Background
Description of the condition
Description of the intervention
Methods
Study design and registration
Criteria for considering studies for this review
Types of studies
Eligibility of individual studies
-
Patient related criteria:
-
Age 18 years or older.
-
Long-term opioid therapy, reflecting prescribed opioid more than 70% of days for at least 3 months [28].
-
Presentation to acute healthcare setting secondary for a presumed or confirmed complication of prescribed opioid therapy.
-
-
Study-related criteria
-
Evaluating an intervention representing a harm reduction strategy.
-
Comparing the effectiveness of different interventions between each other or individual interventions compared to current care.
-
Addressing patient or healthcare system related outcomes (i.e. number of opioid prescriptions, repeat presentations to ED or acute healthcare, number of overdoses).
-
Search methods
Database: Ovid MEDLINE(R) Epub Ahead of Print, In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, Ovid MEDLINE(R) Daily and Ovid MEDLINE(R) 1946 to Present | |
---|---|
1 exp. Narcotics/ (111132) | |
2 actiq*.tw,kf. (27) | |
3 carfentan*.tw,kf. (243) | |
4 codeine*.tw,kf. (4872) | |
5 demerol*.tw,kf. (231) | |
6 (dihydro-morph* or dihydromorph*).tw,kf. (451) | |
7 dilaudid*.tw,kf. (69) | |
8 dur?gesic*.tw,kf. (84) | |
9 fentanyl*.tw,kf. (16667) | |
10 fentora*.tw,kf. (9) | |
11 heroin.tw,kf. (12893) | |
12 (hydro-codone* or hydrocodone*).tw,kf. (858) | |
13 (hydro-morphone* or hydromorphone*).tw,kf. (1359) | |
14 morphine*.tw,kf. (47330) | |
15 narcotic*.tw,kf. (14412) | |
16 lorcet*.tw,kf. (5) | |
17 lortab*.tw,kf. (6) | |
18 opiate*.tw,kf. (23769) | |
19 opioid*.tw,kf. (73603) | |
20 (oxy-codone* or oxycodone*).tw,kf. (2670) | |
21 (oxy-contin* or oxycontin*).tw,kf. (226) | |
22 percocet*.tw,kf. (58) | |
23 percodan*.tw,kf. (14) | |
24 pethidine*.tw,kf. (2304) | |
25 phentanyl*.tw,kf. (119) | |
26 sublimaze*.tw,kf. (22) | |
27 vicodin*.tw,kf. (56) | |
28 or/1–27 [Combined MeSH & text words for opioids] (186296) | |
29 Addiction Medicine/ (4) | |
30 Behavior, Addictive/ (7744) | |
31 exp. “Chemical and Drug Induced Liver Injury”/ (26678) | |
32 Drug abuse/ (87805) | |
33 exp. Drug Misuse/ (10703) | |
34 Drug Overdose/ (9457) | |
35 Neurotoxicity Syndromes/ (4428) | |
36 exp. Opioid-Related Disorders/ (22304) | |
37 Poisoning/ (21631) | |
38 Psychoses, Substance-Induced/ (5082) | |
39 Self-Injurious Behavior/ (6447) | |
40 Street Drugs/ae [adverse effects] (1421) | |
41 Substance-Related Disorders/ (87805) | |
42 Substance Withdrawal Syndrome/ (20325) | |
43 ((abus* or addict* or chronic* or depend* or disorder* or intoxicat* or mis-us* or misus* or over-dos* or overdos* or poison* or withdrawal*) adj3 (drug* or fentanyl* or heroin* or narcotic* or opiate* or opioid* or oxy-co* or oxyco* or morphine*)).tw,kf. (97309) | |
44 ((drug* or substance* or toxic*) adj2 psycho*).tw,kf. (18771) | |
45 or/29–44 [Combined MeSH & text words for chronic drug use] (263106) | |
46 Burn Units/ (2227) | |
47 Coronary Care Units/ (4202) | |
48 exp. Critical Care/ (51242) | |
49 Critical Care Nursing/ (1223) | |
50 Emergency Medicine/ (11989) | |
51 Emergency Nursing/ (6602) | |
52 exp. Perioperative Care/ and (acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*).mp. (19203) | |
53 Hospital Medicine/ (119) | |
54 exp. Hospitals/ and (acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*).mp. (42779) | |
55 Hospitalization/ (91123) | |
56 Intensive Care Units/ (45436) | |
57 exp. Life Support Care/ (8408) | |
58 Operating Rooms/ and (acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*).mp. (1581) | |
59 Respiratory Care Units/ (579) | |
60 exp. Specialties, Surgical/ and (acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*).mp. (16202) | |
61 Surgery Department, Hospital/ and (acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*).mp. (1066) | |
62 ((acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*) adj2 (care or centr* or department* or hospital* or unit* or ward*)).tw,kf. (270869) | |
63 ((acute* or critical* or emergenc* or intensiv* or trauma* or urgent*) and (intraoperative or operative or perioperative or postoperative)).tw,kf. (114703) | |
64 ((burn* or cardi* or coronary* or heart* or respiratory*) adj2 (care or department* or room* or unit* or ward*)).tw,kf. (27819) | |
65 ICU.tw,kf. (44322) | |
66 life support.tw,kf. (10639) | |
67 or/46–66 [Combined MeSH & text words for acute healthcare settings] (564082) | |
68 and/28,45,67 [Combined concepts for opioids, chronic drug use, & acute healthcare settings] (2136) | |
69 exp. animals/ not humans/ (4426250) | |
70 68 not 69 [Exclude animal studies] (2116) | |
71 (adolescent/ or exp. child/) not exp. adult/ (1302784) | |
72 (adolescen* or child* or infan* or neonat* or p?ediatric* or youth).ti,jw. (1500398) | |
73 70 not (71 or 72) [Exclude pediatric studies] (1845) | |
74 (comment or editorial or news or newspaper article).pt. (1210379) | |
75 73 not 74 [Exclude opinion pieces] (1810) | |
76 (“1996 *” or “1997 *” or “1998 *” or “1999 *” or 200* or 201*).dt. (17023135) | |
77 and/75–76 [date limit applied] (1410) | |
78 limit 77 to (english or french) (1322) | |
79 remove duplicates from 78 (1315) |
Study assessment
Quality assessment of studies
Data analysis and synthesis
Results
Author and Year of Publication | Setting | # of Subjects | Study detail Inclusion criteria | Supportive Intervention Detail | Supportive Intervention Category | Outcomes | Follow-up Post Intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohort studies | |||||||
Alburaih (2018) [33] | ED | 314 | Retrospective multi-centre. Recurrent visits for pain. | ED-based pain contract (opioid treatment plan) | Support for pt. in pain. | # of ED visits | 24-months |
Alexandridis (2018) [34] | ED + Community | 7200 | Statewide database analysis Chronic pain pt. presenting to ED | Diversion control Naloxone policies Community education Provider education Support for pt. in pain Hospital ED policy Addiction treatment | Diversion control Naloxone policies Community education Provider education Support for pt. in pain Hospital ED policy Addiction treatment | Overdose mortality Overdose-related ED visits | 22-months |
Alexandridis (2019) [35] | ED + Community | 7200 | Retrospective Statewide database analysis Chronic pain pt. Subgroup of pt. on buprenorphine therapy | Diversion control Naloxone policies Community education Provider education Support for pt. in pain Hospital ED policy Addiction treatment | Diversion control Naloxone policies Community education Provider education Support for pt. with pain Hospital ED policy Addiction treatment | PDMP-derived counts of opioid prescriptions and buprenorphine | 22-months |
Allen (2016)a [36] | ED + Community | 13 | Retrospective Chart review Pt with > 360 ER visits in 12 months Complex pain syndrome Problematic substance use | Comprehensive pain and addiction strategy referral from ED. | Support for pt. in pain | # of visits to ED Disposition of pt. after ED visit | 52-months |
Fulton-Kehoe (2015) [37] | Statewide | 1809 | Retrospective Statewide database analysis Pt with >= 1 paid claim for opioid Rx from ED. | Statewide Guideline for best practice implementation | Statewide Prescription Policies | Rates of non-methadone associated opioid poisonings | 45-months |
Ghobadi (2018) [38] | ED | 19,751c | Retrospective Chart review Chronic pain (> 50 MEQ/d for >90d as outpatient) | Multi-ED opioid prescribing guidelines implementation | Statewide Prescription Policies | ED parenteral opioids ED oral opioids ED discharge prescription counts | 12-months |
Gugelmann (2013) [39] | ED | 2462b | Prospective Pt receiving opioids in ED Subgroup analysis of pt. with chronic pain. | Multifacted educational program (round presentations, electronic notification, formal ED nursing staff education, journal clubs). | Provider Education | # of opioid discharge packs Change in opioid dispensing in pt. with RF for dependence | 12-months |
Hartung (2018) [40] | Statewide | N/A | Retrospective Medicaid administrative claims and enrollment data Pt with opioid Rx in ED. Stratification by MEQ dispensed. | Prior authorization for opioid Rx > 120 mg/d MEQ implementation. | Statewide Prescription Policies | Probability of opioid prescription above 120 mg MED | 18-months |
Jurecska (2012) [41] | ED | 91 | Retrospective Chart review Pt with > 3 ED visits in prior 3-Mos or 6 or > presentations in 6-Mo with chronic pain (defined as pain > 6 Mos). | Non-narcotic and adherence rates to narcotics policy implementation | Statewide Prescription Policies | Recurrent visits to ED | 36-months |
Kahler (2017) [42] | ED | 243 | Retrospective Chart review Pt with chronic pain Pt with >=6 ED visits per 12 Mo + at least 1 visit identified as primarily opioid-seeking behavior + case management for ED misuse. | Referral to free outpatient taper-to-abstinence pain management clinic. | Support for pt. in pain | # of ED visits # of PDMP opioid prescriptions # of individual opioid prescribers # of diagnostic tests | 12-months |
Maughan (2015) [43] | ED | N/A | Retrosepctive Database analysis through DAWN (Drug Abuse Monitoring Network) All ED visits involving opioid analgesic related harm (abuse or accidental) | Implementation of prescription drug monitoring program (PDMP) | Electronic Alert System | Rates of ED visits | 84-months |
Olsen (2016) [44] | ED | 46 | Retrospective + prospective Chart review Pt with > 3 ED visits in prior 6-Mo or > 6 ED visits in prior 12-Mo for a chronic painful condition. Inappropriate opioid prescription management | ED opioid prescription drug treatment plan in cooperation with primary care provider. | Support for pt. in pain | # fo ED visits # of opioid pills prescribed | 6-months |
Pace (2017) [45] | ED | 529 | Retrospective Chart review Acute pain Chronic pain (> 3 Mo) | Opioid prescribing pathway with framework for opioid prescription | Hospital ED policy | MEQ dose administered in ED # of IV/IM prescrpitions # of opioid prescriptions at discharge | 6-months |
Svenson (2007) [46] | ED | 15 | Prospective Chart review Pt with > 10 ED visits in prior 12-Mo for chronic non cancer pain. | ED organized care with non-opioid Rx and referral to primary care provider for opioid management. | Support for pt. in pain | # of ED visits # of outpatient clinic visits # of outpatient opioid prescriptions | 12-months |
Whiteside (2017) [47] | ED | 29 | Prospective open Feasibility study Subgroup analysis of ED pt. screened positive for risk of Rx opioid misuse in prior 6-Mo | ED-LINC: Emergency department longitudinal integrated care. Multidisciplinary case management: active care coordination and linkage, opioid guidelines, PDMP usage. | Support for pt. in pain Electronic Alert System Hospital ED policy | Feasibility of intervention Substance use and mental health scores # of ED visits | 6-months |
Randomized Controlled Trials | |||||||
Murphy (2017)d [48] | ED | 165 | Multi-centric Non-blinded Pt with 5 or > ED visits in prior 12-Mo with > pain complaints or drug-seeking behavior. ED presentation > 50% related to pain. Economic evaluation (same cohort as Neven 2016) | Multidisciplinary case management with organized follow-up by case manager. | Support for pt. in pain | Total treatment cost differential | 12-months |
Neven (2016) [49] | ED | 165 | Multi-centric Non-blinded Pt with 5 or > ED visits in prior 12-Mo with > pain complaints or drug-seeking behavior. ED presentation > 50% related to pain. | Multidisciplinary case management with organized follow-up by case manager. | Support for pt. in pain | # of ED visits Odds of receiving an opioid prescription at ED discharge MEQ of opioid dispensed | 12-months |
Rathlev (2016) [50] | ED | 40 | Multi-centric Non-blinded Pt with 4 or > ED visits in prior 12-Mo with opioid use disorder (OUD) identified via SMS billing codes ED presentation related to acute pain. | Multidisciplinary case management development | Support for pt. in pain | MEQ prescribed at discharge MEQ administered in ED or inpatient Total medical charges # of ED visits # of ED visits with advanced imaging # of inpatient admission | 12-months |
Ringwalt (2015) [51] | ED | 411 | Pt with 11 or > ED visits in prior 12-Mo and chronic noncancer pain determined via chart & Rx review | Care linkage to primary care provider with plan for non-opioid based pain management. | Support for pt. in pain | # of prescriptions received from ED. # of ED visits | 12-months |
Author | Representativeness of exposed cohort | Selection of non-exposed cohort | Ascertainment of harm reduction | Outcome of interest absent at start of study | Comparability of cohorts | Assessment of outcome with independency | Adequacy of follow-up length |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alburaih (2018) [33] | * | * | * | ** | * | * | |
Alexandridis (2017) [11] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Alexandridis (2018) [34] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Allen (2016) [36] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Fulton-Kehoe (2015) [37] | * | * | * | * | * | * | * |
Ghobadi (2018) [38] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Gugelmann (2013) [39] | * | * | * | * | * | ||
Hartung (2018) [40] | * | * | * | * | * | * | * |
Jurecska (2012) [41] | |||||||
Kahler (2017) [42] | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * |
Maughan (2015) [43] | * | * | * | * | * | ||
Olsen (2016) [44] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Pace (2017) [45] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Svenson (2007) [46] | * | * | * | * | * | * | |
Whiteside (2017) [47] | * | * | * | * | * |
Author | Random sequence generation | Allocation concealement | Selective reporting | Other bias | Blinding of participants | Blinding of outcome | Incomplete outcome data | Final risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rathlev (2016) [50] | Low | Low | Low | Low | High | Unclear | Low | High |
Neven (2016) [49] | Low | Low | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | Mod |
Murphy (2017) [48] | Low | Low | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | Mod |
Ringwalt (2015) [51] | Low | High | Low | Low | High | Low | Low | Mod |
Harm Reduction strategy | General Definition | Cohort | RCTs |
---|---|---|---|
Support for patients in pain | Support groups, case management and pain clinic vetting and referrals. | 8 | 4 |
Hospital ED policy | Local practices to limit ED or inpatient OA prescribing and checking prescription drugs monitoring programs prior to prescribing | 4 | |
Electronic alert system | Systems that alert providers to possible opioid abuse situations without mandating their use | 4 | |
Provider education | Education of medical professionals in chronic pain treatment | 3 | |
Statewide prescription policies | Practices or wide-ranging regulations to limit OA prescription within a legislative territory | 3 | |
Addiction treatment | Opioid agonist therapies and policies supporting their use | 2 | |
Community education | Promotion of public awareness of prescription opioid overdose | 2 | |
Diversion control | Removal of unused medications and training of local law enforcement with OA diversion | 2 | |
Naloxone policies | Promotion of the adoption of policies to disseminate the opioid antagonist naloxone to opioid users | 2 |