Background
Methods
Study design and participants
Intervention: description of dementia care toolbox
-
◦ Brochures: The 8-page brochure gave an overview on dementia and included a definition of dementia and core symptoms, contact addresses of support services as well as the further procedure after first dementia symptoms appeared. It was available in German, Turkish and Russian.
-
◦ Poster (30 cm × 42 cm): The poster was hung up in the waiting room of the practice to raise awareness of dementia among patients and next of kin. Short questions and statements about core symptoms of dementia were printed on the poster in German, Turkish and Russian.
-
◦ Information card: The double-sided information card contained general information on dementia as well as assistance for challenges, communication, cultural sensitivity for dementia patients with and without a migration background and contact addresses in case of language barriers.
-
◦ Practical tool: To facilitate the diagnostic of dementia in patients with and without a migration background, the practical tool included double-sided printed medical history sheets in Turkish/German, English/German and Russian/German, a non-verbal, culturally sensitive screening test for cognitive impairment and a 20-page booklet on dementia.
Target group | Item | Aim of the material | Topic/Content | Layout | Language |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patients, next of kin | 8-page brochure | Provide overview and support | • Definition of dementia and symptoms • Contact addresses • Procedural steps (GPs) | • Symbols • Diagram • Pictures • Highlighted keywords • Websites | Common language: German Russian Turkish |
Patients, next of kin | Poster (30 cm × 42 cm) | Creating awareness | • Questions about key symptoms of dementia | • Symbols | Common language: German Russian Turkish |
GP, PrA | 2-page information card | Information on how to deal with patients with and without a migration background | • Support services for language barriers • Cultural sensitivity • Contact addresses • Communication advice | • Symbols • Highlighted keywords • Websites | German |
GP | Practical tool | Facilitation of diagnostics for people with and without a migration background | • Medical history sheet • EASY test • 20-page booklet | • Highlighted keywords • Symbols • Interviews • Diagrams • Websites | German-English German-Turkish German-Russian |
Questionnaires
-
I feel confident in dealing with dementia patients with migration background.
-
I feel confident to inform dementia patients with migration background about their disease.
-
I feel confident in answering question from dementia patients with migration background.
-
I have enough knowledge about local help centres that support dementia patients with a migration background and their families.
-
I often have difficulties communicating with patients with migration background.
-
I often have difficulties communicating with dementia patients.
Statistical methods
Ethics statement
Results
Participants’ characteristics
Intervention group | Control group | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
n | (%)a | n | (%)a | |
Total participants | 50 | (40.6) | 73 | (59.4) |
Total practices | 15 | (46.9) | 17 | (53.1) |
n | (%)a,b | n | (%)a,b | |
Profession | ||||
GPs | 14 | (28.0) | 16 | (21.9) |
Male | 10 | (71.4) | 9 | (56.3) |
Female | 4 | (28.6) | 7 | (43.8) |
PrAs | 36 | (72.0) | 57 | (78.1) |
Male | 1 | (2.8) | 0 | (0) |
Female | 35 | (97.2) | 57 | (100.0) |
Gender | ||||
Male | 11 | (22.0) | 9 | (12.3) |
Female | 39 | (78.0) | 64 | (87.7) |
Was your mother or father or were you yourself born abroad? | ||||
Yes | 7 | (14.6) | 12 | (16.4) |
No | 41 | (85.4) | 61 | (83.6) |
Age | ||||
< 50 | 25 | (50.0) | 42 | (58.3) |
> =50 | 25 | (50.0) | 30 | (41.7) |
Duration of employment in this family practice | ||||
< =5 years | 12 | (24.5) | 17 | (23.6) |
< =15 years | 14 | (28.6) | 26 | (36.1) |
> 15 years | 23 | (46.9) | 29 | (40.3) |
Intervention group | Control group | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
n | (%)a,b | n | (%)a,b | |
0 | 11 | (22.9) | 17 | (23.6) |
1 | 13 | (27.1) | 23 | (31.9) |
2 | 11 | (22.9) | 14 | (19.4) |
3 | 7 | (14.6) | 9 | (12.5) |
4 | 3 | (6.3) | 5 | (6.9) |
5 | 3 | (6.3) | 4 | (5.6) |
6 | 0 | (0) | 0 | (0) |
Mean ± SD | 1.73 ± 1.46 | 1.64 ± 1.44 |
Intervention group | Control group | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
n | (%)a,b | n | (%)a,b | |
I feel confident in dealing with dementia patients with migration background | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 24 | (50.0) | 31 | (43.1) |
Neutral | 19 | (39.6) | 28 | (38.9) |
(Fully) Agree | 5 | (10.4) | 13 | (18.1) |
I feel confident to inform dementia patients with migration background about their disease | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 29 | (60.4) | 38 | (52.8) |
Neutral | 9 | (18.8) | 18 | (25.0) |
(Fully) Agree | 10 | (20.8) | 16 | (22.2) |
I feel confident in answering question from dementia patients with migration background | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 19 | (39.6) | 28 | (38.9) |
Neutral | 17 | (35.4) | 23 | (31.9) |
(Fully) Agree | 12 | (25.0) | 21 | (29.2) |
I have enough knowledge about local help centres that support dementia patients with a migration background and their families | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 26 | (54.2) | 44 | (61.1) |
Neutral | 13 | (27.1) | 16 | (22.2) |
(Fully) Agree | 9 | (18.8) | 12 | (16.7) |
I often have difficulties communicating with patients with migration background | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 20 | (42.6) | 22 | (30.6) |
Neutral | 6 | (12.8) | 28 | (38.9) |
(Fully) Agree | 21 | (44.7) | 22 | (30.6) |
I often have difficulties communicating with dementia patients | ||||
(Fully) Disagree | 27 | (57.4) | 34 | (47.2) |
Neutral | 14 | (29.8) | 26 | (36.1) |
(Fully) Agree | 6 | (12.8) | 12 | (16.7) |
Effects of the dementia care toolbox on self-reported confidence in dementia care
Item | Sig | OR | 95% CI |
---|---|---|---|
Overall effect on self-reported confidence in dementia care. | 0.95 | 1.01 | 0.72-1.43 |
I feel confident in dealing with dementia patients with migration background. | 0.15 | 0.57 | 0.26-1.23 |
I feel confident to inform dementia patients with migration background about their disease. | 0.26 | 0.60 | 0.25-1.45 |
I feel confident in answering question from dementia patients with migration background. | 0.64 | 0.82 | 0.36-1.86 |
I have enough knowledge about local help centres that support dementia patients with a migrant background and their families. | 0.35 | 1.43 | 0.68-3.03 |
I often have difficulties communicating with patients with migration background. | 0.30 | 1.63 | 0.65-4.10 |
I often have difficulties communicating with dementia patients. | 0.40 | 0.72 | 0.33-1.56 |