Background
Methods
Phase 1: getting started
Phase 2: deciding what is relevant to the initial interest
Date: 28.09.2021 | ||
Results: 1733 | ||
# | Query | Results |
S1 | (MH “Aged”) OR (MH “Aged, 80 and Over”) OR (MH “Frail Elderly”) | 881,663 |
S2 | (MH “Dementia”) OR (MH “Dementia Patients”) | 44,371 |
S3 | (MH “Geriatrics”) | 5,733 |
S4 | TI ( ((aged or old*) N1 (people or women or person* or men or immigrant* or minorit* or parent*))) OR AB ( ((aged or old*) N1 (people or women or person* or men or immigrant* or minorit* or parent*))) | 95,630 |
S5 | TI ( (senior or seniors or geriatric or elder or elders or elderly or dement* or aging or ageing or “old age”)) OR AB ( (senior or seniors or geriatric or elder or elders or elderly or dement* or aging or ageing or “old age”)) | 250,262 |
S6 | TI old* | 103,533 |
S7 | S1 OR S2 OR S3 OR S4 OR S5 OR S6 | 1,058,844 |
S8 | (MH “Caregivers”) OR (MH “Caregiver Burden”) OR (MH “Caregiver Attitudes”) OR (MH “Caregiver Support”) | 48,117 |
S9 | TI ( ( caregiver* or “care giver*” or caretaker* or “care taker*” or carer*)) OR AB ( ( caregiver* or “care giver*” or caretaker* or “care taker*” or carer*)) | 70,794 |
S10 | (MH “Adult Children”) OR (MH “Family”) OR (MH “Family Relations”) OR (MH “Nuclear Family”) OR (MH “Daughters”) OR (MH “Siblings”) OR (MH “Sons”) OR (MH “Spouses”) OR (MH “Parents”) | 119,876 |
S11 | (MH “Patient-Family Relations”) OR (MH “Fathers”) OR (MH “Mothers”) OR (MH “Significant Other”) | 40,247 |
S12 | S10 OR S11 | 153,957 |
S13 | (MH “Caring”) | 8,871 |
S14 | AB ( caring or caregiving or (care N1 giving)) | 40,743 |
S15 | S13 OR S14 | 46,740 |
S16 | S12 AND S15 | 7,417 |
S17 | TI ( caring or caregiving or (care N1 giving)) | 20,213 |
S18 | TI ( ((children* or son or sons or daughter* or offspring* or sibling* or brother* or sister* or wife* or wives or husband* or partner* or spous* or married* or famil* or parent* or father* or mother* or “next of kin*” or kinship* or “significant other*” or relative or relatives or informal or unpaid or old* or elder* or aged or aging or ageing or senior or seniors or geriatric) N2 (care or caring or caregiving))) OR AB ( ((children* or son or sons or daughter* or offspring* or sibling* or brother* or sister* or wife* or wives or husband* or partner* or spous* or married* or famil* or parent* or father* or mother* or “next of kin*” or kinship* or “significant other*” or relative or relatives or informal or unpaid or old* or elder* or aged or aging or ageing or senior or seniors or geriatric) N2 (care or caring or caregiving))) | 75,458 |
S19 | S8 OR S9 OR S16 OR S17 OR S18 | 160,895 |
S20 | (MH “Immigrants”) OR (MH “Immigrants, Illegal”) OR (MH “Emigration and Immigration”) | 21,404 |
S21 | (MH “Minority Groups”) OR (MH “Ethnic Groups”) OR (MH “Cultural Diversity”) OR (MH “Cultural Values”) | 59,887 |
S22 | (MH “Transients and Migrants”) OR (MH “Undocumented Immigrants”) OR (MH “Refugees”) | 13,613 |
S23 | TI ( ( Immigrant* or migrant* or multicultur* or intercultur* or minorit* or ethnic* or multiethnic* or racial* or refugee* or “non western*” or nonwestern* or “asylum seeker*”)) OR AB ( ( Immigrant* or migrant* or multicultur* or intercultur* or minorit* or ethnic* or multiethnic* or racial* or refugee* or “non western*” or nonwestern* or “asylum seeker*”)) | 127,448 |
S24 | S20 OR S21 OR S22 OR S23 | 169,809 |
S25 | (MH “Qualitative Studies”) OR (MH “Action Research”) OR (MH “Ethnographic Research”) OR (MH “Ethnological Research”) OR (MH “Ethnonursing Research”) OR (MH “Grounded Theory”) OR (MH “Naturalistic Inquiry”) OR (MH “Phenomenological Research”) OR (MH “Phenomenology”) OR (MH “Focus Groups”) OR (MH “Narratives”) OR (MH “Interviews”) OR (MH “Semi-Structured Interview”) OR (MH “Structured Interview”) OR (MH “Unstructured Interview”) | 322,392 |
S26 | (MH “Attitude”) OR (MH “Family Attitudes”) OR (MH “Caregiver Attitudes”) OR (MH “Behavior”) OR (MH “Perception”) | 75,106 |
S27 | TI ( ( Qualitative or Narrative or Phenomenolog* or Hermeneutic* or interview* or “Grounded theor*” or Ethnograph* or themes or Attitude* or Behavior* or Behaviour* or Perception* or View* or experience* or “focus group*”)) OR AB ( ( Qualitative or Narrative or Phenomenolog* or Hermeneutic* or interview* or “Grounded theor*” or Ethnograph* or themes or Attitude* or Behavior* or Behaviour* or Perception* or View* or experience* or “focus group*”)) | 1,125,368 |
S28 | S25 OR S26 OR S27 | 1,234,025 |
S29 | S7 AND S19 AND S24 AND S28 | 1,733 |
Criteria | Inclusion | Exclusion |
---|---|---|
Study design | • Qualitative studies or mixed methods studies with individual interviews and/or focus groups | • Quantitative studies • Mixed methods studies in which qualitative findings cannot be separated from the quantitative studies • Qualitative studies where informal caregivers’ views cannot be separated from other study participants’ views • Qualitative studies where immigrant or non-immigrant background is not possible to identify • Qualitative studies with ‘thin descriptive data’ which cannot provide sufficient detailed to be further interpreted • Qualitative studies on dementia |
Study types | • Peer-reviewed research articles | • Review articles, books, conference papers, theses |
Time frame | • 2011 to 2022 | • Before 2011 |
Language | • English | • All other languages |
Population | • Family caregivers who are current caregivers or had the experience of caring for adults over the age of 50, or who are “older/elderly” if chronological age is not specified • Caregivers with an immigrant background from Asia, Africa and South America residing in Europe | • Family caregivers who do not have experience of caring for adults over the age of 50, or who are “older/elderly” if chronological age is not specified • Caregivers who do not have an immigrant background from Asia, Africa and South America |
Study country (setting) | • European countries | • Countries outside Europe |
Phenomenon of interest | • Studies explicit about family caregivers’ experiences of caregiving to older adults in the family | • Studies where the primary interest is the experiences of the care receivers or health personnel |
Are the results valid? | What are the results? | Will the results help locally? | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Article ref | 1. Aim | 2. Method | 3. Design | 4. Recruitment | 5. Data collection | 6. Relationship | 7. Ethics | 8. Data analysis | 9. Findings | 10. Valuable |
Arora et al_2019 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Arora et al_2020 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Cowan_2014 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | CT | Y | Y | Y | Y |
De Tavernier & Draulans_2018 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | CT | Y | Y | Y |
Giunntoli & Cattan_2012 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Greenwood et al_2016 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | CT | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Ismail _2021 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | CT | N | CT | Y | Y |
Nielsen et al_2018 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Parveen et al_2011 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Pound & Greenwood_2016 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Van Eechoud et al_2016 | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Phase 3: reading the studies
Author/year published | Title | Aim of the study | Older adults’ health status | Country | Study design | Data Collection | Data Analysis | Participants’ immigrant background | Participants (inclusive in our study) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arora et al., 2019 | Ethnic boundary-making in health care: Experiences of older Pakistani immigrant women in Norway | To explore how older Pakistani women experience their healthcare interactions in Norway | Generacaregiving | Norway | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews, Focus groups | Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) | Pakistani | 10 informal caregivers (all female) |
Arora et al., 2020 | Female Pakistani carers’ views on future formal and informal care for their older relatives in Norway | To explore female Pakistani carers’ views on the future formal and informal care and healthcare accessibility of their older relatives in Norway | Genera caregiving | Norway | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews, Field notes | Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) | Pakistani | 10 informal caregivers (all female) |
Cowan, 2014 | The lived experiences of the Sikh population of southeast England when caring for a dying relative at home | To explore and understand the Sikh population of southeast England’s experiences of care for a dying relative at home without support from local SPC team | Palliative care | UK | Phenomenological study | Semi-structured interviews | Interpretative Phenomenological analysis (Smith et. al, 2009) | South Asian (Punjabi-Sikh) | 5 informal caregivers (all female) |
De Tavernier & Draulans, 2018 | Negotiating informal elder care, migration and exclusion: the case of a Turkish immigrant community in Belgium | To go beyond the general discussion on gender inequalities and care and argue that exclusion is a core mechanism through which informal care can be organized or even guaranteed | Genera caregiving | Belgium | Qualitative case study | Semi-structured interviews | Intersectional approach (Crenshaw 1989) | Turkish | 6 informal caregivers (all female) |
Giuntoli & Cattan, 2012 | The experiences and expectations of care and support among older migrants in the UK | To investigate the accessibility and acceptability of care and supported services in Bradford, UK, a city with a large migrant population | Genera caregiving | UK | Qualitative study | In-depth interviews, Focus groups | Framework-Analysis (Ritchie & Lewis, 2003) | Pakistani, Indian, Bangladeshi, Afro- Caribbean | 33 caregivers (didn’t differentiate in numbers between BME group and other European group) |
Greenwood et al., 2016 | Qualitative focus group study investigating experiences of accessing and engageing with social care services: perspectives of carers from diverse ethnic groups caring for stroke survivors | To explore BME and white British carers’ experiences of accessing and receiving social care services in the community, focusing on similarities and differences between ethnic groups | Stroke Survivors | UK | Qualitative study | Focus groups | Thematic analysis | Pakistani, Indian, Black African, Black Caribbean | 31 informal caregivers |
Ismail,2021 | Care in practice: negotiations regarding care for the elderly in multigenerational Arab Muslim families in Denmark | To explore how caring for elderly people with health problems at home raises specific questions about obligations and triggers negotiations across genders and generations | Genera caregiving | Denmark | A single case study | Formal and informal interviews, Field observation | _ | Arab Muslim | 5 informal caregivers (4 female, 1 male) |
Nielsen et al., 2018 | “Caught in a Generation Gap”: A Generation Perspective on Refugees Getting Old in Denmark—A Qualitative Study | To gain better understanding and insight into the care needs of refugee families with aged relatives who are vulnerable in a resettlement country | Genera caregiving | Denmark | Hermeneutic phenomenological approach | Semi structured interviews, Focus group interviews | Systematic text condensation (Malterud, 2012) | Iraqi, Lebanese, Palestinian, Somali | 22 informal caregivers (15 female, 7 male) |
Parveen et al., 2011 | Ethnic variations in the caregiver role: A qualitative study | To explore the experience of British South-Asians in comparison with White-British caregivers, in order to address gaps in the current caregiver literature | Cancer, Stroke & others | UK | Mixed-methods study | Semi-structured interviews, Focus group | Thematic content analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) | Pakistani, Indian, Bangladeshi | 21 informal caregivers (19 female and 2 male) |
Pound & Greenwood, 2016 | The human dimensions of post-stroke homecare: experiences of older migrants in the UK | To explore the post-stroke experiences of older carers from BME and White British populations receiving homecare | Stroke Survivors | UK | Semi-structured interviews | Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) | Pakistani, Indian, BlackAfrican, Black Carribean | 38 informal caregivers (28 female, 10 male) | |
Van Eechoud et al., 2016 | Caring for Family Members Older Than 50 Years of Turkish and Northwest African Descent: The Meaning of Caregiving | To gain insight into the experiences and perceptions of families with Turkish or Northwest African backgrounds, caring for cancer patients aged over 50 | Cancer | Belgium | Constructivist Grounded theory | Loosely structured interviews | Qualitative Analysis Guide of Leuven (Dierckx et al., 2012) | Turkish, Northwest Africa | 32 family caregivers (22 female, 10 male) |
Phase 4: determining how the studies are related
Phase 5: translating the studies into one another
Phase 6: synthesizing translation
Descriptive Categories | Main Themes |
---|---|
• Ideal perceptions of continuing caregiving to older family members • Practical concerns of continuing caregiving • Fear of social exclusion and inaccessibility of appropriate formal services • Determining factors for taking on a caregiving role • Perceived need of sharing caregiving responsibilities • Changing caregiving approaches • Consequences of caregiving • Coping strategies as an individual business | • Strong care norms towards parents • The moral dilemma of continuing care • Uneven care sharing • Use of formal care services |