (Fig. 6 C) and (OR = 1.24; 95 % CI: 1.65, 2.37; P < 0.001) (Fig. 6 C); respectively.
Fig. 6
Forest plot indicating odds ratio of factors associated with intestinal parasitic infection among pregnant women in Ethiopia. (A) Residence, (B) Bare foot, (C) Hand washing habit and (D) consume raw vegetables.
×
Discussion
Women living in low-income countries are at a higher risk of acquiring IPIs that leads to severe anemia. This scenario will put both the mother and the baby at higher risk of morbidity and mortality. This study was conducted to summarize the current evidence of IPIs and associated factors among pregnant women in Ethiopia.
31 eligible studies that have quantified the magnitude of IPIs were included. Accordingly, the pooled prevalence of IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia was estimated to be 27.32 %. However, this pooled prevalence is less than studies from Brazil, where 57.1 % pregnant women were harbored at least one parasite [46],Cameroon (31.91 %) [47],India (42.67 %) [48] and Colombia (41 %) [49].
But, our finding is higher than reports from Kenya (24 and 13.8 %) [50, 51], Ghana (23.0 %) [52], Nigeria (20.8 %) [53], Sudan (13.0 %) [54] and other multicounty studies (20 %) [55]. These differences might be attributed to socioeconomic status, poor hygiene and sanitary facilities, weather, climate and environmental factors in the countries. It is also estimated that more than one-third of Sub-Sahara population are infected with at least one species of helminths [56]. Though pregnant women are vulnerable to IPIs, being pregnant was not yet regarded as a significant risk factor for acquiring enteric parasitic infections in Benin [57].
Anzeige
Hookworm and Ascariasis infection were the most prevalent in this review. Similarly, a global systematic review and meta-analysis identified Hookworm and Ascaris lumbricoides as the leading helminths affecting pregnant women while Giardia lamblia and Entamoeba histolytica lead protozal infection [16]. The most prevalent types of intestinal parasite identified among pregnant women were Ascaris lumbricoides followed and Hookworm in Kenya and Benin [51, 57]. Another study in Kenya identified Hookworm as one of the most common infestation at the first ANC visit [50]. Giardia lamblia and Ascaris lumbricoides in Colombia [49], Schistosoma mansoni and Trichuris Trichiura in Ghana [58] were the most prevalent parasitic infections. Trichuris trichiura was reported as a predominant parasite followed by A. lumbricoides in other study [59] and A. lumbricoides was dominantly identified parasites followed by T. trichiura Venezuela [60].
In addition, our subgroup analysis indicated that the rates of IPIs among pregnant women varied across different regions of the country, study settings and technique of stool examination. As a result, the prevalence is higher in Oromia and Amhara regional state.
Studies conducted in the community showed a higher prevalence than studies done in institutions with a pooled prevalence of 49.93 % (95 %CI: 20.49, 79.37) and 24.84 % (95 %CI: 19.51, 30.17); respectively. This might be related with inadequate water supply and poor sanitation [61]. On the other hand, studies that used a combination of formalin-ether concentration and direct wet mount stool examination techniques reported a higher prevalence of IPIs (35.99 %; 95 %CI: 26.22, 45.78) than studies that used a single stool examination to diagnose intestinal parasites. This evidenced that the detection rate of intestinal parasites improved by concentrating stool samples [39].
Different factors for IPIs were analyzed and the pooled odds ratio was summarized. As a result, rural residents, being bare footed, poor hand washing habits and eating uncooked/raw vegetables have significant association with the occurrence of IPIs among pregnant women in Ethiopia. Similarly, the high occurrence of parasitic infection has been related to the poor hygiene condition [46] and residence area [16, 47] in other studies. It is also evidenced that factors influencing the continuous transmission of IPIs in sub-Saharan countries include poor sanitation and hygiene and non-availability of potable water for domestic use [53]. In line with our analysis, pregnant women who practiced hand washing regularly had lesser infection in India, Kenya and Benin [48, 51, 57].
Contradicting to this view, the prevalence of intestinal parasites was almost same in both rural and urban pregnant women in India [48]. The finding of this review was consistent with studies in Benin where pregnant women who consume uncooked/raw vegetables from food vendors were more likely to be infected with intestinal parasites. However, in contrary to our review result; being barefooted was not significantly affect the prevalence of IPIs [57]. Consuming unwashed vegetable and being barefooted were associated with IPIs among pregnant women [59].
In line with a review conducted in Sub-Saharan countries [53, 56], we also found that the odds of IPIs were found to be higher in pregnant mothers living in rural areas. Because, place of residence, usually determines people’s lifestyles, income, social and cultural activities, and most notably their health conditions.
Strengths and limitations
Our meta-analysis tried to elucidate a national figure on prevalence of IPIs during pregnancy. It included studies done both at institution and community settings. Both cros-sectional and case control stud designs were included which enabled us to identify temporal relationship among predictors and outcome variables. As per our search, this is the first analysis done in Ethiopia. However, this meta-analysis is done only on 5 regions of Ethiopia and as a result; the whole image of the problem might be under represented.
Conclusions
Our systematic review and meta-analysis has estimated a high prevalence of IPIs during pregnancy in Ethiopia. The result indicates the need for priority interventions targeted to improve maternal health during pregnancy. Investing in maternal health is also a key strategy to reduce low birth weight and preterm birth. Apart from socio- economic factors, IPIs during pregnancy are related with poor hygienic practices, being barefooted and eating habits of raw vegetables. Therefore, an optimal personal hygiene and developing shoes wearing habit by the mothers is essential to meet both maternal and child requirements and reduce adverse health consequences in addition to spaced pregnancy. To prevent anemia, pregnant women are advised to take iron, folate supplements, eat iron-rich foods, and prevent intestinal worms.
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge all academic staffs of Addis Ababa University, Debre Tabor University and Bahir Dar University who helped us in this particular study.
Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
‘Not applicable’.
Consent for publication
‘Not applicable’.
Competing interest
‘The authors declare that they have no competing interests’.
Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Trastuzumab deruxtecan scheint auch jenseits von Lungenkrebs gut gegen solide Tumoren mit HER2-Mutationen zu wirken. Dafür sprechen die Daten einer offenen Pan-Tumor-Studie.
Frauen mit lokalem oder metastasiertem Brustkrebs, die Statine einnehmen, haben eine niedrigere krebsspezifische Mortalität als Patientinnen, die dies nicht tun, legen neue Daten aus den USA nahe.
Welche Antibiotika darf man bei unkomplizierter Zystitis verwenden und wovon sollte man die Finger lassen? Welche pflanzlichen Präparate können helfen? Was taugt der zugelassene Impfstoff? Antworten vom Koordinator der frisch überarbeiteten S3-Leitlinie, Prof. Florian Wagenlehner.
Das Risiko, nach einem Gestationsdiabetes einen Typ-2-Diabetes zu entwickeln, hängt nicht nur von der Zahl, sondern auch von der Reihenfolge der betroffenen Schwangerschaften ab.
Update Gynäkologie
Bestellen Sie unseren Fach-Newsletter und bleiben Sie gut informiert – ganz bequem per eMail.
