Background
Methods
Smokers and smoking-attributable deaths
Policy levels and effect sizes
Policy | Description | Effect size (% Effect)a
| Ranges for sensitivity analysisa
| Long term multi-pliera
| Urban adjustorb
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tax as a percent of retail price of cigarettes | Excise tax, taking into account expanded effect through value added tax | 5.9 % (with price elasticity -0.15c and tax as a percent of price increasing from 69 % to 75 %) | (-25 %- + 25 %) | 2 | no |
Smoke-free air laws | |||||
Ban in all indoor workplaces | Ban in all indoor private workplaces | 6 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.25 | yes |
Ban in indoor offices only | Ban except ventilated workplaces | 4 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.25 | yes |
Ban in health facilities, univ, govt. facilities (2 of 3) | Ban in work areas only | 2 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.25 | yes |
Restaurants: Smoke-free in all indoor areas | Ban in restaurants | 2 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.25 | yes |
Pubs and bars: smoke-free | Ban in pubs and bars | 1 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.25 | yes |
Enforcement | MPOWER: 0-10 | 25 % of effect depends on % enforcement (of 10) | |||
Publicity | Based on level of tobacco control funding | 25 % of above effect depends on publicity | |||
Mass Media Campaigns (policies are mutually exclusive) | |||||
Highly publicized campaign | Tobacco control spending ≥ $0.50 USD per capita & media campaign | 6.5 % reduction | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.2 | no |
Moderately publicized campaign | Tobacco control spending ≥ $0.05 and < $0.50 USD per capita | 3.5 % reduction | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.2 | no |
Low publicized campaign | If tobacco control spending < $0.05 USD per capita | 1.0 % reduction | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.2 | no |
Marketing Bansd
| |||||
Ban on direct and indirect marketing | Ban on all direct and indirect advertising | 5 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.3 | no |
Ban on advertising | Ban on all direct advertising | 3 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.3 | no |
Partial ban on advertising | Ban on some direct or indirect advertising | 1 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 1.3 | no |
Enforcement | MPOWER: 0 – 1.0 | 50 % of effect depends on enforcement | |||
Health Warningsd
| |||||
Complete | Bold and graphic, covers 50 % of package | 2 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 2 | no |
Strong | Warning 30–50 % of package | 1 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 2 | no |
Weak | Warning <30 % of package | 0.50 % | (-50 %, +50 %) | 2 | no |
Cessation Treatment Policiese
| |||||
Nicotine Replacement Therapy | If sold by pharmacy or general store and if Rx required | Prev. reduced 0.667 % if available at w/out Rx, 0.334 % if Rx | (-75 %, +75 %) | 2.5 | yes |
Bupropion and Varenicline | Sold by pharmacy with prescription | Prev. reduced 0.334 %, | (-75 %, +75 %) | 2.5 | yes |
Provision of treatments | Type facilities: primary care, hospitals, health professionals, community and other | If provided in in most, prevalence reduced 2.25 %, if provided in some, then 1.125 % | (-75 %, +75 %) | 2.5 | yes |
Quit line type | Operating active quit line | Prev. reduced 0.5 % | (-75 %, +75 %) | 2.5 | yes |
Overall effect | With all of the above policies and publicity based on tobacco control funding | Prev. reduced 4.75 %, 25 % of effect depends on publicity | (-75 %, +75 %) | 2.5 | yes |
Results
Current levels | Smoking prevalence | Number of smokers | Projected deaths of smokers (lower) | Projected deaths of smokers (upper) | |||||
Male | Female | Male | Female | Total | Male | Female | Total | ||
Year 2014 | 24.5 % | 13.2 % | 1,093,088 | 349,468 | 197,076 | 546,544 | 454,308 | 256,199 | 710,507 |
Original policy | Short-term effect size | Long-term effect size | Reduction in number of smokers | Reduction in smoking attributable deaths (lower) | Reduction in smoking attributable deaths (upper) | ||||
Male | Female | Total | Male | Female | Total | ||||
Protect through Smoke-free Air Laws | |||||||||
Moderate | -4.6 % | -5.8 % | 63,403 | 20,270 | 11,431 | 31,702 | 26,352 | 14,860 | 41,212 |
Offer Cessation Treatments | |||||||||
Moderate | -2.6 % | -6.5 % | 70,918 | 22,673 | 12,786 | 35,459 | 29,475 | 16,622 | 46,097 |
Mass Media Campaigns | |||||||||
Low | -5.5 % | -6.6 % | 72,144 | 23,065 | 13,007 | 36,072 | 29,984 | 16,909 | 46,893 |
Warnings on Cigarette Packages | |||||||||
Moderate | -2.0 % | -4.0 % | 43,724 | 13,979 | 7,883 | 21,862 | 18,172 | 10,248 | 28,420 |
Enforcement of Marketing Restrictions | |||||||||
Low-moderate | -4.4 % | -5.7 % | 62,525 | 19,990 | 11,273 | 31,262 | 25,986 | 14,655 | 40,641 |
Raise Cigarette Taxes | |||||||||
Excise Tax 69 % | -5.9 % | -11.7 % | 127,969 | 40,913 | 23,072 | 63,984 | 26,593 | 14,997 | 83,180 |
Combined Policies | |||||||||
-22.6 % | -34.3 % | 374,408 | 119,701 | 67,503 | 187,204 | 155,611 | 87,754 | 243,365 |
-
Increasing excise cigarette taxes from its current level of 69 % to 75 % of price will reduce male and female smoking prevalence by 5.9 % within 5 years, increasing to 11.7 % in 40 years, and will avert between 64 and 83 thousand premature deaths.
-
Comprehensive smoke-free air laws that made all worksites, restaurants, bars and other public places smoke-free along with stronger enforcement will reduce male and female smoking prevalence by 4.6 % in five years, increasing to 5.8 % in 40 years, and will avert between 32 and 41 thousand premature deaths.
-
A well-publicized, comprehensive cessation policy that included a national quitline along with financial full coverage of all treatments will reduce smoking prevalence by 2.6 % in 5 years, increasing 6.5 % in 40 years, and will avert between 35.5 and 46 thousand premature deaths.
-
A high level media campaign will reduce smoking prevalence by 5.5 % in 5 years, increasing to 6.6 % in 40 years, and will avert between 36 and 47 thousand premature deaths.
-
Pictorial health warnings that cover 50 % of the cigarette package will reduce smoking prevalence by 2 % in 5 years, increasing to 4 % in 40 years, and will prevent between 22 and 28 thousand premature deaths.
-
A well-enforced comprehensive ban of direct and indirect advertising (including tobacco products) will reduce smoking prevalence by 4.4 % in 5 years, increasing to 5.7 % in 40 years, and will prevent between 31 and 41 thousand premature deaths.