Capsule Commentary on Phelan et al., Medical School Factors Associated with Changes in Implicit and Explicit Bias Against Gay and Lesbian People among 3492 Graduating Medical Students

Excerpt

Phelan and colleagues surveyed a random sample of 29 US medical schools to assess whether the medical school curriculum, role modeling, climate or contact with sexual minorities impacted medical students’ potential bias against gay and lesbian people.1 They randomly sampled 5823 students during their first and last semester of medical school, assessing implicit sexual orientation bias using the sexual orientation implicit association test, excluding respondents who self-identified as not heterosexual or straight. In most schools, bias decreased during training, though in some bias increased. Predictors of reduced bias included favorable interactions with LGBT people, faculty modeling and witnessing micro-aggression against LGBT people. Students reporting less bias also reported feeling more comfortable and prepared to provide care to LGBT patients. It is interesting to speculate on whether they actually would provide better care, or just that they felt more comfortable seeing these types of patients. It is also interesting to note that the authors excluded the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences (USUHS), the nation’s military medical school—because, according to the authors, “this school has unique characteristics that would have limited generalizability of study findings”—and also excluded students who reported their sexual orientation as other than heterosexual or straight. The authors make assumptions about the experiences of the military medical school trainees and also about LGBT students. It is interesting that an article exploring bias would demonstrate implicit bias in their own study design. …