Background
Periodontal disease is an inflammatory state caused by intra-oral bacteria. Progressive periodontal disease is accompanied by chronic inflammation that destroys the periodontal tissue supporting teeth, which can lead to tooth loss [
1]. In 2010, severe periodontitis was the sixth-most prevalent health condition, affecting 10·8% of people, or 743 million, worldwide [
2]. Thus, the importance of oral care centered on disease prevention and early treatment is recognized globally.
Periodontal disease might be involved in the progression of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), such as cancer, diabetes, circulatory diseases, chronic respiratory diseases, and even Alzheimer disease [
3,
4]. Particularly, many studies have suggested its bidirectional association with diabetes. A study of Pima Indians with a high frequency of type 2 diabetes found a 2.6-fold higher incidence of periodontal disease among those with diabetes than those without [
5]. Furthermore, poor glycaemic control increases the risk of alveolar bone resorption [
6]. Obesity, which is closely related to diabetes, is a chronic inflammatory disease characterized by constant oxidative stress. Elevated fatty acid levels increase oxidative stress in monocyte macrophages, dysregulating the production of adiponectin and other adipocytokines [
7]. These inflammatory- and lipid peroxidation-related diseases also increase susceptibility to bacterial infections and might promote the progression of periodontal disease [
8]. However, most epidemiological studies have been conducted in countries other than Japan; thus, the diabetes and obesity metrics indicated by these studies might not necessarily represent a comprehensive global perspective, given the differences in standards of disease severity among races [
9,
10]. For example, the proportion of Asians with a body mass index (BMI) ≥ 30 kg/m
2 (defined as obese in some European countries) is low [
10]. Obesity is defined at a relatively lower threshold of BMI ≥ 25 kg/m
2 by the Japan Society for the Study of Obesity because obesity complications occur at a lower BMI in the Japanese population than in the European and North American populations [
11].
Given the relationship between periodontal disease and general health, we hypothesized that inflammation caused by periodontal disease may affect general health. Moreover, the decrease in occlusal force may affect general health through changes in food intake. Occlusal force has been shown to be directly related to masticatory function and food selection. In fact, studies involving older Japanese adults have reported that a decrease in occlusal force resulted in a decrease in masticatory force [
12], and that occlusal force was significantly correlated with vitamin and dietary fibre intake [
13] Furthermore, increased PPD due to worsening periodontal disease has been shown to be negatively correlated with occlusal force and involved in food acceptability [
14].
Clarification regarding the association between periodontal disease and NCDs highlights the importance of a healthcare system that connects dental specialists with medical professionals who interact with patients. An oral health care system that establishes better oral health by examining, finding, and treating periodontal disease as well as by promoting maintenance and improvement of general health would be ideal. Systems that include a dental assessment as part of general health examinations in the UK are promising [
15]. Japan has a unique healthcare system that mandates annual health checks for all employees. However, this system does not always include dental examinations [
16].
This cross-sectional study aimed to determine whether periodontal disease correlates with NCD-centred health diagnostic indicators and to determine the effect of NCDs on occlusal force. In addition, the significance of introducing dental examinations into routine health checks under the corporate healthcare system is discussed. This could serve as a means of building a comprehensive, regional, oral healthcare system at facilities that comprehensively manage and support employee health and help prevent early periodontal disease, as well as maintain and promote good general health.
Discussion
We added a dental examination to annual employee health checks at HHCC in this HTC-OHC cross-sectional survey. We assessed bidirectional relationships among the periodontal disease index and general health indices. Clarifying the association between periodontal and systemic diseases with a focus on NCDs would enable the construction of a comprehensive regional healthcare system capable of future intervention. Therefore, we examined whether an association between periodontal disease and systemic disease, which is becoming increasingly clear in many epidemiological studies, could be identified by combining the health diagnostic indices that are normally measured in annual Japanese corporate medical checks with periodontal disease indices.
Diabetes is a metabolic disorder characterized by chronic hyperglycaemia [
25]. Persistent long-term hyperglycaemia causes abnormalities in various organs and complications, such as retinopathy, nephropathy, neuropathy, and cardiovascular diseases [
29], and an increased risk of periodontal disease [
30].
This study analysed the effects of the periodontal disease index, PPD, BOP, PESA, PISA and number of teeth on diabetes. The PPD analysis suggested that periodontal disease increases the risk of developing diabetes by 1.4-fold. Furthermore, the HbA1c findings suggested that diabetes increases the risk of developing periodontal disease by 4.3-fold, independent of age, sex, smoking. Kocher et al. summarized typical epidemiological studies of periodontal disease and diabetes, and showed an increased OR for periodontal disease risk from 1.17- to 3.84-fold due to diabetes, although a study involving Pima Indians found a 11.4-fold increase in the OR [
31]. The ORs calculated herein were higher than those of previous studies. We believe that this is because we narrowed down the healthy subjects in the stratified analysis of periodontal disease. At the time of the stratification analysis, the healthy group had no PPD of 4 mm, and had HbA1c level < 5.7. Therefore, the number of periodontally healthy employees fell to 62, which might have improved the accuracy of the OR. We believe that this study also confirmed the existence of a bidirectional relationship between periodontal disease and diabetes; however, validation in a larger sample is required.
Obesity is a chronic inflammatory disease characterized by excessive fat accumulation in adipose tissues [
32]. Increased oxidative stress might not only lead to local and systemic vascular endothelial failure but also to periodontal disease [
33]. We found a significantly higher BMI among employees with mild and moderate/severe periodontitis than among healthy employees with HbA1c level < 5.7%. Multiple logistic regression analyses also suggested that BMI was 1.3-fold more likely to increase the risk of developing periodontitis. Conversely, having more teeth was associated with decreased risk of obesity, and that PPD was 1.4-fold more likely to increase the risk of developing obesity. The stratified analysis suggested that blood HDL level was significantly reduced in the obesity subjects (
p < 0.001) and significantly increased in the underweight subjects (
p < 0.001). HDL has been reported to have anti-inflammatory effects [
34]. Decreased HDL levels associated with increased sensitivity toward inflammatory stimuli as reflected by enhanced inflammatory and coagulation responses on endotoxin challenge [
35]
Porphyromonas gingivalis (P. gingivalis), a gram-negative oral anaerobe involved in the pathogenesis of periodontitis, induces oxidation of HDL [
36], and lipopolysaccharide from
P. gingivalis suppresses the secretion of adiponectin from adipocytes [
37]. These studies may more accurately explain the relationship between periodontal disease and obesity.
The association between periodontal disease and COPD has given the overlap with chronic inflammatory diseases that involve the breakdown of connective tissue and the existence of common risk factors such as age and smoking [
38]. We found a significantly lower %FEV
1 among employees with moderate/severe periodontitis than among healthy employees. Multiple logistic regression analyses also suggested that COPD increase the risk of developing periodontitis. Conversely, having more teeth was associated with decreased risk of moderate COPD, and that PPD was 1.4-fold more likely to increase the risk of developing COPD. However, no differences in BOP or PISA indicators related to inflammation were observed. A meta-analysis of association studies between periodontal disease and COPD reported an increase in PPD and attachment loss in patients with COPD. However, no differences in bleeding or inflammation were reported, and no definitive results were provided [
39]. The absence of a relationship between COPD and dental inflammation indices (BOP and PISA) or BMI in this study may have been influenced by the absence of subjects classified as “type III severe” or “type IV very severe” by the Gold Guideline COPD classification criteria. Therefore, further validation is required. Barros et al
. compared COPD in toothless subjects versus those with healthy periodontal tissue (teeth and gums) and reported an elevated risk of hospitalization and death among those with toothless jaws [
40]. This suggests a connection between tooth count and COPD. Early and appropriate implementation of periodontal care may reduce the risk of COPD.
The association between periodontal disease and ASCVD has been a topic of interest, given their overlap with chronic inflammatory diseases that involve the breakdown of connective tissue and common risk factors such as age and smoking [
41] We found a significantly increased CAVI in employees with moderate/severe periodontitis. Adjusting for age and smoking behaviour in the multiple logistic regression analysis, the CAVI could potentially increase the risk of moderate/severe periodontitis. Conversely, employees classified as having ASCVD had significantly fewer teeth and decreased PESA compared with the healthy group, whereas PPD did not significantly differ among groups. Associations between periodontal and cardiovascular diseases have been characterized, but their causes are yet to be established [
42].
The decrease in occlusal force may affect general health through changes in food intake. Occlusal force is determined by masticatory muscle strength, tooth placement, and the biomechanical characteristics of the stomatognathic system, including periodontal status [
43]. It is used to evaluate the function and effectiveness of the mastication system [
44]. Damaged periodontal tissues, such as deeper periodontal pockets, perturb the teeth, reducing occlusal force and masticatory ability [
45,
46]. Occlusal function becomes insufficient when the mouth contains < 20 teeth, reducing maximal occlusal strength and masticatory ability [
47]. We measured occlusal strength in some of the employees. Occlusal force was decreased by 22.5% and 19.9% in individuals aged in their 50 s and 60 s compared with those in their 40 s and 50 s, respectively. Occlusal strength decreases in elderly persons [
45], but changes in the occlusal strength of individuals between the ages of 20 and 70 remain unknown. This age-specific trend revealed that the total number of teeth decreased after the age of 40, and that individuals in their 70 s had an average of 20.5 teeth. Therefore, a decrease in the number of teeth is unlikely as the sole cause of decreased occlusal force. Since the sharp decline in occlusal force between the 40 s and 50 s corresponded to significant worsening of disease indicators including NCDs, general health status might somewhat affect periodontal tissues in addition to progress of periodontal disease.
We evaluated associations between periodontal disease index, general health index, and occlusal force. However, multiple linear regression analysis (adjusted for age and smoking status) found a significant negative association emerged between PPD and occlusal force among employees with moderate/severe periodontitis, moderate COPD, and ASCVD. An association has been identified between periodontal disease and moderate COPD and ASCVD, with their common pathology being chronic inflammation. There are similarities in COPD and periodontitis disease mechanisms that of dysfunctional neutrophil behaviors, sustained neutrophilic inflammation, and connective tissue loss caused by oral bacteria [
48]. Local expression of tumour necrosis factor (TNF), interleukin-1β (IL-1β), and IL-6 due to inflammation triggered by bacteria involved in periodontal disease might promote and exacerbate ASCVD [
49]. Chronic inflammations lead to increased PPD and decreased occlusal force.
Furthermore, HbA1c level and occlusal force were significantly and negatively associated with moderate/severe periodontitis, while %FEV
1 was significantly and positively associated with occlusal force in the groups with IGT. The biological mechanisms underlying the relationship between diabetes and occlusal force remain obscure. We believe that chronic inflammatory conditions affect the function of the periodontal ligament (PDL), which is involved in generating occlusal force. The PDL plays an important role in distributing occlusal force over the alveolar bone and maintaining the positions of teeth, with mechanical forces altering cell viability, proliferation, and differentiation within the PDL itself [
50]. Diabetes increases the abundance of PDL osteoclasts, which might be attributed to the increased expression of receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa B ligand (RANKL) in mouse models of diabetes [
51]. Moreover, hyperglycaemia is associated with activation of the NF-κB pathway [
52]. Pabisch et al. discovered an abnormal bone structure in a diabetes mouse model [
53]. Advanced glycation end products (AGEs) accumulate in the blood serum and in cells and tissues during chronic hyperglycaemia in patients with diabetes [
54,
55]. The increased frequency of bone fractures among patients with diabetes might be due to deterioration in bone quality mediated by AGEs [
56]. These results indicated that diabetes alters bone metabolism, PDL function, and bone structure, and that these mechanisms could explain the association between diabetes and occlusal force. However, this awaits further investigation.
Poudel et al. and Sanchez et al. have advocated the need to introduce systems to improve oral health, educate patients about increased risk of oral complications, and provide advice about good dental practices. [
57,
58]. Health disparities that have recently been viewed as problematic are strongly influenced by income and education, which are also important factors that affect general health [
59]. Changing a society’s views on issues such as the importance of oral healthcare or the impact of socio-economic factors and healthcare services as they pertain to quality of life is challenging. However, a model that includes regular oral healthcare should be established and vigorously promoted to achieve societal acceptance. The Industrial Safety and Health Law in Japan requires all companies to have their employees undergo annual health checks, but not dental examinations. This health system has the advantage of being accessible to anyone regardless of income, thus facilitating the accumulation of annual health examination data to monitor baseline health status as well as changes over time. The introduction of periodontal health checks into this system might facilitate the detection of dental health issues that could allow for appropriate action to avoid or prevent symptom exacerbation, as well as associated healthcare costs. The HHCC collects employee health examination data from the point of hiring to the point of retirement. Thus, they implement early detection of systemic diseases and other healthcare measures to prevent worsening of pre-existing conditions. We found that maintaining employee health led to better overall corporate productivity. Moreover, a reduction in medical expenses leads to a more sustainable healthcare system. However, Japanese companies do not apply the same vigilance to oral health as physical health checks. We introduced dental examinations at no additional cost in this study. The rate at which the employees presented at dental clinics at that time was 63.6% (2014), with only a few employees aware of the importance of dental examinations. However, continued annual dental examinations subsequently increased this rate to 81.8% (2015), 89.7% (2016), and 85.1% (2017). People in Japan do not generally attend dental clinics unless subjective symptoms appear, with dentistry remaining outside the scope of regular health maintenance. However, this trend is not unique to Japan, since economic status and lack of knowledge about oral healthcare are established barriers to the inclusion of dentistry in regular health checks in other countries [
58]. The association between periodontal disease and general health was communicated to the employees in this study via the internal public relations department, which improved the collective understanding of the importance of regular dental health examinations. When a need for dental treatment was apparent, we provided the affected employee with a referral letter for a thorough dental examination. We also established a medical test feedback system to evaluate the extent to which dental treatment contributes to improved health, as well as how it affects health insurance expenditure. Japan has the highest life expectancy in the world, but healthcare costs are increasing due to the expansion of advanced medical care and the aging population. We believe that expanding systems such as oral healthcare will help slow the burden of increasing medical expenses.
This cross-sectional study had some limitations. In this study, PPD and BOP calculated from PPD and BOP were used as periodontal disease indexes in the analysis, and CAL was not measured. Conventionally, periodontal diseases are classified according to CAL. However, in the large-scale periodontal disease medical examination carried out in this study, it was difficult to accurately measure CAL in other places aside from the clinic within limited time. PISA quantifies the inflammatory burden posed by periodontitis, and can be easily and broadly applied [
19]. PISA could be considered an alternative periodontal index that represents an individual's periodontal status, and could be widely applied in various periodontal studies [
60]. PISA can be calculated with the help of Excel spreadsheets by entering the values of CAL, location of the gingival margin, and PPD as measured on six sites per tooth. We calculated the PESA and PISA using the spreadsheets by entering the values of PPD and BOP in this study. Nessa et al. suggested that the calculation of PISA using CAL always includes measurement errors related to observer, instrument, and the teeth of patients, and that their interactions might lead to imprecise quality with regards to the amount of tissue [
19]. Moreover, they discussed that using PPD instead of CAL, i.e. entering PPD into the formula for CAL, will diminish this underestimation. However, measurement of CAL is required to accurately perform periodontal disease classification, and validation is required on the data obtained. HbA1c, age, and smoking were extracted as important confounding factors from the correlation analysis in this study. In the multiple logistic analysis, these were used as covariates to calculate the Odds ratio and SPRC (β). However, other potential confounding factors may include gender, lifestyle habits such as alcohol intake, and drug administration, and the results may differ. The correlation between dental and health indicators does not necessarily imply a causal relationship. In addition to the factors that we analysed herein, other factors influence the association between periodontal disease and general health. Therefore, long-term follow-up studies are needed to establish causal relationships. This study included a limited group of corporate employees that included only 10.6% women; therefore, our findings were biased towards men. Thus, long-term follow-up studies involving a larger female cohort are needed to fully determine causal relationships.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.