The majority of studies consisted of quantitative cross-sectional descriptions and/or analyses, and were conducted after 2008. Only 10 employed qualitative tools (5%) and four adopted a mixed-methods approach (2%). Qualitative research addressed health care services, occupational factors and emotional health, but was almost non-existent in the literature addressing communicable and non-communicable conditions. Only three studies collected data at both country of origin (CO) and destination, truly incorporating a transnational dimension.
Most studies compared specific health indicators of HAs with those of the locally born populations. The “HA population” was often grouped as an analytical category and only a minority of studies focused on nationals from a single country. The country of origin of study participants - sometimes not indicated in the description of the sample - was often not considered in the interpretation of results.
Health status
Of all the studies reviewed 74 (38%) addressed one or more communicable infections. Of these, 29 focused on HIV (Additional file
4), 11 on other sexually transmitted infections (STIs) (Additional file
5), and 14 on Tuberculosis (TB) (Additional file
6). An additional 20 studies focused on other communicable diseases (Additional file
7). With the exception of research focused on a range of “imported diseases” and studies on STIs and TB where the interlinks with HIV were often made explicit, most studies addressed a single specific disease, with limited accounts of the concurrence of different pathologies and how these intersect with individuals’ quality of life.
Studies in Britain [
17], Italy [
18] and Spain [
19] reported higher HIV prevalence rates in homosexual and to a lesser extent heterosexual HA men vs locals, with rates going from 4.5% in heterosexual HA men in Spain [
19] to 78% in men who have sex with men (MSM) who injected drugs and attended STI clinics in Italy [
20]. In Spain, the most common area of origin of reported HIV cases in the foreign born was HA [
21] and the proportion of HIV cases of HA origin increased from 17% to 22% between 2000 and 2007 [
22]. A quarter of HIV+ HAs attended at a tropical medicine unit in Spain had not started treatment when indicated [
23].
Amongst sex workers, HIV rates differed markedly by sex. A 0.2% prevalence was found in HA female sex workers in Spain [
24] while amongst transsexual women HIV rates were above 16% in both Italy and Spain [
25-
28]. The HIV prevalence in HA male sex workers in Spain (16%) was well above the rates in locals (9%) [
29].
Misconceptions about HIV were common amongst HAs in Spain [
30,
31], where HA MSM reported unprotected anal sex more frequently than local MSM [
32]. In the Netherlands, sex workers who originated from HA used condoms less consistently than those originating from other countries and the locally born [
33].
A study conducted in England and Wales, reported that 39% of the HIV+ cases identified in persons born in South/Central America had probably acquired the infection in the UK [
34]. Similarly, many of the HIV infections in HAs living in Spain appeared to have been locally acquired [
35] with the highest percentages of recent infection reported in this population (28%) as compared to locals (23%) and persons from Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) (12%) [
36]. In the European Union (EU), the percentage of Latin-Americans amongst AIDS reports in MSM is increasing [
37].
This review also identified some encouraging findings: no differences in response to HIV treatment were found in HAs
vs locals [
38] nor signs of increased transmission of drug resistant HIV [
39] and the number of HIV diagnoses in HA children were reported to decrease [
40,
41]. In Britain, self-reported HIV test uptake reached 90% in MSM born in South/Central America [
17] and in Spain, fear of discrimination was not reported to be a major barrier to HIV testing at mobile units [
42].
An additional 11 studies focused on other STIs, including the human T-cell lymphotropic virus (HTLV) [
43-
47], human papilloma virus (HPV) [
48-
50], syphilis [
51], chlamydia [
52] and Karposi sarcoma [
53]. In Switzerland and Spain, HAs were disproportionally affected by syphilis [
51,
54]. The prevalence of chlamydia was three times higher in a sample of undocumented migrants (78% originating from Latin-America) who presented at a Swiss hospital to undergo voluntary termination of pregnancy
vs a control sample of pregnant women with legal residency permit who attended the same hospital during the same time period [
52]. The higher prevalence of HTLV-1/2 in HA females
vs locals [
46] and other migrant groups [
44,
45] prompted suggestions for HTLV antenatal screening in HA pregnant women in Spain [
44,
45]. Similarly, the high prevalence of HPV infection (21%-62%) [
48-
50] and increased risk of cervical cancer [
55,
56] led researchers to highlight the importance of promoting cervical cancer screening in this population [
55-
57].
We identified 14 studies focused on TB [
58-
71]. Several studies found high percentages of HAs amongst TB cases diagnosed in migrants [
58-
63], ranging from 43-44% in migrant children in Spain and Italy [
58,
61] to 68% in undocumented migrants in Switzerland [
62]. In Italy and Switzerland HAs were at higher risk of TB than migrants from other areas [
65,
66]. In Spain, HAs were more likely to develop TB as an AIDS defining disease than locals [
67] and HA inmates were at higher risk of latent TB than Spanish-born prisoners [
68].
Only 2.8% of foreign-born TB cases were ill on arrival to Spain but half developed the disease within the following 2 years [
59,
60]. Although this was often attributed to reactivation of latent infection [
60,
66] transmission between local and foreign-born communities made an important contribution to the burden of TB [
63]. The bidirectional transmission operating between communities was partially attributed to cultural and linguistic “similarities” that enhanced social interaction between HAs and the locally-born [
60,
63]. The high mobility of this population- including cases of deportation in undocumented migrants- could impede TB treatment compliance [
62] although one study found that HAs adhered to treatment better than locals (82%
vs 76%) [
70]. In consistency with studies conducted with other migrant groups [
72], misconceptions about TB transmission routes prevailed [
71].
An additional 20 studies focused on other communicable diseases. These mainly described the prevalence of cysticercosis [
73-
75], hepatitis A, B, C and G [
76-
80], malaria [
81], toxoplasma gondii [
82,
83], intestinal parasitosis, visceral toxocarlasis [
84,
85], rubella [
86,
87], varicella [
88], and other infectious/parasitic diseases [
84,
85,
89,
90]. These studies often drew screening [
78-
80,
87,
88] and vaccination recommendations [
91,
92].
b)
Non-communicable conditions
Less attention has been paid to non-communicable conditions, which accounted for 17% of the articles reviewed. We identified 15 studies that focused on cardiovascular diseases (CVD) and related risk factors (Additional file
8), 13 cancer (Additional file
9), and four on other non-communicable conditions (Additional file
10).
Studies on cancer focused on prevalence rates in migrants
vs non-migrants [
56,
57,
93-
99], uptake of gynaecological screening [
55,
100,
101] and psychosocial vulnerabilities in affected children [
102]. Prevalence of cancer in HAs
vs locals varied depending on the type of cancer [
98]. HAs were at increased risk of gallbladder [
94], testicular [
93,
98], stomach [
98] and papillary thyroid cancer (females) [
96], but at lower risk of nervous system [
93,
97,
98], breast [
95], ovarian [
99], colon cancer [
98], and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma [
98]. Risks of cervical cancer increased in HA women aged > 50 [
56] and Central Americans [
55]. Some studies suggest that genetic and childhood environmental risk factors might explain differences in nervous system, breast, gallbladder and thyroid cancer rates better than exposures after migration [
94-
97]. Other factors could also influence some types of cancers as illustrated by the lower mammogram uptake reported in HAs
vs locally born females [
100,
101].
CVD risks were reported to be lower in HAs
vs locals in one study [
103] but could increase over the years [
104]. Important heterogeneities were identified: South Americans in Spain had a reduced risk of mortality from ischemic heart disease [
105] but persons originating from Central America and the Caribbean showed the highest mortality rates due to cerebro-vascular pathologies [
105-
107]. In Sweden, the risk of stroke in Chileans and locals was similar [
108].
The prevalence of diabetes mellitus (DM) in HAs was below the level identified in locals and other migrants in a study conducted in a Spanish primary care centre [
109]. However, the prevalence of risk factors underlying metabolic conditions linked to diabetes such as obesity, overweight and high body mass index (BMI) was consistently above the level found in autochthonous populations [
110-
113]. Obesity rates reached 17% in HA males living in Spain [
110] and in Sweden the difference in BMI persisted after adjusting for age, educational status, physical activity and smoking [
113]. The prevalence of overweight in adopted children of HA origin living in Sweden was particularly high in Chileans (28.6%) as compared with locals (14%), leading researchers to suggest that genetic factors could play a major role in the development of this condition [
112]. The role of genetic
vs environmental exposures was seen as less clear in the case of DM [
114]. In one study conducted in Sweden, adoptees and second generation migrants originating from HA had a lower risk for DM than locals [
115]. In another study, also conducted in Sweden, the low risk for DM persisted in adoptees from low prevalence South American countries, but increased in children born in Sweden whose parents originated from South America. These findings point to exposures in utero or early childhood as relevant factors to be considered [
116].
While non communicable conditions such as osteoarthritis and skin problems tended to be less prevalent amongst HAs there were some exceptions such as headaches, migraines, anaemia, low back pain and constipation [
117]. The three studies focused on allergies found that the HA population was disproportionally affected by allergies/asthma [
118-
120] with symptoms appearing mostly after arrival in Europe [
119].
c)
Emotional and psychological health
We identified 20 studies (10%) that focused on “emotional and psychological health” (Additional file
11). The presence of vulnerability factors in the HA population living in Europe is well described in the literature and includes exposure to traumatic experiences of violence at the countries of origin [
121] as well as post-migration stressors including adaptation to a new context [
122-
125], cultural barriers [
126], economic difficulties [
121], inability to meet pre-migration expectations [
127], occupational worries [
128], poor sense of control [
121], break-up of social and family ties, feelings of loss, novelty and nostalgia, undocumented residence status [
122], and lack of a consolidated community [
129]. In Italy, higher rates of “somatisation” were described amongst HAs [
130,
131]. However, evidence on the actual prevalence of psychological disorders in this population is inconclusive with studies reporting higher [
129,
132,
133], similar [
134], and lower rates [
135]
vs local populations. Differing patterns have also been found when disaggregating the analysis by sex [
136] and country of birth [
137], including reports of wide disparities in antidepressant consumption [
138].
Some studies question the widespread concept of migration as a “risk factor” for poor mental health and suggest that general socio-economic stressors- as opposed to stressors specific to the migration process- could have the greatest impact on mental distress in the HA population. A study in Barcelona found for example that “homesickness” and perceived discrimination were not associated to psychopathology [
127] and in Sweden, economic difficulties were stronger risk factors for psychological distress than pre-migration exposure to violence [
121]. We identified inconsistencies regarding the role played by perceived discrimination on HA’s health with studies finding both strong [
139-
141] and no association [
134] with mental health indicators.
The use of coping strategies to manage stress was seldom investigated. Religiosity was reported to be high and negatively related to stress in both sexes [
142]. Logical analysis, reappraisal, seeking guidance and problem-solving were strategies more widely used than negative coping modalities such as cognitive avoidance, acceptance-resignation, seeking alternative rewards and emotional discharge [
128]. However, somatisation, anxiety, hostility and obsessive-compulsive disorders were reported to increase with length of stay, as did the use of avoidance coping strategies [
128]. In a study conducted in Spain, social integration in the community positively correlated with subjective well being [
123]. However, other studies conducted in Spain found that participation in a community group was positively related to poor mental health [
139] and that Ecuadorians from high ethnic density neighbourhoods were more likely to have mental health problems than those living in areas with low ethnic density [
143].
d)
Maternal and child health
A total of 27 studies addressed maternal and child health [
144-
170] (Additional file
12). The use of caesarean section (CS) was consistently higher in HAs
vs locals [
146,
149-
153,
160,
166] and all the studies that investigated rates of low birth weight (LBW) except for two [
151,
165] found that these were higher [
144,
158-
161,
166] or similar [
153] in children born to local women. However, in Finland, newborns to Latin-American mothers had more interventions after birth and higher perinatal mortality [
151] and in Sweden, the risk of non-normal birth was 50% higher [
163]. In Spain, the risk of some infections [
158,
164], poor prenatal care [
158] and rates of very low birth weight were also higher in children born to HAs mothers when compared with locals [
161].
The single study that employed a qualitative approach identified that some HA women in Spain perceived pre-natal controls to offer little benefit [
145] although in Sweden, HA women did not use antenatal care either less nor later than recommended [
155]. The use of intrapartum epidural analgesia was common [
147,
150] and mothers were satisfied with its use as a pain reliever [
148].
Some researchers pointed to greater use of contraceptive methods in HAs as compared to people from SSA and Asia [
168] but there was a strikingly high variability in reported use by country of origin, ranging from 100% in Colombians to 55% in Dominicans [
169]. A study with undocumented Latin-American women in Geneva found that four out of five pregnancies resulting in live births were unintended [
170].