Background
Patient-centred care
Methods
Aim of literature review
Search strategy
Inclusion/Exclusion
Inclusion | Exclusion |
---|---|
Published between January 1970 and February 2013 | Published prior to 1970 |
Published in English and full-text accessible | Articles which were not available in English or full text unavailable |
Content directly relevant to dentistry or related disciplines | Not concerned with the field of dentistry |
Articles investigating the conceptual framework or dimensions of patient-centred care | Articles not directly related to “patient-centred care” |
Any publication undertaking primary research into PCC irrespective of type of study design | Opinion articles, reviews or reports of non-original research |
-
Publication of primary research study within peer-reviewed journal
-
Research related to dentistry
-
Research findings describing a conceptual framework for patient-centred care or its constructs.
Search outcome
Quality appraisal
Data extraction
Results
Authors | Title | Journal | Date | Type of article | Reason for exclusion | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Bauer, J., et al. | Interdisciplinary resources optimize Evidence-Based Dental Practice | J Evid Based Dent Pract | 2005 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
2 | Bedos, C., et al. | Patient-centred approaches: new models for new challenges | J. of the Canadian Dental Assoc | 2011 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
3 | Brennan, M., et al. | Patient satisfaction and oral health-related quality of life outcomes of implant overdentures and fixed complete dentures | Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants | 2010 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
4 | Chapple, H., et al. | Exploring dental patients’ preferred roles in treatment decision-making - a novel approach | British Dental Journal | 2003 |
QR
| Focuses on SDM rather than PCC |
5 | Cobb, D. S. | Patient-centered care in an academic health center: faculty perspective | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
6 | Cohen, L. A., et al. | Comparison of patient centeredness of visits to emergency departments, physicians, and dentists for dental problems and injuries | J Am Coll Dent | 2010 |
QUAN
| Assessment of level of PCC following dental injury using NHQR questionnaire rather than defining dimensions of PCC |
7 | Dierens, M., et al. | Patient-centered outcome of immediately loaded implants in the rehabilitation of fully edentulous jaws | Clinical Oral Implants Research | 2009 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
8 | Eriksen, H. M., et al. | A patient-centred approach to teaching and learning in dental student clinical practice | Eur J Dent Educ | 2008 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
9 | Fernandes, L., et al. | Patient-centered evaluation of orthodontic care: a longitudinal cohort study of children’s and parents’ attitudes | Am J. of Ortho & Dentofacial Orthopedics | 1999 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
10 | Formicola, A. J., et al. | Evolution of dental school clinics as patient care delivery centers | J Dent Educ | 2006 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
11 | Formicola, A. J., et al. | Evolution of dental school clinics as patient care delivery centers | J Dent Educ | 2008 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
12 | Freeman, R. | Communicating with children and parents: recommendations for a child-parent-centred approach for paediatric dentistry | Eur Arch Paediatr Dent | 2008 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
13 | Gerbert, B., et al. | The provider-patient relationship in academic health centers: the movement toward patient-centered care | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
14 | Gold, S. A. | Managing the patient-centered practice | J Calif Dent Assoc | 2000 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
15 | Hegarty, A. M., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures in oral medicine: are they valid and reliable? | Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2002 |
QUAN
| Study to compare patient-centred outcome measures and not PCC |
16 | Heymann, H. O. | The “patient-centered” practice | J Esthet Restor Dent | 2008 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
17 | Hietasalo, P., et al. | Cost-effectiveness of an experimental caries-control regimen in a 3.4-yr randomized clinical trial among 11-12-yr-old Finnish schoolchildren | European Journal Of Oral Sciences | 2009 |
QUAN
| “Patient-centred” used solely as a descriptive term and no reference to PCC. |
18 | Jones, C., et al. | Darzi and Dentistry:The Emerging Quality Agenda for GDPs in England | Dental Update | 2009 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
19 | Hislop, J. M. | Chapter 7: PATIENT-CENTERED COMMUNICATION | Dental Communication Unlimited | 1999 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
20 | Kalkwarf, K. L. | Patient-centered care in an academic health center: an administrator’s perspective | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
21 | Kalkwarf, K. L. | Patient-centered care and today’s dental practice | J Am Coll Dent | 1997 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
22 | Kulich, K. R., et al. | A qualitative analysis of patient-centered dentistry in consultations with dental phobic patients | Journal Of Health Communication | 2003 |
QR
| INCLUDED |
23 | Levine, R. A. | A patient-centered periodontal program for the 1990s, Part II | Compendium | 1990 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
24 | Levine, R. A. | A patient-centered periodontal program for the 1990s, Part I | Compendium | 1990 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
25 | Loignon, C., et al. | Providing humanistic care: dentists’ experiences in deprived areas | Journal of Dental Research | 2010 |
QR
| INCLUDED |
26 | Logan, H. L. | What does patient-centered care mean in an academic health center? A conclusion | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
27 | Logan, H. L. | What does patient-centered care mean in an academic health center? An introduction | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
28 | Madhan, B., et al. | Attitudes of postgraduate orthodontic students in India towards patient-centered care | J Dent Educ | 2011 |
QUAN
| Assessment of level of PCC of ortho students using PPOS questionnaire rather than defining dimensions of PCC |
29 | Mahajan, A., et al. | A Patient-Centered Clinical Evaluation of Acellular Dermal Matrix Graft in the Treatment of Gingival Recession Defects | Journal of Periodontology | 2007 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
30 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures in oral surgery: validity and sensitivity | Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2003 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
31 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures for oral mucosal disease are sensitive to treatment | Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2003 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
32 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 2. Quality of life | Dent Update | 2007 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
33 | McNair, A., et al. | A qualitative study to develop a tool to examine patients’ perceptions of NHS orthodontic treatment | Journal of Orthodontics | 2006 |
QR
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
34 | Miles, L. L. | The patient-centered practice | J Calif Dent Assoc | 2000 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
35 | Newsome, P., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 1. An overview | Dent Update | 2006 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
36 | Newsome, P., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 3. Patient satisfaction | Dent Update | 2007 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
37 | Ni Riordain, R., et al. | A patient-centered approach to developing a quality-of-life questionnaire for chronic oral mucosal diseases | Oral Surg, Oral Med, Oral Path, Oral Rad & Endo | 2011 |
QR
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
38 | Nimmo, A., et al. | Patient-centered competency-based education in fixed prosthodontics | J Prosthodont | 1996 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
39 | Pastagia, J., et al. | The effect of patient-centered plaque control and periodontal maintenance therapy on adverse outcomes of periodontitis | The Journal Of Evidence-Based Dental Practice | 2006 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
40 | Phillips, C. | Patient-centered outcomes in surgical and orthodontic treatment | Semin Orthod | 1999 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
41 | Roskell, C., et al. | Developing patient-centred care in health professionals: reflections on introducing service-learning into the curriculum | Int J of Therapy & Rehab | 2012 |
QR
| Pilot study to promote PCC rather than explore dimensions |
42 | Sachdeva, R. C. | SureSmile technology in a patient--centered orthodontic practice | Journal Of Clinical Orthodontics: JCO | 2001 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
43 | Scambler, S., et al. | Professional attitudes towards disability in special care dentistry | Journal of Disability & Oral Health | 2011 |
QR
| INCLUDED |
44 | Shenkin, J. D. | Patient-Centered Caries Prevention in Children may be More Cost-Effective in the Long Term than Traditional Dental Care | J Evid Based Dent Pract | 2011 |
R
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
45 | Stutts, L. A., et al. | Patient-Centered Outcome Criteria for Successful Treatment of Facial Pain and Fibromyalgia | Journal of Orofacial Pain | 2009 |
QUAN
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
46 | Travess, H. C., et al. | The development of a patient-centered measure of the process and outcome of combined orthodontic and orthognathic treatment | J Orthod | 2004 |
QR
| Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
47 | Tresolini, C. P. | Health care relationships: instruments for effective patient-focused care in the academic health center | J Dent Educ | 1996 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
48 | Weinstein, P. | Provider versus patient-centered approaches to health promotion with parents of young children: what works/does not work and why | Pediatr Dent | 2006 |
O
| NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
Author | Reference | Country | Research topic | Methodology | Participant group | Analysis | Brief overview | Key features |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kulich, K. R., et al.
| (40) | Sweden | Assessment of patient-centred dentistry in dental phobic patients | Qualitative approach using semi-structured interviews based on video analysis of consultation. | 30 interviews conducted with 5 dentists working in a clinic treating anxious patients. Based on 2 separate consultations with 15 patients | Grounded theory | Study to ascertain the key features in delivering PCC to anxious patients attending a specialist clinic in Sweden. Model of care developed based on “holistic perception and understanding of the patient.” | • Communication |
• Empathy | ||||||||
• Understanding | ||||||||
• Positive outlook | ||||||||
• Patient contact | ||||||||
Loignon, C., et al.
| (41) | Canada | Identify effective approaches to providing care for patients living in poverty | Qualitative approach based on semi-structured interviews | Interviews conducted with 8 dentists with experience of treating patients living in poverty | Thematic analysis | Research to determine what features of PCC are most effective in delivering dental care to people in poverty in Canada. Domains based around socio-humanistic approach. | • Understanding |
• Empathy | ||||||||
• Non-judgemental | ||||||||
• Overcome social distance | ||||||||
• Direct contact | ||||||||
• Communication | ||||||||
Scambler, S., et al.
| (42) | UK | Assessment of professional attitudes towards disability in special care dentistry | Qualitative approach based on focus groups & semi-structured interviews | Sample of 30 participants including dentists and staff working within special care dentistry | Retroductive analysis using a theoretical framework | Study to explore attitudes of staff working in Special Care Dentistry towards disability and provision of dental care. Analysis highlighted importance of PCC and revealed key features. | • Holistic approach |
• Individualised care | ||||||||
• Information/support | ||||||||
• Time | ||||||||
• Communication | ||||||||
• Trust |
Kulich 2003 | Loignon 2010 | Scambler 2011 | |
---|---|---|---|
Was there a clear statement of the aims of the research? | Y | Y | Y |
Is a qualitative methodology appropriate? | Y | Y | Y |
Was the research design appropriate to address the aims of the research? | Y | Y | Y |
Was the recruitment strategy appropriate to the aims of the research? | Y | Y | Limited detail on recruitment/sampling |
Were the data collected in a way that addressed the research issue? | Y | Y | Y |
Has the relationship between researcher and participants been adequately considered? | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
Have ethical issues been taken into consideration? | Y | Y | Y |
Was the data analysis sufficiently rigorous? | Detail provided on analysis but would appear to have been conducted independently | Y | Lack of detail about who conducted analysis |
Is there a clear statement of findings? | Y | Y | Y |
How valuable is the research? | Y | Y | Research subject not directly related to literature review but does provide some information on PCC |
Reviewers comments | Research highlights 5 facets of delivering a socio-humanistic approach which is consistent with patient-centred care. Recognition that this patient-centred approach had been developed as a consequence of personal experiences and reflection rather than specific training. Study specifically concerned with patients living in poverty, but findings likely to be relevant to delivery of PCC in dentistry in general. | Very interesting paper in terms of research question, methodology and findings. The use of video recording the consultation and then using this as part of the interview process would appear to have enriched the data considerably. Clear theoretical framework described with strong similarities to pre-existing models. | Research focuses on staff attitudes towards delivery of dental care to disabled adults and compares the results against a theoretical framework based on the social model of disability. Key theme to emerge from the interviews is PCC which is described as being “at the heart of the model”. Features of PCC described which focus on a holistic approach, individualised care, communication, trust, information and support. |
-
Understanding patients’ social context
-
Taking time and showing empathy
-
Avoiding moralistic attitudes
-
Overcoming social distances
-
Favouring direct contact with patients
Discussion
Dimensions of PCC according to Institute of Medicine | Dimensions of PCC within evidence-based dental literature (3 papers) |
---|---|
1. Compassion, empathy and responsiveness to needs, values and expressed preferences | 1. Empathy, equality, dignity, respect, engagement, trust, courtesy, “listened to”, responsive, individualised care, humanistic approach. |
2. Co-ordination and integration | 2. - |
3. Information, communication and education | 3. Communication, information. |
4. Physical comfort | 4. - |
5. Emotional support, relieving fear and anxiety | 5. Emotional understanding, understood, non-judgemental, positive outlook, patient contact, relationship. |
6. Involvement of family and friends | 6. (Consent issues) |
Conclusions
Key findings
-
Future research should ensure that a patient’s perspective of PCC is adequately represented.
-
There is a lack of evidence to adequately understand PCC within dentistry.
-
The evidence which is currently available on PCC in dentistry is not necessarily generalisable to general dental practice.
-
Further research is necessary to understand the key features of PCC within general dental practice if we wish to use this as a quality indicator.