Background
Methods
Eligibility criteria
Literature search
Study selection and assessment
Data extraction process
Synthesis of results
Results
Study selection
Characteristics of included studies
Study, design, included studies if SR* | Population | Intervention | Control | The setting and nationality |
---|---|---|---|---|
Robinson 2012[32], Systematic review, 3/4 studies were relevant for inclusion | People with cognitive impairment | Defined as ‘Any kind of advance care planning’ by review authors. | Usual care | Any care environment, including nursing homes |
Caplan 2006, Controlled before after design | A structured educational programme (Let Me Decide) for health personnel, residents and their families | Nursing homes in Canada, Australia and USA | ||
Molloy 2000, Randomised controlled trial | The Let Me Decide programme in addition to hospital-to-the-nursing-home | |||
Morrison 2005, Non-randomised controlled trial | Half-day course for social workers in guiding residents and families in ACP. Feedback to physicians was given in intervention group to initiate referral to palliative care. | |||
Hall 2011[33], Systematic review | Residents of care homes for older people | Defined as ‘All types of palliative care service delivery interventions’ by review authors. | Not specified | Setting defined as ‘collective institutional settings where care is provided’ Nursing homes in USA |
1/3 studies was relevant for inclusion: Casarett 2005, Randomised controlled trial | ||||
Hutt 2011[34], Controlled before-after study | Nursing home residents with symptoms of systemic lower respiratory tract infection | Multifaceted implementation of a national guideline for management of nursing-home-acquired pneumonia | Usual care | 16 nursing homes in Colorado, USA (8 intervention homes and 8 control homes) |
Loeb 2006[35], Cluster randomised controlled trial | Nursing home residents with pneumonia | On-site treatment of pneumonia according to pathway | Usual care | 22 nursing homes Ontario, Canada |
Lee 2002[36], Cluster randomised controlled trial | Nursing home residents with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease | Community nurses followed up residents for 6 months post-hospitalisation according to a care protocol | Usual care | 45 nursing homes in Hong Kong, China |
Study, design | Population | Intervention | Control | The setting and nationality |
---|---|---|---|---|
Díaz-Genúndez 2011[30], Controlled before-after study | Nursing home residents | Ambulatory geriatric team doing comprehensive geriatric assessments of residents and revision of their medication, in addition to providing educational sessions and support to staff | Usual care | 14 nursing homes in Spain (10 voluntary intervention homes, 14 control homes) |
Shippinger 2012[31], Controlled before-after study | Nursing home residents | Mobile GEriatric Consultant geriatric service (GECO) in addition to usual care | Usual care | Two nursing homes in Austria (one intervention home and one control home) |
Study, design, Included studies if SR* | Population | Intervention | Control | The setting and nationality |
---|---|---|---|---|
Thomas 2010[29], Systematic review | Healthcare workers caring for elderly residents in institutions | Promotion of vaccination of healthcare workers with any influenza vaccine given alone or with other vaccines | Usual care | Any type of institution for elderly, including nursing homes |
2/5 studies were relevant for inclusion: Hayward 2006, Lemaitre 2009, Cluster-randomised controlled trials | Nursing homes in England and France | |||
Jefferson 2010[28], Systematic review | Elderly people | Vaccination with any influenza vaccine | Usual care | Irrespective of setting, including nursing homes |
One to 27 out of 75 studies were relevant: Feery 1976, Saah 1986b, Horman 1986, Fyson 1983a, Patriarca 1985a, Goodman 1982, Straburg 1986, Fyson 1983b, Meiklejohn 1987, Cartter 1990c, Cartter 1990a, Cartter 1990, Aylor 1992, Morens 1995, Monto 2001, Murayama 1999, Ruben 1974, Saah 1986a, Arroyo 1984, Coles 1992, Patriarca 1985b, Caminiti 1994, Deguchi 2001, Howells 1975a, Howells 1975b, Howells 1975c, Saah 1986c, Strassburg 1986, Arden 1988, Cartter 1990b, Taylor 1992, Mukerjee 1994, Isaacs 1997, Leung 2007, D’Alessio 1969, Currier 1988, Saito 2002a, Saito 2002b, Gross 1988, Cuneo Crovari 1980, Howarth 1987a, Howarth 1987b | Nursing homes in USA, Australia, Canada, Japan, Italy, China, UK |