Background
Rationale
Vaccine acceptability, hesitancy, and uptake
Barriers and supports to vaccine acceptability and uptake
HPV vaccine-specific barriers, supports, and effective interventions
Barriers and supports to HPV vaccine acceptability and uptake in indigenous peoples
Methods/design
Aims
Research questions
Eligibility criteria
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
---|---|
Global Indigenous peoples (including First Nations, Inuit, and Métis (Canada), American Indians and Alaskan Natives (USA), and Indigenous peoples in other countries including, but not limited to, China, South Asia, former Soviet Union, Southeast Asia, South America, Africa, Central America/Mexico, Arabia, Japan and the Pacific Islands, Australia, New Zealand, Greenland and Scandinavia) [69, 94] and participants may include vaccine recipients, youth, parents, grandparents, guardians, Elders and/or knowledge holders, health care providers, policy−/decision-makers, and community leaders, without restriction on gender or age, AND | Studies that do not include global Indigenous peoples or in which one or more global Indigenous peoples comprise less than 50% of the study participants OR Studies that do not discuss barriers or supports to vaccination or HPV vaccination AND/OR Studies that do not discuss vaccination interventions, or HPV vaccination interventions or enhancing the acceptability or uptake of vaccination or HPV vaccination, or reducing vaccine or HPV vaccine hesitancy OR Studies lacking extractable data (i.e., policy papers or papers with no data) OR |
Studies discuss barriers or supports to vaccination or HPV vaccination AND/OR | Non-original research |
Studies discuss vaccination interventions to increase acceptability or uptake of vaccination or HPV vaccination, or to reduce vaccine or HPV vaccine hesitancy |
Outcome measures
Study type
Data sources and search strategy
Databases: Ovid MEDLINE(R) Epub Ahdead of Print, In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, Ovid MEDLINE(R) Daily and Ovid MEDLINE(R) 1946 to present (Feb 22, 2017) |
The core search around the concepts of HPV and vaccination is as follows: |
1. exp. Papillomavirus Infections/ |
2. exp. Vaccination/ |
3. (hpv or human papilloma* or vaccin* or immuniz*or immunis*).kw,tw. |
4. 1 or 2 or 3 |
To identify studies involving Canadian indigenous populations, we applied a filter developed by health librarians at the University of Alberta [109] to identify Canadian indigenous populations to the above search. |
We also ran this search against subject headings and keywords to identify studies related to selected global indigenous populations, as follows: |
Databases: Ovid MEDLINE(R) Epub Ahead of Print, In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, Ovid MEDLINE(R) Daily and Ovid MEDLINE(R) 1946 to present (Feb 22, 2017) |
1. exp. Papillomavirus Infections/ |
2. exp. Vaccination/ |
3. (hpv or human papilloma* or vaccin* or immuniz* or immunis*).kf,tw. |
4. 1 or 2 or 3 |
5. exp. american native continental ancestry group/ or exp. oceanic ancestry group/ |
6. exp. Health Services, Indigenous/ |
7. exp. United States Indian Health Service/ |
8. (aborigin* or Alaska* Native* or American Indian* or Amerindian* or Eskimo* or community-based participatory or indigenous or Inuit* or Maori or Métis or Native American* or Native Hawaiian* or native people* or tribe* or tribal or Pacific Islander* or Torres Strait Islander*).kf,tw. |
9. 5 or 6 or 7 or 8 |
10. 4 and 9 |
Gray literature search strategy
Gray literature resource name | URL |
---|---|
Health Sciences Online (HSO) | |
OAISter | |
International Network in Indigenous Health Knowledge and Development (INIHKD) | |
Canadian Electronic Library’s Public Documents Collection (previously the Canadian Health Research Collection) | |
Center for World Indigenous Studies | |
Circumpolar Health Database | |
Health Info Net | |
Metis Health Database | |
Native Indigenous Studies Portal | |
Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) | |
First Nations Development Institute | |
Active Circle | |
Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development (Government of Canada) | |
Centre for Indigenous Peoples’ Nutrition and Environment (CINE) | |
First Nations Environmental Health Innovation Network | |
Assembly of First Nations | |
First Nations and Inuit Health Branch (Government of Canada – Health Canada) | |
National Collaborating Centre for Aboriginal Health (NCCAH) (Government of Canada) | |
National Aboriginal Health Organization (NAHO) (Agency was closed June 29, 2012; archival data will be searched using the Canadian Health Research Collection – archives available on the NAHO website to December 22, 2017) | |
Network Environment for Aboriginal Health Research (NEAHR) | |
BC Centres for Disease Control (Chee Mamuk - Aboriginal Health) | |
First Nations in BC Knowledge Network | |
First Nations Health Authority | |
Aboriginal Portal | |
Indigenous Affairs Website (Government of Alberta) | |
Ministry of Government Relations (First Nations Metis and Northern Affairs) (Government of Saskatchewan) | |
Centre for Aboriginal Health Research (CAHR) | |
First Nations, Metis and Inuit Health (University of Manitoba) | |
Indigenous and Municipal Relations (Government of Manitoba) | |
Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation (Government of Ontario) | |
Centre for Indigenous Studies (University of Toronto) | |
Secretariat aux affaires autochtones (Gouvernement de Quebec) | |
Aboriginal Affairs (Government of New Brunswick) | |
Office of Aboriginal Affairs (Government of Nova Scotia) | |
Aboriginal Affairs Secretariat (Government of Prince Edward Island) | |
Department of Labrador and Aboriginal Affairs Office (LAAO) (Government of Newfoundland & Labrador) | |
Aboriginal Relations (Government of Yukon) | |
NWT Aboriginal Governments | |
Aboriginal Affairs and Intergovermental Relations (Government of the North West Territories) | |
Department of Executive and Intergovermental Affairs (Aboriginal Affairs) Government of Nunavut | |
Population Research and Outcomes Studies Unit (PROS) (University of Melbourne) | |
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander-Australian Government Policy and Program Connection Website (Government of Australia – and State Site Portal) | |
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare | |
Australian Policy Online | |
The Lowitja Institute (Australia’s National Institute for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Research) | |
National Centre for Immunization Research and Surveillance (NCIRS) (Government of Australia) | |
Immunize Australia | |
Toi Te Ora Public Health (Government of New Zealand) | |
New Zealand Ministry of Health | |
US Centers for Disease Control | |
US Indian Health Service (Federal Health Program for American Indians and Alaska Natives) | |
Immunize Canada | |
Ministry of Health-BC | |
BC Centre for Disease Control | |
Immunize BC | |
Alberta Health | |
Alberta Health Services | |
Immunize Alberta | |
SK Ministry of Health | |
Manitoba Ministry of Health, Seniors and Active Living | |
Ontario Ministry of Health and long-term care | |
Public Health Ontario | |
Quebec Ministry of Health | |
Institut national de santé publique du Québec (INSPQ) | |
New Brunswick Ministry of Health | |
Nova Scotia Department of Health and Wellness | |
Nova Scotia Health Authority | |
PEI Health and Wellness | |
Health PEI | |
Newfoundland and Labrador Department of Health and Community Services | |
Canadian Association for Immunization Research and Evaluation (CAIRE) | |
Canadian Center for Vaccinology | |
Vaccine Evaluation Center | |
Canadian Immunization Research Network (CIRN) | |
Yukon Government Department of Health and Social Services | |
NWT Health and Social Services | |
Nunavut Department of Health | |
Canadian Public Health Association | |
Australian Indigenous Health Info Net |
Preliminary findings
Study selection
Title and abstract screening (Level 1)
Full-text review and data abstraction (Level 2)
Variable | Definition | |
---|---|---|
Study characteristics | ||
Refid | Study unique reference identification number | |
Author | Author last name, initials | |
Year | Year of publication | |
Title | Full title of manuscript | |
Language | Original language of publication | |
Location | Geographic location (country) of study | |
Time | Data collection period (start to end of recruitment) | |
Data | Data collection method(s) | |
Funding | Reported funding source(s) for study | |
Population | Indigenous population, community or ethnicity, as defined by study authors and eligibility criteria as reported by authors | |
Target | Target population (health care providers, vaccine recipients, parents, policy makers etc.) | |
Report(s) | Source(s) of reported barriers and/or supports | |
Number | Number of participants in study | |
age_mean, age_sd | Age of included participants [mean (SD), median (IQR), or categorical age, as reported] | |
age_med, age-iqr | ||
age_cat | ||
Youth | Study participants (or cohort of study participants) were < 18 years (Yes = 1, No = 0, Not Reported NR =99) | |
Gender | % female | |
Gender_target | Female, male, female and male | |
Context | Describe context of implementation (may include a description of the social, economic, policy, healthcare, organizational or other contextual facets that may influence scale implementation) | |
Setting | Describe study setting, as defined by study authors (may include characteristics of the locations, personnel, resources for implementation and/or criteria for eligibility as an implementation site that are used in the study | |
setting_other | Describe ‘other setting’, as defined by study authors | |
Aimobj | Study aims and objectives | |
Design | Study design | |
0 = RCT (Randomized controlled trial) | ||
1 = NRCT (non-randomized controlled trial) | ||
2 = cohort | ||
3 = case control | ||
4 = controlled before-after | ||
5 = interrupted time series | ||
6 = qualitative | ||
7 = cross-sectional survey | ||
8 = scoping, systematic or other synthesis | ||
9 = mixed methods | ||
10 = other | ||
design_other | Describe ‘other study design’ | |
Sampling | Describe sampling strategy | |
Inclusion | Study inclusion criteria, as reported by study authors | |
Exclusion | Study exclusion criteria, as reported by study authors | |
vaccine_delivery | Agency, authority, or group(s) administering vaccine | |
vaccine_setting | The environment (clinic, school or other) where the vaccine was delivered | |
vaccine_type, vaccine_batch | Type and/or batch of vaccine administered | |
vaccine_series | Describe how the vaccine administered (one dose, 3 doses etc.) | |
vaccine_status | Reported vaccination status of study participants (Yes = 1, No = 0) | |
vaccine_statusdescribe | If yes, describe whether full series, or only partial vaccination etc. | |
mod_frame | Authors describe explicitly, a health model, framework or theory utilized to frame their study (Yes = 1, No = 0, Not clear = 99) | |
mod_frame_valid | Did the researchers use or test the model/framework or theory? (Yes = 1, No = 0, Not reported = 99) | |
mod_framedescribe | Describe model, framework or theory | |
Studylim | Reported study limitations | |
Onoffres | Location of participants (on reserve, off reserve) | |
onoffres_other | Describe location of participants if participants are located off reserve | |
Geography | Relative geographic location as reported by study authors | |
Ses | Reported socioeconomic status of participants | |
education_level | Reported level of education of participants | |
knowledge_gen* | Reported participant knowledge about vaccination | |
attitudes_gen* | Reported participant attitudes about vaccination | |
beliefs_gen* | Reported participant beliefs about vaccination | |
behaviors_gen* | Reported participant behaviors regarding vaccination | |
knowledge_HPV* | Reported participant knowledge about HPV vaccination | |
attitudes_HPV* | Reported participant attitudes about HPV vaccination | |
beliefs_HPV* | Reported participant beliefs about HPV vaccination | |
behaviors_HPV* | Reported participant behaviors regarding HPV vaccination | |
HPV_aware | Awareness of HPV vaccine | |
sex_status | Participants reporting sexually active | |
pap_status | Participants reporting prior abnormal pap smear test | |
STI_status | Participants reporting previous STI | |
HPV_status | Participants reporting prior HPV infection | |
Barriers and Supports | ||
barrier* | Describe barriers to vaccine (all types) | subcategories will be determined inductively |
barrier_descr | Describe which vaccine type the reported barriers discuss | |
barrier_HPV* | Describe barriers to HPV vaccine | subcategories will be determined inductively |
support* | Describe supports to vaccine (all types) | subcategories will be determined inductively |
support_descr | Describe which vaccine type the reported supports discuss | |
support_HPV* | Describe supports to HPV vaccine | subcategories will be determined inductively |
recommend_gen* | Describe study recommendations for vaccination (all types) | subcategories will be determined inductively |
recommend_descr | Describe which vaccine type the recommendations pertain to | |
recommend_HPV* | Describe study recommendations for HPV vaccination | subcategories will be determined inductively |
Vaccine Intervention Outcomes | ||
Outcomeimplem | Describe primary and other outcomes of the implementation strategy, and how they were measured | |
Outcomeintervent | Describe primary and other outcomes of the intervention, and how they were measured | |
Process | Describe the process evaluation objectives and outcomes related to the mechanism by which the strategy is expected to work | |
Intervention* | Describe vaccine intervention | subcategories will be determined inductively |
intervention_HPV* | Describe HPV vaccine intervention | subcategories will be determined inductively |
implemintervent | Describe the implementation strategy | |
HPVimplemintervent | Describe the HPV-specific implementation strategy | |
Subgroups | Describe any subgroups or nested studies undertaken in the study | |
RR | Risk ratios reported | |
RR_pvalue | Reported p-values for RR | |
OR | Odds ratios reported | |
OR_pvalue | Reported p-values for OR | |
Econintervent | Methods for resource use, costs, economic outcomes and analysis for the intervention | |
Econimplem | Methods for resource use, costs, economic outcomes and analysis for the implementation strategy | |
Samplesize | Describe the sample sizes, calculations | |
Analysis | Describe analytic methods with rationale for methodological choice | |
Subanalysis | Describe subanalyses, representativeness and outcomes of subgroups including those recruited to specific research tasks | |
Fidelimplem | Fidelity of the implementation strategy as planned and adaptation to suit context and preferences | |
Fidelintervent | Fidelity of delivering the core components of the intervention | |
Contextchange | Describe contextual changes that may affect outcomes | |
Harms | Describe all important harms or unintended effects for each group | |
vaccine_acceptance | Reported factors influencing vaccine acceptance (study participant attitudes and beliefs) | |
vaccine_uptake | A rate or quantification of the number or proportion of the study population who received vaccine intervention | |
vaccine_refuse | A rate or quantification of the number or proportion of the population who refused vaccine intervention | |
vaccine_hesitancy | Describe reported factors relating to under-immunization, delay or questioning of vaccines, selecting only certain vaccines, desire to access a trustworthy healthcare provider [Specific description of hesitancy as a barrier (all types of vaccine)] | |
hesitancy_HPV | Describe reported factors relating to under-immunization, delay or questioning of vaccines, selecting only certain vaccines, desire to access a trustworthy healthcare provider [Specific description of hesitancy as a barrier (HPV vaccination)] | |
CDGA_IC | CGDA Intervention Category [142] – Informational, Behavioral, Environmental | |
CGDA_IL | CDGA Intervention Intensity Level [142] – active engagement to individual, active engagement to population, passive engagement with significant effort, passive engagement with minimal effort | |
Interventimplic | Describe policy, practice or research implications for the intervention, including sustainability | |
Imlemimplic | Describe policy, practice or research implications for the implementation strategy, specifically related to scalability | |
Regulatory | Ethics approval, trial/study registration (and protocol if available), governance of data use, presence of conflicts of interest etc. |
Methodological quality
Data analysis
Review aims | Method | Guiding questions | Anticipated review outputs |
---|---|---|---|
Primary Aims | |||
1: To identify and assess the documented barriers and supports to HPV and other vaccinations in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples | Thematic synthesis | • What are the documented barriers and supports described in eligible studies? • What is the quality of the eligible literature? (QATSDD tool) • What, if any, themes arise in the literature describing barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples? | • To describe articles that report barriers and/or supports to HPV and other vaccines • To establish the quality of included articles (item and total study scores) • To analyze and (where possible) group barriers and facilitators meaningfully across studies • To analyze any themes among barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine that are specific to Canadian Indigenous populations • To statistically analyze measured barriers and supports across studies (should they be deemed appropriate for meta-analysis) |
Quantitative Analysis | • What, if any, barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples are statistically significant? | ||
2: To identify and assess the documented effective interventions to increase acceptability, uptake or reduce hesitancy of vaccination, and HPV vaccination, in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples | Descriptive statistics, narrative summary | • What interventions are documented to increase vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability and uptake and reduce hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous populations? • What is the quality of the eligible literature? (QATSDD tool) • What, is the nature of vaccine or HPV acceptability, hesitancy and uptake in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples? | • To describe articles that report effective strategies for increasing vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability, uptake or reducing hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples • To establish the quality of included articles (item and total study scores) • To describe quantitatively and qualitatively (thematic synthesis) the nature and characteristics of interventions to increase vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability and uptake or reducing hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples • To synthesize evidence of knowledge, beliefs, and attitudes of Canadian and global Indigenous peoples arising in the eligible literature |
Descriptive Analysis | • What are the features (e.g. intervention category, definition, intensity level) and CFIR domain/subdomain assessment of each reported intervention? | • To describe and systematically assess effective interventions and report findings using the CFIR framework domains/subdomains. | |
Secondary Aims | |||
3: To identify and assess documented barriers and supports to vaccination, and HPV vaccination, in youth (< 18 years) within Canadian and global Indigenous peoples. | Thematic synthesis | • What are the documented barriers and supports described in eligible studies for vaccine and HPV vaccine in youth (< 18 years) within Canadian and global Indigenous peoples? • What is the quality of the eligible literature? (QATSDD tool) • What, if any, themes arise in the barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine in youth (< 18 years) in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples? | • To describe articles that report barriers and/or supports to HPV and other vaccines in Canadian and global Indigenous youth (< 18 years) • To establish the quality of included articles • To analyze (and where possible) group barriers and facilitators meaningfully across studies • To analyze any themes among barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine that are specific to youth (< 18 years) in Canadian Indigenous populations • Cross-study qualitative synthesis of themes describing barriers and supports |
Quantitative Analysis | • What, if any, measured barriers and supports to vaccine or HPV vaccine in youth (< 18 years) in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples are statistically significant? | • To statistically analyze measured barriers and supports across studies (descriptive statistics; based on recent systematic reviews it is unlikely that a meta-analysis will be possible) | |
4: To identify and assess documented interventions to increase acceptability and uptake and reduce hesitancy of vaccination and HPV vaccination in youth (< 18 years) within Canadian and global Indigenous peoples. | Descriptive statistics, thematic summary | • What interventions are documented to increase vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability, uptake and reduce hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous youth (< 18 years)? • What is the quality of the eligible literature? • What, if any, themes arise in the descriptions of interventions for vaccine or HPV acceptability/hesitancy and uptake in Canadian and global Indigenous youth (< 18 years)? | • To describe articles that report effective strategies for increasing vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability, uptake or reducing hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous peoples • To establish the quality of included articles • To describe quantitatively (descriptive statistics) and qualitatively (thematic synthesis) the nature and characteristics of interventions to increase vaccine or HPV vaccine acceptability, uptake or reduce hesitancy in Canadian and global Indigenous youth (< 18 years) (based on recent systematic reviews it is unlikely that a meta-analysis will be possible) • To synthesize Canadian and global Indigenous youth (< 18 years) knowledge, beliefs and attitudes arising in the eligible literature • Cross-study qualitative synthesis of themes describing acceptability, uptake and reduced hesitancy interventions |
Descriptive Analysis | • What are the features (e.g., intervention category, definition, intensity level) and CFIR domain/subdomain assessment of each reported intervention to increase acceptability and uptake, and reduce hesitancy of vaccination and HPV vaccination in youth (< 18 years) within Canadian and global Indigenous peoples? | • To describe and systematically assess interventions to increase acceptability and uptake, and reduce hesitancy of vaccination and HPV vaccination in youth (< 18 years) within Canadian and global Indigenous peoples, and report findings using the domains/subdomains of the CFIR framework. |