Background
The global burden of adolescent and young adult cancer
Diversity of AYAs with cancer
The acute psychosocial impact of cancer and its treatment
The long-term psychosocial impact of cancer and its treatment
Approaches to assessing the psychosocial health of cancer survivors
Methods
Database search to identify relevant publications
Inclusion and exclusion of measures
Measure coding
Sample characteristics
Psychometric properties
Psychometric Property | Criteria |
---|---|
Reliability
| |
Internal consistency
degree to which responses to all items on a scale are consistent [43] | Calculated correlations for total scale and domains [44] |
Test-retest
reproducibility of scores on a scale over repeated administrations [44] | Second administration within 2-14 days [46] Calculated correlations for total scale, domains and items [47] - Cohen's kappa coefficient (κ) > 0.60 [44] |
Validity
| |
Face
subjective assessment of whether a scale 'appears' to measure what it is designed to measure [43] | Assessed as reasonable by those who administer/complete it [43] |
Content
degree to which the content of a scale is representative of the issue being measured [43] | |
Construct
way in which the internal structure of a scale relates to other conceptual constructs [44] | Stated hypothesis about correlations between measures [44] Calculated correlations between known-groups [42] Performed factor analysis [44] - Eigenvalues > 1 [49] |
Criterion
how well a scale agrees with existing "gold standard" measurement of the same issue [44] | Provided rationale for "gold standard" measure [44] Stated type of criterion validity (concurrent or predictive) [43] |
Responsiveness
| Reported floor/ceiling effects [51] - < 5% of respondents have highest or lowest score [51] Reported magnitude of change [42] |
Acceptability
level of burden placed on those who complete the measure [42] | Reported response rate, missing items, reading level, time to complete [42] |
Feasibility
level of burden placed on those who administer the measure [42] | Reported perceived time to administer, score, interpret [42] |
Cross-cultural adaptation
conceptually, linguistically equivalent and display similar psychometric properties to the original form [42] | Confirmed reliability and validity reflects the original version [42] |
Inter-rater agreement of coding existing measures
Results
Database search to identify relevant publications
Measure | Items | Domains | Description | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
AQoL
Adolescent Quality of Life Instrument | 16 | 5 | normal activities, social/family interactions, health status, mood, meaning of being ill | |
MMQL Adolescent Form
Minneapolis-Manchester Quality of Life Instrument | 46 | 7 | physical, psychological, social, and cognitive functioning, body image, outlook on life, intimate relations | |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A) Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory Child and Adolescent Forms | 27 | 8 | pain and hurt, nausea, procedural anxiety, treatment anxiety, worry, cognitive problems, perceived physical appearance, communication | |
QOL-CS
Quality of Life-Cancer Survivors | 41 | 4 | physical, psychological (distress and fear), social, and spiritual well-being | [16] |
PCQL-32
Pediatric Cancer Quality of Life Inventory - 32 Short Form | 32 | 5 | disease and treatment-related symptoms, physical, psychological, social, and cognitive functioning | |
PCQL Modular Approach Pediatric Cancer Quality of Life Inventory Modular Approach | 23 | 5 | (core) physical, psychological, social, (modules) pain, nausea | [62] |
PIE
Perceived Illness Experience Scale | 34 | 9 | physical appearance, interference with activity, peer rejection, integration in school, manipulation, parental behaviour, disclosure, preoccupation with illness, impact of treatment |
Sample characteristics
Sample characteristics | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Measure
|
Inclusion/exclusion
|
Setting
|
Response rate (%)
|
Sample
size (n)
|
Age
(yrs)
|
Gender (%)
|
Cancer type
(%)
|
Cancer treatment stage (%)
|
AQoL
[35] | Reported | Hematology /oncology clinic | 95 | 75 | 9-20 mean 12.4 | M (55) F (45) | Leukaemia (50) Bone/joint (17) Lymphomas (9) Neurological (9) Hodgkin's (5) Other (9) | In treatment (55) Pre or post treatment (45) |
MMQL Adolescent Forrm
[52] | - | Nine hospitals | - | 268 | 13-20.9 median 16.6 | M (56) F (44) | Leukaemia ALL (37) Leukaemia AML (8) Hodgkin's (11) Non-Hodgkin's (11) Brain (6) Other (27) | On therapy (41) Off therapy > 1 year (59) |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A)
[55] | Reported | Hematology/oncology center and Center for Cancer and Blood Diseases | - | 220 | 5-18 mean 10.9 | M (56) F (44) | Leukaemia (50) Brain (7) Non-Hodgkin's (6) Hodgkin's (3) Wilm's Tumor (6) Other (28) | On treatment (54) Off treatment < 1 year (18) Off treatment > 1 year (28) |
QOL-CS
[16] | Reported | University medical center | 53 | 176 | 16-28 mean 21.8 | M (43) F (57) | Leukaemia (30) Brain/CNS (11) Lymphoma (21) Wilm's Tumor (10) Sarcomas (16) Other (11) | 3-27 yrs post-diagnosis (100) (average 13.3 yrs) |
PCQL-32
[59] | Reported | Three pediatric cancer centers | 89.5 | 291 | 8-18 mean 11.78 | M (61) F (39) | Leukaemia ALL (44) Leukaemia AML (6) Leukaemia other (1) Hodgkin's (6) Non-Hodgkin's (9) Other (34) | Newly on-treatment (37) Relapsed on treatment (8) Remission off-treatment (11) Long-term off-treatment (44) |
PCQL Modular Approach
[62] | Reported | Three pediatric cancer centers | 89.5 | 291 | 8-18 mean 11.78 | - | - | On treatment (45) Off treatment (55) |
PIE
[63] | Reported | Children's cancer unit | - | 41 | 8-24 mean 14.6 | M (49) F (51) | Leukaemia ALL (68) Wilm's Tumor (15) Sarcomas (12) Non-Hodgkin's (5) | Maintenance treatment (41) Follow-up only (59) |
Psychometric properties
Measure | Internal consistency | Test-retest reliability | Face/content validity | Construct validity | Responsiveness | Acceptability | Cross-cultural | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Time
|
ICC
|
Convergent/divergent
|
Known groups
|
Factor analysis
| ||||||
AQoL
| √ | √ | - | √ | - | √ | √ | - | √ | - |
MMQL Adolescent Form
| √ | √ | √ | √ | √ | √ | - | - | - | √ |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A)
| √ | - | - | √ | √ | √ | - | - | √ | √ |
QOL-CS
| √ | - | - | - | √ | √ | √ | - | √ | - |
PCQL-32
| √ | - | - | √ | √ | √ | - | √ | √ | - |
PCQL Modular Approach
| √ | - | - | √ | - | √ | - | √ | √ | - |
PIE
| √ | - | - | √ | √ | √ | - | - | √ | - |
Reliability
Internal consistency
Measure | Internal consistency | Test-retest reliability | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
n
|
Cronbach's alpha α > 0.70
|
n
|
Administration Period
|
Intraclass correlation ICC > 0.70
| |
AQoL
[35] | 75 | Total scale = 0.77 No domains reported | 17 | Pre-weekend to post-weekend Post-weekend to one month [36] | - |
MMQL Adolescent Forrm
[52] | 397 | Total scale = 0.78 6/7 domains > 0.70 Physical = 0.88 Psychological = 0.83 Social = 0.81 Cognitive = 0.89 Body image = 0.80 Outlook = 0.85 | 87 | Two week interval | Total scale = 0.71 5/7 domains > 0.70 Physical = 0.90 Cognitive = 0.88 Body image = 0.73 Outlook = 0.76 Relations = 0.81 |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A)
[55] | 220 | Total scale = 0.72 6/8 domains > 0.70 Pain and hurt = 0.70 Nausea = 0.79 Procedural Anxiety = 0.82 Treatment Anxiety = 0.79 Worry = 0.74 Cognitive = 0.76 | - | - | - |
QOL-CS
[16] | 176 | Total Scale = 0.87 5/6 domains > 0.70 Physical = 0.81 Psychological = 0.82 Fears = 0.88 Social = 0.76 Spiritual = 0.78 | - | - | - |
PCQL-32
[60] | 291 | Total scale = 0.91 4/5 domains > 0.70 Disease/treatment = 0.83 Physical = 0.78 Psychological = 0.76 Cognitive = 0.81 | - | - | - |
PCQL Modular Approach
[62] | 281 | Total scale = 0.83 No domains reported All modules > 0.70 Pain = 0.82 Nausea = 0.71 | - | - | - |
PIE
[63] | 41 | Total scale = 0.84 2/9 domains > 0.70 Manipulation = 0.70 Parental behaviour = 0.73 Total scale = 0.91 4/9 domains > 0.70 Peer rejection = 0.79 Parental behaviour = 0.71 Preoccupation illness = 0.73 Food = 0.70 [64] | 41 | - | - |
Test-retest
Validity
Face/content
Measure | Face/Content validity | Construct validity | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Convergent
r
> 0.40 Divergent
r
< 0.30
|
Known groups (discriminate)
|
Factor Analysis Eigenvalues > 1
| ||
AQoL
[35] | Assessed by survivors Review of literature Item wording, redundancy Pilot test (n = 7) | - | Receiving treatment (n = 41) Not receiving treatment (n = 34) P = 0.000 | 6 factors Represented 66.5% of variance |
MMQL Adolescent Forrm
[52] | Assessed by survivors Focus group (n = 20) Interviews (n = 20) Pilot test 1st (n = 10) 2nd (n = 10) | Child Health Questionnaire - Child Form Hypotheses supported 42 correlations > 0.40 | Healthy adolescents (n = 129) On therapy (n = 110) Off therapy (n = 158) P < 0.05 for 4 domains | - |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A)
[55] | Adapted from Pediatric Cancer Quality of Life Inventory (PCQL), PedsQL 1.0 Cancer Module, and PedsQL | PedsQL 4.0 Generic Core Scale PedsQL Multidimensional Fatigue Scale Hypotheses supported 34 correlations > 0.40 | On treatment (n = 106) Off treatment < 1 year (n = 41) Off treatment > 1 year (n = 73) P < 0.05 for 3 domains | - |
QOL-CS
[16] | - | Cancer Specific Worry Scale Psychosocial Worry Scale General Health Worry Scale Hypotheses supported 9 correlations > 0.40 | Other condition (Y = 28, N = 148) After-effects (Y = 86, N = 90) Income (< $25 K = 36, > $25 K = 127) Gender (F = 101, M = 75) Marital status P < 0.05 for 5 factors | 6 factors Represented 56.2% of variance |
PCQL-32
[60] | Assessed by survivors Review of literature Interviews and pilot test Item wording, relevance, redundancy, reduction [59] | Children' Depression Inventory Stait-Trait Anxiety Inventory-32 (Child) Social Support Scale (Child/Adoles) Self-Perception Profile (Child/Adoles) Child Behaviour Checklist Hypotheses Supported 10 correlations > 0.40 15 correlations < 0.30 | On treatment (n = 125) Off treatment (n = 156) P < 0.05 for total scale and 3 domains | - |
PCQL Modular Approach
[62] | Adapted from the PCQL long form and PCQL-32 | - | On treatment (n = 125) Off treatment (n = 156) P < 0.05 for the core and symptom modules | - |
PIE
[63] | Assessed by survivors Interviews (n = 15) Item reduction | Rotterdam Symptom Checklist Functional Disability Inventory Restrictions Scale Psychological Symptoms Hypotheses Supported 9 correlations > 0.40 20 correlations < 0.30 | Younger children Older Children Maintenance treatment Completed treatment P < 0.05 for 2 domains | - |
SF-36 Functional Evaluation Scale Hypotheses Supported 38 correlations > 0.40 44 correlations < 0.30 [64] |
Construct/criterion
Responsiveness
Measure | Responsiveness | Acceptability | Cross-cultural |
---|---|---|---|
AQoL
[35] | - | Response rate 95% Reading level Flesch-Kincaid grade 6.2 [36] | - |
MMQL Adolescent Forrm
[52] | - | - | Anglicised for UK and shortened to the MMQL-29 [53] Internal consistency in an online format [54] Reliability and validity demonstrated |
PedsQL 3.0 Cancer Module (C&A)
[55] | - | Missing items 0.5% | Initial development in English and Spanish [55] Reliability and validity demonstrated |
QOL-CS
[16] | - | Response rate 53% | - |
PCQL-32
[61] | On treatment Floor 1.6-20.0% Ceiling 0% | Response rate 89.5% Missing items 0.01% | - |
Off treatment Floor 1.9-32.7% Ceiling 0% | |||
PCQL Modular Approach
[62] | On treatment Floor 0-3.1% Ceiling 3.1-22.9% | Response rate 95% Missing items 0.01% | - |
Off treatment Floor 0-1.9% Ceiling 10.6-35.6% | Reading level Flesch-Kincaid grade 1.8 | ||
PIE
[63] | - | Reading level Flesch-Kincaid grade 7 | - |