Introduction
Method
Search strategy
Eligibility criteria
Study design
Population
Interventions
Outcomes
Data management
Study selection
Data collection process
Quality (risk of bias) assessment
Outcomes and data synthesis
Results
Results of search
Characteristics of included trials
Study | Condition | Health professionals | Patients | Comparison | Outcome | Longest duration of follow-up | Country | Context | Methods |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kinmonth 1998 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 107 (43 GPs and 64 nurses) Age: NA | n = 360 Mean age: 57.7 Sex: 59.2% male | Int: Patient centred care skills training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI, communication performance, patient satisfaction, patient understanding, quality of life (ADDQoL), wellbing | 12 months | UK | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 41) |
Brug 2007 | Diabetes | n = 37 (dietitians) Age: 24 to 45 | n = 209 Mean age: NA Sex: NA | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | HbA1C, BMI, Self-care management | 6 months | Netherlands | Home-care organizations | Individual RCT |
Rubak 2009 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 65 (GPs) Age: NA | n = 265 Mean age: NA Sex: NA | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | Patient-doctor relationship (Health Care Climates Questionnaire), self-care management (Summary of Diabetes Self Care Activities), patient understanding (Diabetes Illness Representation Questionnaire) | 12 months | Denmark | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 48) |
Sequist 2010 | Diabetes | n = 124 (91 GPs and 33 NPs) Age: NA | n = 2699 Mean age: 62.4 Sex: 48.7% male | Int: Cultural competency training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI, Communication performance | 12 months | USA | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 31) |
Heinrich 2010 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 33 (nurses) Age: NA | n = 584 Mean age: 59 Sex: 45.1% male | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI, patient-doctor relationship (Health Care Climates Questionnaire), self-care management (Summary of Diabetes Self Care Activities), quality of life (DSQoL) | 24 months | Netherlands | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 33) |
Rubak 2011 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 140 (GPs) Age: NA | n = 628 Mean age: 61 Sex: 58% male | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI | 12 months | Denmark | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 80) |
Robling 2012 | Type 1 diabetes | n = 79 (Health practitioners) Age: NA | n = 693 Mean age: 4 to 15 Sex: 49% male | Int: Talking Diabetes consulting skills Con: No training | HbA1C, BMI, quality of life, self-care management | 12 months | UK | Secondary and tertiary care | Cluster RCT (n = 26) |
Farmer 2012 | Type 2 diabetes | n:NA Age: NA | n = 211 Mean age: 63.2 Sex: 65.4% male | Int: Theory of planned behaviour training Con: No training | HbA1C Adherence (Medication Adherence Report Scale), health status (12-item Short Form Medical Outcomes), satisfaction (Diabetes Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire) | 3 months | UK | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 13) |
Welschen 2012 | Type 2 diabetes | n:NA Age: NA | n = 262 Mean age: 58.6 Sex: 43.1% male | Int: Six-step CVD risk communication training Con: No training | Patient understanding, wellbeing (Short Form Spielberger State Anxiety Inventory), risk perception (Brief Illness Perception Questionnaire), satisfaction (COMRADE scale) | 3 months | Netherlands | A managed care system coordinates patients and specialists | Individual RCT |
Jansink 2013 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 53 (nurses) Age: 42.7 | n = 521 Mean age: 64.0 Sex: 54.9% male | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI, quality of life (Euroqol) | 14 months | Netherlands | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 58) |
Tinsel 2013 | Hypertension | n:NA Age: NA | n = 1120 Mean age: 64.4 Sex: 45.7% male | Int: Shared decision making Con: No training | Blood pressure, patient understanding, adherence (Medication Adherence Report Scale) | 20 months | Germany | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 37) |
Juul 2014 | Type 1 and 2 diabetes | n = 34 (nurses) Age: NA | n = 4034 Mean age: 60.5 Sex: 56.5% male | Int: Communication skills training Con: No training | HbA1C, lipids, BMI, health status (12-item Short Form Medical Outcomes), patient-doctor relationship (Health Care Climates Questionnaire), patient understanding (Problem Areas in Diabetes scale and Perceived Competence for Diabetes Scale) | 18 months | Denmark | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 40) |
Ma 2014 | Hypertension | n = 12 (nurses) Age: NA | n = 120 Mean age: 58.8 Sex: 49.2% male | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | Blood pressure, lipids Adherence (Treatment Adherence Questionnaire of Patients with Hypertension), health status (36-item short form) | 6 months | China | Primary care | Individual RCT |
Manze 2015 | Hypertension | n = 58 (doctors) Age: NA | n = 379 Mean age: 60.6 Sex: 29.6% male | Int: Patient-centered counseling and cultural competency training Con: No training | Blood pressure, communication performance, adherence (Hill-Bone Compliance to High Blood Pressure Therapy Scale) | 18 months | USA | Primary care | Individual RCT |
Kressin 2016 | Hypertension | n:NA Age: NA | n = 8866 Mean age: 66.2 Sex: 98.8% male | Int: Patient-centered counseling Con: No training | Blood pressure, communication performance, adherence | 14 months | USA | Primary care | Individual RCT |
Okada 2017 | Hypertension | n:NA (pharmacists) Age: NA | n = 125 Mean age: 64 Sex: 40% male | Int: Motivational interviewing training Con: No training | Blood pressure Adherence (Medication Adherence Report Scale), health status (WHO-Five wellbeing index and EQ-5D) | 4 months | Japan | Pharmacy | Cluster RCT (n = 73) |
Akturan 2017 | Type 2 diabetes | n = 8 (doctors) Age: NA | n = 112 Mean age: 56.9 Sex: 34.8% male | Int: BATHE (Background, Affect, Troubling, Handling, and Empathy) training Con: No training | Diabetes empowerment score | 6 months | Turkey | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 8) |
Belin 2017 | Hypertension | n = 35 (health providers) Age: NA | n = 240 Mean age: 37 Sex: 22.7% male | Int: Communication skills training Con: No training | Blood pressure, communication performance (Health Literacy Assessment Questions), adherence, patients’ self-efficacy | NA | Iran | Primary care | Individual RCT |
Ismail 2018 | Type 2 diabetes | n:NA (nurses) Age: NA | n = 334 Mean age: 58.9 Sex: 48.8% male | Int: Diabetes-6 (six psychological skill) training Con: No training | HbA1C, blood pressure, lipids, BMI, health status (PHQ-9 and Diabetes Distress Scale) | 18 months | UK | Primary care | Cluster RCT (n = 24) |
Type and duration of intervention
Study | Conceptual frameworks or theory for interventions | Training content | Training types | Number of sessions | Training evaluation reported before trials |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kinmonth 1998 | Action research | Training aimed patient centred care. The first half day was to review the evidence for patient centred consulting and a further full day was to practice skills with a facilitator, including active listening and negotiation of behavioural change. | Lectures, group discussions | 1.5 days | Yes |
Brug 2007 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing (MI). The first day was to introduce MI theory and principles and the second day was to practice MI skills. Another one-day follow-up workshop for discussing experiences with experts and refresh knowledge. Training was developed and conducted by authors. | Workshop | 3 days | No |
Rubak 2009 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. A book was used to guide specific skills e.g. empowerment, ambivalence, the decisional balance schedule, the visual analogue scale, stage of change, and reflective listening. The courses consisted of a 1½-day training sessions with a half-day follow-up twice. Training was conducted by only one trained teacher. | NA | 2.5 days | No |
Sequist 2010 | NA | Training aimed cultural competency. Training goals included understanding attitudes of trust and bias, increasing knowledge about health disparities and skills. The curriculum reviewed potential racial and cultural biases in health care, appropriate methods of collecting clinically relevant cultural data, and ways to incorporate such information into effective clinical care plans for diabetes. | Lectures, group discussions, community engagement activities | 2 days | No |
Heinrich 2010 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. Trainees received a project folder with information about the study, training material (e.g. cases for role-playing), background information about MI. Trainees received instruction charts specifying counselling techniques. Trainees were visited three times after being trained. | Role play, discussions, audio-taped consultations feedback | 21.5 h | No |
Rubak 2011 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. Training was conducted by a trained teacher. Training included specific skills, e.g. empowerment, ambivalence, the decisional balance schedule, the visual analogue scale, stage of change, and reflective listening. | NA | 2.5 days | No |
Robling 2012 | Medical Research Council (MRC) framework | Training aimed constructive consultations (Talking Diabetes).Training emphasized shared setting of agendas and a guiding communication style, strategies and skills drawn from motivational interviewing practice. | Role play, web based modules, work shop, case studies | 2 days | Yes |
Farmer 2012 | Theory of Planned Behaviour | Training aimed theory of planned behaviour. These included perceived benefits and harms of taking medicines. Positive beliefs were reinforced verbally and non-verbally through provision of tailored information and problem solving was facilitated around negative beliefs. | Audio-taped consultations feedback | 1 day | Yes |
Welschen 2012 | Leventhal’s self-regulation theory,Theory of Planned Behavior | Training aimed cardiovascular disease risk communication. This included communication of the absolute risk, visual communication, message framing, communication with the patient for a reaction. | NA | 1 day | No |
Jansink 2013 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing and agenda setting. This included building motivation for change, asking open questions, listening reflectively, affirming, summarizing, eliciting change, expressing empathy, developing discretion, rolling with resistance and supporting self-efficacy. Training were spread equally over 6 months. | Video recording feedback | 2 days | Yes |
Tinsel 2013 | NA | Training aimed shared decision making (SDM) and motivational interviewing. This included risk communication, the process steps of SDM, introduction of a decision table with options. | Role play | NA | Yes |
Juul 2014 | Self-determination theory | Training aimed self-determination theory. This included patient-health care provider relationships, communication skills, patient worksheets, implementation of the course content in daily practice. | NA | 2 days | Yes |
Ma 2014 | Social cognitive theory | Training aimed motivational interviewing and social cognitive theory. Training was presented by a certified trainer. Training included building rapport with the patients, evaluating the patients’ confidence and motivation for behaviour changes, helping change patients behaviours and so on. | Lectures, role play, discussions | 3 days | Yes |
Manze 2015 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling and cultural competency training. Training was led by experts in medicine and patient-centered counseling. Training includes implementing 5 A's: ask the patient about their BP management, assess their medication adherence, advise the patient about pharmacologic treatment, assist them in overcoming barriers to treatment adherence and arrange for follow-up. The cultural competency training included understanding patients, their social and financial risks for non-adherence, their fears and concerns. | Role play, work shop | 2 sessions | No |
Kressin 2016 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling. Training was led by an experienced trainer. Training includes implementing 4 A's: ask about patients’ hypertension beliefs, assess patients’ prior experiences in changing behaviors, assist patients in making needed changes, and address relapse. | Role play, discussions | 2 h | Yes |
Okada 2017 | NA | Training aimed modified motivational interviewing. Training was based on empowerment or coaching-style communication, including: using an open question, setting each goal with patients, and closing with encouragement. | NA | 4 h | No |
Akturan 2017 | NA | Training aimed BATHE interview (Background, Affect, Troubling, Handling, and Empathy). Training was evaluated by researchers. Trainees were asked to use the BATHE technique on their patients 3 times, with 3-month intervals. | Role play | 3 h | No |
Belin 2017 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling. Training was led by a doctor specialist. Trainees were used open-ended questions to identify the needs, barriers, patient beliefs, and ideas consistent with the patient centered counseling approach. Trainees identified that poor patient–provider communication and improved communication skills. Training was conducted using a training package and a self-assessment checklist. | Focus-group discussion, workshop | 5 sessions | No |
Ismail 2018 | NA | Training aimed six psychological skills. The six skills were drawn from MI and CBT, including: active listening; managing resistance; directing change; supporting self-efficacy; addressing health beliefs and shaping behaviours. | NA | NA | Yes |
Kinmonth 1998 | Action research | Training aimed patient centred care. The first half day was to review the evidence for patient centred consulting and a further full day was to practice skills with a facilitator, including active listening and negotiation of behavioural change. | Lectures, group discussions | 1.5 days | Yes |
Brug 2007 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing (MI). The first day was to introduce MI theory and principles and the second day was to practice MI skills. Another one-day follow-up workshop for discussing experiences with experts and refresh knowledge. Training was developed and conducted by authors. | Workshop | 3 days | No |
Rubak 2009] | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. A book was used to guide specific skills e.g., empowerment, ambivalence, the decisional balance schedule, the visual analogue scale, stage of change, and reflective listening. The courses consisted of a 1.5 day training sessions with a half-day follow-up twice. Training was conducted by only one trained teacher. | NA | 2.5 days | No |
Sequist 2010 | NA | Training aimed cultural competency. Training goals included understanding attitudes of trust and bias, increasing knowledge about health disparities and skills. The curriculum reviewed potential racial and cultural biases in health care, appropriate methods of collecting clinically relevant cultural data, and ways to incorporate such information into effective clinical care plans for diabetes. | Lectures, group discussions, community engagement activities | 2 days | No |
Heinrich 2010 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. Trainees received a project folder with information about the study, training material (e.g., cases for role-playing), background information about MI. Trainees received instruction charts specifying counselling techniques. Trainees were visited three times after being trained. | Role play, discussions, audio-taped consultations feedback | 21.5 h | No |
Rubak 2011 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing. Training was conducted by a trained teacher. Training included specific skills, e.g., empowerment, ambivalence, the decisional balance schedule, the visual analogue scale, stage of change, and reflective listening. | NA | 2.5 days | No |
Robling 2012 | Medical Research Council (MRC) framework | Training aimed constructive consultations (Talking Diabetes). Training emphasized shared setting of agendas and a guiding communication style, strategies and skills drawn from motivational interviewing practice. | Role play, web-based modules, workshop, case studies | 2 days | Yes |
Farmer 2012 | Theory of Planned Behaviour | Training aimed theory of planned behaviour. These included perceived benefits and harms of taking medicines. Positive beliefs were reinforced verbally and non-verbally through provision of tailored information and problem solving was facilitated around negative beliefs. | Audio-taped consultations feedback | 1 day | Yes |
Welschen 2012 | Leventhal’s self-regulation theory, theory of planned behavior | Training aimed cardiovascular disease risk communication. This included communication of the absolute risk, visual communication, message framing, communication with the patient for a reaction. | NA | 1 day | No |
Jansink 2013 | NA | Training aimed motivational interviewing and agenda setting. This included building motivation for change, asking open questions, listening reflectively, affirming, summarizing, eliciting change, expressing empathy, developing discretion, rolling with resistance, and supporting self-efficacy. Training was spread equally over 6 months. | Video recording feedback | 2 days | Yes |
Tinsel 2013] | NA | Training aimed shared decision making (SDM) and motivational interviewing. This included risk communication, the process steps of SDM, introduction of a decision table with options. | Role play | NA | Yes |
Juul 2014 | Self-determination theory | Training aimed self-determination theory. This included patient-health care provider relationships, communication skills, patient worksheets, implementation of the course content in daily practice. | NA | 2 days | Yes |
Ma 2014 | Social cognitive theory | Training aimed motivational interviewing and social cognitive theory. Training was presented by a certified trainer. Training included building rapport with the patients, evaluating the patients’ confidence and motivation for behaviour changes, helping change patients behaviours and so on. | Lectures, role play, discussions | 3 days | Yes |
Manze 2015 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling and cultural competency training. Training was led by experts in medicine and patient-centered counseling. Training includes implementing 5 A's: ask the patient about their BP management, assess their medication adherence, advise the patient about pharmacologic treatment, assist them in overcoming barriers to treatment adherence and arrange for follow-up. The cultural competency training included understanding patients, their social and financial risks for non-adherence, their fears and concerns. | Role play, workshop | 2 sessions | No |
Kressin 2016 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling. Training was led by an experienced trainer. Training includes implementing 4 A's: ask about patients’ hypertension beliefs, assess patients’ prior experiences in changing behaviors, assist patients in making needed changes, address relapse. | Role play, discussions | 2 h | Yes |
Okada 2017 | NA | Training aimed modified motivational interviewing. Training was based on empowerment or coaching-style communication, including using an open question, setting each goal with patients, and closing with encouragement. | NA | 4 h | No |
Akturan 2017 | NA | Training aimed BATHE interview (Background, Affect, Troubling, Handling, and Empathy). Training was evaluated by researchers. Trainees were asked to use the BATHE technique on their patients 3 times, with 3-month intervals. | Role play | 3 h | No |
Belin 2017 | NA | Training aimed patient-centered counseling. Training was led by a doctor specialist. Trainees were used open-ended questions to identify the needs, barriers, patient beliefs, and ideas consistent with the patient centered counseling approach. Trainees identified that poor patient–provider communication and improved communication skills. Training was conducted using a training package and a self-assessment checklist. | Focus-group discussion, workshop | 5 sessions | No |
Ismail 2018 | NA | Training aimed six psychological skills. The six skills were drawn from MI and CBT, including: active listening; managing resistance; directing change; supporting self-efficacy; addressing health beliefs and shaping behaviours. | NA | NA | Yes |
Measurement of outcomes
-
The diabetes specific quality of life (1 trial)
-
The EuroQol (1 trial)
-
Audit of diabetes dependent quality of life (1 trial)
-
The EQ-5D (1 trial)
-
The SF-12 (1 trial)
-
Determinants of Lifestyle Behavior Questionnaire (1 trial)
-
The Problem Areas in Diabetes (PAID) scale (1 trial)
-
The Diabetes Empowerment Process Scale (1 trial)
-
The chronic disease self-efficacy scales (1 trial)
-
The Management Self Efficacy Scale for people with DM2 (1 trial)
-
The Summary of Diabetes Self Care Activities (2 trials)
-
The Diabetes Illness Representation Questionnaire (1 trial)
-
The Brief Illness Perception Questionnaire (1 trial)
-
The Perceived Competence for Diabetes Scale (1 trial)
-
The Treatment Self-Regulation Questionnaire (2 trials)
-
The Clinician & Group Survey – Adult Primary Care Questionnaire (1 trial)
-
The Medication Adherence Report Scale (2 trials)
-
The Hill-Bone Compliance to High Blood Pressure Therapy Scale (1 trial)
-
The Health Care Climates Questionnaire (3 trials)
-
The Patients’ perceived participation (1 trial)
-
The Combined Outcome Measure for Risk communication and treatment Decision making Effectiveness scale (1 trial)
-
Diabetes Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire (1 trial)
-
The Health Literacy Assessment Questions (1 trial)
-
The Short Form Spielberger State Anxiety Inventory (1 trial)
-
The PHQ- 9 (1 trial)
-
The Diabetes Distress Scale (1 trial)
Assessment of risk of bias in include studies
Effectiveness of communication skills training for health professionals on clinical outcomes in patients with T2DM and hypertension
Outcomes | Studies | Number of patients | I2 (%) | Pooled effects (95% CI) |
---|---|---|---|---|
HbA1c (%) | 6 | 4501 | 0 | -0.02(-0.01 to 0.05) |
Systolic blood pressure (mm Hg) | 8 | 2505 | 97 | -2.61(-9.19 to 3.97) |
Diastolic blood pressure (mm Hg) | 8 | 2440 | 93 | -0.60(-3.65 to 2.45) |
body mass index (kg/m2) | 3 | 552 | 1 | -0.12(-0.79 to 0.55) |
Triglyceride (mmol/L) | 2 | 625 | 0 | 0.04(-0.09 to 0.18) |
Total cholesterol (mmol/L) | 5 | 4217 | 11 | 0.10(0.04 to 0.17) |
LDL cholesterol (mmol/L) | 3 | 908 | 57 | 0.06(-0.14 to 0.26) |
HDL cholesterol (mmol/L) | 2 | 622 | 0 | 0.05(-0.00 to 0.10) |