A targeted interprofessional educational intervention to address therapeutic adherence of venous leg ulcer persons (TIEIVLU): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
verfasst von:
Sebastian Probst, Lara Allet, Jocelyne Depeyre, Sophie Colin, Monika Buehrer Skinner
Venous leg ulcers are slow-healing wounds with a high recurrence rate of 70% and a 60% risk of becoming chronic. Signs and symptoms such as pain or exudate are not only a burden on those affected but also on the healthcare system and society in general. The estimated leg ulcer prevalence in the general population is 1%. Treatment costs for leg ulcers are estimated to be 3% of overall health expenditure. Current therapeutic approaches are multifaceted and include compression therapy, leg elevation, specific ankle-exercises and a protein diet. They require an interdisciplinary team of health care professionals. Approximately 70% of patients have a knowledge deficit with regards to therapeutic measures and have difficulties with adherence to treatment protocols. Therefore, it is of utmost importance that the treatment team provides effective patient education and support during the learning phase. However, there is little evidence and no published studies that describe and evaluate effective interdisciplinary educational interventions that target compliance/adherence to the treatment plan in patients with leg ulcers. We therefore propose to develop an evidence-based interprofessional educational intervention and evaluate its feasibility first in a pilot study and subsequently in a randomized controlled trial.
Method/Design
First, the development of an evidence-based educational intervention in collaboration with an expert panel is proposed and second, a randomized controlled feasibility study in a wound-care outpatient clinic. Eligible patients (n = 20) with leg ulcers will be randomized to receive either interdisciplinary education and usual care or only usual care, for 12 weeks. Data will be analyzed using SPSS version 25. Univariate and bivariate analysis will be conducted according to the data level and distribution of the data.
Discussion
We will first develop an evidenced-based educational intervention and second, we will examine the feasibility of implementing this educational intervention in a realistic care context in patients with leg ulcers. The results will inform the final design of a subsequent randomized controlled trial, which will examine the effectiveness of the educational intervention. An intervention that enhances patient adherence to therapy would be beneficial to individual patients and to society as a whole.
Trial registration
ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03454698. Registered on 6 March 2018.
Venous leg ulcers (VLU) are poorly healing wounds caused by chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) [1]. CVI is a form of peripheral vascular disease that originates from an obstruction of the venous system or a defective venous valve, leading to edema, venous hypertension, skin inflammation and finally to venous leg ulcers [2]. Of all poorly healing wounds 60% are attributable to VLU [3]. Healing times are long with 60% of these wounds healing within 6 months and another 33% within 1 year. The wound never closes in 7% of cases [4]. Up to 70% of patients with leg ulcers suffer a recurrence within 3 months after wound closure [5‐7]. Hence, VLU is a health problem that affects most patients for life [8].
Epidemiological data from industrialized countries including the USA and Scandinavia have shown that the prevalence of leg ulcers is 1% in the general population and 3% in people over 80 years of age [9]. An extrapolation of these findings to the Swiss context would suggests that there are an estimated 84,000 to 94,000 people suffering from VLUs, of whom 12,500 are above 80 years of age [10].
Anzeige
Consequently, these chronic wounds are a burden not only on the affected persons themselves, requiring expensive treatment, but also on society as a whole, as an estimated 2–3% of all health expenditure covers the treatment of this condition [9]. With a Swiss health budget of nearly 78 billion Swiss francs in 2017, this would translate into an annual cost up to 3 billion Swiss francs [11].
Current treatment of venous leg ulcers
Standard care for the treatment and prevention of VLU includes compression therapy, elevation of the leg, exercises in the foot region, ambulating and a balanced diet rich in proteins and vitamins [12‐16]. The therapeutic approach to the management of VLU is a multifaceted approach targeting the management of risk factors associated with prolonged healing times and recurrence. As patient adherence to the care plan is an essential factor in leg ulcer healing and in the prevention of recurrent ulcers, the individual components and factors associated with non-adherence are of interest. Most of the evidence on adherence originates from small studies and there are no published results from large-scale studies. The following sections reflect published evidence on measures taken to prevent recurences.
Adherence to and patient knowledge of compression therapy
Adherence to compression therapy
A systematic review found that patients’ adherence to compression therapy varies widely between 10% and 80% [17]. Findings showed that non-adherence to compression therapy is associated with delayed wound healing and equates to a 2–20-fold increase in recurrence [18]. The literature cites a lack of patient knowledge of adherence to treatment as a reason for non-adherence [19‐21]. For example, Edwards and colleagues [19] showed that because of these knowledge deficits, only 27% of patients with leg ulcers wear compression stockings. One reason given for patients’ knowledge deficit is lack of education by professionals during delivery the of care, due to a lack of up-to-date information and appropriate time resources to provide the required education [22].
Interventions to improve adherence and knowledge
Intervention studies seeking to influence adherence to compression therapy and other aspects of the treatment were carried out by Heinen and Brooks. Based on their identification of factors for non-adherence, Heinen and co-workers developed and evaluated a counselling program aimed at improving the adherence to compression therapy and physical activity in patients with leg ulcers (“Lively Legs”) [23]. Treatment adherence was surveyed using patient interviews. One of the main findings was that although an increase in adherence was observed after 18 months in both groups (from 37% to 46% in the intervention group and from 27% to 45% in the control group), no significant or relevant difference was found between the groups. These findings might first be explained by the fact that the patients’ wound status was different at baseline—overall 68% had an open wound, while in 32% of patients the wound had already closed—and second by the fact that the overall dropout rate was 26%.
An educational intervention was examined in a study by Brooks and co-workers [24]. The subjects in the control group wore the compression stockings for an average of 3.3 h per 24 h longer when compared to the intervention group. No published studies describe any successful and/or feasible interventions that increase adherence to compression treatment.
Adherence to and knowledge of elevation of the legs and physical activity (walking and foot exercises)
Adherence to leg elevation and physical activity
In addition to adherence to compression therapy, the recurrence rate of leg ulcers is associated with elevating the legs to heart level for 30 min three to four times a day [25] and with regular isometric exercises. Brooks and co-workers [24] found that patients who had been educated to elevate their legs did this for 2 h longer per day than the control group, which had received no such guidance (f = 2.88, p = 0.015). A further measure described in the literature as reducing recurrence is to instruct patients to ambulate for 150 min a week (30 min, 5 days per week) at slow to medium pace to increase blood flow [26].
Isometric exercises in the ankle area are another way to prevent recurrence of leg ulcers. Van Hecke and co-workers [27] observed an increase in adherence to foot exercise regimes from 0 at baseline to 17 after 3 months (p = 0.003; Z = − 2.97). Kelechi and co-workers [28] observed an improvement in eversion of the right ankle by a mean of 1.3 (SD = 13.0; p = 0.543) following three home visits and three Skype consultations, in a small study of 21 participants.
Adherence to and knowledge of nutritional recommendations
Adherence to nutritional recommendations and relationship to wound healing
The patient’s diet and nutritional status are strongly associated with wound healing. Older adults’ adherence to nutritional recommendations is often insufficient due to their comorbidities, multiple medication usage, chewing and swallowing difficulties, physical limitations, limited access to healthy foods or a lack of social support [29, 30]. Malnutrition amongst older adults in general has been described but is still unaddressed [31].
Patients with chronic wounds require higher than recommended dietary allowances of nutrients to promote wound healing due to the increased metabolism activated by chronic inflammation and increased cellular activity in the wound. Possibly there is a discrepancy between nutritional needs and food consumption, especially when it comes to protein intake [31]. Protein deficiencies slow the healing process and the formation of scars, as the formation of connective tissue and collagen synthesis requires the presence of amino acids such as arginine or cysteine [32, 33]. Patients with protein deficiency are advised to increase their daily protein intake to 1.2–1.5 g/kg body weight.
Education for leg ulcer patients
The literature indicates that patients with VLUs do not have sufficient knowledge of the pathophysiology of their condition or of preventive measures to perform effective self-management [1, 2, 20, 34]. Since knowledge of preventive and therapeutic measures is a prerequisite for their implementation, education and support from healthcare specialists is essential.
Successful educational interventions are described in populations with other conditions like diabetes mellitus or asthma [35, 36]. However, there are few data on the effectiveness of educational measures in patients with venous leg ulcers. In particular there are no data on educational measures targeting improvement of patients’ knowledge of the etiology/pathophysiology of their disease and their adherence to customized treatment measures. Because patients are often left on their own after their ulcer has healed and have to take sole responsibility for their leg care, this education should take place before the completion of treatment. Due to their close therapeutic relationship, wound-care specialists are predestined to offer this educational training. The education aims to improve the adherence to treatment recommendations.
The few studies available show that the recurrence rate can be reduced by up to nine times by providing education [24, 37]. O’Brien and co-workers [38] performed a qualitative study, interviewing 10 patients about their attitudes to physical exercise. The results showed that patients learnt to understand the relationship between the wound and their adherence to treatment. A randomized controlled trial showed that by educating the patient, the recurrence rate was reduced from 36% to 4% within 1 year (log rank test = 8.28, p = 0.004) [24]. A recent randomized controlled feasibility trial using a 12-week supervised exercise program as adjunct therapy to compression in patients with VLU showed that due to exercises the healing rate was higher in the intervention group (83% vs. 60%) [39]. There is no published evidence on the effectiveness of interprofessional interventions in patients with VLU.
Study objectives
The aim of the protocol is (1) to develop an interdisciplinary educational intervention (nursing, physical therapy and nutrition) and (2) to evaluate the feasibility of implementing it for patients with VLUs and compare their adherence to therapy to that among patients receiving standard care. The results from this pilot study will inform the design of the main study, which will measure the effectiveness of this interdisciplinary intervention.
Methods: participants and interventions
The TIEIVLU study is a project with two parts. First is the development of an evidence-based interprofessional patient education intervention and second is the implementation of the intervention and testing of its feasibility and acceptability.
Anzeige
A small-scale single-center, randomized, controlled trial is proposed as a pilot to the main study. Randomization will occur at the subject level, Feasibility and acceptability will be measured using the participation rate and the completeness of the data.
The educational intervention will be developed at the School of Health Sciences, HES-SO University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Geneva. The content of this educational tool is to improve patient’s knowledge and self-efficacy and subsequently adherence to comprehensive treatments such as compression therapy, leg elevation, physical activity and nutrition.
Setting
The pilot study will be conducted in one outpatient wound-care clinic in western Switzerland. This outpatient wound-care center specializes in the care of patients with leg ulcers. Their staff are interested and experienced in the conduct of scientific studies. The participating outpatient wound-care center treats 45–66 patients with leg ulcers every year.
Eligibility criteria
The following inclusion criteria apply to participants in this study:
An existing open venous leg ulcer
An ankle brachial pressure index (ABPI) between 0.8 and 1.3
Age over 18 years
Proficiency in the French language
In addition, the following exclusion criterion applies:
Valid informed consent is not or cannot be given
Groups
A randomized controlled pilot trial with three measurement points will be carried out over 3 months to evaluate whether the intervention sustains an effect on the participants’ adherence to treatment. (Fig. 1). The control group (CG) will receive usual care. “Usual care” for patients in the CG is defined as follows: visits to the outpatient wound-care center as directed by a physician and wound care performed by the wound expert according to the hospital’s own standards. This standard corresponds to the one from the European Wound Management Association (EWMA).
Fig. 1
Randomization and data collection
×
The intervention group (IG) will receive usual care plus the educational intervention: “usual care” as described for the CG also applies to the IG. The intervention will consist of giving patients an opportunity to learn about the use of compression bandages, wearing and putting on compression stockings, physical activity, good skin care and a high-protein, vitamin-rich diet. This group will be supervised by another study nurse (not the nurse who is in charge of the control group).
The nurse performing the intervention will be a wound expert well-versed in the use of compression bandages, wearing and putting on compression stockings, physical activity, good skin care and a high-protein diet. The intervention nurse will conduct the educational sessions. The content of the educational sessions will be standardized and identical and will cover:
Pathophysiology of leg ulcers
Wearing of compression stockings
Isometrics exercises in the region of the lower extremities
Physical activity
High-protein diet
Anzeige
The educational sessions will follow a standardized protocol.
Patients in the CG will receive usual care at the outpatient clinics. Usual care includes the T = tissue removal, I = infection control, M = moisture balance and E = edge advancement (TIME) strategy proposed by the EWMA [40]. This treatment strategy optimizes the wound-healing process by reducing edema, exudate, and bacteria in the wound.
Patients in the intervention (IG) group will be receiving the same usual care as the patients in the CG. In addition, they will receive training in the following activities at 3-month intervals over 1 year.
Putting on and wearing compression stockings
The pathophysiological reasons why clients should be wearing compression stockings will be explained. In addition, each patient will receive an individual demonstration of how to best put on and take off the compression stockings.
Exercises in the region of the lower extremities
Patients will be instructed to do regular foot and ankle exercises that can help strengthen the leg muscles and improve blood flow in the legs. While they are sitting (or standing), they have to flex their ankles by pointing their toes away from them and then pointing them up. Patients are instructed to do 10 repetitions of the exercise several times each day [41‐43]. These exercises are consistent with the exercises in the guidelines for exercise and physical activity for older adults [44].
Physical activity
Patients will receive a wearable Fitbit. A Fitbit is an activity tracker, wireless-enabled wearable device that measures the number of steps walked. Through this technology the numbers of patients’ steps will be calculated and the patient will be reminded to move [45].
Elevation
Patients will be advised to elevate their feet to heart level at least 2 h per day.
Nutrition
Patients will be educated to eat a protein-rich diet. As with the movement, patients will also be instructed to evaluate their protein intake with the help of a nutrition log. To this end, patients will be educated on the protein content of various common foods.
Sample
The study participants recruited will be consecutive patients of the participating institution that meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria. For this pilot study 20 patients will be recruited.
Anzeige
Recruitment
Study participants will be recruited by nursing staff in the participating outpatient wound-care center. Patient lists will be screened daily for potential study participants diagnosed with venous leg ulcers. The nurses will assess the inclusion and exclusion factors for these potential participants and, if inclusion is possible, invite them to participate. Participants will be given 24 h to decide whether or not to participate. After obtaining informed consent, the participants will be referred to the study nurse, who will collect the data at baseline and at further data acquisition times along the timeline (T0 to T3). In the event that a person declines to participate, a mini-dataset will be collected comprising data on age, gender and reason for refusal. The mini-dataset will not contain health-related data. However, patients will be orally informed that stating the reason for declining to participate is entirely voluntary and that they can have the reason struck from the record at any time.
Methods: assignment of intervention
Randomization
After collection of baseline data, participants will be randomly assigned following simple randomization procedures (computerized random numbers) to one of two treatment groups. Gray sealed opaque numbered envelopes will be used. The intervention nurse will open the envelope and allocate the participant to the respective group.
Blinding
Due to the intervention being an educational program, neither the participants nor the staff performing the intervention can be blinded to treatment allocation. However, the person entering and analyzing the data will be blinded to the participants’ group assignments.
Methods: data collection, management and analysis
Data collection
The feasibility (including acceptability) will be measured using the participation rate and the completeness and the acceptability of the intervention. The participation rate is the number of persons participating in the study divided by the number of persons eligible for participation. The completeness is measured by calculating the amount of missing data. The acceptability of the intervention is assessed from the data on self-care in patients with venous leg ulcers, physical activity and quality of life, food intake and nutritional status. The data from the intervention and control groups will be collected by each group’s own trained study nurse. Baseline data will be collected at the outpatient clinic whereas at T1, T2 and T3 the data will be collected during home visits.
Anzeige
At baseline (T0), basic demographic data such as age, sex, height, weight, marital status, socioeconomic factors and medical history will be recorded. Diagnostic information on the first occurrence of leg ulcers, venous interventions, deep-vein thrombosis, cardiac situation (chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) severity, Ankle Brachial Pressure Index (ABPI; ABPI = Pleg/Parm), blood pressure, heart rate, edema) and other comorbidities will be obtained from the patient documentation on a single occasion. The data on self-care in patients with venous leg ulcers, physical activity and quality of life, food intake and nutritional status are obtained using instruments specifically validated for these concepts.
Health-related behavior is acquired monthly as a self-report (questionnaire) by the participants. The questionnaire enquires into the following parameters during the previous 24 h:
Duration of wearing the compression stockings (in hours)
Frequency and duration (time) of the elevation of the leg above heart level (minutes per day)
Amount of physical activity (through a Fitbit)
Number of foot exercises performed (how many days a week the foot exercises are performed)
Nutrition (food intake assessment and nutritional status)
Self-care
In addition, the following wound-related data are collected in patients with wounds:
Date of recurrence
Wound characteristics (size, time to possible healing, wound classification according to Widmer [46])
Wound dressings used (including for compression)
Data management
The study nurse (SN) will collect the data on the intervention and control the accuracy of the documentation. Data entry will be performed using electronic support (EvaSys software) or paper format. The data quality assessment will be conducted in a cross-over procedure among the SNs.
Data entry will be checked for logical inconsistencies, extreme outliers, missing data and distributional properties. A random sample of 10% of all data entry forms will be checked. If the error rate is higher than 5% a second data entry will be performed.
All data will be kept in a cabinet in the project manager’s office at the School of Health Sciences, Geneva. Confidentiality will be assured. Only the investigators and the designated research team will have access to the data. Patient data will be coded, and the patient’s name and unique identifiers will not appear on any data forms. Links between ID and encoding will be accessible only with password restricted to the principal investigator. The Statistical Package for Social Sciences IBM SPSS 25.0 will be used for data analysis.
Statistical methods
Univariate analysis
The sample (intervention and control groups) will be described, according to the data level, in terms of their demographic and health data, using descriptive statistics. Absolute and relative frequencies will be determined for categorical variables. Numerical averages and standard deviations will be calculated for normally distributed variables. The numerical median and IQR or range will be calculated for non-normally distributed variables. Exact 95% confidence intervals will be calculated where relevant. The calculations will be performed for each data acquisition time point.
Bivariate analysis
To compare the groups (intervention and control) at T0, a parametric test (t test) or a non-parametric test (Mann-Whitney U test) will be used for sociodemographic and health-related data depending on the data level and distribution. All tests will be two-sided.
Ethics approval
The study will not be started until it has been examined and improved by the Ethics Committee in the Canton of Geneva. The ethical foundations of this study are based on the “Research on Humans” guideline of the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS) [47]. Following the SAMS guideline by analogy, the three principles of research ethics—respect for individuals, welfare and justice—will be given special attention in this study.
Discussion
This protocol is designed to develop an interprofessional educational intervention and to examine it in everyday care. If the results of this feasibility study are positive a larger study will be conducted. This larger study will generate new information on the knowledge, attitudes and behaviors of patients with VLU in regards to adherence to treatment recommendations and to what effect these can be modified by an interdisciplinary educational intervention. The results will subsequently inform the development/review of current clinical guidelines. Enhancing patient adherence to therapy is a challenge that is not unique to the care of patients with VLU or the field of wound care. The findings can be applied to patients with other chronic conditions that require close adherence to treatment regimes Additional file 1.
Acknowledgements
For this study protocol we have no acknowledgements.
Funding
This study was funded with an unrestricted grant of the Ebnet foundation, Switzerland.
Availability of data and materials
This is a study protocol. The data of this pilot study will be available after completion.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable for the study protocol.
Consent for publication
We give our consent to publish this article in Trials.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
A targeted interprofessional educational intervention to address therapeutic adherence of venous leg ulcer persons (TIEIVLU): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
verfasst von
Sebastian Probst Lara Allet Jocelyne Depeyre Sophie Colin Monika Buehrer Skinner
