Background
Angioleiomyomas (ALMs) are benign soft tissue tumors commonly occurring in middle-aged women as nodules in the subcutaneous tissue of the lower extremities[
1], which is composed of mature smooth muscle cells and a prominent vascular component. But as intracranial lesions are extremely rare, only 12 cases were recorded in the literature to date, to the best of our knowledge. Most of the intracranial cases were in dura or at least in ex-neuro axis sites, such as the cavernous sinus dura[
2,
3], except 2 cases which were in other parenchymal locations such as the basal ganglia[
4,
5]. The lack of experience makes the preoperative diagnosis very difficult. Due to its benign nature, surgical excision is curative.
Our center admitted about 4403 cases of primary intracranial tumor in the last 5 years, only 3 of which (less than 0.1%) were identified as ALM. Case 1 is the second report of intra-sella ALM (the first was reported in 2010)[
6], case 2 is a large subtentorial tumor, and case 3 is the first report of ALM in the skull vault. The magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) features were unusual and have potential to be helpful in distinguishing ALMs from pituitary tumors, meningiomas, and other tumors. A histopathology study revealed this characteristic figure. Although ALMs are very rarely encountered, it should be considered earlier in the diagnostic process, and be properly treated with caution.
Discussion
ALM is a benign, vascular, smooth muscle tumor, commonly developing in the subcutaneous tissues of the lower extremities; an intracranial location is extremely rare. The first case was reported in 1994 by Lach
et al.[
7]. Since then, 12 cases have been subsequently described, and our current data is the largest series ever since the first report. In all the available cases (see Table
1), the male/female ratio is 12/3, not like the subcutaneous counterpart which has a female bias[
1,
8]. According to the 2002 World Health Organization classification of soft tissue tumors, ALM is recognized as an independent tumor entity. Its histological features are mainly composed of an abundant number of vascular channels separated by loosely organized smooth muscle bundles with a variable amount of collagen. SMA (smooth muscle actin) as a bio-marker of muscle cells, and CD34 for the endothelium of vessels, are essential for diagnosis. The histogenesis of these lesions is not clear.
Table 1
Literature review for the intracranial angioleiomyoma
| 47, M | Gait abnormality with a right-sided limp for 14 months. | In the leptomeninges of the right parietal lobe, No attachment to dura. 2 cm. | TR. | 4 yrs. NR. |
| 12, F | Headache, seizures, left hemi-dystonia, and apraxia of eyelid closure. | Right head of caudate, large and cystic. The 2nd lesion at left globus pallidus. | The right one: TR en bloc. | 20 mths. NR. Left lesion quiescent |
| 47, F | Progressive hearing loss for 18 months. | Left auditory meatus. 1 cm. | TR. | 1 year. NR. |
| 52, M | Horizontal diplopia and headache for 2 yrs. Facial numbness and impaired visual acuity for 6 mths. | Right cavernous sinus, 6.0 × 6.0 × 5.0 cm. Eroding the peripheral bone structure. | TR. Piecemeal resection, Severe bleeding | Not mentioned. |
Colnat-Coulbois et al.[ 2] | 50, M | Vertical diplopia for left trochlear nerve palsy. | Left cavernous sinus. About 3 cm. | TR, Venous bleeding | 6 yrs. NR. |
| 43, M | Headache, blurred vision, dizziness, gait abnormalities. | Left cerebellar lesion attached to dura. 4.4 × 3.9 × 3.9 cm. | TR. | NR. |
| 53, M | Headache for 3 months, visual deterioration. | Intra-sella, cystic, less than 1 cm. | TR. | NR. |
| 62, M | A sudden seizure. | In the middle cranial fossa, near cavernous sinus. 3.7 × 3.5 × 3.3 cm. | Not mentioned. | 7 mths. NR. |
| 42, M | 8-year history of poorly localized headaches. | Infratentorial and located near the incisura, 0.8-1.0 cm. | TR en bloc with minimal bleeding | 1 yr and 11 mths, NR. |
| 36, M | 8-year history of worsening daily headaches. | Falcine, posterior to the splenium, 2.5 cm. | Subtotal resection. | 2 yrs and 2 mths, NR. |
| 60, M | Headache, seizures, and irritability for 2 mths. | Right putamen (2 cm). Left hippocampus, bilateral optic nerves and thickened meninges. | No surgery. | Died of recurrent seizures and septicemia. |
| 40, M | Focal epilepsy for 2 years. | In the falx cerebri, about 2 cm. | TR en bloc. | Not mentioned. |
Current case 1 | 51, F | Visual deterioration for 2 months. | Intra-sella 3 cm. | TR with severe bleeding. | Died of delayed hemorrhage |
Current case 2 | 49, M | Weakness of lower limbs for 1 year. | Sub-tentorium, affixed to torcular. 4.2 × 4.6 × 5.7 cm. | Subtotal R. severe bleeding | 1 year, NR. |
Current case 3 | 77, M | Headache for 5 months. | Left temporal diploic space, 1.6 × 3.1 × 3.9 cm. | TR. | 1 year, NR. |
The reported cases developed often in the dura matter, typically near large venous vessels like venous sinus or skull diploic structure, Our intra-sella case 1 involved the medial side of cavernous sinus and case 2 showed a large lesion in posterior cranial fossa arising from straight sinus and torcular. Figueiredo
et al.[
3] and Colnat-Coulbois
et al.[
2] reported para-cavernous lesions. Gasco
et al.[
10] reported a large ALM originated from the transverse sinus. A few cases reported small nodules on the dura[
6,
11,
13], and a peculiar case in auditory meatus[
9]. Some ALMs occur on cranial bone, with the majority were in the facial bones such as the mandible and maxilla[
14]. Vijayasaradhi
et al.[
15] reported a lesion in the low frontal bone which eroded the outer table only, growing outward. In case 3, the inner table was eroded and the tumor invaded inward. Other than these ex-axis lesions, two exceptional cases should be mentioned which are primary multi-centric intra-parenchyma ALMs. Ravikumar
et al.[
5] reported a patient with two lesions, a large and cystic one in the right head of caudate and a solid one in the left globus pallidus. Shinde
et al.[
4] in 2012 described a primary multicenter ALM distributing in the right putamen (2 cm), left hippocampus, bilateral optic nerves, and thickened meninges. The clinical signs and symptoms are diverse, which depend on the anatomical location and the size of the lesion. Nonetheless, the common character of all these cases is that the tumor is benign, grows slowly, with no intracranial hemorrhage, no recurrence, or malignant transformation.
The imaging of ALM is confusing, the differential diagnosis of lesion with similar feature includes all extra-axis enhancing tumors such as meningiomas, pituitary tumor, angiopericytomas, cavernous hemangiomas, and schwannomas. By comparing the MRI scans of our presented cases, some common characters of ALM can be identified. The tumor shows a hyper-signal on T2-w and T2-FLAIR images and an iso-signal on T1-w images, with a flame-like partial enhancement after the injection of gadolinium. The ‘enhancement flame’ seemed to rise from the tumor base, while not reaching the far end of the tumor. Case 1 and case 2 are dramatically similar in this way. This phenomenon can also be seen in the image provided by Colnat-Coulbois
et al.[
2]. Their explanation is a ‘delayed progressive enhancement’, which means the tumor will be fully enhanced when enough time is given. The exact reason of this imaging is not clear now, in our opinion it may be due to its distinguishable blood vessel structure, which does not exist in other tumors. All in all it should be considered as a distinctive diagnostic clue. This phenomenon has not been formally presented and emphasized enough in the available literature.
Histological differential diagnosis of ALMs included other intracranial entities such as glioblastoma multiform (GBM), arteriovenous malformation (AVM), cavernous hemangioma, angiofibroma (AFM), and myopericytoma (MPC). As an infiltrating high-grade glioma, GBM is often a necrotic and cystic lesion, with high metabolism and high proliferation ability. It is usually GFAP-positive, has no diffused vessel structure, and mitotic figures can be seen. In our ALM cases, after meticulous searching, no mitoses was found, the Ki67-/MIB-index was very low, and GFAP was always negative. AVMs are described as abnormalities consisting of tangled masses of tortuous arteries, veins, and abnormal connecting channels. In the cavernous hemangioma we can also see extremely distant blood vessels or a blood-filled sinus. In ALMs, CD34 is positive in the vessel endothelium, SMA is positive in the smooth muscle bundles, and (80 to 90% of cases) desmin is also frequently immuno-positive[
16]. Angiofibroma is most often found in the ‘juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma’ (JNA) with intracranial extension, which usually develops in teenage boys, mostly in the nasopharyngeal region. JNA has an abundant vessel component but no smooth muscle (CD34 positive, SMA negative). Primary intracranial myopericytoma (MPC) is even rarer than ALM. The histological features of the two tumors may present similarly as both have myoid-appearing cells and a diffused vessel structure. However, MPC have oval-to-spindle shaped cells with a striking tendency for concentric perivascular growth[
16], which can be distinguished immediately, and the neoplastic cells are usually negative for desmin antibodies.
Although ALM is benign and seemed to be easily curative by surgery in the literature, we have to say, for the abundance of vascular structure, surgery on ALM in certain locations is difficult and risky, especially when the tumor is rather large. In case 1, the operation was difficult and the delayed fatal complication was extremely rare. The reason of the formation of the pseudo-aneurysm was not clear, lessons should be drawn from the catastrophic outcome. The tumor might have eroded the wall of ICA, the risk of potential postoperative hemorrhage should be considered, and an earlier angiography could have avoided the fatal outcome. In case 2, as a large vascular mass in the posterior fossa, there was heavy blood loss in order to excise it piecewise. Figueiredo
et al.[
3] also reported severe blood loss in an excision of a 6 cm cavernous ALM. Now the preoperative polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) embolism has been commonly used in the patients with juvenile nasopharyngeal angiofibroma in many hospitals, the similar preoperative endovascular embolism may be a possible way to reduce the intraoperative bleeding of large lesions. When the intracranial ALMs are too dangerous to operate, radiotherapy becomes an alternative treatment option.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors’ contributions
LS reviewed the literature and drafted the manuscript. YZ and LS were clinically responsible for patient care. HW directed the operation and revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.