Management of patients with pulmonary mycobacteriosis in France: a multicenter retrospective cohort study

Nontuberculous mycobacteria pulmonary disease (NTM-PD) is not notifiable in France, as well as in most of the world. A large amount of epidemiological information remains unavailable. The microbiological diagnosis, even insufficient, is essential to make the diagnosis of infection. The clinical significance of a single positive sputum specimen in culture is difficult to estimate. It is important to follow the recommendations that at least two sputa or one bronchoalveolar lavage be culture-positive to consider microbiological criteria for NTM-PD [1, 2]. To do this, it is essential to correctly identify NTM at the species level [3]. The cost of management of NTM-PD has been evaluated four-fold higher than that for matched control, related to hospitalization for 63% and antibiotic treatment for 22% [4].

A comparison between different countries showed that nodulobronchiectatic forms were more frequent in Japan than in Europe (59.8% vs 39.2%, respectively), and that moderate to severe clinical forms were less common in Japan than in Europe (31% to 2% vs. 59% to 19%, respectively) [5]. Patients were more often treated in Europe than in Japan (68% vs 43%, respectively). In this study, it appears that in Europe, Italian and Spanish patients were more than six times as likely to be treated than patients in France. The most influential factors for treating NTM-PD were age > 60 years and severe clinical signs [5]. Two recent studies reported very low adherence of practitioners to ATS/IDSA treatment recommendations, particularly for Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC) and M. abscessus species, as well as a great variability of practices [5, 6]. But these studies have been performed with questionnaires fulfilled by physicians. It is difficult to know who are these physicians and if these physicians are representative of all physicians who take care of NTM-PD patients. The other point of view is to analyze management of NTM-PD patients and to compare to ATS/IDSA guidelines.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate management and prognosis of French patients with NTM-PD according to the 2007 ATS/IDSA recommendations over a period of six years, from January 2009 to December 2014. This study also described an overview of NTM-PD epidemiology in France.

This study was designed as a multicenter, retrospective, observational, cross-sectional study of patients aged more than 18 years and with NTM-PD, conducted according to the STROBE guidelines. The study protocol was approved by institutional review board and ethics committee (PI2018_843_0049). We gave written information on the study to each patient. In case of opposition to participate, patient was not included. The potential opposition is indicated in the medical record.

The Mycobacteria Medical (MycoMed) Study Group is a French network of 18 microbiological laboratories. The main objectives of the MycoMed Study Group are i/ to promote exchanges on laboratory practices and diagnostic approach in Mycobacteriology as part of laboratory accreditation, ii/ to initiate clinical-biological studies. Two previous studies of this Group analyzed incidence of MAC pulmonary disease between 2000 and 2002 and incidence of NTM-PD in HIV-negative patients from 2001 to 2003 [7, 8].

Patients ≥ 18 years-old were included from January 2009 through December 2014 in 18 French Hospitals belonging to the MycoMed network.

All patients with at least one positive respiratory sample with NTM were eligible but only patients meeting the 2007 ATS/IDSA criteria after reviewing medical records were included. Patients with cystic fibrosis were excluded from the study. We have chosen 2007 ATS/IDSA criteria instead of 2017 BTS and 2020 ATS/IDSA/ERS/ESCMID, as our last was included in 2015, before publications of these 2 recent guidelines [2, 9].

Demographic, bacteriological and clinical and radiological data were obtained from medical records. For the primary survival analysis, the date of each patient’s first positive specimen was used to ascertain comorbidity history. This allowed us to avoid comorbidity ascertainment bias introduced by differential survival times.

Respiratory specimens were decontaminated using the NALC-NaOH method. Microscopic examination was performed by Zielh-Neelsen staining, and specimens were inoculated onto liquid culture medium (mainly BD BACTEC™ MGIT™ 960 system, Becton Dickinson) and a solid culture medium (mainly Löwenstein-Jensen). NTM identification at the species level was based on molecular characterization using commercial kits: AccuProbe® system (Gen-Probe, Inc., USA), INNO-LiPA Mycobacteria system (Innogenetics, Belgium), and GenoType Mycobacterium system (Hain Lifescience, Germany). Partial gene sequencing (rpoB/hsp65/16S-23S internal transcribed spacer, 16S rRNA) was less used. Since 2013, identification by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry began to be carried out in some laboratories. In case of discrepancies or failures of identification, strains were sent to the French national reference center for mycobacteria.

We decided to group M. intracellulare and M. chimaera as some centers did not do at this time difference between the two species. For the same reason, we will present results for M. abscessus complex and not for each subspecies.

After descriptive analysis, univariate analysis was done for qualitative variables, Pearson’s Chi² or Fisher exact test and for quantitative variables, Student t-test or Wilcoxon rank test. We ascertained mortality from the medical records. Follow-up time was computed from the index date that defined an NTM disease episode until the date of death, migration, last hospital consultation, 3 years after index date, or 1^st June 2017, whichever came first. We used Kaplan–Meier analysis with log-rank testing to calculate and compare crude cumulative survival according to study variables, and Cox regression (univariate and multivariate survival analysis). Statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9.1 software.

During the period study, 568 NTM-PD were included. Among them 91 were excluded because of lack of radiologic data (87 cases) or identification of two different NTM species (4 cases). Overall, the remaining 477 cases (53.3% of males) met the 2007 ATS/IDSA criteria for NTM-PD, and were included. The median age was 65 years [range 18–96].

MAC comprised the majority (286/477, 60%) of all NTM findings (M. avium, n = 149; M.intracellulare, n = 134; MAC without subspecie identification, n = 3), followed by, M. xenopi (94/477, 19.7%), M.kansasii (27/477, 5.7%), M.abscessus complex (18/477,3.8%) M.fortuitum complex (17/477, 3.6%) (M. fortuitum (n = 13; M. chelonae, n = 4). Other unfrequent NTM species were identified in 5.4% (26/477) of cases: M. simiae (n = 10), M. malmoense (n = 4), M. genavense, M. scrofulaceum and M. szulgai in two cases for each species while M. arupense, M. florentinum M. heckeshornense, M. interjectum, M. lentiflavum and M. shimoidei were only isolated once. In the remaining 9 cases, NTM could not be identified at the species level.

Previous studies on NTM-PD are often general reviews mainly on the MAC complex [3, 10], or epidemiological studies based on laboratory data without clinical or radiological criteria [11, 12]. Few cohort studies met ATS criteria [13, 14].

Our cohort included 477 patients who met the 2007 ATS/IDSA criteria for NTM-PD from 18 centers between 2009 and 2014. Only two previous French studies reported data on 101 pulmonary MAC infections from 2000 to 2002, and on 262 NTM-PD from 2001 to 2003 according to the 1997 ATS criteria [7, 8]. Our study is one of the biggest cohort studies of NTM diseased patients and allows us to have real conclusions about NTM-PD epidemiology and management in France.

Unfortunately, this study did not include all NTM-PD cases in France as only 18 centers participated, and does not permit to calculate the exact incidence and prevalence in France. Nevertheless, these 18 centers from the MycoMed network are among the biggest hospitals in France. One other limitation was the delay between the last included patients and the final analysis. Indeed, as it is retrospective study, we needed some administrative authorizations, and some time to give information to all concerned patients.

The diagnostic practices are homogeneous and standardized in these 18 centers, responding to published recommendations [15, 16], and identical to European practices [11]. Solid and liquid culture media were used as recommended [15]. The majority of NTMs were identified at the species level, most often using line probe hybridization, more rarely on-demand sequencing, or recently mass spectrometry [15, 16].

The following quality criteria can be highlighted for our cohort: i/ less than 2% of the strains could not be identified to the species level, ii/ it does not contain any contaminating species such as M. gordonae or M. terrae complex [1], iii/ finally very few pulmonary M. fortuitum complex infections, most often considered as non-pathogenic, were included [17].

In our cohort, the species distribution of NTM was close to that reported earlier in France [8] and more recently in a survey study of NTM in the European Union, which included France [18]. MAC was the commonest group of cultured organisms, as reported worldwide [18]. While studies showed that M. avium was the predominated subspecies recovered from human specimens [7, 18] in Europe, we found a similar number of M. avium and M. intracellulare isolates in our cohort. M. xenopi, followed by M. kansasii, were the second and the third species, respectively, the most frequently encountered in France. In the collaborative study of the NTM-NET network, M. abscessus complex and M. kansasii were the second and the third species, respectively.

The analysis of radiological and microbiological aspects of pulmonary NTM highlighted the variability associated with the species, and with the study period. Regarding MAC, the two-series meeting the ATS 1990 criteria of Obayashi and Wright reported a percentage of direct-smear positive patients greater than 50%, especially in the case of upper lobe cavitary lesions [13, 19]. In the cohort of Wright [17], microscopy examination of pulmonary NTM due to MAC, M. abscessus and M. kansasii was positive in 58%, 51% and 78% respectively. By comparison, in two subsequent studies of MAC meeting the 2007 ATS criteria, the percentages of cavitary lesions and positive direct examinations were 18% and 31% in the study of Boyle [12], and 20% and 35% in the study of Ito [20]. Our cohort was characterized by 19.1% of cavitary lesions and 36.7% of smear-positive results, similar to previous studies [14, 20].

The decrease of these two criteria is probably due to the lack of positive direct examination in the 2007 ATS criteria.

In our cohort, we found a high (61%) percentage of smear-positive samples and a small (11%) percentage of cavitary lesions in NTM-PD due to the M. abscessus complex. In comparison, the Wright study also reported a high percentage of positive direct examinations of 51.3% in NTM due to M. abscessus [19]. Specific studies were conducted on M. kansasii lung infections. In the Wright series, 29 (78.4%) of 37 specimens positive in culture for M. kansasii were smear positive. The 37 specimens concerned only 8 patients for whom the radiological data were not known [19]. M. kansasii is an NTM so far known to present a similar clinical picture to that of pulmonary tuberculosis with fibrocavitary lesions in the upper lobes [1]. A recent study reviewing clinical manifestations and radiographic findings of patients with M. kansasii respiratory isolates provided further clarification [21]. Indeed, among 54 patients who met the ATS/IDSA diagnostic criteria, 44% exhibited the fibrocavitary form and 32% the nodulo-bronchiectatic form [21]. Our series even showed that up to 55% of M. kansasii NTM-PD developed nodular bronchiectatic forms. It is very likely that the change in ATS criteria in 2007 has led to the diagnosis of more nodular forms among M. kansasii NTM-PD.

Nearly half of M. xenopi were direct-smear positive for 34% cavitary forms. These results were closely related to those published in 2009 [22], reporting 61% of positive direct examinations and 31% of cavitary forms among the 136 M. xenopi pulmonary NTM in France.

Finally, the least NTM, with some positive smearin our series, were due to M. fortuitum (17.6%). In the Park study, direct examination was positive in 9/26 patients (35%) with at least three positive cultures to M. fortuitum [17].

Overall, 62.9% of patients were treated in our cohort, with 72.4% smear-positive specimens. The prevalence of treated patients depends on the studies. In two cohorts of MAC NTM-PD, 46.1% and 53.1% of patients received antimicrobial therapy respectively vs 67.1% in our study of which 62.5% were smear-negative [14, 20]. Seventy-five and 72.2% of M. kansasii and M. abscessus complex infections were treated respectively, regardless of whether the patients were smear-positive or not, which correlates well with the recognized pathogenicity of these species [1, 2, 23]. For M. xenopi, 54.6% of patients received treatment, which is more than the 32% reported in a previous French study [22]. But in the French study, one third of patients were very immunosuppressed (AIDS with less than 50 CD4/mm³) and a vast majority of them died before bacteriological diagnosis. Finally, only 4 (23.5%) patients infected with M. fortuitum were treated. Results obtained by Park et al. showed that there was no clinical worsening or persistent positive cultures among the 25 untreated patients on a 12-month follow-up [17]. These data confirm the low pathogenicity of this species, most often responsible of colonization or transient infection that does not require generally a treatment [1, 23].

Our results highlight the conformity of practices of French clinicians with the ATS/IDSA guidelines. Most patients received at least three drugs during 12 months or more. These results are in contrast with those of US and European countries [5, 6]. These differences could be partly explained by the study methodology and physician expertise. These physicians were randomly surveyed to generate nationally representative analyses of practice. These physicians included practitioners outside of reference centers and in non-specialized fields. These adequacy between French practices and ATS/IDSA guidelines found in our study could maybe explain the good prognosis of treated patients in our cohort in contrast to literature data especially for MAC and M. xenopi [22, 24, 25]. Indeed, a more favorable evolution was observed in our treated patients, whether or not patients are positive for direct examination. The decision to initiate a treatment should be individualized, based on clinical factors, radiological lesions, and some microbiological data (NTM specie, number and type of positive samples, and probably positive smear, often associated with cavitary lesions), as recommended by the 2 recent NTM guidelines [2, 9]. In our study, the treatment rate was high, but we have strictly selected patients: all have ATS/IDSA NTM disease diagnosis criteria, with a low rate of patients with an unique smear negative BAL. Moreover, all patients were clinically and radiologically symptomatic. The risk of treatment nonadherence is higher in patients with few symptoms, that is why treatment decision should be discussed according to patient and disease characteristics and with patient point of view. We have chosen to classify in more or less than 12 months, even if recommendations is 12 months after sputum conversion, because it is not easily, in the real life to have the date of sputum conversion..Finally, our lower mortality in comparison to previous published studies could be too due to patients characteristics or management differences: diagnosis or treatment prior to ATS/IDSA 2007 publication, less common use of macrolides [22]), predominance of observation without treatment [25], type of comorbidities (for example systemic immunosuppression [22] or NTM species included (especially M. xenopi [22, 25]. Indeed, in some others studies [26, 27], outcome was mainly associated with age, comorbidities and not with species (except M. xenopi associated with a poor prognosis) [26]. In our study, M. abscessus appeared with the poorest prognosis. Nevertheless, it is difficult to conclude, as only few patients with M. abscessus have been included in this cohort (n = 12) and no differentiation between M. abscessus stricto sensu and M. massiliense is available.

This study based on collaboration between microbiologists and clinicians gives us very complete clinical, radiological, microbiological, treatment and outcome data. The three NTM species involved in pulmonary disease in France between 2009 and 2014 were MAC, M. xenopi and M. kansasii. This cohort study highlighted the role of adherence to treatment guidelines in prognosis, with an individual discussion of treatment or watchful waiting. In case of treatment, this treatment for slow growing NTM, as actually recommended, should be included at least 3 drugs for a duration of 12 months after sputum conversion. The main limitation will be the realization of control samples.