Background
Methods
Step 1 Research scoping
Step 2 Data collection
Semi-structured telephone interviews
Project title (year) | Funding A$ | Study design | Intervention | Key outcome variables(statistical significance) | Key implications | Dissemination methods |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Making Connections (2000) | 10,000 | Action research | Community development | None (no comparator) | Goal of developing an early intervention program was not able to be achieved. | Report |
Nutrition Practices in Youth Housing (2000) | 38,100 | Literature review and formative assessment | Nutrition standards | Improved nutritional practices (no comparator) | Provided input into the nutritional policy process for standards and accreditation of youth housing services, but was success limited by the political and institutional context. | Report, conference presentations, policy briefing |
Reducing Smoking in Mental Health Units (2000) | 38,449 | Mixed methods (clinical audit, in depth interviews, surveys) | NRT, counseling with follow-up & organizational change | Offer and acceptance of NRT (no comparator) | Demonstrated NRT is acceptable to many staff and patients of mental health units and important for managing nicotine dependence in the context of a Smoke Free Workplace Policy. Identified key organizational and cultural barriers to practice change. | Report, conference presentations, presentation to local networks |
Rural Hearing Conservation (2000) | 17,670 | Mixed methods (screening, mail survey) | Hearing screening and education | Hearing conservation behavior(no comparator) | Confirmed the extent of hearing loss in farmers and salience in rural communities. Recommended that the Rural Hearing Conservation Program be continued and, where possible, expanded. | Report, summaries, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, policy briefings, website |
Secondary Prevention in Patients with CVD (2000) | 239,295 | Cluster RCT | Mailed information packages for patients, general practitioners and combined intervention | Medication use (NS) Behavioral risk advice [exercise, diet & smoking cessation] (NS) except for physical activity (P = 0.04) in patient intervention stream | There is insufficient evidence upon which to make a recommendation that information only interventions should be incorporated into the routine practice of CVD registers. | Report, conferences, presentations to local clinical groups |
Tai Chi and Falls Prevention for Older People (2000) | 274,384 | RCT | Tai chi exercise | Falls incident rate (P = 0.008) | Participation in weekly tai chi classes prevents people falling multiple times and improves balance in community dwelling older people. As the trial used existing community facilities it provided a model for an effective and sustainable public health intervention. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, thesis, presentations to practitioner networks |
Balance: | ||||||
Sway on floor (P = 0.04) | ||||||
Sway on foam mat (P = 0.001) | ||||||
Lateral stability (P = 0.04) | ||||||
Coordinated stability (P = 0.005). | ||||||
Mental Health First Aid Training (2002) | 178,432 | Cluster RCT & qualitative evaluation | Mental health literacy training | Correct diagnosis (P=0.001) Help offered to person with mental health problem (P = 0.031) | The training course produced positive changes in knowledge, attitudes and behavior when given to members of the public by instructors from a local health service. Showed strong promise a strategy in broader mental health promotion and workforce development initiatives. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers (open access), policy briefings, training, political advocacy, websites, media |
Safer Streetscapes for Older People (2002) | 179,609 | Mixed qualitative methods | Fall risk assessment and capital works | Environmental and policy change (no comparator) | Qualitative consultative methods employed elicited information from older people that can be used to advocate for changes to the streetscape. | Report, conferences, council briefings |
Treatment of Nicotine Dependant Inpatients (2002) | 249,970 | Quasi-experimental design | Smoking care provision | Smoking care outcomes: | Incorporation of smoking care intervention strategies into routine clinical and organization performance management and accreditation processes has the potential to facilitate widespread NRT provision in hospitals. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, thesis, presentations to policy, practitioner & university networks, media |
Smoking status identified (NS) | ||||||
Management of smoking discussed (P = 0.01) | ||||||
Offered NRT (P <0.001); | ||||||
Provided NRT (P <0.01) | ||||||
Provided written resources (P <0.01) | ||||||
Provided post-discharge NRT (P = 0.03). | ||||||
Monitored withdrawal (NS) | ||||||
Advised discharge support (NS) | ||||||
Pedometers in Cardiac Rehab (2004) | 200,000 | RCT and focus groups | Pedometers, step calendar, and behavioral counseling and goal setting | Physical activity: | A pedometer based intervention can be offered as an effective and accessible option for those who do not attend cardiac rehabilitation to increase their physical activity levels. This intervention could also be promoted as an important adjunct to existing cardiac rehabilitation programs. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, thesis, local presentations |
Total physical activity time (P = 0.044) | ||||||
Total physical activity sessions (P = 0.016) | ||||||
Walking sessions (P = 0.035) | ||||||
Psychosocial: | ||||||
Cognitive self-management strategy use (P = 0.001) | ||||||
Psychological distress (P <0.001) | ||||||
Reducing Falls Injuries within Aged Care (2004) | 300,000 | Cluster RCT | Multi-strategic best practice falls prevention strategies | Facility level: | It was difficult to change the culture within residential aged care and particularly of the visiting medical officers. It seems unlikely that any sustained reduction in hip fractures in residential aged care facilities can be obtained without outside support. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, presentations to policy & practitioner networks |
Fall risk assessment (P = 0.002) | ||||||
Monthly number of falls (NS) | ||||||
Any fracture (NS) | ||||||
Hip fracture (NS) | ||||||
Death (NS) | ||||||
Individual level: | ||||||
Hip fracture (NS) | ||||||
Death (NS) | ||||||
Walk-to-School (2004) | 257,000 | Cluster RCT | Education, travel access guides, environment change | Student mode of travel reported by students: | No clear pattern in the results, due to the high variation in the percentages of students in the intervention and control schools who changed their travel mode. The research identified the strong influence of the parent’s journey to work on their child’s journey to school. The project contributed to methodological development in this field of research. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, presentations to local councils, media |
Morning journey (NS) | ||||||
Afternoon journey (NS) | ||||||
Student mode of travel reported by parents: | ||||||
Morning journey (NS), except walking trips in a usual week (P = 0.05) | ||||||
Afternoon journey: (NS) | ||||||
Cycling Infrastructure and its Promotion (2006) | 280,537 | Quasi-experimental | Community engagement and social marketing | Sufficient activity to confer health benefit (NS) | There was no overall increase in the prevalence of cycling in the intervention area, and therefore there was no difference in overall levels of physical activity between the intervention and comparison areas. After adjusting for baseline levels of minutes riding, there was a significant increase in the total mean number of minutes riding in the intervention area compared with the comparison area. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers |
Mean minutes of physical activity (NS) | ||||||
Adjusted mean number of minutes riding (P = 0.039) | ||||||
Exercise to Prevent Falls After Stroke (2006) | 292,708 | RCT | Group-based physiotherapist-led exercise classes and advice | Falls incident rate (NS) | No overall effect on falls, exploratory analysis however did find a significant differential effect of the intervention according to baseline walking speed. The intervention was more likely to prevent falls in faster walkers. | Report, conference presentations, peer-reviewed papers, policy briefings, newsletters, practitioner networks, political advocacy |
Falls based on faster initial walking speed (P = 0.03) | ||||||
Smoking Cessation in Indigenous Communities (2006) | 290,200 | Action research (mixed qualitative and quantitative methods) | Subsidized nicotine replacement therapy and weekly support sessions with case manager | Provision and use of NRT (no comparator) 12 month quit rate (no comparator) | Twenty-four percent of Smokers Program participants remained smoke-free at a minimum of 12 months after Program completion. Program prompted people to attempt quitting and provided opportunities for health workers to talk about smoking and smoking-related illness with their clients. | Report, conference presentations, local seminars, Aboriginal health worker research forums |
TOTAL
|
2,846,354
|
-
Recall of research aims, key finding and implications
-
Dissemination process (how, factors influencing the dissemination process)
-
Interface with end users – how research team worked with potential end users (investigators only)
-
Interface with researchers – how were end users involved in the research project, how did they hear about the findings (end users only)
-
Overall impact – how have the findings been used
-
Specific impacts – capacity building, partnerships, policy and product development, health and other sector impacts, societal and economic impacts
-
Circumstances surrounding the use of the findings, or limited impact of the findings
-
Evidence of impacts – documentary sources
-
Nomination of end users (investigators only)
Bibliometric analysis
Step 3 Impact Assessment
Data synthesis and verification panel
Results
Project characteristics
Interviews | Research outputs | Mean independent assessment of impacts* | Panel assessment of impact* | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Project (year) | CI (n) | EU (n) | Conferences (n) | Papers (n) | Citations (n) | Advance knowledge (mean) | Capacity building (mean) | Policy & practice (mean) | Health, social, economic (mean) | Overall (mean) | Group overall |
Ranked by Group Overall impact | |||||||||||
Mental Health First Aid Training (2002) | 1 | 3 | n/a | 4 | 66 |
8
|
7
|
8
|
6
|
8
|
8
|
Tai Chi and Falls Prevention for Older People (2000) | 1 | 3 | 7 | 2 | 77 |
8
|
7
|
7
|
6
|
7
|
7
|
Treatment of Nicotine Dependant Inpatients (2002) | 1 | 4 | 3 | 7 | 31 |
6
|
6
|
6
|
5
|
7
|
7
|
Rural Hearing Conservation (2000) | 1 | 2 | 4 | 4 | 14 |
6
|
6
|
7
|
4
|
6
|
6.5
|
Smoking Cessation in Indigenous Communities(2006) | 1 | 1 | 4 | 0 | - |
4
|
5
|
6
|
4
|
5
|
6.6
|
Pedometers in Cardiac Rehab (2004) | 1 | 2 | 4 | 2 | 6 |
6
|
5
| 3 | 2 |
5
|
5
|
Exercise to Prevent Falls After Stroke (2006) | 1 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 3 |
5
|
4
|
5
| 3 |
5
|
5
|
Walk-to-School (2004) | 1 | 1 | n/a | 6 | 44 |
6
|
4
|
4
| 2 |
4
|
4.5
|
Reducing Falls Injuries within Aged Care (2004) | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 |
4
|
4
|
5
| 3 |
5
|
4.5
|
Reducing Smoking in Mental Health Units (2000) | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | - | 3 | 3 |
4
| 2 |
4
|
4
|
Cycling Infrastructure and Its Promotion (2006) | 1 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 23 |
5
|
4
|
4
| 3 |
4
|
4
|
Secondary Prevention In Patients with CVD (2000) | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | - | 3 |
4
| 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 |
Nutrition Practices in Youth Housing (2000) | 2 | 2 | 4 | 0 | - | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 |
Safer Streetscapes for Older People (2002) | 1 | - | 1 | 0 | - | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 |
Making Connections (2000) | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | - | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Total
(mean)
|
17
|
29
|
36
|
27
|
265
|
(4)
|
(4)
|
(5)
|
(3)
|
(5)
|
(4.
5)
|
Semi-structured interviews and panel impact assessments
Key Impacts | Illustrative Quotes |
---|---|
Policy Impacts
| |
Agenda and priority setting, e.g., attracting funding to the issue of interest, identifying priority groups and settings for intervention. | “[evaluation findings] I think it did have an effect because we were able to promote the issue of hearing loss and the need for protection and in a way that we hadn’t been able to before and it’s just become a more important issue.”(EU1 - Rural hearing) |
Informed policy debates, e.g., data used in briefings with health ministers, inform parliamentary debates, and met with senior bureaucrats. | “[attended]…the Victorian State Parliament inquiry into mental illness and work, and talked about mental first aid, and the politicians were very enthused about it all…And we’ve certainly met with individual politicians, and individual public servants. (CI - Mental Health First Aid ) |
Informed policy planning, e.g., identifying areas for investment in tai chi for older people and smoking cessation brief intervention. | “…knowing that tai chi could be effective in resisting falls, means that it’s something that we can promote and recommend for falls prevention.” (EU1 - Tai Chi and Falls) |
Directly underpinned new policy, e.g., provision of mental health first aid in human service agencies across Australia, inclusion of physical activity in the NSW Falls Prevention Policy 2007–2010, importance of developing specific measures to reduce smoking in mental health units. | “…in the early days where people were struggling with implementation of the smoke-free workplace policy, sort of just showed a way for the people and a comprehensive approach…And to be able to demonstrate that we could affect change across whole hospitals was really an important thing to be able to say that it can be done. “ (CI - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) |
Used to support existing policy, e.g., importance of smoke free environments in mental units, supported the implementation of NSW Smoke-free Workplace Policy and proved that the strategies proposed in the NSW Guide for Nicotine Dependent Inpatients could be implemented. | “…it sort of reinforced the understanding that mental health services are a specific and special case. And that we needed to make sure that we had specific guidelines and that there was more buy in from consumers and psychiatrists and all of the other stakeholders.” (EU2 - Reducing Smoking in Mental Health Units) |
Evaluated existing programs, e.g., Rural Hearing Conservation. | |
Practice Impacts
| |
Informed organizational development in the health sector, e.g., provided that standardized approach provision of smoking cessation advice in health services. | “So Mental Health First Aid is core business for a lot of people working in, what was typically a tertiary and mental health service, people providing clinical services, now there’s a big health promotion, early intervention strategy…” (EU2 - Mental Health First Aid) |
Lead to new intervention tool and resources, e.g., standardized provision of tai chi, mental health literacy training, provision of exercise for stroke survivors, materials to support falls prevention in aged care facilities. | “it’s provided a model of best practice that’s been able to be implemented really broadly.” (EU2 - Falls and Aged Care) |
Informed professional development for health staff, human service workers and fitness leaders, e.g., smoking cessation brief interventions, provision of tai chi to older people. | “[project officer] now has a PhD, she’s a lead researcher and program manager and developer in our organization and that really come out of the opportunity. If the funding had not been there to do that program of work, that wouldn’t have happened…” (EU1 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatient) |
Informed and supported existing health promotion programs, e.g., Rural Hearing Conservation Program, Tai Chi for Older People. | |
Informed program planning, e.g., choice of target groups and settings for intervention and availability of treatment programs. |
Facilitators | Barriers |
---|---|
Nature of the intervention
|
Poorly defined interventions without a clear purpose and outcomes
|
Simplicity of intervention. Easy to explain and has a clear rationale | “… it was almost an impossible project and it was starting from no base. (EU1 – Making Connections) |
Capacity of intervention to be packaged and ‘agents’ trained in its delivery
|
Use of intervention approaches that are difficult to replicate in other settings and target groups
|
“It’s very structured, very organized – it comes with comprehensive teaching notes and instruction and people keep in contact – even though people aren’t employed by Mental Health First Aid Australia in Melbourne, they refer to, what I call the mother ship, on a regular basis and keep in close contact…” (EU2 - Mental Health First Aid) | |
Can be easily replicated and scaled-up
| |
Organization change approaches
| |
“…we developed – the policy compliance procedure an annual audit of the records of the patients who were on the ward at the day so you’ve got an annual reporting of whether procedures are being complied with.” (EU3 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) | |
Integration into usual practice
| |
“I think that really the key things are that the program was integrated into the core business of the service…the very fact that you have ongoing dedicated support from trained workers, that that’s clearly a key component of the success of the program…” (EU 1 - Smoking Cessation in Indigenous Communities) | |
Project aligned to the priorities of policy makers and practitioners with adaptations made over time to meet needs
| |
“…so it was really from someone in the [Department]head office making that remark that then led to the other project which was never what we envisaged but it was still a very good idea.”. (CI - Mental Health First Aid) | |
Effective partnerships
| |
Partnerships formed through research projects led to deeper relationships and further policy driven research
|
Inability to form partnerships with key influencers and end-users
|
““It has influenced our research direction for my colleagues… it’s promoted a bit more inter-professional research opportunities” (CI - Stroke and Falls) | “So they did try and form different partnerships, but that’s a very fractured and continues to be a very fractured area to work in.” (EU – Making Connections) |
Continuity and partnerships between researchers and end-users from the inception of projects facilitated dissemination, ownership and use of the findings. | |
“…relationship between [Chief Investigator] and the Local Area Health Service, definitely strengthened, and I think that has been demonstrated by that second demonstration grant.” (EU2 - Pedometer and Cardiac Rehab) | |
Leadership and champions
| |
Multiplier effect of leadership “So I guess having champions in an area health service… just infects the whole system if you like because if one area is doing it rigorously from a research perspective and building on the research.” (EU4 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) |
No clear alignment with potential leaders in the field of interest who can advocate for project findings
|
Research quality
| |
High research quality and credibility
|
Poor research quality
|
“… based on those early trials, it gives you confidence to say, well we know it worked.”(EU3 – Mental Health First Aid) | “…the clear finding to me was it should never have been funded” (EU - Making Connections) |
“ And, also, the fact of having it published in the Peer Review Journal…in the Cochrane Review which I think that’s very influential that review in terms of setting the agenda for what kind of interventions will be funded in Australia and internationally in falls prevention. I think that’s really important.” (EU1- Tai Chi and Falls) |
Projects findings did not provide definitive answers, needed to be considered alongside a body of evidence about effective interventions. “…you can see because it’s a kind of a mixed finding, so people think, oh, that’s too hard” (CI Walk to School) |
Dissemination approaches
| |
Use of active dissemination strategies such as discussion of findings at workshops between researchers and end-users. “So it’s got a lot of dissemination through talks we’ve done all over the place, nationally and overseas.... A lot of it would be things like departmental seminars” (CI - Mental Health First Aid) |
Findings not tailored to end-users needs
|
Poor links with policy makers and practitioners networks
“When I first read it, I thought I don’t know anything about this.” (EU - Making Connections) | |
A range of ‘knowledge transfer’ products produced, e.g., short reports highlighting key findings and recommendations, well packaged project resources, websites, etc. | |
“[About publishing in open access journals] Anyone can go onto the Web and find it and get the full text of it for free. And we did that deliberately as a strategy because we wanted the findings available to anyone… And the website now is a major dissemination source and the report of this study is there on that website.” (CI –Mental Health First Aid) | |
End-users acted as ‘knowledge brokers’ facilitating dissemination of project findings within their sector “…we had a.... busy email list there with a lot of sharing, a lot of questions. We realized that there was a real need for trying to skill up clinicians in how to work with people in addressing nicotine dependence.” (EU4 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) | |
Contextual issues
| |
Supportive policy context for addressing the issues with the release of project findings fitting well with some policy cycles (Smoke Free Workplace Policy, Falls Prevention Policy) |
Political instability and poor timing Frequent changes in health ministry positions, health service restructures and poor fit with some policy cycles. |
“they'd had a whole practical level of working with hospitals to try to get this stuff to happen, they were able to help us compose the performance criteria.” (EU3 – Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) | “And, then, a lot of the restructuring within area health services and within the department…had an impact on getting the falls plan out.” (EU1 – Tai Chi and Falls) |
Mechanisms and structures in place to profile findings and implement recommendations, e.g., Policy relevant forums involving key end-users |
Limited sector capacity and resources, e.g., lack of funds to implement the findings in some sectors: |
“I have a link now with the Heart Foundation and the Heart Foundation and Stroke Foundation are now more closer working together; it’s largely come out of this work as well so the National Stroke Foundation with having round tables at the time of this project ”(CI - Falls and Stroke) | “…it’s not because we actually get funding, it’s just because we have a farm safety group here made up of a mix of farmers, Essential Energy, CWA, Department of Primary Industries and a few other groups that have literally kept this alive.” (EU1 - Rural Hearing Conservation) |
Ensuring good fit with organizational culture and ways of working
| |
“…in environments that have already got established sort of chain of command and specific behaviors and expectations, and then go in and start telling people what to do. It doesn’t work. And often I went in and did a lot of it in the beginning to show them that it wasn’t a great deal of work.” (EU3 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) | |
Alignment with policy priorities
| |
“…when these clinical practice guidelines came out, there was greater take up… because they had already done the ground work.” (EU3 - Nicotine Dependent Inpatients) | |
Confluence of events
| |
“When it went to the United States, a very important thing… Virginia Tech massacre. And there’d been this student who had a mental illness and nobody did anything about it…that was then an external event that had an influence on its spread to America.” (CI - Mental Health First Aid) |