Background
Methods
Search strategy
Eligibility criteria
Data extraction and quality assessment
Data analysis
Results
Search
Study quality
Study characteristics
Paper ID | Condition | Number of Admissions | Geographical Units (N) a | Mean Age (SD)b | Covariate Adjustmentc | Statistical Methods | Tested Cause | Untested Cause |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Australia | ||||||||
Ansari 2005 [56] | Diabetes | 38,900 | Primary Care Partnerhips (32) | N/A | A,S | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Graphs | SC Access | |||||||
SC Quality | ||||||||
Clinical Guidelines | ||||||||
Coding Quality | ||||||||
Tennant 2000 [57] | Dental | 3,754 | Health service region (32) | <18 (100 %) | A | Raw Data | None | None |
Graphs | ||||||||
Canada | ||||||||
Crighton 2007 [58] | Influenza | 241,803 | County (49) | N/A | A,S | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Pneumonia | Maps | SC Access | ||||||
Spatial Analysis | PC Quality | |||||||
Range Analysis | Clinical Guidelines | |||||||
COV | ||||||||
Crighton 2008 [59] | Influenza | 241,803 | County (49) | N/A | A,S | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Maps | ||||||||
Coding Quality | ||||||||
Pneumonia | ||||||||
Spatial Analysis | ||||||||
Curtis 2002 [60] | Diabetes | 15,872 | District Health Board (16) | <18 (100 %) | A,S | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Maps | ||||||||
PC Quality | ||||||||
Extremal Quotient | ||||||||
Jin 2003 [25] | Pneumonia | 36,516 | Health Region (17) | 18-44 (18 %) | A,S | Raw Data | SC Access | Case Mix |
46-64 (19 %) | Graphs | |||||||
65-74 (20 %) | ||||||||
75-84 (26 %) | ||||||||
85+ (16 %) | ||||||||
To 1996 [24] | Gastroenteritis | 10,105 | County (41) | <1 (25.3 %) | A,S | Range | Case Mix | Coding Quality |
1 (25.7 %) | COV | SC Access | ||||||
2 (14.5 %) | SCV | |||||||
3-5 (17.3 %) | Extremal Quotient | |||||||
6-8 (7.0 %) | ||||||||
9-14 (4.4 %) | ||||||||
12-14 (2.9 %) | ||||||||
15-17 (2.8 %) | ||||||||
New Zealand | ||||||||
Bandaranayake 2011 [61] | Influenza | 1,743 | District Health Board (20) | N/A | None | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Graphs | ||||||||
Barnett 2010 [26] | ACSCs | 24,894 | GP Practice (102) | N/A | None | Raw Data | Case Mix | None |
Graphs | PC Quality | |||||||
PC Access | ||||||||
Practice Size | ||||||||
Dharmalingam 2004 [62] | ACSCs | N/A | Modified District Health Board (29) | N/A | A | Raw Data | Case Mix | None |
Tables | ||||||||
Ellison-Loschmann 2004 [53] | Asthma | 25,865 | Territorial Authority (74) | N/A | None | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Maps | ||||||||
Spain | ||||||||
Magan 2008 [63] | ACSCs | 64,409 | Health District (34) | 78.9 | A,S | Raw Data | Case Mix | PC Quality |
Cardiovascular Disease | Maps | Clinical Guidelines | ||||||
Heart Failure | Tables | Staffing Levels | ||||||
Pneumonia | Range | |||||||
COV | ||||||||
SCV | ||||||||
UK | ||||||||
Downing 2007 [20] | Asthma | 2,271 | GP Practice (94) | <65 (84.8 %) | A,S,O | Hierarchical Model | Case Mix | None |
Cardiovascular Disease | >65 (15.2 %) | Variance Estimates | PC Quality | |||||
COPD | ||||||||
Diabetes | ||||||||
Stroke | ||||||||
Giuffrida 1999 [22] | Asthma | N/A | Health Authority (90) | N/A | None | Range | Case Mix | Clinical Guidelines |
Diabetes | SC Access | |||||||
Staffing Levels | ||||||||
Starr 1996 [56] | Stroke | N/A | Local government districts (22) | 40-59 (100 %) | None | Raw Data | Case Mix | SC Access |
Tables | ||||||||
US | ||||||||
Adams 1993 [64] | Alcohol Abuse | 87,147 | State (50) | >65 (100 %) | A,S,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | Coding Quality |
Maps | ||||||||
Casper 2010 [65] | Heart Failure | N/A | County (3,187) | >65 (100 %) | A | Raw Data | None | Coding Quality |
Maps | PC Access | |||||||
Chen 2011 [19] | Heart Failure | 55,097,390 | State (52) | 79.0 (7.7) | A,S,C,O | Raw Data | None | None |
Maps | ||||||||
Gorton 2006 [66] | Pneumonia | 4,948 | County (67) | 59.6 mo | A,S,O | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Maps | SC Access | |||||||
Holt 2011 [67] | COPD | 3,786,908 | State (50) | >65 (100 %) | None | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Hospital Referral Region (949) | Maps | |||||||
Spatial Analysis | ||||||||
Laditka 1999 [68] | ACSCs | 21,923 | Hospital Market Area (24) | >65 (100 %) | A,S | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Tables | PC Access | |||||||
Lanska 1994 [69] | Stroke | 318,000 | State (49) | >65 (100 %) | A,S,O | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
Maps | SC Access | |||||||
Spatial Analysis | SC Access | |||||||
Clinical Guidelines | ||||||||
Procedure/Drug | ||||||||
Availability | ||||||||
High readmission rates | ||||||||
Maliszewski 2011 [60] | Influenza | 2,010 | County (58) | <18 (24.4 %) | A,S,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | None |
>65 (12.4 %) | Maps | |||||||
Spatial Analysis | ||||||||
Morris 1994 [23] | Asthma | N/A | County (3,079) | >65 (100 %) | A,S,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | Coding Quality |
COPD | Maps | SC Access | ||||||
Pneumonia | Spatial Analysis | Staffing Levels | ||||||
Ogunniyi 2012 [70] | Heart Failure | 845,421 | County (1,014) | 65-75 (30.8 %) | A | Raw Data | None | Case Mix |
State (10) | 75-84 (41.3 %) | Tables | SC Access | |||||
>85 (27.9 %) | Maps | PC Access | ||||||
Spatial Analysis |
Paper ID | Condition | Number of Admissions | Geographical Units (N)a | Mean Age (SD)b | Covariate Adjustmentc | Statistical Methods | Tested Cause | Untested Cause |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Belgium | ||||||||
Claeys 2013 [55] | MI | 2,079 | Hospital (33) | 62 (13) | None | Raw Data | Case Mix | Discharge Planning |
Graphs | ||||||||
Canada | ||||||||
Feagan 2000 [71] | Pneumonia | 858 | Hospital (20) | 69.4 (17.7) | A,S,C,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | Clinical Guidelines |
Tables | Hospital Type | PC Access | ||||||
% Variation Explained | Procedure/Drug Availability | |||||||
Denmark | ||||||||
Klausen 2012 [21] | Pneumonia | 12,753 | Hospital (22) | 65-74 (32.5 %) | A,S,C | Raw Data | Case Mix | Clinical Guidelines |
75-84 (40.6 %) | Graphs | Hospital Size | PC Quality | |||||
>85 (26.9 %) | P-Values (Cox Regression) | Condition Volume | ||||||
Spain | ||||||||
Cabre 2004 [72] | Pneumonia | 1,769 | Hospital (27) | 66.4 (18.1) | A,S,C | Hierarchical Model Variance Estimates | Case Mix | SC Access |
SC Quality | ||||||||
Clinical Guidelines | ||||||||
PC Quality | ||||||||
Garau 2008 [73] | Pneumonia | 3,233 | Hospital (10) | 66 (18.5) | A,SC,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | None |
Tables | ||||||||
P-Values (Cox Regression) | ||||||||
Pozo-Rodriguez 2012 [74] | COPD | 5,178 | Hospital (129) | 75 (IQR: 68–80) | None | IQR | None | None |
UK | ||||||||
Hosker 2007 [75] | COPD | 8,013 | Hospital (233) | 71 (IQR: 71–74) | None | IQR | None | None |
Price 2006 [27] | COPD | 910 | Hospital (234) | N/A | A,S,C | IQR | SC Quality | None |
ICC | Clinical Guidelines | |||||||
Hospital Size | ||||||||
Roberts 2002 [76] | COPD | 1,400 | Hospital (38) | 72 | None | Range | Case Mix | SC Quality |
IQR | ||||||||
Rudd 2001 [77] | Stroke | 6,894 | Health Region (10) | 75 (12) | A,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | None |
Tables | SC Quality | |||||||
P-Values (Kruskal-Wallis) | ||||||||
US | ||||||||
Brogan 2012 [78] | Pneumonia | 43,819 | Hospital (29) | 3 (IQR: 1–6) | None | Raw Data | Procedure/Drug Availability | None |
Graphs | ||||||||
Range | ||||||||
Conway 2009 [28] | UTI | 20,892 | Hospital (25) | 1-2 mo (16.7 %) | None | Raw Data | Case Mix | Coding Quality |
2-6 mo (29.9 %) | Graphs | Clinical Guidelines | ||||||
6-24 mo | Condition Volume | |||||||
(19.1 %) | ||||||||
2-12 y (34.3 %) | ||||||||
Drye 2012 [79] | Heart Failure | 718,508 | Hospital (3,135) | >65 (100 %) | None | Raw Data | None | None |
Graphs | ||||||||
MI | ||||||||
Range | ||||||||
Pneumonia | ||||||||
Krumholz 1999 [80] | Heart Failure | 905 | Hospital (49) | <65 (42 %) | A,S,C,O | Raw Data | Case Mix | SC Quality |
>65 (58 %) | Graphs | |||||||
% Variation Explained |
Reporting methods and covariate adjustment
Magnitude of variation
Paper ID | Author Conclusions |
---|---|
Significant Variation | |
Australia | |
Ansari 2005 | “There was a wide variation (almost fivefold) in admission rates” |
Tennant 2000 | “[8 of 32 regions] had significantly less episodes of hospitalization…than the State average” |
Canada | |
Crighton 2007 | “Marked differences in rates between counties…large variability in county rates” |
Crighton 2008 | “The heterogeneity in…hospitalization rates and significant spatial clustering” |
New Zealand | |
Barnett 2010 | “Substantial variation in admission rates” |
Dharmalingam 2004 | “Substantial geographical variation in the level of avoidable hospitalisation” |
Spain | |
Magan 2008 | “Considerable variability in these rates” |
UK | |
Giuffrida 1999 | “Clear variation…in crude admission rates” |
Starr 1996 | “There was considerable variation…between districts” |
US | |
Adams 1993 | “There was considerable geographic variation” |
Casper 2010 | “Magnitude of geographic disparity was substantial between the high- and low-rate counties” |
Chen 2011 | “Rates in 1998 and 2008 varied significantly by state” |
Gorton 2006 | “Rates vary widely” |
Holt 2011 | “Substantial geographic variations in COPD hospitalization risk among states and HSAs” |
Laditka 1999 | “Significant variation in preventable hospitalization” |
Morris 1994 | “The geographic distribution in hospital admission rates is unequivocally heterogeneous” |
Variation Exists | |
Canada | |
Curtis 2002 | “Differences observed for DKA are clinically important” |
Jin 2003 | “The incidence of…hospitalization varies” |
To 1996 | “Variation among the counties…was moderately large” |
New Zealand | |
Bandaranayake 2011 | “We observed a heterogeneous distribution” |
US | |
Maliszewski 2011 | “Hospitalization rates were dependent upon neighbouring county hospitalization rates” |
Insignificant Variation | |
UK | |
Downing 2007 | “Generally the variances were small meaning there was little unexplained variation” |
US | |
Lanska 1994 | “Hospitalization rates show relatively little small-scale variation” |
No Conclusion | |
New Zealand | |
Ellison-Loschmann 2004 | No conclusions |
US | |
Ogunniyi 2012 | No conclusions |
Paper ID | Author Conclusions |
---|---|
Significant Variation | |
Belgium | |
Claeys 2013 | “Large inter-hospital variations” |
Canada | |
Feagan 2000 | “Considerable heterogeneity in LOSwas noted among the hospitals” |
Denmark | |
Klausen 2012 | “We show significant regional differences” |
Spain | |
Cabre 2004 | “Significant variations…among the 27 community hospitals” |
Garau 2008 | “Length of stay varied markedly among centres” |
UK | |
Hosker 2007 | “Wide variability between hospitals” |
Price 2006 | “The wide variation between hospital units…is probably unacceptable” |
Roberts 2002 | “The variation between hospitals…was very wide” |
US | |
Conway 2009 | “We found high variability in outcomes” |
Krumholz 1999 | “Significant inter hospital differences in the unadjusted length of stay” |
Variation Exists | |
UK | |
Rudd 2001 | “[Length of stay] varied by a mean of eight days between region” |
US | |
Brogan 2012 | “LOS differed across hospitals” |
Drye 2012 | “Mean patient LOS at the hospital level varied for each condition” |
No Conclusion | |
Spain | |
Pozo-Rodriguez 2012 | No conclusions |