Background
Methods
Protocol and registration
Eligibility criteria
Information sources
Search
Database: MEDLINE 1950 to present, MEDLINE In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations Search Strategy | |
---|---|
1 | exp disease outbreaks/sn (5773) |
2 | exp disease outbreaks/ep (3512) |
3 | exp disease outbreaks/pc (12003) |
4 | exp *Disease Outbreaks/ (42825) |
5 | 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 (47887) |
6 | exp population groups/ (197252) |
7 | exp population surveillance/ (48732) |
8 | exp measles/ (12908) |
9 | exp measles vaccine/ (7121) |
10 | exp Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccine/ (2056) |
11 | exp mumps/ (3574) |
12 | exp mumps vaccine/ (2965) |
13 | exp rubella/ (7276) |
14 | exp rubella vaccine/ (4256) |
15 | exp influenza human/ (33423) |
16 | exp influenza vaccine/ (15305) |
17 | exp influenza vaccines/ (15305) |
18 | exp poliomyelitis/ (15592) |
19 | exp poliovirus vaccines/ (6073) |
20 | exp whooping cough/ (6302) |
21 | exp tetanus/ (8118) |
22 | exp Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis Vaccine/ (2306) |
23 | exp Diphtheria/ (5187) |
24 | exp pertussis vaccine/ (6539) |
25 | exp diphtheria tetanus vaccine/ (307) |
26 | exp meningococcal infections/ (9327) |
27 | exp meningococcal vaccines/ (2232) |
28 | exp hepatitis b/ (43927) |
29 | exp hepatitis b vaccines/ (7243) |
30 | exp hepatitis b virus/ (18871) |
31 | exp pneumococcal infections/ (16122) |
32 | exp pneumococcal vaccines/ (4460) |
33 | 8 or 11 or 13 or 15 or 18 or 20 or 21 or 23 or 26 or 28 or 30 or 31 (160650) |
34 | 9 or 10 or 12 or 14 or 16 or 17 or 19 or 22 or 24 or 25 or 27 or 29 or 32 (47477) |
35 | exp vaccines/ (165840) |
36 | exp vaccination/ (54688) |
37 | exp mass vaccination/ (1849) |
38 | 33 and (35 or 36 or 37) (38389) |
39 | 5 and (6 or 7) and (34 or 38) (640) |
40 | 39 (640) |
41 | (vaccin$ adj (rate$ or coverage$)).ti,ab. (5377) |
42 | (low adj vaccinat$).ti,ab. (211) |
43 | 40 and (41 or 42) (105) |
44 | exp immunization programs/ (8797) |
45 | 5 and (34 or 38) (4269) |
46 | (group$ or ethnic$ or minorit$ or communit$ or subgroup$).ti. (277479) |
47 | 45 and 46 (173) |
48 | 47 (173) |
49 | (ethnic$ or minorit$ or communit$ or subgroup$).ti,ab. (518807) |
50 | 45 and 49 (394) |
51 | exp disease susceptibility/ (103745) |
52 | exp health services accessibility/ (79608) |
53 | exp vulnerable populations/ (5086) |
54 | exp patient acceptance of healthcare/ (154409) |
55 | exp treatment refusal/ (10295) |
56 | exp minority groups/ (9817) |
57 | exp attitude to health/ (275774) |
58 | 50 and (51 or 52 or 53 or 54 or 55 or 56 or 57) (52) |
59 | 58 (52) |
60 | 45 and 53 (10) |
61 | 45 and 56 (2) |
62 | 60 or 61 (12) |
63 | (34 or 38) and outbreak$.ti. and ((ethnic$ or minorit$ or communit$ or subgroup$).ti. or exp. *patient acceptance of healthcare/ or exp. *treatment refusal/ or exp. *minority groups/) (65) |
64 | 63 (65) |
65 | (34 or 38) and outbreak$.ti. and 57 (31) |
66 | 65 (31) |
67 | exp treatment refusal/ (10295) |
68 | exp “religion and medicine”/ (9768) |
69 | (34 or 38) and outbreak$.ti. and 68 (17) |
70 | (34 or 38) and outbreak$1.ti. and 67 (18) |
71 | 69 or 70 (31) |
72 | 71 (31) |
73 | (34 or 38) and (exp *treatment refusal/ or exp. *“religion and medicine”/) (116) |
74 | 73 (116) |
75 | outbreak$.ti,ab. and (72 or 74) (35) |
76 | (united adj states).ti. (36958) |
77 | 75 not 76 (33) |
78 | 77 (33) |
79 | 43 or 59 or 62 (158) |
80 | 79 and (exp *health services accessibility/ or exp. *minority groups/ or exp. *attitude to health/ or exp. *treatment refusal/ or exp. *“religion and medicine”/) (27) |
81 | 64 or 66 or 72 or 78 (97) |
82 | 81 or 59 or 62 or 80 (143) |
83 | 82 (143) |
84 | 83 not 76 (140) |
85 | (Peru or Nigeria or Sydney or Brazil or Zealand or Mexico or Australia$).ti. (91932) |
86 | 84 not 85 (127) |
87 | (35 or 36 or 37) and (exp *health services accessibility/ or exp. *minority groups/ or exp. *attitude to health/ or exp. *treatment refusal/ or exp. *“religion and medicine”/) and outbreak$.ti. (24) |
88 | 87 (24) |
89 | 88 not 86 (4) |
90 | 89 not 76 (2) |
91 | exp *treatment refusal/ and exp. *“religion and medicine”/ (114) |
92 | 91 and (35 or 36 or 37) (5) |
93 | 92 (5) |
94 | 67 and 68 and (35 or 36 or 37) and outbreak$.ti,ab. (4) |
95 | 94 (4) |
96 | 33 and 68 (76) |
97 | 34 and 68 (26) |
98 | 96 or 97 (82) |
99 | 98 (82) |
100 | 99 not (86 or 90 or 93 or 95) (62) |
101 | 100 not (76 or 85) (57) |
102 | 86 or 90 or 93 or 95 or 101 (189) |
103 | (measles and outbreaks).ti. (97) |
104 | 103 and italy.ti. (1) |
105 | (34 or 38) and outbreak$.ti. and coverage$.ti. (22) |
106 | 105 (22) |
107 | 106 not 102 (19) |
108 | exp ethnic groups/ (105533) |
109 | 4 and exp. *ethnic groups/ and 33 (36) |
110 | 109 (36) |
111 | 110 not 102 (25) |
112 | (minority and coverage).ti. and (35 or 36 or 37) (2) |
113 | exp *minority groups/ and (35 or 36 or 37) and coverage.ti. (2) |
114 | (religious and vaccin$ and coverage).ti. (1) |
115 | exp *Immunization Programs/ (5694) |
116 | 115 and 68 (18) |
117 | 116 (18) |
118 | 117 not 102 (12) |
119 | 107 or 111 or 113 or 118 (58) |
120 | 119 not (76 or 85) (53) |
121 | 4 and 33 (10049) |
122 | exp hepatitis a/ (17195) |
123 | exp dysentery/ (10986) |
124 | exp shigella/ (10261) |
125 | 33 or 122 or 123 or 124 (191696) |
126 | 4 and 125 (11161) |
127 | 7 and 126 (1495) |
128 | 127 (1495) |
129 | (56 or 108) and 126 (100) |
130 | 129 (100) |
131 | 128 or 130 (1579) |
132 | 131 (1579) |
133 | exp anthroposophy/ (180) |
134 | epidemiology.fs. (1122530) |
135 | exp *measles/ or exp. *mumps/ or exp. *rubella/ or exp. *influenza human/ or exp. *poliomyelitis/ or exp. *whooping cough/ or exp. *tetanus/ or exp. *Diphtheria/ or exp. *meningococcal infections/ or exp. *hepatitis b/ or exp. *hepatitis b virus/ or exp. *pneumococcal infections/ (131969) |
136 | exp *hepatitis a/ or exp. *dysentery/ or exp. *shigella/ (27317) |
137 | 135 or 136 (157514) |
138 | exp europe/ (1059556) |
139 | 132 and (137 or 133) and 138 and 134 (693) |
140 | 139 (693) |
141 | (outbreak or population or (low adj vaccination)).ti. (153831) |
142 | 140 and 141 (211) |
143 | 140 (693) |
144 | limit 143 to “review articles” (17) |
145 | 142 or 144 (228) |
146 | exp Treatment Refusal/ (10295) |
147 | 140 and (133 or 146) (5) |
148 | 132 and (133 or 146) (7) |
149 | 145 or 148 (230) |
150 | (measles$ or mumps$ or rubella$ or influenza$ or poliomyelitis$ or (whooping adj cough) or tetanus$ or diphtheria$ or pertussis$ or meningococcal$ or hepatitis$ or pneumococcal$ or dysentery$ or shigella$).ti. (245343) |
151 | (outbreak$ or epidemic$ or denominat$).ti. (45258) |
152 | (minorit$ or (isolated adj group$) or (low adj vaccinat$) or (vaccine$ adj (rate or rates or coverage$)) or ethnic$ or communit$ or (treatment adj refus$) or religious$ or gipsy or gipsies or anthropo$).ti. (131353) |
153 | 150 and 151 (8602) |
154 | 152 and 153 (276) |
155 | 154 not (102 or 120 or 149) (191) |
156 | 102 or 120 or 149 or 154 (644) |
157 | remove duplicates from 156 (591) |
Database: MEDLINE 1950 to present, MEDLINE In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations Search Strategy: | |
---|---|
1 | exp measles/ (12908) |
2 | exp measles vaccine/ (7121) |
3 | exp Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccine/ (2056) |
4 | exp mumps/ (3574) |
5 | exp mumps vaccine/ (2965) |
6 | exp rubella/ (7276) |
7 | exp rubella vaccine/ (4256) |
8 | exp influenza human/ (33423) |
9 | exp influenza vaccine/ (15305) |
10 | exp influenza vaccines/ (15305) |
11 | exp poliomyelitis/ (15592) |
12 | exp poliovirus vaccines/ (6073) |
13 | exp whooping cough/ (6302) |
14 | exp tetanus/ (8118) |
15 | exp Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis Vaccine/ (2306) |
16 | exp Diphtheria/ (5187) |
17 | exp pertussis vaccine/ (6539) |
18 | exp diphtheria tetanus vaccine/ (307) |
19 | exp meningococcal infections/ (9327) |
20 | exp meningococcal vaccines/ (2232) |
21 | exp hepatitis b/ (43927) |
22 | exp hepatitis b vaccines/ (7243) |
23 | exp hepatitis b virus/ (18871) |
24 | exp pneumococcal infections/ (16122) |
25 | exp pneumococcal vaccines/ (4460) |
26 | 1 or 4 or 6 or 8 or 11 or 13 or 14 or 16 or 19 or 21 or 23 or 24 (160650) |
27 | 2 or 3 or 5 or 7 or 9 or 10 or 12 or 15 or 17 or 18 or 20 or 22 or 25 (47477) |
28 | exp vaccines/ (165840) |
29 | exp vaccination/ (54688) |
30 | exp mass vaccination/ (1849) |
31 | exp hepatitis a/ (17195) |
32 | exp dysentery/ (10986) |
33 | exp shigella/ (10261) |
34 | (26 or 31 or 32 or 33) and (28 or 29 or 30) (40134) |
35 | 27 or 34 (58398) |
36 | exp Treatment Refusal/ (10295) |
37 | exp Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice/ (66897) |
38 | exp “Patient Acceptance of Health Care”/ (154409) |
39 | exp Attitude to Health/ (275774) |
40 | exp “Attitude of Health Personnel”/ (114245) |
41 | (argument$ or belief$ or ideolog$ or attitud$ or objection$).ti. (44532) |
42 | exp Ethnic Groups/ (105533) |
43 | exp Minority Groups/ (9817) |
44 | exp Religion/ (45812) |
45 | exp Immunization Programs/ (8797) |
46 | exp Complementary Therapies/ (168626) |
47 | exp Vaccination/ (54688) |
48 | exp Decision Making/ (112804) |
49 | exp Patient Compliance/ (50195) |
50 | exp Immunization/ (131148) |
51 | anthroposoph$.ti. (130) |
52 | 35 or 45 or 47 or 50 (165486) |
53 | 36 or 37 or 38 or 39 or 40 or 41 or 48 or 49 (478347) |
54 | 42 or 43 or 44 or 46 or 51 or homeopath$.ti. (316493) |
55 | 52 and 53 and 54 (324) |
56 | exp africa/ or exp. americas/ or exp. asia/ or exp. australia/ (1996966) |
57 | (vaccin$ or immuniz$ or immunis$ or measle$ or mumps or rubella$ or polio or mmr).ti. (157864) |
58 | (relig$ or orthodox$ or protestant$ or racial$ or anthropos$ or refusal or gypsy or gypsies or homeopat$ or homoeopat$ or jewish$ or minorit$ or multiethnic$ or unorthodox$ or latino or ideolog$ or ethnicity or (ethnic adj background) or (alternative adj medicine$) or (parental adj refusal$)).ti. (37918) |
59 | 57 and 58 (310) |
60 | (55 or 59) not 56 (202) |
61 | remove duplicates from 60 (193) |
NEW (set 62 is the “new” set 58): | |
62 | (relig$ or orthodox$ or protestant$ or racial$ or anthropos$ or refusal or gypsy or gypsies or homeopat$ or homoeopat$ or jewish$ or minorit$ or multiethnic$ or unorthodox$ or latino or roma or sinti$ or traveler$ or tinker$ or ideolog$ or ethnicity or (ethnic adj background) or (alternative adj medicine$) or (parental adj refusal$)).ti. (40501) |
63 | 57 and 62 (501) |
64 | (55 or 63) not 56 (346) |
65 | remove duplicates from 64 (334) |
Search strategy with renewed set 58 | |
1 | exp measles/ (12908) |
2 | exp measles vaccine/ (7121) |
3 | exp Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccine/ (2056) |
4 | exp mumps/ (3574) |
5 | exp mumps vaccine/ (2965) |
6 | exp rubella/ (7276) |
7 | exp rubella vaccine/ (4256) |
8 | exp influenza human/ (33423) |
9 | exp influenza vaccine/ (15305) |
10 | exp influenza vaccines/ (15305) |
11 | exp poliomyelitis/ (15592) |
12 | exp poliovirus vaccines/ (6073) |
13 | exp whooping cough/ (6302) |
14 | exp tetanus/ (8118) |
15 | exp Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis Vaccine/ (2306) |
16 | exp Diphtheria/ (5187) |
17 | exp pertussis vaccine/ (6539) |
18 | exp diphtheria tetanus vaccine/ (307) |
19 | exp meningococcal infections/ (9327) |
20 | exp meningococcal vaccines/ (2232) |
21 | exp hepatitis b/ (43927) |
22 | exp hepatitis b vaccines/ (7243) |
23 | exp hepatitis b virus/ (18871) |
24 | exp pneumococcal infections/ (16122) |
25 | exp pneumococcal vaccines/ (4460) |
26 | 1 or 4 or 6 or 8 or 11 or 13 or 14 or 16 or 19 or 21 or 23 or 24 (160650) |
27 | 2 or 3 or 5 or 7 or 9 or 10 or 12 or 15 or 17 or 18 or 20 or 22 or 25 (47477) |
28 | exp vaccines/ (165840) |
29 | exp vaccination/ (54688) |
30 | exp mass vaccination/ (1849) |
31 | exp hepatitis a/ (17195) |
32 | exp dysentery/ (10986) |
33 | exp shigella/ (10261) |
34 | (26 or 31 or 32 or 33) and (28 or 29 or 30) (40134) |
35 | 27 or 34 (58398) |
36 | exp Treatment Refusal/ (10295) |
37 | exp Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice/ (66897) |
38 | exp “Patient Acceptance of Health Care”/ (154409) |
39 | exp Attitude to Health/ (275774) |
40 | exp “Attitude of Health Personnel”/ (114245) |
41 | (argument$ or belief$ or ideolog$ or attitud$ or objection$).ti. (44532) |
42 | exp Ethnic Groups/ (105533) |
43 | exp Minority Groups/ (9817) |
44 | exp Religion/ (45812) |
45 | exp Immunization Programs/ (8797) |
46 | exp Complementary Therapies/ (168626) |
47 | exp Vaccination/ (54688) |
48 | exp Decision Making/ (112804) |
49 | exp Patient Compliance/ (50195) |
50 | exp Immunization/ (131148) |
51 | anthroposoph$.ti. (130) |
52 | 35 or 45 or 47 or 50 (165486) |
53 | 36 or 37 or 38 or 39 or 40 or 41 or 48 or 49 (478347) |
54 | 42 or 43 or 44 or 46 or 51 or homeopath$.ti. (316493) |
55 | 52 and 53 and 54 (324) |
56 | exp africa/ or exp. americas/ or exp. asia/ or exp. australia/ (1996966) |
57 | (vaccin$ or immuniz$ or immunis$ or measle$ or mumps or rubella$ or polio or mmr).ti. (157864) |
58 | (relig$ or orthodox$ or protestant$ or racial$ or anthropos$ or refusal or gypsy or gypsies or homeopat$ or homoeopat$ or jewish$ or minorit$ or multiethnic$ or unorthodox$ or latino or roma or sinti$ or traveler$ or tinker$ or ideolog$ or ethnicity or (ethnic adj background) or (alternative adj medicine$) or (parental adj refusal$)).ti. (40501) |
59 | 57 and 58 (501) |
60 | (55 or 59) not 56 (346) |
61 | remove duplicates from 60 (334) |
Study selection
Data collection process
Syntheses of results
Results
Identification of the under-vaccinated groups in Europe
Orthodox Protestant communities
Anthroposophists
Roma
Irish Travellers
Orthodox Jewish communities
Description of ideologies, beliefs or attitudes towards vaccination among the identified UVGs
Orthodox Protestants (1 study) | Anthroposophists (2 studies) | Roma (5 studies) | Irish Travelers (4 studies) | Orthodox Jewish (2 studies) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Perceived severity/susceptibility of VPD
| |||||
Perceived non-severity of VPD: | |||||
- some VPD are not severe (e.g. not severe: measles, mumps, pertussis; severe: tetanus, polio and diphtheria) | 1 | 1 | 1 | ||
- some VPD are helpful for child’s development (e.g. measles) | 2 | 1 | |||
Perceived non-susceptibility to VPD (e.g. only a small number of children with VPD disease) | 1 | ||||
Perceived safety/effectiveness of vaccine
| |||||
Perceived un-safety of the vaccine (adverse events, misconceptions) | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 | |
Perceived non-effectiveness of the vaccine (e.g. graphs and reports do not prove effectiveness of the vaccines) | 2 | ||||
Beliefs about vaccine (components of the vaccine could be dangerous e.g. poisons, toxins, contaminants) | 1 | 1 | |||
Flexibility / freedom
| |||||
Adapting vaccination schedule to the child (schedule not flexible enough) | 1 | ||||
Combined vaccines should be monovalent (parents like to choose, parents perceive overload of antigens of various diseases in combination vaccine) | 1 | ||||
Knowledge
| |||||
Need for more information or lack of information (e.g. risk of vaccination / scientific facts from the Public Health authorities, where and when to vaccinate) | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 | |
Low awareness of vaccination as a preventive measure | 1 | ||||
Social networks
(parents heard term MMR linked with fears)
| 1 | ||||
Ideas about prevention
| |||||
Anthroposophic (healthy lifestyle, confidence in the health of the child, freedom of choice in healthcare and natural remedies, let the body experience certain infections) | 2 | ||||
Complementary medicine being unavailable | 1 | ||||
Religious beliefs (trust in God) | 1 | 1 | |||
Social structural aspects
| |||||
Socio-economic and cultural differences (e.g. language barriers, improper housing, low level of formal education, illiteracy) | 4 | 3 | |||
Improvement in access and facilities for their children (e.g. limited and inflexible clinic hours) | 1 | ||||
Poor access to health care centres (e.g. high spatial mobility for Roma and Irish Travellers) | 4 | 3 | |||
Exposure to stigmatization, marginalization and discrimination | 3 | 3 | |||
No trust in information from the Public Health authorities | 1 | 1 |