Background
Methods
Literature search
Study selection
Critical appraisal of individual studies
Data collection and classification
Preventability
Root cause
Results
Study design and characteristics
Auteur | Publication year | Country | Study design | Setting | Disease group/department of index admission | Duration | Additional data source | Questions/topics available | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Agrawal | 2015 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Decompensated cirrhosis | 30 days | NA | NA |
2 | Auerbach | 2016 | USA | cross-sectional | multicenter | General medicine | 30 days | Interviews with patients; surveys of patients’ physicians | Topics |
3 | Balla | 2008 | Israel | cross-sectional | monocenter | Medicine | 30 days | Interviews with patients | Topics |
4 | Bianco | 2012 | Italy | cross-sectional | monocenter | Medical or surgical illness | 30 days | Interviews with patients | NR |
5 | Burke | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Internal medicine | 7 days and 30 days | Interviews with patients (pilot) | NR |
6 | Cakir | 2010 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Not specified | 30 days | NA | NA |
7 | Cooksley | 2015 | England | retrospective | monocenter | Oncology | 30 days | NA | NA |
8 | Clarke | 1990 | England | retrospective | multicenter | General medicine/surgery, geriatrics | < 28 days/0–6 days and 21–27 days | NA | NA |
9 | Dawes | 2014 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | General surgery | 30 days | NA | |
10 | Feigenbaum | 2012 | USA | cross-sectional | multicenter | Not specified | 30 days | Interview with patients, providers and family | Questions and topics |
11 | Frankl | 1991 | USA | prospective | monocenter | Internal medicine | 30 days | NA | NA |
12 | Glass | 2013 | USA | retrospective | multicenter | Patients undergoing pancreatectomy | 30 days | NA | NA |
13 | Greenberg | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Patient with a aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage | 30 day | NA | |
14 | Haines-Wood | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | All departments | 15 days | NA | NA |
15 | Halfon | 2002 | Switserland | prospective | monocenter | All departments | 30 days and 365 days | NA | NA |
16 | Harhay | 2013 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Kidney transplantation | 30 days | NA | NA |
17 | Jiminez-Puente | 2004 | Spain | cross-sectional | monocenter | All departments | 6 months | NA | NA |
18 | Jonas | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Paediatrics | 15 days | NA | NA |
19 | Kelly | 2015 | UK | retrospective | monocenter | Learning disability | 30 days | NA | NA |
20 | Maurer | 2004 | Switserland | prospective | monocenter | Internal medicine | 90 days | NA | NA |
21 | Meisenberg | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Oncology | 30 days | NA | NA |
22 | Miles | 1999 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | All departments | 28 days | NA | NA |
23 | Mittal | 2016 | USA | retrospective | multicenter | Acute ischemic stroke | 30 days | NA | NA |
24 | Nahab | 2012 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Stroke and cerebrovascular disease | 30 days | NA | NA |
25 | Nijhawan | 2015 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | HIV patients | 30 days | NA | NA |
26 | Oddone | 1996 | USA | prospective | multicenter | General medicine | 6 months | NA | NA |
27 | Pace | 2014 | Canada | prospective | multicenter | Medical wards | 30 days | NA | NA |
28 | Phelan | 2009 | Ireland | retrospective | monocenter | Heart failure | 365 days | NA | NA |
29 | Ryan | 2014 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Heart failure | 30 days | NA | NA |
30 | Saunders | 2015 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Oncology | 30 days | NA | NA |
31 | Shah | 2013 | UK | retrospective | monocenter | Neurosurgery | 30 days | NA | NA |
32 | Shalchi | 2009 | UK | retrospective | monocenter | Acute medical assessment unit | 14 days | NA | NA |
33 | Shimizu | 2014 | USA | cross-sectional | monocenter | Internal medicine | 30 days | Interviews with patients | Topics |
34 | Stein | 2016 | USA | cross-sectional | monocenter | Internal medicine | 30 days | Interviews with patients | Questions and topics |
35 | Sutherland | 2016 | UK | retrospective | monocenter | Colorectal Surgery | 30 day | Interviews with patient/ caretaker and attending surgeon | Topics |
36 | Tejedor-Sojo | 2015 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Paediatrics | 30 days | NA | NA |
37 | Toomey | 2016 | USA | cross-sectional | monocenter | Paediatrics | 30 day | Interviews with parents/guardians, patients, inpatient clinicians and primary care providers | NR |
38 | Vachon | 2012 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Trauma patients | 30 days | ||
39 | Van Walraven | 2011 | Canada | prospective | multicenter | Medicine and surgery | 6 months | Interview with patients | Topics |
40 | Vinson | 1990 | USA | prospective | monocenter | Congestive heart failure | 90 days | Interview with patient or family | NR |
41 | Wallace | 2015 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Paediatrics | 30 days | NA | NA |
42 | Wasfy | 2014 | USA | retrospective | multicenter | Patients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention | 30 days | NA | NA |
43 | Weinberg | 2016 | USA | retrospective | monocenter | Total hip arthroplasty | 30 or 90 days | NA | NA |
44 | Williams | 1988 | UK | cross-sectional | monocenter | Geriatrics/all departments | 28 days | Interviews with patient/carer/hospital ward sister and GP | NR |
45 | Yam | 2010 | China | retrospective | multicenter | Medicine | 30 days | NA | NA |
Cause classification
Cause | Example - preventable | Example - unpreventable |
---|---|---|
Complication | ||
Adherence | Reasons probably within control of hospital services (may include compliance [59]; patient compliance [51]; non-compliance with prescribed medication [82]; improved medication compliance [14]; medication non-compliance [77]; caretaker related - Noncompliance with discharge medications [86]; Noncompliance that could have been prevented by care givers [78]; patient compliance problems [67]; fluid related - nomcompliance diet and medication and hepatic encephalopathy - noncompliance to medication [54] | Reasons probably beyond control of hospital services (may include compliance [61] |
Disease progression |
Root cause | Definition | Includes | References |
---|---|---|---|
Technical | Defect materials, poor design of material or inaccessible material. | ||
Organization – integrated care | Failures at integrated care level such as coordination and communication problems. | Coordination; Admissions for tests, procedures, or treatments that could have been performed in the previous admission; quality management (assurance and control); Responsibilities; Better use of community services, inappropriate discharge setting or appropriate discharge setting not available, care could have been provided in; primary care setting; Problems with healthcare transitions; social readmission; Suboptimal primary care case management, lack of home health/home physical therapy visit, earlier PCP follow-up necessary | |
Organization - department level care | Failures related to inadequate organization of care for a single patient. These failures may be related to clinical processes such as diagnostics, medication, surgical procedure, surgical complications. | Surgical and non-surgical, disease-specific complications, general complications (nosocomial infection, wound complication, dehydratation, bleeding). Suboptimal drug treatment, error in drug prescription, overdosing, suboptimal medication reconciliation. Proper diagnostics not performed or not timely performed. Inadequate pain control, closer management/monitoring of comorbid disease, delay in palliative care consultation. Lack of discharge planning, early discharge. Patient education. Timely outpatient clinic visit scheduled | |
Human - care provider | Failures resulting from shortcomings in skills and knowledge of the care provider. | Decision to admit patient, disregarding diagnostic results or concerns from collegeaues, wishful thinking, lack of experience to make a proper decision. Inadequate (clinical) skills and knowledge; or lack of experience. Patient not sufficiently monitored by care provider. Neglegence, fault | |
Human - informal caregiver | Inadequate support from informal caregiver. | Inadequate social support, wishful thinking | |
Patient - selfmanagement | Incorrect behavior of the patient that may include incompliance, abuse of medication, non-adherence.) | Not showing up for follow-up care, non-compliance with medication or diet; substance abuse; patient coping, wishful thinking, lack of knowledge, patient preference (leaving against medical advice) | |
Patient - disease | Unexpected complications related to the patient’s condition (disease progression, comorbidity, severity of illness). | Unavoidable complication; unavoidable disease progression; chronic or relapsing disorder. | |
Unclassifiable | Causes which cannot be allocated to one of the other themes because the cause has an ambiguous meaning |