Introduction
Materials and methods
Study participants
Data collection
Outcome measures
Sample size calculation
Data analyses
Economic evaluation
Ethical considerations
Results
Recruitment and retention
Baseline comparison of groups
Cohort |
Difference
P-value | Cohort |
Difference
P-value | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Characteristics | A (n = 75) | B (n = 176) | B1 (n = 92) | B2 (n = 84) | |||
Socio-demographic | Age mean(SD) | 72.9 (8.7) | 71.6 (10.6) | 0.340a
| 71.1 (10.4) | 72.1 (10.8) | 0.524a
|
Gender = Female (%) | 27(36) | 74(42) | 0.371b
| 38(41) | 36(43) | 0.835b
| |
Ethnicity = White (%) | 70(97) | 171(99) | 0.156b
| 89(99) | 82(100) | 1.000b
| |
Domestic status =Live alone (%) | 21(30) | 38(22) | 0.347b
| 14(16) | 24(30) | 0.155b
| |
Education, Highest qualification | No qualifications (%) | 25(42) | 56(36) | 0.658c
| 31(39) | 25( 32) | 0.296c
|
GCE/O Level (%) | 8(13) | 25(16) | 14(18) | 11(14) | |||
A-Level (%) | 4(7) | 14(9) | 5(6) | 9(12) | |||
Vocational qualification | 15( 25) | 42(27) | 22(28) | 20( 26) | |||
Working status | Unable to work (%) | 6(9) | 11(6) | 0.275b
| 7( 8) | 4(5) | 0.554b
|
Able to work (%) | 7(10) | 31(18) | 14(16) | 17(21) | |||
N/A Retired (%) | 56(81) | 128(75) | 67(76) | 61(74) | |||
Hours worked last week (SD) | 20.55(16.07) | 25.05(15.75) | 0.560a
| 21.08(15.52) | 28.28(15.67) | 0.227a
| |
Hours normally worked per week mean(SD) | 26(13.38) | 30.19(13.2) | 0.492a
| 27.05(13.44) | 32.5(12.99) | 0.307a
| |
Days sick leave in past 4 weeks mean (SD) | 2 (4.47) | 3.76 (7.75) | 0.630a
| 5.1 (7.64) | 2.87 (7.95) | 0.492a
| |
Clinical | Months, first diagnosis to T0 mean (SD) | 7.6(4.66) | 6.51(3.72) | 0.075a
| 7.81(4.11) | 5.09(2.59) | <0.001a
|
Months, end of last treatment to T0 mean(SD) | 3.08(2.54) | 2.22(1.69) | 0.010a
| 2.53(1.81) | 1.9(1.5) | 0.015a
| |
Months, end of last treatment to PTFU mean(SD) | - | - | - | - | 3.75(3.61) | - | |
Number of LTCs mean (SD) | 1.1 (1.19) | 0.95 (1.07) | 0.348a
| 1.02 (1.14) | 0.88 (0.99) | 0.372a
| |
Diabetes ( %) | 10(14.3) | 25(15) | 0.892b
| 15(17.4) | 10(12.3) | 0.356b
| |
Heart Disease (%) | 7(10) | 21(12.6) | 0.575b
| 10(11.6) | 11(13.6) | 0.704b
| |
COPD (%) | 2(2.9) | 6(3.6) | 1.000d
| 3(3.5) | 3(3.7) | 1.000d
| |
Arthritis (%) | 17(24.3) | 23(13.8) | 0.049b
| 10(11.6) | 13(16) | 0.407b
| |
Depression (%) | 3(4.3) | 6(3.6) | 0.726d
| 3(3.5) | 3(3.7) | 1.000d
| |
High blood pressure (%) | 27(38.6) | 48(28.7) | 0.138b
| 30(34.9) | 18(22.2) | 0.071b
| |
Last treatment received | Surgery (%) | 59(84) | 117(70) | 0.114b
| 47 (53) | 70(90) | <0.001b
|
Chemotherapy (%) | 10(14) | 43(26) | 36(40) | 7( 9) | |||
Radiotherapy (%) | 1(1) | 3(2) | 3(3) | 0(0) | |||
Other (%) | 0(0) | 4(2) | 2(2) | 2(3 ) | |||
Additive treatment | Surgery only (%) | 52(69) | 107(61) | 0.024b
| 40(43) | 67(80) | <0.001b
|
Surgery + Chemotherapy (%) | 8(11) | 48(27) | 36(39) | 12(14) | |||
Surgery + Chemotherapy +Radiotherapy (%) | 10(13) | 16(9) | 12(13) | 4( 5) | |||
Surgery + Radiotherapy (%) | 3(4) | 5(3) | 4(4) | 1(1) | |||
Surgery + Microwave Ablation (%) | 1(1) | 0(0) | (0) | (0) | |||
Surgery +Chemotherapy +Microwave Ablation (%) | 1(1) | 0(0) | (0) | (0) | |||
Previous cancer diagnosis | Yes (%) | 8(11) | 14(8) | 0.487b
| 9(10) | 5( 6) | 0.348b
|
No (%) | 67(89) | 162(92) | 83(90) | 79(94) | |||
Metastatic disease removed prior to T0: No (%) | 72(96) | 171(97) | 0.699d
| 87(95) | 84(100) | 0.060d
| |
Patient Reported Outcome Measures | EQ5D-5 L index, mean(SD) [worst −0.594,best 1] | 0.8(0.21) | 0.82(0.17) | 0.480a
| 0.79(0.16) | 0.86(0.17) | 0.010a
|
EQ5D-5 L VAS mean(SD) [worst 0–100] | 76.57(21.16) | 77.35(16.95) | 0.758a
| 73.5(18.55) | 81.73(13.79) | 0.001a
| |
FACT:PWB mean(SD) [worst 0, best 28] | 24.05(4.9) | 24.7(3.74) | 0.307a
| 23.91(4.26) | 25.59(2.82) | 0.003a
| |
FACT:SWB mean(SD) [worst 0, best 28] | 22.97(5.41) | 22.6(6.13) | 0.662a
| 23.16(4.98) | 21.99(7.15) | 0.224a
| |
FACT:EWB mean(SD) [worst 0, best 24] | 20.68(3.96) | 20.52(3.28) | 0.744a
| 20.23(3.05) | 20.82(3.5) | 0.246a
| |
FACT:FWB mean(SD) [worst 0, best 28] | 20.52(8.02) | 20.63(6.65) | 0.705a
| 19.92(6.34) | 21.65(6.88) | 0.060a
| |
FACT: CRCs mean(SD) [worst 0, best 28] | 21.38(5.12) | 22.06(4.55) | 0.301a
| 20.98(5.06) | 23.23(3.62) | 0.001a
| |
FACT-G total mean(SD) [0 worst, best 108] | 89.81(16.35) | 89.08(14.15) | 0.736a
| 88.22(12.84) | 90.01(15.48) | 0.429a
|
Outcomes at T2
Cohort |
Difference
P-value | Cohort |
Difference
P-value | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Characteristics | A (n = 53) | B (n = 79) | B1 (n = 38) | B2 (n = 41) | |||
Socio-demographic/Clinical | Age at T2 mean(SD) | 72.9 (8.7) | 71.6 (10.6) | 0.340a
| 71.1 (10.4) | 72.1 (10.8) | 0.524a
|
Months from first diagnosis to T2 mean (SD) | 15.05(4.31) | 14.21(3.24) | 0.201a
| 15.55(3.6) | 12.96(2.26) | 0.003a
| |
Months from end of last treatment to T2 mean(SD) | 11.08(2.45) | 10.47(1.77) | 0.128a
| 10.68(1.81) | 10.29(1.73) | 0.333a
| |
Months from end of last treatment to PTFU mean(SD) | Not applicable | 6.28(4.10) | Not applicable | 15.52(2.42) | 5.38(2.94) | <0.001a
| |
Additive Treatment | Surgery only (%) | 38(72) | 49(62) | 0.123b
| 16(42) | 33(80) | 0.004b
|
Surgery + Chemo (%) | 4(8) | 19(24) | 14(37 | 5(12) | |||
Surgery + Chemo +RT (%) | 6(11) | 8(10) | 5(13) | 3(7) | |||
Surgery + RT (%) | 3(6) | 3(4) | 3(8) | 0(0) | |||
Surgery + MA (%) | 1(2) | 0(0) | 0(0) | 0(0) | |||
Surgery + Chemo + MA (%) | 1(2) | 0(0) | 0(0) | 0(0) | |||
Patient reported outcomes | EQ5D-5 L health score mean(SD) | 0.81(0.23) | 0.83(0.17) | 0.480a
| 0.79(0.16) | 0.87(0.15) | 0.033a
|
EQ5D-5 L VAS mean(SD) | 81.58(18.45) | 78.5(15.56) | 0.302a
| 73.57(16.66) | 83.07(13.07) | 0.006a
| |
FACT:PWB mean(SD) | 24.19(5.6) | 25.31(3.7) | 0.199a
| 24.56(3.96) | 26.05(2.19) | 0.043a
| |
FACT:SWB mean(SD) | 22.92(4.65) | 21.7(6.35) | 0.227a
| 21.64(6.53) | 21.82(6.25) | 0.899a
| |
FACT:EWB mean(SD) | 20.94(3.39) | 20.28(3.13) | 0.269a
| 19.82(3.23) | 20.73(2.99) | 0.205a
| |
FACT:FWB mean(SD) | 21.38(6.92) | 20.97(5.7) | 0.715a
| 19.46(5.72) | 22.4(5.37) | 0.022a
| |
FACT: CRCs mean(SD) | 22.2(4.89) | 22.66(3.51) | 0.566a
| 21.77(3.75) | 23.55(3.05) | 0.026a
| |
FACT-G total mean(SD) | 91.98(15.01) | 88.31(13.3) | 0.163a
| 85.48(13.58) | 91.15(12.56) | 0.063a
|
Outcome at T2 [range] | Constant | Ba
| Predictor |
P - value | R2
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
EQ5D-5 L [−0.594 to 1(best)] | 0.877 | -0.066b
| Number of longstanding conditions including ‘other’ at T2 | <0.001 | 0.121 |
FACT-G at T2 [0 to 108(best)] | 95.225 | -5.266c
| Number of longstanding conditions including ‘other’ at T2 | <0.001 | 0.168 |
+13.226d
| Had heart disease at T2 | 0.008 | |||
-5.741e
| Had chemotherapy by T0 | 0.047 | |||
Colorectal Cancer Concerns [0 to 28(best)] | 24.227 | -3.197f
| In work at T2 | 0.001 | 0.188 |
-1.240g
| Number of longstanding conditions including ‘other’ at T2 | 0.003 | |||
+3.637h
| Had heart disease at T2 | 0.009 |
Quality of care | Expectations about care | ||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohort | Excellent | Very good | Good | Fair | Poor | Total | Exceeded | Met | Fell short | Total | |||||||||
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
|
n
|
%
| ||||
Aa
| OPFU | 16 | 35.6 | 15 | 33.3 | 9 | 20 | 4 | 8.9 | 1 | 2.2 | 45 | 9 | 21.4 | 31 | 73.8 | 2 | 4.8 | 42 |
B1b
| OPFU | 6 | 17.1 | 16 | 45.7 | 7 | 20 | 5 | 14.3 | 1 | 2.9 | 35 | 4 | 12.1 | 25 | 75.8 | 4 | 12.1 | 33 |
B2c
| PTFU | 10 | 29.4 | 16 | 47.1 | 6 | 17.6 | 2 | 5.9 | 0 | 0 | 34 | 5 | 16.1 | 26 | 77.4 | 0 | 0 | 31 |
Mann Whitney U test | A and B1 (OPFU) vs. B2 (PFTU) at T2 |
p = 0.371 |
p = 0.542 | ||||||||||||||||
B1 (OPFU) vs. B2 (PTFU) at T2 |
p = 0.110 |
p = 0.165 |