Background
Malaria is a world’s most widespread febrile illness and causes significant public health concern in morbidity and mortality. Approximately 85% of the global infectious disease burden has been attributed to malaria and six other infectious diseases. As per the recent WHO estimates, 219 million cases reported in 91 countries with an estimated mortality of 405,000 [
1]. Out of the total
P. vivax malaria cases reported in 2019, 53% of
P. vivax burden is in the WHO South-East Asia Region, and around 47% of them in India alone [
1]. Although severe malaria is known to be associated with
P. falciparum, in the last decade, reports have highlighted severe
P. vivax malaria, which was earlier considered benign [
2,
3]. Several studies have reported severe life-threatening symptoms in
P. vivax patients from Asia, South America, and Africa [
4,
5]. In India, a more extensive series of studies have associated 9–68% of severe
P. vivax infections with a severe and fatal disease in both children and adults [
5‐
10]. The complications related to severe
P. vivax malaria include the symptoms of altered sensorium, seizures, cerebral malaria, jaundice, acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), shock, acute kidney injury (AKI), and severe anemia [
5,
9]. Mechanisms underlying the biology, pathogenesis and epidemiology of the severe vivax syndromes remain poorly understood and require further investigation.
The clinical outcome of malaria is thought to be mainly contributed by the host, parasite and environmental factors [
11]. India aims to eliminate malaria nationally but has struggled to do so. Despite all the measures for the control and elimination of malaria, the biggest hurdle in the path is the increasing resistance to insecticides and antimalarials to the growing trend of population migration [
12]. In India, first-line treatment for the uncomplicated
P. vivax malaria includes the combination of chloroquine (CQ, for eliminating blood stages) and primaquine for liver stages (hypnozoites). Currently, complicated
P. vivax malaria cases are subjected to Artemisinin combination therapy [
13]. These combinations of drugs remain overall effective, but with the reports of resistance from the past few years makes malaria control and elimination a difficult task [
14,
15]. Regardless of several clinical reports, the true estimates of the antimalarial resistance have been poorly defined. A few therapeutic assessment studies from southwestern and eastern India have reported the outstanding efficacy of CQ in treating uncomplicated
P. vivax malaria patients with 0.8% (1/125) of therapeutic failure [
16‐
18]. Unlike
P. falciparum, in
P. vivax in view of the various confounding factors like the variant immune status, reinfection, frequent relapses and the lack of continuous in-vitro culture methods, the therapeutic efficacy studies and in-vitro susceptibility assays is always cumbersome to conduct [
19]. In order to monitor the drug resistance in
P. vivax, the molecular markers in the malaria parasites are considered as one of the important tools [
20]. In
P. vivax, Pvmdr1 and Pvcrt have been recognized as homolog of Pfmdr1 and Pfcrt and it has been linked in the modulation of chloroquine susceptibility [
19,
21]. In the areas of co-endemicity, Sulfadoxine/pyrimethamine (SP) had been rigorously used for the treatment of
P. falciparum and severe malaria, enabling the selection of resistant
P. vivax [
22]. An increased morbidity rate has been reported due to
P. vivax malaria in southeast Asia, with the emergence and spread of less susceptible strains of
P. vivax to antifolate drugs [
23]. Mutations in the
P. vivax ortholog enzymes Pvdhfr and Pvdhps targeted by SP have also been identified in the areas of
P. falciparum treated with combinational therapy consisting of SP and are linked to decreased sensitivity to Sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) [
22]. The ever-expanding burden of severe
P. vivax infections together with the drug resistance could result in an enormous expansion of the fatal infection similar to
P. falciparum [
24]. Hence, it becomes essential to study the current status of the chloroquine and SP drug resistance in
P. vivax cases. In the present study, we assessed the CQ (Pvcrt-o and Pvmdr-1) and SP (Pvdhfr and Pvdhps) drug resistance patterns among the complicated and uncomplicated
P. vivax isolates. The baseline molecular information on CQ and antifolate drug resistance will help in formulating the future drug policy for malaria in India.
Discussion
Various studies have reported the increase in CQ resistant
P. vivax in New Guinea and Indonesia with declining reports of CQ efficiency from almost all the endemic countries [
30]. The present situation of the increasing burden of severe
P. vivax infections, delay in diagnosis, partially effective treatment regimens, and the arising antimalarial drug resistance could result in an enormous expansion of the fatal infection similar to
P. falciparum [
24]. The patterns of drug resistance of Pvcrt-o and Pvmdr-1 have been identified in the clinical isolates. A total of 17.5% (7/40) complicated vivax isolates was found to have lysine (AAG) insertion at the 10th amino acid position of exon1 of Pvcrt-1 as compared to the isolates of uncomplicated group 9.5% (7/73). The findings of the present study are in complete concordance with the recent study from India, which has reported (first time in India) the insertion of lysine residue (AAG) in the Pvcrt gene in 5.6% of the isolates [
31]. In contrast to Indian studies, a very high prevalence of K10 insertion in the Pvcrt gene have been reported from Thailand (56–89%) and Myanmar (46–72%) [
27,
31‐
33].
Pvmdr-1 gene analysis revealed the presence of double mutants (T958
M /F1076
L) in 100% (41/41) of the complicated and in 98.7% (76/77) of the uncomplicated group isolates, with the presence of a single triple mutant (T958
M/F1076
L/Y1028
C) observed in isolates of
P. vivax uncomplicated group of patients. The observed nucleotide diversity in Pvmdr-1 gene was present at low level (π = 0.00007 ± 0.00005) as compared to a previous study by Cubides et al. (π = 0.0013) [
34]. The overall increased (12.4%) prevalence of AAG insertion in Pvcrt with the complete absence of Y976F in Pvmdr-1 was observed. Suwanarusk et al. reported a correlation between an increased CQ IC50 with the K10 insertion and Y976F mutation in Pvcrt-o and Pvmdr-1 gene [
19]. In Pvmdr-1 gene, the overall dominance of double haplotype (
M958/L1076) was seen in 99% of the clinical isolates in concordance with the earlier studies [
31]. Khattak et al. have reported the complete absence of Y976F mutation in the Pvmdr-1 gene, with 98% of the isolates harboring F1076
L mutation [
28]. Previous studies have reported T958
M mutation, localized in the transmembrane domain of the Pvmdr-1 gene, from countries having low to a high level of Chloroquine Resistance (CQR). Another mutation observed in our patient cohort was Y1028C in the Pvmdr-1 gene, which was observed in only 1.3% (1/77) of clinical isolate in the uncomplicated group of the patients. A recent Indian study by Joy et al. have reported a similar mutational frequency for Y1028C (1.2%) [
31]. The present study results are consistent with the previous study’s results, showing a rise in the Pvmdr-1 F1076L prior to Y976F in the clinical isolates [
35,
36]. If the hypothesis by Brega et al. of the two-step trajectory of mutations at codon F1076L followed by Y976F may be responsible for leading CQ resistance is true, then the F1076L observed in the study is a warning sign of emerging CQR in North India prior to the appearance of drug resistance phenotype in the population [
36]. Studies have reported an association between the increased morbidity rate due to
P. vivax with the emergence and spread of less susceptible strains of
P. vivax to antifolate drugs [
23].
The emergence of SP resistance is favored in some patients due to the exposure of the
P. vivax to the sub-therapeutic levels of SP [
37]. The genetic structure of Pvdhfr and Pvdhps was explored. In the Pvdhfr gene, the double mutant haplotype I
13P
33F
57R58T
61N117I
173 (S58
R/ S117
N) was observed in 22.9% (11/48) and in 20% (17/85) of the isolates in complicated and uncomplicated groups, respectively. In contrast, the majority (78.9%) of the isolates were found to be of wild type (I
13P
33F
57S
58T
61S
117I
173), with the complete absence of other mutations (F57L, T61S and I173L/F) as reported earlier in the literature [
22,
38,
39]. Unlike the previous reports from India, no such triple (
L57
R58
N117) and quadruple (
L57
R58
M61
N117) mutations were observed [
22,
39]. Low nucleotide diversity (π = 0.00182 ± 0.00012) was observed for Pvdhfr as compared to the previous study by Cubides et al. (π = 0.0037) [
34]. The overall prevalence of the double mutant haplotypes of Pvdhfr (I
13P
33F
57R58T
61N117I
173) obtained was 21% and was comparable to the previous reports from India (38.6 to 40.5%), Pakistan (23–27.4%), Iran (9.5%), and Thailand (35.6%) [
35,
40,
41]. A previous study by Hastings et al. has reported the association of a combination of S58
R and S117
N with the increased resistance (400 times more than the wild type) to pyrimethamine drug [
42]. The results of the predominant presence of the double mutants in the present study was suggestive of the drug pressure on the sympatric
P. vivax population which might have occurred, due to the use of SP for the treatment of
P. falciparum infections [
27].
Previous literature has also suggested the presence of tandem repeat variant (TRV) polymorphisms in the Pvdhfr gene, which could act as another marker for
P. vivax SP resistance [
43]. On the basis of size polymorphism of the repeat region (TRV), a total of five types were identified. Out of the five types, the predominance of type I (30.8%) consisting of 3 GGDN repeats at amino acid position 88 of Pvdhfr was found. In agreement with previous reports from India, we have also found the exclusive association of the type I (TRV) with the double mutants of Pvdhfr gene in both the groups, whereas the other types were seen to be associated with the wild type alleles [
22,
39]. This clearly suggests a more susceptible nature of GGDN repeats getting mutated, thereby developing high levels of resistance. Contrarily Saralamba et al. have reported no association of these allelic types with the point mutations [
41]. However, further studies are required to provide a better understanding of the association of TRVs as molecular markers to predict drug resistance and the impact on the infection dynamics [
39].
Studies have reported an increased prevalence of mutations in the Pvdhps gene in high SP user areas as compared to low SP user regions. In vitro and in vivo studies have reported the reduced binding affinity of sulphadoxine to Pvdhps containing the double mutation 383
G 553
G, as compared to wild type
A383
A553 [
44]. In the Pvdhps gene, very limited polymorphism was observed, which agrees with the earlier reports from Iran, Lao PDR, India and Colombia [
40,
41,
45]. In the present study, only a single SNP (D459A) in Pvdhps was identified among the 15.5 and 5% of the clinical isolates in the complicated and uncomplicated group of patients with the absence of other SNPs (A553G). The presence of D459A was found to be statistically significantly associated (χ2 (1) = 3.904;
p = 0.04) with the complicated group. The association of D459A SNP with the complications has also been reported earlier by Garg et al. from India where it was found in the patients with hepatic dysfunction. However, out of the novel mutations reported in the group of patients with severe manifestations, F365L and D459A were present far away from the drug binding cavity and had no effect on drug binding as predicted from in silico studies [
27]. In view of the previous and present study results on anti-malaria drug resistance surveillance among the complicated and uncomplicated groups, might indicate higher antifolate drug pressure on the
P. vivax parasites. The analysis of test of neutrality revealed no role of the evolutionary natural selection in the Pvdhfr and Pvdhps drug resistance genes, whereas the statistically significant negative Fu and Li′s D and F test statistic value of Pvmdr-1 gene clearly depicts the selective sweeps (population expansion) might have occurred recently in the
P. vivax population of the uncomplicated group of patients.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.