Background
Cerebrotendinous xanthomatosis (CTX: OMIM#213,700) is a rare autosomal-recessive lipid storage disease caused by deficiency of the mitochondrial cytochrome P 450 enzyme, sterol 27-hydroxylase (CYP27A1, EC 1.14.15.15) due to mutations in the
CYP27A1 gene [
1]. Decreased activity of sterol 27-hydroxylase leads to impaired bile acid synthesis, resulting in reduced production of bile acids, especially chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA), in addition to elevated serum cholestanol and urine bile alcohols. Clinical manifestations of CTX include neonatal jaundice or cholestasis, refractory diarrhea, juvenile cataracts, tendon xanthomas, osteoporosis, coronary heart disease, and progressive neuropsychiatric disturbances [
2‐
9]. A phenotypic heterogeneity, even within the same family, is a characteristic feature of CTX [
2]. Replacement treatment with CDCA can lead to biochemical and clinical improvements [
10,
11]. However, once significant neuropsychiatric manifestations are established, clinical symptoms may continue to worsen despite normalization of serum cholestanol levels [
3,
8,
12,
13]. Here, we report two Japanese CTX siblings with the identical genotype showing different clinical courses and responses to treatment with CDCA.
Discussion and conclusions
CYP27A1 is the only gene known to be associated with CTX and therefore, the diagnosis is confirmed by the presence of biallelic pathogenic mutations in the
CYP27A1 gene [
4,
9,
14].
CYP27A1 pathogenic mutations include missense and nonsense mutations, splice-site mutations, and insertion/deletion mutations [
6,
14]. Regarding the present report,
CYP27A1 gene analysis of family members identified a novel compound heterozygous mutation, c.1176_1177delGA, and the known c.1420C > T mutation. The siblings in this study were enrolled in a nationwide survey in Japan and the c.1176_1177delGA variant was reported in the article by Sekijima et al. as a novel mutation [
9]. The c.1176_1177delGA
CYP27A1 mutation is predicted to lead to a frameshift and a premature stop codon. The truncated protein is considered to be functionally null, consistent with the idea that a loss of sterol 27-hydroxylase function mechanism is responsible for CTX. Genetic analysis of the family members revealed that the c.1176_1177delGA mutation is in
trans with the c.1420C > T mutation, which is known to be pathogenic. The c.1176_1177delGA mutation was not detected in publicly available databases: dbSNP 150 (
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), 1000 Genomes Project, The Exome Aggregation Consortium (ExAC) (
http://exac.broadinstitute.org), and Human Genetic Variation Database (HGVD) (
http://www.genome.med.kyoto-u.ac.jp/SnpDB/). Considering these findings, the c.1176_1177delGA mutation was classified as pathogenic according to the recommendation of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology (ACMG-AMP) [
15]. Furthermore, this mutation was not listed in the Human Gene Mutation Database (HGMD) (
http://www.hgmd.org) or ClinVar (
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/).
Nagai et al. reported a case of triplets with CTX. All three patients equally exhibited xanthomas, cataracts, intellectual disability, pyramidal and cerebellar signs, and sensory loss [
16]. A case of three CTX siblings with the similar clinical presentations of tendon xanthomas, cataracts, osteoporosis, mental retardation, cerebellar ataxia, and peripheral neuropathy has also been reported [
17]. It has been shown that there are possible associations between c.1421G > A (p.Arg474Gln) and classical form CTX, c.1241G > A (p.Arg405Gln) and spinal form CTX, and c.435G > T (p.Gly145 =) and non-neurological form CTX [
9]. On the other hand, striking phenotypic heterogeneity between CTX patients with the same mutation, even within families, has also been reported [
2]. In the present siblings, there is considerable phenotypic variability, although they share the same
CYP27A1 mutations. It has been suggested that environmental factors are responsible for phenotypic variability [
17]. However, a considerable difference in the severity of intellectual disability and parkinsonism was observed in a pair of identical twins with CTX who had been continuously living together and had similar eating habits [
18]. Therefore, it is possible that, rather than environmental factors, currently unknown genetic modifiers or certain epigenetic factors are responsible for the clinical heterogeneity in CTX [
18].
After the landmark study published in 1984, in which the long-term efficacy of oral CDCA was demonstrated, it was approved as a first-line treatment for CTX [
10]. While CTX has been considered to be a treatable metabolic disorder, clinical deterioration can be observed even after initiation of CDCA treatment [
3]. Therefore, it is important to recognize that normalization of serum cholestanol level is not necessarily correlated with a good prognosis [
3]. Retrospective cohort studies have demonstrated that the age at diagnosis and initiation of CDCA treatment is associated with the prognosis of CTX patients [
8,
12,
13]. It was found that presence of significant neurological manifestations at the time of diagnosis was associated with a poor prognosis in CTX patients who were 25 years of age or older [
8]. On MRI, cerebellar vacuolation has been recently indicated as a poor prognostic marker in CTX [
19,
20], while absence of dentate nuclei signal changes is associated with a better prognosis [
20]. In the present siblings, CDCA treatment lead to a similar gradual decline in serum cholestanol, but the clinical courses were markedly different. The proband (Case 1) showed cognitive decline after beginning treatment with CDCA, despite initial improvement in WAIS-III scores. He also exhibited progressive diffuse brain atrophy and widespread signal changes on follow-up MRI, with progressive neurological manifestations including dysarthria, dysphagia, and spastic paraplegia. On the other hand, the younger sister (Case 2) showed a good response to CDCA treatment, although she had cognitive impairment at the time of diagnosis. Thus, initiation of CDCA treatment before the appearance of characteristic brain MRI findings and severe neurological symptoms seems to be associated with a good clinical course.
In conclusion, we report two CTX siblings with a novel compound heterozygous mutation who showed markedly different phenotypes and clinical courses. Further studies are needed to elucidate mechanisms responsible for the clinical diversity in CTX. There can be a crucial “point of no return” in CTX, after which initiation of treatment cannot prevent progression of the disease and therefore, early diagnosis and treatment are essential [
12]. Prognostic factors predicting treatment outcome should be identified for CTX.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.