Introduction
Arguments in favor of abstention from milk and dairy products after dental procedure | Frequency Germany | Frequency International |
---|---|---|
a. Milk and dairy products increase risk of infection | 38.6% **a,b | 19.8% ***a,b |
b. Lactic acid bacteria may adversely affect wound healing | 30.7% **a, *b | 15.8% ***a,b, **c |
c. Possible adverse effect on development of coagulum, coagulum surface may disintegrate | 23.7% *a | 12.2% ***a, **b |
d. Possible reduced efficiency of antibiotics | 5.3% **b | 2.7% |
e. Dairy products my cause tuberculosis infection (specifically unpasteurized raw milk products) | 1.8% | 0.9% |
f. milk may react with resorbable suture (adhesion, mucous congestion) | 1.8% | 0.9% *c |
Material and methods
Literature review
German pilot study and international survey
Results
Literature review
First author, year | Study type | Probiotic | Findings (effect of probiotics on wound) |
---|---|---|---|
Valdez, 2005 [7] | Animal model study and in vitro study | L. plantarum | Enhanced wound healing |
Brachkova, 2011 [9] | Animal model study | L. plantarum | Reduction of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in wound |
Nasrabadi, 2011 [10] | Animal model study | L. brevis and L. plantarum | Decreased inflammation and improved wound healing |
Jones, 2012 [11] | Animal model study | L. fermentum | Enhanced wound healing |
Poutahidis, 2013 [12] | Animal model study | L. reuteri | Enhanced wound healing |
Partlow, 2016 [14] | Animal model study | S. bouladrii | Unimproved wound healing, unchanged microbiome |
Argenta, 2016 [15] | Animal model study | L. plantarum | Decreased mortality and production of inflammatory markers (TNF-α, IL 6 and 10), less septicemic accumulation in organs |
Satish, 2017 [16] | Animal model study | L. plantarum | Reduced severity and length of infection and collagen concentration (less scarring) |
Oryan, 2018 [17] | Animal model study | S. cerevisiae | Enhanced burn wound healing |
Ong, 2019 [18] | Animal model study | L. plantarum | Enhanced wound healing, suppressed Staphylococcus aureus infection at wound |
Tagliari, 2019 [19] | Animal model study | L. paracasei, B. lactis, L. rhamnosus, L. acidophilus | Enhanced wound healing, increased collagen production |
Khodaii, 2019 [20] | Animal model study | L. reuteri | Enhanced collagen production, accelerated wound healing |
Han, 2019 [21] | Animal model study | L. reuteri | Promoted wound healing through activation of GMSCs |
Han, 2020 [26] | Animal model study | L. reuteri | Inhibited inflammation and enhanced wound healing through promoting MSCs |
Mohtashami, 2020 [23] | Animal model study | L. bulgaricus, L. plantarum | Enhanced wound healing |
Ong, 2020 [24] | Animal model study | L. plantarum | Suppressed Staphylococcus aureus, and thereby improved wound healing |
Moreira, 2021 [25] | Animal model study | L. johnsonii, L. paracasei, and L. rhamnosus | Promoted skin wound closure and decreased scar formation and inflammation |
First author, year | Study type | Patients: probiotic/control group | Probiotic | Findings: Effect of probiotics on wound |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rayes, 2002 [27] | Prospective | 30/30 | L. plantarum | Incidence of infections significantly lower |
Kanazawa, 2005 [28] | RCT | 21/23 | L. casei, B. breve | Decreased quantity of pathogens in symbiotic group, thereby less surgical-site infections |
Sugawara, 2006 [29] | RCT | 40/41 | L. casei, B. breve | Incidence of postoperative infectious complications lower |
Rayes, 2007 [30] | RCT | 40/40 | P. pentosaceus, L. mesenteroides, L. paracasei subsp. paracasei, L. plantarum | Incidence of postoperative bacterial infections significantly lower with Lactobacilli |
Peral, 2009 [31] | RCT | 38/42 | L. plantarum | Non-infected 3rd-degree burn: no effect Infected 2nd-degree burn: suppressed pathogens, enhanced wound healing Infected 3rd-degree burn: improved wound healing |
Peral, 2010 [32] | Pilot study | 34/0 | L. plantarum | Decreased wound bacterial load and stimulated wound healing |
Liu, 2011 [38] | RCT | 50/50 | L. plantarum, L. acidophilus, B. longum | Enhanced transepithelial resistance, reduced blood enteropathogenic bacteria, fewer surgical site infections |
Usami, 2011 [33] | RCT | 32/29 | L. casei, B. breve | No infectious complications |
Zhang, 2012 [34] | RCT | 30/30 | B. longum, L. acidophilus | Decreased postoperative occurrence of infectious complications |
Kotzampassi, 2015 [35] | RCT | 84/80 | L. acidophilus, L. plantarum, B. lactis, S. boulardii | Decrease in incidence of postoperative pneumonia and of surgical site infections |
El Ghazely, 2016 [36] | RCT | 20/20 | L. fermentum, L. delbrueckii | Reduction in incidence of infections, wound healing enhanced |
Komatsu, 2016 [37] | RCT | 168/194 | L. casei, B. breve | Synbiotics suppress increase in potentially pathogenic species, less surgical site infections (not significant) |
Wälivaara, 2019 [39] | RCT | 32/32 | L. reuteri | No significant impact of probiotic application on wound healing after third molar extraction |
First author, year | Study type | Dairy product | Sample size Treatment/control group | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rodrigues, 2005 [8] | Animal model study (rats) | Kefir | 5 groups of 5 members | Kefir enhanced wound healing |
Badr, 2012 [40] | Animal model study (diabetic mice) | Whey protein | 40/20 | Whey protein enhanced wound healing in diabetic mice |
Schutt, 2014 [41] | Cross-over study (clinical diagnosis) | Ice cream | 6/6 | Consumption of dairy products had no influence on microbiome in oral cavity |
Rouabhia, 2017 [42] | In vitro study | Yogurt | Yogurt enhanced gingival epithelial cell growth and keratin K5 production | |
Hemmati, 2018 [13] | Animal model study (rabbit) | Low-fat milk ointment | 6 groups of 6 members | Low-fat milk ointment enhanced wound healing rate |
Oryan, 2018 [17] | Animal model study (burn wound from rats) | Kefir | 12 | Improvement of angiogenesis and proliferation of fibroblasts |
German pilot study and international survey
Specialization | Contacted Germany | Response rate Germany | Response rate Germany | Contacted International | Response rate International | Response rate International |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
OMFS | 17 | 13 | 76.5% | 61 | 45 | 73.8% |
Oral surgeon | 30 | 25 | 83.3% | 6 | 6 | 100.0% |
Dentist/periodontist | 103 | 76 | 73.8% | 76 | 57 | 75.0% |
Total | 150 | 114 | 76.0% | 143 | 108 | 75.5% |
Country | Guidelines or recommendations | Comments |
---|---|---|
Argentina | Yes/no | Avoidance only in the older generation of surgeons because of resorbable suture materials used formerly such as catgut and because of increasing bacteria level and metabolism |
Austria | Yes | |
Belgium (Flemish) | Yes | Whenever patient is unable to clean the mouth properly: avoidance of milk-based products in the first week to avoid fermentation and bad oral odor |
Belgium (Walloon) | No | No restrictions. On the contrary: milkshakes with eggs and sugar and cream (calories and proteins) recommended |
Brazil | No | |
Chile | No | The protocols issued by universities and Health Ministry do not avoid milk or dairy. Also, the Universidad Austral in the city of Valdivia (area with greatest German influence) does not make recommendations to avoid milk or dairy after oral surgery |
China | No | The older generation recommended to avoid food products which are infested with bacteria rapidly, i.e., within a few hours or with change in quality difficult to detect. With the wide availability of frozen food and refrigerators, foods can be stored for a much longer time without degenerating |
Denmark | No | |
England | No | |
Estonia | No | |
France | No | |
Germany | Yes | |
India | No | Consumption of milk and dairy products recommended after all minor oral surgery procedures. A usual practice is asking the patient to start having ice creams around 30 min to 1 h post any minor surgical procedure |
Iran | No | |
Israel | No | |
Italy | No | Some surgeons suggest a liquid or soft and creamy diet (yoghurt or milk shakes in particular) |
Japan | No | |
Lithuania | No | |
Malaysia | No | |
Netherlands | No | |
Norway | No | |
Portugal | No | |
Slovenia | No | |
Slovakia | No | |
Sweden | No | |
Switzerland | Yes | |
Spain | No | |
Thailand | No | Patients who cannot chew well after receiving oral surgery are recommended to eat ice cream or yoghurt. |
Yemen | No | |
USA | No |
Region | Dentistry specialty | Recommendation to abstain from milk/dairy products | No recommendation to abstain from milk/dairy products |
---|---|---|---|
Germany | OMFS (n = 13) | 30.8% (n = 4)*a | 69.2% (n = 9) |
Germany | Oral surgeon (n = 25) | 48.0% (n = 12) | 52.0% (n = 13) |
Germany | OMFS/oral surgeon (n = 38) | 42.1% (n = 16)*b | 57.9% (n = 22) |
Germany | General dentist (n = 76) | 64.9% (n = 49)*a,b | 35.1% (n = 27) |
Germany | Total (n = 114) | 56.1% (n = 64)**c | 43.9% (n = 50) |
International | Total (n = 108) | 4.6% (n = 5)**c | 95.4% (n = 103) |
Source of Information | Dentists (international + Germany) (n = 133) | Specialist dentists for oral surgery (international + Germany) (n = 31) | OMFS (international + Germany) (n = 58) | Total (international + Germany) (n = 222) | Total (Germany only) (n = 114) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Teaching at University | 29.3% (n = 39) ***a | 41.9% (n = 13) ***b | 0% (n = 0) ***b | 23.4% (n = 52) ***c | 45.6% (n = 52) ***c |
Recommendations by other dentists - Lactobacilli could affect wound healing | 12.8% (n = 17) *a | 22.6% (n = 7) **b *a | 1.7% (n = 1) **b | 11.3%* (n = 25) *c | 21.1%* (n = 24) *c |
Personal experience - To avoid fermentation and bad oral odor - Dairy products could increase the bacteria level and metabolism - (old) resorbable suture materials could resorb faster | 12.0% (n = 16) | 38.7% (n = 12) **b | 8.6% (n = 5) **b | 14.9% (n = 33) | 25.4% (n = 29) |
Specialist literature | 6.8% (n = 9) **d | 25.8% (n = 8) ***b **d | 0 = % (n = 0) ***b | 7.7% (n = 17) **c | 18.4% (n = 21) **c |
Not specified | 42.9% (n = 57) | 19.4% (n = 6) | 70.7% (n = 41) | 46.8% (n = 104) | 0% (n = 0) |