Background
Method
Results
Predominant clinical practices
Inpatient N (%) | Outpatient N (%) | |
---|---|---|
Screening | ||
1. Routine |
10 (50%)
|
8 (40%)
|
a Routine screening with objective tests for all people with tetraplegia | 8 (40%) | 0 (0%) |
b Routine screening with objective tests for high risk people with tetraplegia | 2 (10%) | 0 (0%) |
c Routine screening for subjective signs and symptoms | 0 (0%) | 8 (40%) |
2. Partial Responds when alerted to signs and symptoms |
10 (50%)
|
12 (60%)
|
3. None |
0 (0%)
|
0 (0%)
|
Diagnosis | ||
1. Spinal |
10 (50%)
|
4 (20%)
|
a Diagnostic tests ordered and interpreted by spinal doctor | 5 (25%) | 3 (15%) |
b Diagnostic tests ordered and interpreted by spinal doctor with some support from sleep specialist | 2 (10%) | 0 (0%) |
c Internal referral to spinal unit colleague/s for diagnosis | 3 (15%) | 1 (5%) |
2. External |
9 (45%)
|
16 (80%)
|
a Referral to sleep specialist | 9 (45%) | 13 (65%) |
b Referral to primary care | 3 (15%) | |
3. None |
1 (5%)
|
0 (0%)
|
Treatment | ||
1. Spinal |
8 (40%)
|
3 (15%)
|
a Prescribed and overseen by spinal doctor | 4 (20%) | 3 (15%) |
b Prescribed and overseen by spinal doctor with some support from sleep specialist | 1 (5%) | 0 (0%) |
c Managed internally by spinal unit colleague/s | 3 (15%) | 0 (0%) |
2. External |
11 (55%)
|
17 (85%)
|
a Managed by sleep specialist | 11 (55%) | 16 (80%) |
b Managed by primary care | 1 (5%) | |
3. None |
1 (5%)
|
0 (0%)
|
Factors influencing practice
Factors influencing screening practices
Domain | Belief statements | Representative quotes | Frequency of belief out of 20 |
---|---|---|---|
Knowledge | I don’t know of any clinical practice guidelines recommending management of OSA in tetraplegia. | “No I don’t know or aware of any existing clinical guidelines.” | 10 |
Regarding clinical practice guidelines: “I assume they [clinical practice guidelines] exist. But I wouldn’t go hunting for them because I don’t disagree with the concept that they should be screened.” | |||
I know that the prevalence of OSA is very high in tetraplegia and that OSA causes negative outcomes. | “So the paper that I usually refer to…where they followed acute spinal cord injuries, so it was within the first year, and they test for sleep apnoea and it was up to like 80%. And then most other papers say, you know, up to 60% of spinal cord injury will have sleep apnoea.” | 14 | |
“Yes. I’m aware it is high. It is definitely high in the first 2-3 months, but I can see a lot of the studies from one year post injury, that’s quite variable, it’s varies from 40-70%.” | |||
Social/Professional Role and Identity | As the doctor managing the patients’ rehabilitation and spinal cord injury needs, screening for OSA is my clinical responsibility. | “I think it should be the physician’s role. I think that’s the most appropriate person because if the symptoms come back positive, it does have to be a medical referral onto the respiratory clinic.” | 17 |
“I think it is our responsibility as their spinal cord injury doctor to understand sleep apnoea and understand respiratory; it falls under the umbrella of respiratory management, right. Especially somebody with a cervical injury, like you have to know what MIPS and MEPS are, vital capacities are, what their PFTs are. And sleep apnoea is just another component of that.” | |||
Beliefs about Capabilities | I am confident/not confident that I am identifying OSA in most of my patients. | “I think we get everything, we get all patients we need, well we catch all the patients who are in need of ventilation, yes.” | 8 |
“I’d say I’m pretty confident, yeah I don’t miss it in many patients.” | |||
“I wouldn’t be very confident [to identify OSA symptoms]. The symptoms, there are so many other contributors to the symptoms that are described, I wouldn’t be very confident.” | 8 | ||
“In the acute phase, I think I’m probably missing a good proportion. Just ballparking, maybe 30%, 30 to 40%, I might be missing. In the community phase, of those that I follow regularly, probably missing less, but I’m sure I'm still missing some. Maybe 10%, 10–20%.” | |||
Beliefs about Consequences | Routine screening may identify non-symptomatic OSA that does not need to be treated. | “Okay, but even if you screen symptoms, and they have some symptoms, people can be affected by their symptoms in a different way. Did he have a problem? If he didn’t have a problem, why suddenly I found a problem with him and I start him to sleep with a machine on. The problem is blanket screening and blanket investigation we’ll end up having more people on a treatment that otherwise may not need to be. That is my worry.” | 3 |
“From my point of view, in the clinic, I’d probably be most interested in following up patients who had symptoms that were relevant to them. I guess a disincentive for me is to be actively pursuing investigation results of patients who don’t seem to have symptoms of that. Because what’s the point? I mean, like, with any test or referral, there’s a saying in medicine, don’t do it if it’s not going to change the treatment. Yeah, well it would be a waste of resources, but also it’s inconvenient for the patient.” | |||
Routine screening helps prevent patients who are poor at recognizing their symptoms from being missed. | “Yeah because patients do not complain about that, that you have to measure it before you know that they have it, so sometimes they have the complaints of tiredness and that kind of stuff and then you have a trigger but if they don’t have that complaint then the screening might disappear.” | 3 | |
I am/I am not sure that the benefits of routine screening would outweigh the costs. | “No question about it, yes. Because most patients, when they’re eventually getting ventilation during the night, they feel a lot better and they can have more… what do you call it, they can do much better during the day, so I think most patients will benefit from it (screening).” | 13 | |
“Have to do it. Yeah, of course. The only long run if you ignore something which is there and you don’t treat it, you don’t manage it, of course at the end of the day that will cost you even more. And also you have to respect the patient’s wellbeing and their needs.” | |||
“I wouldn’t be convinced. I’m not convinced of that at the moment, no. Should I just screen them all? I don’t know if that would be cost-effective, I don’t think so.” | 5 | ||
“I think it’s probably only worthwhile when the patient initiates the concern about fatigue and sleepiness because, otherwise, my experience is that if they’re really not troubled by symptoms in the day, they do not tolerate CPAP.” | |||
Memory, Attention and Decision Processes | A checklist/form is helpful/would be helpful to prompt me to screen for OSA in the inpatient unit and outpatient clinic. | “With our clinics we do have a template, we always get prompted to ask these questions about sleep, excessive snoring, does your partner notice you are not breathing for a while, and then we check the risk factors. So as long as the template is there we usually – I usually, you get prompted to ask it and I would.” | 14 |
“Inpatients definitely, so we have some standing orders ... And on there it was just immediate, everyone gets overnight oximetry and pulmonary function tests, and then in outpatient I do have like a template I use when I see patients, so there’s a respiratory heading which usually prompts me to ask about that.” | |||
“And I often think, “Oh, gosh, I should remember to ask the patients about their breathing but I never seem to. So, I think that if there was a box, like, are you having sleep-disordered breathing symptoms, I mean, most doctors have an idea what those symptoms are, you could just quickly ask the patient four or five questions.” | |||
“I think it will be nice if we can come up with a routine screen that we will screen everybody on admission, like an admission ASIA, something like that, we could do an admission and a discharge. If it’s a very short questionnaire that we can do. I think it would be worthwhile.” | |||
Environmental Context and Resources | I don't have enough time in outpatients to screen for OSA symptoms. | “I think it’s, for us like, probably the time that I am allotted with patients, so there’s a lot of things to cover. | 6 |
“In our current setup we don’t have time. We still allocate an hour for the patient, there are so many things to discuss, especially if they come once a year. And we don’t have any allied health clinic.” | |||
Patients often have more important medical issues to discuss in their outpatient appointment than OSA. | “So they're having a very hard time with bladder, with bowel, with pain, spasticity, and then unfortunately the respiratory system does fall on the wayside a little bit. And if you – if they are really worried about their bladder, and you finish talking about their bladder, and they're thinking about their bladder, and start talking about sleep apnoea, they tend not to take it – it's hard to then take on so much information.” | 6 | |
“Usually I’ll have the patient kind of lead the discussion as to what their most important thing they want to talk about that day is and I’ll kind of ask them prompting questions just to see a more general review of systems, but in that appointment, like, yeah I think that might be why things are getting missed because they may just want to talk about pain that day or they may just want to talk about their bladder or their pressure ulcer; we don’t get around to discussing sleep apnoea as well as we should.” |
Factors influencing diagnosis and treatment practices
Domain | Belief statement | Representative quotes | Frequency of belief out of 20 |
---|---|---|---|
Skills | I don't have the necessary skills to interpret diagnostic tests and prescribe treatments for OSA. | “I don’t order oximetry or spirometry or something myself because I’m not sure how to interpret it.” | 11 |
“Lack of confidence and lack of training. Especially about the machines and about what pressures, and so on, to start with. I know that we would titrate it depending on the oximetry or the sleep study, but I would not know exactly how to start.” | |||
Social/Professional Role and Identity | The diagnosis and treatment of OSA is outside my scope of practice. It should be managed by a sleep/respiratory specialist. | “If I was looking up the literature that wouldn’t be something I’d look up because it would never be appropriate for me to be the one prescribing the treatment for sleep-disordered breathing.” | 6 |
“I don’t have the appropriate speciality qualification to interpret the results and prescribe the treatment. So, it would be sort of a, I’m trying to think of the word, it would be breaching my scope of practice. It would be implying to the patient that I know what I’m talking about when I don’t.” | |||
“The way our system works is once I get pulmonologists involved it’s sort of like their thing.” | |||
“I don’t consider myself a sleep specialist so if they’ve got symptoms that are consistent with that and there’s concerns on the oxygen saturation, that’s when I take them to the respirologist to see.” | |||
Beliefs about Capabilities | I am not confident to diagnose and treat OSA without sleep/respiratory specialist involvement. | “But I think I like having the respirologist there to discuss sort of a game plan of what pressures to start them at, even though it’s auto CPAP or, you know.” | 12 |
[Regarding diagnosing OSA] “I’ve not been trained in it. You know, I can read a graph but just because I can read labels I am not confidently able to say, “Yes, you have sleep apnoea.”” | |||
“Personally, I don’t feel confident in prescribing.” | |||
Beliefs about Consequences | CPAP is beneficial to my patients with tetraplegia and OSA. | “So once patients are diagnosed and treated successfully, the change in terms of cognitive improvement, we have patients who would sleep through their therapy sessions, their family meetings, because they were so tired. We have patients who are on numerous sleep inducers just to get them to sleep. So once we see that patients can come off of these medications, they’re fully participating and learning about their spinal cord injury, that’s huge, right, because that will decrease the length of stay in rehab, and all of the other complications associated with them.” | 9 |
“And then I’d say the more impressive thing that has happened, not uncommonly in patients who use it on our unit, is all of a sudden they do way better in tolerating therapies the next day, even day-to-day, like, “We’re going to try this tonight,” and the next day the therapists are like, “What did you do differently with Mr Smith? He’s like a different guy today.” It’s like, “Well, I think he has sleep apnoea and used CPAP last night. I guess his sleep apnoea was really affecting him.” And we have lots of the patients like that, I would say.” | |||
Adherence to CPAP is poor/good in our unit. | “Of the patients who can’t take the mask off themselves, I'd say 80% of them don’t tolerate it. It’s bad but what are you going to do. I totally understand.” | 7 | |
“I think the biggest challenge for us right now is to get people to adhere to the CPAP machine.” | |||
“But patients just find it [CPAP] really difficult to tolerate, so most patients go untreated.” | 4 | ||
“No I would say normally we have a high compliance in tetraplegics… I would say 80% is compliant. We have of course some person who are not compliant and we check their compliance with the usual things.” | |||
Environmental Context and Resources | We have poor/good access to overnight sleep studies and sleep specialists. | “It’s hard to get an in-patient sleep study now…But, yeah, that’s been a bit of an inhibitory factor, you know, to ask about patients early on and then say, “Well, you can have a sleep study in 14 months when you’re out of hospital.”” | 6 |
“It’s a logistical problem if they need a lot of care or ceiling lifts or anything like that, or an attendant. Because you know what sleep labs look like. They’re not designed for people in wheelchairs.” | |||
“Having a sleep study is very difficult, for our inpatients, because [nearby acute hospital] has a sleep service but that is not manned, there is no nursing support.” | 4 | ||
“In a few weeks patients can go there and get the measurements, yep. And when we do it in our ward then it’s also very quickly, so the waiting list is no problem, no.” | |||
I can’t diagnose OSA and/or prescribe treatment because the patient’s CPAP machine won’t be funded. | “But most commercial payers in [XX country] require that a polysomnography is done, documented before they’ll pay for it. So we’re kind of hamstrung a little bit in that way.” | 7 | |
“I prescribe it, they won’t get funded. So there is a minority who can get funding or self-fund, but you still need to involve a respiratory professional in the set-up and reading and the compliance. | |||
Our spinal unit has trained nurses and allied health to help manage OSA / We would need trained nurses and allied health to help manage OSA. | “Yeah we’ve got nurses involved in this part of our clinic. The nurses would go to the patients with our CPAPs and then advise them around the mask they would use and instruct them and all that.” | 9 | |
“So, we use a couple of our physios that kind of are the respiratory leads but, actually, any of our physios have the competence to set up BiPAP, CPAP, etcetera.” | |||
“We also need the nurses of course, they have to be knowledgeable about this, we have to train the team, the doctors, everybody else, so maybe in the future we will, yes.” | 4 | ||
“I need to have other special respiratory nurse who needs to train and they need to educate.” | |||
I practice in the same way as my colleagues from the same spinal unit. | “We do the same thing. Whoever it is, they’ll be doing the same thing in our unit.” | 16 | |
“I think we have a clear policy of all the screening and referring and intervention for sleep apnoea is probably standard practice.” | |||
Social influences | Our OSA management program is the result of a “clinical champion” | “It started with my colleague…maybe even 10 years ago or a bit longer he saw [another hospital’s] sleep laboratory and you know the screening on sleep apnoea they do in their spinal cord centre … my colleague got inspired and started to set up a similar department here which existed of nurses and himself and later I would take part in that as well and over the years kind of grew in our expertise I guess.” | 6 |
Participant: “You sort of need a champion.” Interviewer: “Right, so you’ve basically, you’re the one who set up this program for your unit?” Participant: “Yep, pretty much, yeah, yeah.” | |||
“My colleague and I started 20 years ago and realised that our tetraplegic patients were falling asleep during therapies... And then, and then we started assessing our patients, realised this is a problem. And then since this experience done 20 years ago now and then it became the standard. It was just translation from research to daily routine and now it’s well implemented.” |