Background
Methods
Search strategy and extraction
Analysis
Quality evaluation
Calculating incremental coverage
Calculating incremental intervention cost
Calculating incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICERs)
Results
Publication Year | First author | Location | Study type | Intervention description | Intervention type | Urban / rural | Campaign vs. routine | Delivery platforma |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2009 | Andersson | Pakistan (Balochistan province) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | Community discussion groups on vaccine benefits, costs, and coverage | Demand generation | Not stated | Routine | Mobile |
2010 | Banerjee | India (Rajasthan state) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | Monthly immunization camps conducted by mobile team in villages | Delivery approach | Rural | Routine | Mobile |
2007 | Barham | Mexico (7 states) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | Cash transfers conditional on children attending preventative health visits and mothers attending health education talks | Demand generation / Cash transfers | Both | Routine | Both |
Nicaragua | Cash transfers conditional on children attending preventative health visits and mothers attending health education talks | Demand generation / Cash transfers | Not stated | Routine | Both | |||
2017 | Byberg | Guinea-Bissau (9 regions) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | Giving measles vaccination to all unvaccinated children 9–36 months regardless of number of children present | Delivery approach | Rural | Campaign | Mobile |
2014 | Carnell | Ethiopia (Amhara, Oromia and SNNP regions) | Pre-post design | I: Strengthen health systems (planning, HMIS, logistics, health care financing) II: Improve health workers’ skills (through training and supervision in immunization, ENA and IMCI) III: Introduce community health promoters | Health systems strengthening | Rural | Routine | Fixed |
2003 | Drain | Madagascar (Antananarivo and Fianarantsoa provinces) | Randomized controlled trial | Clinic staff used auto-disable syringes on all days or on non-routine immunization days | Novel technology | Both | Both | Fixed |
2014 | Hayford | Bangladesh (Dhaka) | Pre-post design | I: Extended hours at satellite clinics; II: training for vaccinators; III: clinic screening tool to identify children with missed doses; IIII: volunteer community group to assist at satellite clinics | Delivery approach | Urban | Campaign | Mobile |
2013 | Khan | Bangladesh (Mirpur area of Dhaka) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | Oral cholera vaccination for high-risk, urban population aged one and older | Delivery approach | Urban | Campaign | Both |
2005 | Levin | Indonesia (West Nusa Tenggara province) | Pre-post design | Delivering birth dose of Hepatitis B vaccine using prefilled injection device | Novel technology | Not stated | Routine | Mobile |
2011 | Owais | Pakistan (Karachi) | Randomized controlled trial | Home-based vaccine promotion education by community health workers using pictoral cards | Demand generation | Urban | Routine | Mobile |
2007 | Pandey | India (Uttar Pradesh state) | Cluster randomized controlled trial | 4–6 meetings in each village to disseminate information on entitled health and education services | Demand generation | Rural | Routine | Mobile |
2018 | Powell-Jackson | India (Uttar Pradesh state) | Randomized controlled trial | Health information messaging targeting mothers of unvaccinated or incompletely vaccinated children through home visits | Demand generation | Rural | Routine | Fixed |
2009 | Rainey | India (Uttar Pradesh state) | Pre-post design | Identifying and vaccinating newborns with OPV within 72 h of birth | Delivery approach | Both | Campaign | Both |
2006 | Soeung | Cambodia | Cross-sectional design | Developing and implementing immunization microplans that are supported by performance based agreements and a secure system of financing | Health systems strengthening | Rural | Routine | Fixed |
Coverage and cost information
Publication Year | First author | Vaccine / intervention breakout | Baseline coverage | Endline coverage | Incremental coverage | Intervention cost (2017 USD) | Intervention cost per person exposed (2017 USD) | ICER |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2009 | Andersson | Measles | 22% | $86,968 | $162.25 | $124.86 | ||
DPT3 | 23% | $119.43 | ||||||
2010 | Banerjee | Intervention A | 2% | 18% | 11% | $41,109 | $83.70 | $1.09 |
Intervention B | 0% | 39% | 34% | $66,460 | $41.89 | $0.66 | ||
Control | 1% | 6% | ||||||
2007 | Barhama | Mexico: MCV treatment areas | 92% | 91% | 3%b | $2303 million | $44.07 | *c |
Mexico: MCV control areas | 95% | 91% | ||||||
Nicaragua: FVC treatment areas | 54% | 83% | 11% | $5,007,901 | $67.11 | *d | ||
Nicaragua: FVC control areas | 55% | 73% | ||||||
2017 | Byberg | 84% | 97% | 13% | $76,994e | $1.41 | $3.29 | |
2014 | Carnellf | DPT3 | 45% | 65% | 8% | $26,049,434g | *h | * |
Measles | 46% | 64% | 13% | |||||
2003 | Drain | Auto-disable syringes | 16% | Not stated | $78.06 | |||
Mixed syringes | 17% | $5.03 | ||||||
2014 | Hayford | 43% | 99% | 56% | $36,190 | $41.40 | ||
2013 | Khan | 72% | $680,581 | $3.94 | $5.50 | |||
2005 | Levin | 68% | 80% | 12% | $11,709i | $0.12 | $1.00 | |
2011 | Owais | Intervention | 77% | 72% | 19% | $1.15 | *j | |
Control | 76% | 52% | ||||||
2007 | Pandey | Intervention | 53% | 72% | 20% | $5997 | $1.38 | $6.88 |
Control | 47% | 46% | ||||||
2018 | Powell-Jackson | Intervention | 0% | 43% | 15% | $11,137 | $23.64k | $161.95l |
Control | 0% | 28% | ||||||
2009 | Rainey | 38% | 65% | 27% | Not stated | $3.72 | $9.01 | |
2006 | Soeung | 16% | $186,031 | $2.20 | $13.75 |