Sensory and motor neuronopathy in a patient with the A382P TDP-43 mutation

TDP-43, a protein involved in RNA processing, is thought to play a determinant role in the pathophysiology of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), in which it is abnormally processed and sequestered in the cytoplasm, the perikaryon, and dystrophic neurites of neurons [1, 2]. Variations in the TARDPB gene, which encodes TDP-43, occur in about 3% of sporadic and familial cases of ALS [3] and are mostly found in cases with a usually predominant lower motor neuron involvement and in a few patients with cognitive deficits [4‐6]. We here report the case of a patient with the A382P TDP-43 mutation who developed a unique phenotype consisting of a slowly spreading sensory and motor neuronopathy.

A 72-year-old right-handed non-smoker man was referred in March 2001 after a 6-year progression of a sensory, then motor, deficit in the left arm. He reported that his mother died when she was 56 after a 4-year evolution of a neurological disease that started in the upper limbs and progressively paralyzed her, including speech and deglutition. Symptoms first appeared in the patient in April 1995, with paresthesia in the left hand (month 1 = M1). In July (M4), motor deficit and muscle atrophy were absent, but 128 Hz tuning fork perception was reduced in the left index finger. Motor conduction velocities (MCV) and compound motor action potentials (CMAP) were normal in both the median and ulnar nerve, while sensory action potentials (SAP) were reduced in the left median and ulnar nerves and slightly reduced in the right sural nerve (see Additional file 1 for the electrophysiological methods and the detailed results of the ENMG study). Needle examination showed only an increased number of polyphasic motor unit potentials (MUPs) in the left abductor pollicis brevis (28% of MUPs). The cervical spine and plexus MRI was normal. Because of persistent paresthesia, somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) were recorded in October 1996 (M18) and were normal in the right median nerve, whereas the left N9 potential amplitude was reduced and the N13, P14, and N30 potentials abolished (Table 1).

Four years later, in January 1998 (M35), motor deficit and muscle atrophy appeared in the left arm, while the sensory symptoms extended to the elbow. In July (M40), SAPs were reduced in both the median and ulnar nerve, predominantly on the left. MCVs and CMAPs were normal. Needle examination showed chronic neurogenic changes in the abductor policis brevis, abductor digiti minimi, first dorsal interosseus, and extensor carpi radialis longus in both hands, but predominantly on the left side.

In November 2000 (M68), the left arm showed diffuse muscular atrophy. Tendon reflexes were abolished and fasciculations were observed in the left biceps brachii and pectoralis major. In March 2001 (M72), the motor deficit was restricted to the left arm, with an MRC score of 3 in the deltoideus, biceps brachii, triceps brachii, and abductor pollicis brevis muscles. Muscle atrophy was restricted to the left upper limb and fasciculations were observed in all four limbs. Tendon reflexes were absent in the left arm and normal in the other limbs. The plantar response was indifferent on both sides. Bulbar involvement was absent. Tuning fork 128 Hz perception was absent at the left wrist and elbow, present at the clavicle, and reduced at the left ankle and knee. Stereognosia and graphesthesia were abolished in the left hand, while pain and thermal sensation were almost normal. There was no cognitive impairment and no dysautonomic manifestation. SAPs were absent in the left radial, ulnar, and median nerves and reduced in the other limbs. CMAPs were reduced in the left median and ulnar nerves and normal on the right side and in both peroneal and tibial nerves. Motor conduction velocities and F-wave latencies were normal. Fibrillation potentials were recorded in the upper limbs and fasciculations were present in the left vastus lateralis. SEPs were not recordable in the left median and both tibial nerves, but were normal in the right median nerve with the exception of a reduced N9 potential (Table 1).

The motor deficit slowly progressed in the left arm and, in January 2004 (M104), proximal weakness appeared in the left leg. The Norris limb score was 45/63 and the bulbar score 42/42. Forced vital capacity was normal. SAPs could not be recorded in the upper limbs and were severely reduced in the lower limbs, especially on the left side. CMAPs were reduced or absent in the left median, ulnar, tibial, and peroneal nerves and reduced in the right median and peroneal nerves. Conduction velocities were normal. Positive sharp waves and fibrillation potentials were recorded in all four limbs. SEPs were abolished in the four limbs, except in the right median nerve, where a N20 potential was recorded (Table 1). CO2 laser-evoked potentials (LEPs), evaluating Aδ and C fibers, were abolished in both hands and feet. The patient died suddenly in June 2004 (M110). No autopsy was performed. The clinical and neurophysiological data are summarized in Figure 1.

The following investigations were performed in October 2001 (M79) and were normal: cerebrospinal fluid analysis, blood cell count, ionogram, serum creatinine, glycemia, liver enzymes, vitamin E, B12 and folates, TSH, hexosaminidase A and B, amino acid chromatography, and Apo A and Apo B. Serology was negative for HIV, VDRL-TPHA, and hepatitis B and C. Screening for monoclonal gammopathy, red blood cell acanthocytosis, and antinuclear, anti-SSA, anti-SSB, anti-mitochondrial, anti-gliadin, anti-disialosyl ganglioside, and anti-onconeural antibodies, including Hu and CRMP5/CV2 antibodies, was negative. The salivary gland biopsy was normal. No mutations of the frataxin and TTR genes were found. X-ray and CT thoracic scans were normal, as was abdominal ultrasound. A muscle biopsy (left vastus lateralis) showed neurogenic changes without mitochondrial abnormalities.

In December 2001 (M81), a left superficial radial nerve biopsy was normal on paraffin-embedded H-S and Congo red-stained sections. Semithin sections disclosed a severe reduction in large myelinated fiber density (Figure 2A and 2B). Only a few fibers were degenerating. Regenerating clusters were absent. Immunohistochemistry was performed on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded samples of the nerve biopsy from the patient and, as control, a patient with a sensory neuropathy using rabbit polyclonal anti-human TDP43 antibodies (Protein Tech Group, Inc; Chicago, IL, USA) at a 1/1000 dilution. Nerve sections were deparaffinised, subjected to immunochemical detection with the antibodies, processed with a ultra View Universal DAB Detection Kit (Ventana Medical Systems, S.A., Illkirch, France), and counterstained with H-E. In both the patient and control, Schwann cell nuclei were immunolabeled, while no labeling was observed in the cytoplasm or in axons (Figure 3). In June 2003, the brain MRI was normal, while the T2 weighted cervical spine MRI showed a hypersignal in the left posterior column (Figure 2C).

The sample was sequenced for mutations in the SOD1, TARDBP, and FUS genes. A previously reported heterozygous change from an alanine to a proline at amino acid 382 [7], resulting from the substitution of a guanine by a cytosine at position one of the codon (c.1278G > C), was identified in exon 6 of the TARDPB gene (p.A382P) (Figure 4). This variant was not identified in 360 control participants [8]. Family members were not available for genetic analysis. The mutated alanine is conserved in seven out of nine tested species, but is a proline in the mouse and rat (Figure 4B). Two bioinformatics programs, Polyphen [9] and SIFT [10], were used to predict the effect of the polymorphism on the protein. Polyphen predicted the change to be benign, while SIFT predicted that it would affect protein function, with a low confidence in the prediction.

This is the first time, to our knowledge, that a variant in TARDBP has been identified in a patient with a sensory and motor phenotype. It is very unlikely that this resulted from a coincidental association of sensory neuropathy and motor neuron disease, since the motor and sensory manifestations started in the same metameric territory and followed a parallel course. Moreover, an extensive work-up found no other cause of sensory neuropathy. Despite the absence of pathological evidence, the severe sensory involvement is very suggestive of sensory neuronopathy, i.e. of sensory neuron degeneration in dorsal root ganglia [11]. Thus, the sensory perturbations had a typical non-length-dependent pattern both clinically and on sensory nerve conduction study. The presence of SEPs with early absent N13 potentials and still recordable N9 potentials also suggests sensory neuronopathy [12]. Moreover, this indicates that the central process of the sensory neurons was involved before the peripheral process. Central process degeneration was also demonstrated by the presence of abnormal signals in the posterior column on spinal cord MRI, as reported previously [13]. Finally, the CO2 laser-evoked potentials indicated that, despite a predominant large neuron involvement, small nociceptive neurons were also involved.

The patient's mother's history was highly suggestive of neuromuscular disease, arguing for a hereditary transmission of the disorder. The A382P mutation identified in the patient has been reported in another ALS case, but the sensory phenotype of this patient was not specified in the publication [7]. The mutation, which was absent in 720 control chromosomes [8], was predicted to have mixed effects by two different bioinformatics software programs. The missense mutation, which is also a proline in the rat and mouse, was located in the C-terminal glycine-rich region, where most TARDPB mutations have been found [14]. Thus, with the available information, it can be hypothesized that the TARDPB variant actually caused the particular phenotype of this patient.

Sensory neuron involvement had not previously been reported for TDP-43 mutations and, when mentioned, SAPs have been reported as normal [15, 16]. Pathological studies in the few available cases [4, 17] and in transgenic models [18, 19] did not specifically examine dorsal root ganglia, although TDP-43 is normally expressed in sensory neuron nuclei [20]. On the patient's nerve biopsy, no abnormal accumulation of TDP-43 was found in peripheral axons, in keeping with the fact that, in the central nervous system of patients with TARDBP mutations or sporadic ALS, the protein does not accumulate in axons, but in the neuron cell body and dendrites [1, 4].

ALS is usually considered as a propagating process that recruits locally and spreads with an orderly progression [21]. In this patient, the electrophysiological results suggested a pre-existing widespread sensory dysfunction upon which the degenerative process developed focally in the left arm, then extended to the contralateral side and, through descending pathways, to the lumbar region. At each level, sensory neurons were electrophysiologically involved before motor neurons.

The combination of severe sensory and motor neuronopathy is rarely encountered in clinical practice. It has been reported in patients with paraneoplastic Hu-antibodies, [22] in facial onset sensory and motor neuronopathy (FOSMN) [23], and in rare genetic diseases, such as Tangier disease [24]. The A382P TDP-43 mutation should be considered in patients with such an association.

The patient gave informed consent for the genetic analysis. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal. Consent for publication could not be obtained from the family of the deceased patient, as they could not be reached.