The relationship between vitamin D receptor gene polymorphism and deciduous tooth decay in Chinese children

Dental caries is one of the most common diseases and its prevalence is more than 50% in many countries [1]. Untreated dental caries can cause further serious problems, such as caries related pulpitis, abscesses, pain, tooth loss and other co-morbidities, which affects growth and well-being in preschool children [2, 3]. As we known, dental caries is a multi-factorial disease, which is caused by environmental factors, behavioral factors and gene-by-environment interactions [4]. Although the importance of genetic factors have been recognized, until now only a few caries susceptibility genes have been identified and verified [5‐7].

As a biological macromolecule in nucleus, the VDR gene has the effect of modulating the biological function of the major metabolites of vitamin D, which plays an important role in the formation of teeth, particularly in the calcification of enamel and dentin [8, 9]. Vitamin D is pivotal to maintaining a stable relationship between phosphate and calcium ions, which are known as vital factors in protecting and strengthening the teeth. A randomized trial have found that lack of vitamin D during pregnancy is associated with enamel dysplasia in children [10]. Further cohort study found that enamel dysplasia was associated with risk of dental caries [11, 12]. Vitamin D is not only involved in the regulation of calcium and phosphate levels, but also an important part of the immune system [13]. Vitamin D deficiency leads to uncontrolled changes in the immune system, which then blocks the correct immune response to oral microbial infections that occur during periodontitis or untreated caries [14]. Meta-analysis found that supplemental vitamin D was associated with 47% reduced risk of dental caries [9]. The biological function of Vitamin D is modulated by VDR protein, through interaction with the VDR protein [15]. As reported, the activity of VDR protein is affected by VDR gene polymorphisms [16]. We speculated that VDR polymorphisms might be a genetic factor for deciduous tooth decay. Thus, we performed a case-control study to clarify whether there was association between four VDR gene polymorphisms BsmI, TaqI, ApaI and FokI with deciduous tooth decay in Chinese children.

A total of 380 children recruited in this study, 131 (34.47%) were caries-free. The mean age was 5.85 years in caries-free subjects and 5.72 years in caries experience subjects (dmft: 6.6 ± 4.4). A significant difference for factors like age and S. mutans between caries experience and caries-free were observed in the present study. The demographic and clinical details of the subjects were presented in Table 1.

The genotypes and allele frequency distribution of four polymorphic sites in genes selected amongst caries-free subjects and subjects with caries experience were presented in Table 2. All SNPs were in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in unaffected individuals. The variant genotypes and allele frequency of BsmI were different between caries experience and caries-free groups (p = 0.005 and p = 0.027 respectively). However, no difference was found in genotypes and allele frequency of the polymorphism TaqI, ApaI, FokI between caries-affected and caries-free individuals (Table 2).

A binary logistic regression adjusted for genotypes, age and S. mutans factor was present in Table 3. In BsmI, the genotype Bb showed significant association with deciduous tooth decay (p = 0.007), demonstrating a increased risk for caries (OR = 1.856, 95% CI = [1.184, 2.908]). However, VDR polymorphisms ApaI, TaqI and FokI were not associated with deciduous tooth decay (ApaI: OR = 0.839, 95% CI = [0.614, 1.145], p = 0.268; TaqI: OR = 1.150, 95% CI = [0.495, 2.672], p = 0.744; FokI: OR = 0.856, 95% CI = [0.616, 1.191], p = 0.356).

Dental caries is caused by a complex interaction between genetics and the environment [22]. Reports of families and animal breeding, together with genomics, have indicated that genetic component was associated with dental caries [23‐25], and more than 40% of caries risk was attributed to genetic factors [26]. Published studies found that the caries risk may be determined by patients’ DNA, in addition to environmental factors related to the risk of dental caries, such as oral hygiene, diet, bacteria and host factors [4, 27, 28].

Mutations in genes involved in enamel formation, such as enamelin (ENAM), amelogenin (AMELX), matrix metalloproteinase-20 (MMP-20) and kallikrein-related peptidase (KLK4), were associated with amelogenesis imperfecta [29]. Moreover, studies have found the link between dental caries and amelogenesis imperfecta. Some studies have clarified the genetic variation in AMELX linked with enamel formation contributed to caries susceptibility [30, 31]. Also, genetic variation in MMP-13 and MMP-20 was involved in increased caries risk during the enamel development [28, 32]. The VDR gene, identified as a candidate gene related to dental caries, mediated the biological function of the major metabolite of vitamin D, which was associated with enamel formation [8, 9]. Mutations in VDR gene influenced the activity of VDR protein, which then affected the biological function of Vitamin D [15, 16]. Vitamin D regulates the metabolism of calcium and promotes calcium depositing onto the enamel. A meta-analysis indicated that supplemental vitamin D was linked with more than 40% reduced risk of dental caries [9]. Purvis et al. [10] found that there was relationship between vitamin D deficiency and enamel hypoplasias, which was in turn associated with increased caries risk [11, 12].

In this study, we performed a case-control study to clarify the association of four VDR gene polymorphisms BsmI, TaqI, ApaI and FokI with deciduous tooth decay in Chinese children. The results showed VDR polymorphisms BsmI containing the Bb genotype was associated with increased risk of deciduous tooth decay (OR = 1.856, 95% CI = [1.184, 2.908], p = 0.007). In VDR gene, the SNP BsmI was situated at the 3’UTR corresponding genomic DNA region [33]. However, the molecular mechanisms of deciduous tooth decay regulated by the VDR gene were not certain. We speculated that the SNP BsmI mutation (Bb) at 3’UTR region would affect the mRNA stability, consequently would affect the amount and activity of protein translated. Valdivielso et al. [16] found that the activity of VDR protein was influenced by mutations in the VDR gene. VDR protein mediated the biological function of Vitamin D, via interaction with the Vitamin D, which was associated with dental caries [9, 10, 15].

In contrast, we found VDR polymorphisms ApaI, TaqI and FokI were not associated with deciduous tooth decay. These results were inconsistent with previous study performed by Hu et al. [34], which determined significant association between VDR polymorphism TaqI and permanent tooth decay susceptibility in Chinese adults. According to studies conducted by Bayram M et al. [35] and Borilova Linhartova et al. [36], influences of genetic factors on enamel caries differ between the primary and permanent teeth. Thus, the inconsistency between our results and other reported study may be caused by difference between the primary and permanent dentitions. Cogulu et al. [37] found TaqI genotypes in VDR gene might be used as a marker for determining dental caries susceptibility in Turkish children, however our study and other study conducted by Izakovicova Holla et al. [38] found no association of TaqI VDR polymorphism with caries, this difference may reflect the geographic and ethnic variations. The frequencies of VDR SNPs in our study (performed in Guangzhou, southern China) were different with the frequencies found within other study by Li et al. (performed in Nanjing, eastern China) [21], for example in BsmI the frequency in our study highly differed with Li’s study, we speculated it was caused by geographic variations (Guangzhou versus Nanjing).

The limitation of this study was that we only investigated the relationship between VDR polymorphisms and caries risk of children in Guangzhou, China; however, dental caries was caused by multiple genetic factors and environment. The mechanism of the possible effect of VDR on susceptibility to dental caries remained unclear, further research in people with different ethnic backgrounds should be performed to reveal the mechanism of VDR gene in caries incidence, and clarify its interactions with other susceptibility genes and environmental factors.