Background
Methods
Search strategy
Inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | |
---|---|---|
Population | Involved Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander adults 18 years of age and above who had participated in a chronic disease program Program evaluation involved over 50% Aboriginal participation or stratified analysis for Aboriginal people | Involved children or young people less than 18 years of age |
Concept | Evaluated chronic disease programs involving disease prevention and/or management activities for, but not limited to, chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, diabetes, asthma, arthritis, chronic pain, cancer, mental health conditions, chronic kidney disease, liver disease or tooth decay and/or risk factors for developing chronic diseases, such as an unhealthy weight, exceeding alcohol drinking guidelines, smoking, poor diet or physical inactivity. | Program not evaluated |
Context | Program evaluated in the Australian primary health care context (e.g. ACCHOs, general practice clinics and community-health clinics) | Programs evaluated in inpatient hospital facilities and sub-acute rehabilitation facilities Outcomes not published in English |
Study selection and data extraction
Results
Finding 1: heterogeneity of included programs
Program name | Citation | Years of program | Type of program | Targeted chronic disease(s)/risk factor(s) | Evaluation study design | Aboriginal participant sample size | Evaluation outcome measures |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cooking Classes for Diabetes Program | Aboriginal Health & Medical Research Council 2009 [28] Abbott, Davison, Moore & Rubinstein 2010 [29] Abbott, Davison, Moore & Rubinstein 2012 [30] | 2002–2007 | Health promotion | Diabetes, Poor nutrition | Qualitative - post program semi-structured interviews | 73 program participants, 23 interview participants (4 m, 19 f) | Participant experience |
Health Lifestyle and Weight Management Program | Aboriginal Health & Medical Research Council 2009 [28] | 2005–2008 | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Poor nutrition, physical inactivity | Mixed methods -pre, interim and post program quantitative and qualitative measures | Not reported | Clinical measures: BMI, height, weight, blood pressure, blood sugar level, waist, chest and hip ratio Participant experience |
Healthy Food Awareness Program | Aboriginal Health & Medical Research Council 2009 [28] | 2008 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Poor nutrition, physical inactivity, smoking, obesity, renal disease, diabetes and other chronic diseases | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
‘No More Dhonga’ Short Course | Adams et al. 2006 [31] | 2004 | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Smoking | Mixed methods-interim and post program measures | 32 participants | Stakeholder feedback Course attendance and smoking quit rate |
Home-Based, Outreach case Management of chronic disease Exploratory (HOME) Study program | Askew et al. 2016 [32] | Not reported | Chronic disease management | Diabetes type 2, cardiovascular disease, respiratory disease, kidney disease | Mixed methods-post program semi-structured interviews, pre, interim and post program quantitative measures | 41 participants, data collected from 37 participants (32 m, 68% f) | Feasibility, acceptability and appropriateness of model |
Renal Treatment Program | Bailie et al. 2006 [33] | 1995–1999 | Chronic disease management | End state renal disease | Quantitative-interrupted time series of pre/post quantitative measures | 266 participants, data collected from 98 participants | Clinical measure: blood pressure |
Moorditj Djena program | Ballestas et al. 2014 [34] | 2011-ongoing | Chronic disease management | Diabetes type 2, peripheral arterial disease, peripheral neuropathy | Mixed methods- interim program focus groups, interviews and review of quantitative data | Data collected from 702 participants (majority Aboriginal – not specified) Participation not reported for qualitative data | Program delivery, quality of implementation and organizational context |
Nurse-led practitioner project for chronic kidney disease | Barrett et al. 2015 [35] | 2012-ongoing | Chronic disease management | Chronic kidney disease | Quantitative-clinical audit | 187 participants | Rates of detection and improvement in chronic disease management |
Flinders self-management model (CCSM) | Battersby et al. 2008 [36] | 2001–2002 | Chronic disease management | Diabetes | Mixed methods-pilot study with pre, interim and post quantitative data, post program focus group | 60 participants (28 m, 32 f) | Program acceptability and clinical outcomes (HbA1c, Diabetes Assessment Form, SF-12) |
Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome clinic program | Boyle et al. 2017 [37] | 2012–2013 | Chronic disease management | Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS) | Mixed methods-post implementation evaluation using clinical audit, semi-structured interviews and focus groups | Clinical audit involved 36 f participants, interviews with 8 clinicians and focus group with 8 f participants | Process evaluation of program fidelity, barriers and enablers and whether the program met community needs |
Diabetic retinopathy screening program | Brazionis et al. 2018 [38] | 2014–2016 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Diabetes | Quantitative- cross-sectional study design | 301 participants (33% m, 67% f) | Clinical effectiveness: diabetic retinopathy prevalence rates and severity compared to other screening programs |
Primary Health Care Outreach program of Aboriginal Health Checks | Burgess et al. 2011 [39] | 2005 | Chronic disease management | Cardiovascular disease and other chronic diseases | Quantitative- interrupted time series study with pre/post measures | 64 participants (43 m, 21 f) | Clinical measures (absolute cardiovascular risk, blood pressure, BMI), follow up appointments and outcomes |
12 week exercise and nutrition program | Canuto et al. 2012 [40] Canuto 2013 [41] Canuto et al. 2013 [42] | 2010–2011 | Health promotion | Poor nutrition, physical inactivity | Mixed methods-pragmatic randomised trial with mixed methods process evaluation | 100 f participants at baseline, 41 lost to follow up. Not reported how many participated in interviews | Program effectiveness on waist circumference, weigh and biomedical metabolic markers Factors influencing program attendance |
Healthy Lifestyle Programme (HELP) | Chan et al. 2007 [43] | Not reported | Chronic disease management | Diabetes, cardiovascular risk factors | Quantitative- pre and post study | 101 participants | Effectiveness of a lifestyle intervention on clinical measures |
Cardiac failure education program | Clark et al. 2014 [44] Clark et al. 2015 [45] | Not reported | Chronic disease management | Cardiovascular disease | Mixed methods-pilot study with pre and post data | 5 participants (3 m, 2 f) | Feasibility and acceptability of resource |
Drug and alcohol screening intervention | Clifford et al. 2013 [46] | Not reported | Chronic disease prevention | Drug and alcohol misuse | Quantitative- pre and post study | 314 participants | Proportion of clients with alcohol screening |
Health literacy intervention | Crengle et al. 2017 [47] | 2013 | Chronic disease management | Cardiovascular disease | Quantitative-multi-site pre and post study | 171 participants, 11 lost to follow up | Effect of intervention on medication knowledge |
Grog mob | D’Abbs et al. 2013 [48] | 2008–2009 | Chronic disease prevention | Risky alcohol behaviour | Mixed methods-descriptive analysis of post program data | 49 participants | Examine whether program met its objectives, document implementation processes and gauge the impact on client outcomes |
Cardiac and pulmonary secondary prevention program | Davey et al. 2014 [49] | 2011–2013 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Cardiovascular and pulmonary disease | Mixed methods-pre and post study | 92 participants (36 m, 56 f), qualitative feedback from 51 participants | Program uptake and effectiveness |
Smoking cessation program | DiGiacomo et al. 2007 [50] | 2005–2006 | Chronic disease prevention | Smoking | Quantitative- case review | 37 participants (10 m, 27 f) | Screening rates and quit attempts |
‘Heart health’ program cardiac secondary prevention | Dimer et al. 2010 [51] Dimer et al. 2012 [52] Dimer et al. 2013 [53] Maiorana et al. 2012 [54] Maiorana et al. 2015 [55] | 2009–2010 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Cardiovascular disease | Mixed methods-pre and post data, interviews, yarning sessions and questionnaires | 98 participants (35 m, 63 f) | Uptake and effectiveness of program on lifestyle and cardiovascular risk factors |
Intensive quit smoking intervention | Eades et al. 2012 [56] | 2005–2009 | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Smoking | Quantitative-randomised controlled trial | 263 f participants | Effectiveness of intervention on smoking rates |
Give up the smokes program | Gould, McGechan & Zwan 2010 [57] | 2007–2008 | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Smoking | Quantitative- pre and post study | 10 participants | Cultural appropriateness of program |
Diabetes Management and Care program | Gracey et al. 2006 [58] | 2002 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Diabetes, poor nutrition, physical inactivity | Quantitative- pre and post study | 418 participants (181 m, 237 f) | Impact of program on clinical measures |
Koorie Men’s health day | Isaacs & Lampitt 2014 [59] | Not reported | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Mental illness | Mixed methods-descriptive study | 20 m participants (data available for 17) | Model outcomes |
Oral health literacy program | Ju et al. 2017 [60] | Not reported | Health promotion | Oral health | Quantitative-randomised controlled trial | 400 participants at baseline, 106 lost to follow up | Oral health literacy |
Oral health periodontal program | Kapellas et al. 2013 [61] Kapellas et al. 2014a [62] Kapellas et al. 2014b [63] Kapellas et al. 2017 [64] | 2010–2012 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Oral health | Quantitative-randomised controlled trial | 273 participants, follow up data available for 169 | Improvements in clinical outcomes |
Structured chronic disease care planning program | Kowanko et al. 2012 [65] | 2008–2011 | Chronic disease management | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-Participatory Action Research framework | 36 participants involved in longitudinal study, otherwise not reported | Impact of chronic disease self-management strategies on health outcomes |
Nurse-led Chronic Kidney Disease program | Lawton et al. 2016 [66] | 2007-ongoing | Chronic disease management | Chronic kidney disease | Quantitative-interrupted time series | Not reported | Improvement in rate of chronic kidney disease detection and clinical markers |
Walk about Together Program (WAT) | Longstreet et al. 2008 [67] | 2003–2005 | Health promotion | Unhealthy weight, poor nutrition | Quantitative-pre and post study | 100 participants (12% m, 88% f). | Nutrient intake of program participants |
Be Our Ally Beat Smoking (BOABS) program | Marley et al. 2014a [68] Marley et al. 2014b [18] | 2009–2012 | Health promotion | Smoking | Mixed methods-randomised controlled trial with qualitative component | 168 randomised, 19 lost to follow up | Efficacy of smoking cessation program at 12 months follow up |
Getting better at chronic care program | McDermott et al. 2015 [69] Schmidt, Campbell & McDermott 2016 [70] Segal et al. 2016 [71] | 2011–2013 | Chronic disease management | Diabetes and other chronic diseases | Mixed methods-pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial with qualitative component and economic analysis | 213 participants randomised (38% m, 62% female), 24 lost to follow up, 21 interview participants | Program effectiveness in improving care of participants with diabetes Experience of health workers implementing program Program cost-effectiveness |
Work it out program | Mills et al. 2017 [72] | 2012–2014 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Cardiovascular disease | Quantitative- quasi-experimental with pre and post data | 85 participants | Impact on clinical outcomes at 12 weeks post implementation |
Mental illness brief intervention program | Nagel & Thompson 2008 [73] Nagel et al. 2008 [74] | 2004–2007 | Chronic disease management | Mental illness | Mixed methods-randomised controlled trial with qualitative component | 49 participants | Program effectiveness on clinical outcomes |
Get Healthy Service program | Quinn et al. 2017 [75] | 2009–2015 | Health promotion | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-pre and post study with qualitative component | 30 participants interviewed (5 m, 25 f), quantitative data collection involved 1462 participants | Program reach and impact on lifestyle risk factors |
Antiviral therapy Hepatitis C program | Read et al. 2017 [76] | 2016-ongoing | Chronic disease prevention and management | Hepatitis C | Quantitative-observational cohort study | 23 participants | Efficacy of program |
Quality Assurance for Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander Medical Services (QAAMS) program | Shephard 2006 [77] Shephard et al. 2017 [78] Spaeth, Shephard & Schatz 2014 [79] | 1999-ongoing | Chronic disease management | Diabetes | Mixed methods-key stakeholder and client questionnaire with open questions, case studies, comparison of baseline and post implementation data, longitudinal quality assurance data, before and after study design | 161 participants completed client questionnaire, 907 program participants | Program satisfaction Quality assurance and imprecision Clinical and operational efficiency |
Point-of-Care in Aboriginal Hands | Shepherd et al. 2006 [80] | 2001-ongoing | Chronic disease management | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-interviews, comparison of baseline and post implementation data | Data collected from 626 participants | Community acceptability of program |
Western Desert Kidney Health Screening program | Sinclair et al. 2016 [81] | 2012 | Chronic disease prevention and management | Chronic kidney disease, diabetes | Qualitative-interviews | 26 participants (11 m, 15 f) | Community acceptability of program |
COACH programme | Ski et al. 2017 [82] | Not reported | Chronic disease prevention and management | Cardiovascular disease | Quantitative-longitudinal outcomes in participants | Not reported | Program effectiveness in reducing cardiovascular risk |
Diabetic retinopathy screening program | Spurling et al. 2010 [83] | 2007–2009 | Chronic disease management | Diabetes | Mixed methods-semi-structured interviews, descriptive analysis of demographic data and screening rates | 132 participants (60 m, 72 f) | Program impact and accessibility |
Indigenous adult health checks program | Spurling, Hayman & Cooney 2009 [84] | 2007–2008 | Chronic disease prevention and management | All chronic diseases | Quantitative- cross-sectional study | 413 participants | Evaluate role of program |
Shared medical appointment program | Stevens et al. 2016 [85] | Not reported | Chronic disease prevention and management | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-post program questionnaires, interviews and field notes | 14 m participants | Program acceptability and appropriateness |
Community singing program | Sun & Buys 2012 [86] Sun & Buys 2013a [87] Sun & Buys 2013b [88] Sun & Buys 2013c [89] Sun & Buys 2013d [90] Sun & Buys 2013e [91] Sun & Buys 2013f [92] Sun & Buys 2016 [93] | 2010–2012 | Chronic disease management | Cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cancer, depression, psychosis | Mixed methods-pre and post study design with numerous outcome measures, questionnaires, focus group sessions | 45 participants | Program effectiveness and impact |
Home Medicines Review program | Swain 2016 [94] Swain & Barclay 2015 [95] | 2001-ongoing | Chronic disease management | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-focus group sessions with indigenous consumers, interviews with health workers, cross-sectional survey with pharmacists | 102 participants | Usefulness of program for Indigenous people Facilitators and barriers to program uptake |
‘Yaka Narali’ Tackling Indigenous Smoking program | Tane et al. 2016 [96] | 2009-ongoing | Health promotion | Smoking | Qualitative-interviews | 30 participants | Program effectiveness |
Ngangkari Program | Togni 2017 [97] | Not reported | Chronic disease management | Mental illness, Social and Emotional Wellbeing | Qualitative-interviews and focus group sessions | 18 participants | Developmental evaluation of program model |
Deadly Liver Mob program | Treloar et al. 2018 [98] | 2013-ongoing | Health promotion and chronic disease prevention | Hepatitis C | Mixed methods-pre and post study with qualitative component | Quantitative data collected from 710 participants, 19 participant interviews | Program acceptability |
Music therapy program | Truasheim 2014 [99] | 2012 | Chronic disease management | All chronic diseases | Mixed methods-survey data and some clinical measures | 13 participants (4 m, 9 f) | Examine cultural safety of program |
Perinatal mental health program | Verrier et al. 2013 [100] | Not reported | Chronic disease prevention and management | Mental illness, Social and Emotional Wellbeing | Mixed methods-pre and post study with quantitative and qualitative data | Not reported | Program impact |
Finding 2: geographical distribution of programs
Evaluation n (%) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Implementation n (%) | Major Cities | Inner Regional | Outer Regional | Remote | Very Remote | Total | Aboriginal population (%)b |
Major Cities | 26 (32.1) | 26 (32.1) | 37.4 | ||||
Inner Regional | 10 (12.3) | 10 (12.3) | 23.7 | ||||
Outer Regional | 14 (17.3) | 1 (1.2) | 15 (18.5) | 20.3 | |||
Remote | 3 (3.7) | 1 (1.2) | 2 (2.5) | 6 (7.4) | 6.7 | ||
Very Remote | 15 (18.5) | 6 (7.4) | 2 (2.5) | 1 (1.2) | 24 (29.6) | 11.9 | |
Total | 58 (71.6) | 10 (12.3) | 8 (9.9) | 4 (4.9) | 1 (1.2) | 81 (100) | 100 |