Background
Venereal diseases, sexual promiscuity and receptive anal intercourse are associated with an increased risk for anal cancer. Particularly, in HIV-infected individuals an alarming increase of HPV-associated malignancies has to be expected [
1‐
3]. Recent data from the US AIDS-cancer registry reveal for women and men with HIV-infection 6.8 and 37 times greater relative risks for anal cancer compared to respective control populations. It appears, that potent antiretroviral therapy has limited effect in inducing regression of HPV-lesions and HPV-DNA tends to persist in the anorectal canal [
4]. Progression from high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL) to cancer may take as long as 10 or more years in HIV-seronegative individuals. Therefore it is hypothesised, that in the era of antiretroviral therapy the incidence of anogenital cancer in HIV-positive patients will increase as consequence of prolonging survival combined with persistent deviations of the immune system.
A breakthrough in the prophylaxis of cervical cancer has been achieved by introduction of cervical cytological testing described in the report of Papanicolaou and Trout [
5]. A 53% reduction in cervical cancer mortality was reported in Sweden [
6]. and Quinn estimated 1997 that without screening there might have been 800 more deaths in England from cervical cancer in women under 55 years of age [
7]. Nowadays, high risk lesions could also be identified by detecting viral HPV-DNA in cervical smears [
8].
The incidence of anal cancer in HIV-positive men will be probably higher than the incidence of cervical cancer prior the use of cervical cytology screening [
9]. However, even in risk groups – such as HIV-positive homosexual men – there are no such standard screening and management procedures established for the anus. Routine cytological screening has to await an effective proved intervention for anal intraepithelial neoplasia [
10]. Antibodies to HPV capsid antigens are reliable markers for cumulative HPV exposure and have been used in prospective studies, that linked HPV infection to cancers [
11]. Therefore we investigated HPV-antibodies in order to estimate the HPV-prevalence as risk factor for the development of HPV-associated malignancies, particularly, in HIV-positive men.
Methods
HIV-positive patients
The AIDS clinic at the University of Innsbruck is the only centre for patients with HIV/AIDS of the Austrian Tyrol. More than 95% of the Tyrolean AIDS-patients with AIDS reported to the health authorities are in treatment at this clinic. One hundred and sixty-eight HIV-positive men (aged 23 to 61 years, median 43) were regularly seen at our department and sera from the year 1998 were available from all of the patients. Fifty-nine were homosexuals (35.1%), previous or present intravenous drug use was known from 60 men (35,7%) and blood products were the source of HIV-infection in 8 men (4,7%). The remaining 41 men (24.5%) were infected by heterosexual contacts or the transmission route was unknown.
The CD4-cell counts at the time of serum collection were: 42 patients <200/μl, 61 patients 200–400/μl, 65 patients >400/μl. Sixty (35.8%) patients were according to the classification of the Centre of Disease Control (CDC) in asymptomatic disease stage CDC A, fifty-four (32.1%) in mild symptomatic CDC B and fifty-four (32.1%) in CDC C. Stage CDC C is equivalent to AIDS. Antiretroviral therapy at the time of serum collection (1998) was already initiated in 96 (57.1%) individuals. HPV-associated diseases in HIV-positive men were present in 28 (16.6%) patients: 25 (14.8%) men had condylomatous warts and 3 (1.7%) invasive carcinomas (2 anal and 1 rectal squamous cell carcinoma). Two of this 3 carcinoma patients were homosexuals. History for other sexually transmitted diseases (STD) was positive in 42 (25%) men, being treated for genital herpes, gonorrhoea, clamydia or syphilis.
HIV-negative patients with HPV lesions
HIV-negative individuals with HPV-associated diseases studied were 55 men with condylomatous genital warts and 7 men with genitoanal cancer. An additional group consisted of 70 nonpregnant HIV-negative women with external condylomatous warts but normal pap smears, in order to allow comparison of seroresponses in women and men.
Control patients
There were two groups of male HIV-negative patients as follows: First, 98 heterosexual men randomly chosen from patients visiting the dermatological outpatient clinic representing a cross-section of men attending a university hospital in Austria, with no bias as to social or economic status. The reasons for consulting the clinic were skin disorders (e.g. eczema, psoriasis). Patients with drug abuse, homosexuality, malignancies, existing or previous HPV-related diseases or other STD were excluded (questionnaire). The second control group consisted of 100 blood donors being routinely screened for infectious diseases or immune activation (serum neopterin level) but without available information concerning genital warts or sexual behaviour.
The age of all 260 HIV-negative men (median age 42,5 years) did not differ significantly compared with the HIV-positive patients.
HIV-serology and sampling
Sera were screened for HIV antibodies using the Enzygnost Anti HIV 1/2 ELISA (Behring, Germany) and confirmed by Western Blot (Du Pont de Nemours, Germany, or Biotechnologies, Singapore) in at least two different samples. Serum samples for HPV analysis obtained from all individuals were frozen, preserved at -80°C and used for later HPV serology.
HPV-ELISA
Baculovirus-expressed HPV-6, -11, -16, -18, -31 and BPV-1 L1-virus-like particles (VLPs) were used as antigens in direct ELISAs as described previously [
12]. Briefly, VLPs 1:100 diluted in PBS were attached to wells of round bottom ELISA plates (Nunc™ Brand Products and Petra Plastic 96 rounded wells γ-sterilized Typ F – ELISA 11041 E) by incubating 90 μl of VLP-solution/well at room temperature for 45 min. VLP-free PBS-incubated wells were used as negative control wells. All plates were washed three times with PBS (SLT Labinstruments 812 SW2) and were incubated with 200 μl milk-buffer (1 g Fixmilch Instant
® + 20 ml Dulbecco's
® phosphate buffered saline) / well for 30 min (room temperature). Patient sera were heat-inactivated at 56°C for 30 min and used at a final serum dilution of 1:100. Each patient's serum (25 μl) and positive and negative controls were tested in duplicate wells and incubated for 1 h and washed again three times. Monoclonal antibodies (100 μl) corresponding to VLP-types (positive control wells) were diluted with 5% milk-PBS (final dilution of 1:200). Subsequently the wells were incubated with goat anti-human IgG (1:10000), and RαM (1:1000) antibodies (Sigma, St. Louis). After incubation for 30 min. (room temperature) the wells were washed three times and substrate (TRIS-puffer with p-Nitrophenylphosphate tablets) was added. Optical densities (OD's) were read on a microplate reader (SLT Labinstruments 400 ATC, Salzburg, Austria; Software Easy-Fit) at 405 nm 30, 60, and 90 min after adding substrate. Means and standard deviations (SD) of duplicate wells were calculated as final OD values for each serum sample. There was a high correlation of paired values and there were only rarely duplicates which were not consistent with each other. These tests were repeated. The coefficient of variation of selected sets of samples for each ELISA experiment ranged between 0.7 and 4%. In addition in subsets of more than 100 patient sera reproducibility was at least 94%.
Statistical analysis
In all experiments patient and control sera were analysed together. Means and SD of ELISA absorbency values of the control group (dermatology clinic patients) were used statistically to define positive and negative patient sera for each target antigen (HPV-6, -11, -16, -18, -31 and bovine PV-1). Individual values in the control group exceeding the mean + 3 SD were excluded and the remaining readings were averaged again until no further values exceeded the recalculated mean + 3 SD. Samples with values greater than the recalculated final mean + 3 SD were designated positive for reactivity to the appropriate antigen in the current experiment. For scalar variables, the non parametric Mann-Whitney U test was used for statistical analysis, because group OD values had an asymmetric distribution; Fisher's exact test was used for categorical variables. P < 0.05 (two tailed) was considered statistically significant. All calculations were done with SheePS Counting Software (SPSS) 7.0 for Windows 95.
Discussion
Among women and men the incidence of anal cancer has increased in recent decades. Anal cancer is an infectious disease associated with human papillomavirus (HPV) exposure influenced by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) epidemic [
13]. High risk HPV-DNA, which is known to cause cancer of the cervix, was found in 84% of anal cancer tissue specimens [
14]. The present study demonstrates, that HIV-infected men are able to generate a vigorous anti-HPV serological response against these infections. This is not surprising since in HIV-positive patients the humoral immunity is much less impaired compared to cellular immune functions. In addition, HPV has probably been acquired many years before severe deficiencies of immune functions in AIDS patients develop.
In HIV-positive individuals the seroreactivity rate was lower in men than in women compared to our recently published data on IgG reactivity to HPV-6/ -11 and -16/ -18/ -31 in 19% / 31% and 49% / 30% / 24% in HIV-positive women, respectively [
12]. In this previous study HPV-seropositivity in HIV-positive women was even higher than in 48 HIV-negative women with cervical intraepithelial lesions or cancer exhibiting percentages as follows: 8% / 2% and 31% / 15% / 15%. The phenomenon of lower HPV-seroreactivity in men was also seen in the present study comparing HIV-negative men and women with condylomatous warts. In general, men appear to be less likely to be HPV-seropositive, despite of exhibiting increased risk behaviour [
15]. Nevertheless, HPV-antibody detection in men was associated with HPV-associated lesions and/or HIV-seropositivity. The most striking result was the observation, that even those HIV-positive individuals without clinical evident HPV-associated lesions exhibited antibody responses preferentially to oncogenic HPV-types, whereas the prevalence of low risk antibodies was only moderately increased. This observation strongly suggests that – at least in part – immune deviations associated with HIV rather than differences in exposure history contributed to the observed discrepant low risk and high risk HPV sero-prevalences in HIV-positive individuals.
The highest HPV-seroprevalence was observed in the subgroup of homosexual men. This prevalence was in the range of a previous study on HPV-6 and HPV-16 antibodies in men [
16]. In addition, Hagensee
et al have shown a similar seroprevalence in homosexuals with or without HIV. The phenomenon that high-risk HPV-antibodies are much more prevalent than low-risk antibodies in HIV-positive and/or homosexual individuals reflects obviously the known increased risk for anogenital malignancies in these populations. It is interesting to note, though, that in our HIV-negative men high risk HPV-antibodies were not a reliable marker for anogenital cancer, although the 3 tested high risk HPV types (16, 18, 31) normally comprise more than 80% of oncogenic HPV-types e.g. detected in cervical carcinomas in Europe: Only 2 of 7 HIV-negative cancer patients had these high risk antibodies, whereas in the small group of 3 HIV-positive cancer patients all had antibodies. In risk populations a further increase of anal carcinomas has to be expected in the future, since at the end of the study in 2002 (including a follow up period of 3–4 years) three HIV-positive men had already HPV-related carcinomas. This rate would be equivalent to an incidence of 170 per 100 000.
The rate of antibody double reactivities with more than one HPV-type was in the range as observed in HIV-positive women [
12], suggesting comparable exposure to various HPV-types in women and men. Double reactivity could reflect crossreactivity or infection with multiple HPV types, but at least in part the data indicate infection with multiple HPV-types, since we have previously performed competition experiments and analyses with monoclonal mouse antibodies showing, that type specific IgG antibodies exist, which discriminate even the closely related HPV types -6 and -11 [
17]. In the present study there was accordingly a trend for double reactivity in homosexuals and in HIV-positive men with histories of STDs suggesting infections with multiple HPV types.
The extraordinary high prevalence of high risk HPV-antibodies exceeding the low risk HPV-antibody prevalence in HIV-positive individuals needs to be interpreted. HIV-infected individuals are obviously not able to sufficiently control particularly high risk HPV by cellular immune mechanisms resulting in prolonged persistence of HPV-DNA as demonstrated [
18]. The occurrence of complete life cycles of HPV and subsequent capsid expression is thought to be the primary determinant of a detectable humoral response, reflecting lifetime cumulative exposure to HPV [
19]. Seropositivity is probably a better marker for past sexual behaviour than presence of HPV-DNA [
20]. Therefore, our data suggest that HIV-positive men are intensely exposed to high-risk HPV proteins throughout the natural course of their HIV infection. This persistence of oncogenic HPV-types could be one explanation for the association of HIV with HPV-associated malignancies. An interaction of HIV and HPV and local factors are probably also involved in the carcinogenesis in HIV-positive individuals [
21,
22].
Dysplasia may also develop in visually normal anal mucosa [
23], but routine anal cytology is not established. In addition, women – despite of the absence of evidence for cervical disease – may also be at risk for anal disease, in a region were HPV-screening is usually not performed. HPV-serology could be used for risk assessment in HIV-positive patients to circumvent these problems, since serology is convenient, economic and can detect past and present HPV-infection, independently of an anatomical region. In HIV-negative women it has been shown, that HPV-antibodies in prediagnostic sera indicate risk for occurrence of cervical cancer: the relative risk was highest (odds ratio = 7,5) in patients with high antibody levels [
24].
Conclusions
We conclude, that the high seroprevalence of HPV-antibodies in HIV-positive men reflects a high lifetime cumulative exposure to oncogenic HPV-types. This may be due to risky sexual behaviour in combination with defects of the immunological control of HPV. The serological data are in line with published results on anal intraepithelial neoplasia associated with HPV-DNA, which was demonstrated in 84 % among HIV-positive homosexual men [
25]. A role of HPV-serology for diagnostic strategies in HIV-infected individuals remains to be determined, but the presented serological data will be the basis for a close follow up in the next decade, in order to better understand the natural history of anogenital HPV-infection in HIV-positive men in the era of antiretroviral therapy. HIV-infected patients may also be candidates for prophylactic HPV-vaccination strategies, since in these individuals a humoral immune response to HPV occurs.
Authors' contributions
RH: study idea, data analysis and interpretation, report writing; AP: handling of serum specimens and patient data. PT: sexual behaviour questionnaire, serum assays, data analysis; MS: assistance with data analysis; AW: supervision of laboratory tests, data analysis in female patients, manuscript review; RZ: interpretation of data, responsible for HIV-positive patients, manuscript review. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.