Background
Methods
Study site
SODIS campaign
SODIS-use assessment
Indicator | Rational and Interpretation | |
---|---|---|
SODIS-use indicators
| ||
1. |
"Bottles sun-exposed"
Proportion of weeks during which SODIS bottles were observed to be exposed to sunlight (as observed by community-based staff) | Indicator for the intention to disinfect water using SODIS. Indirect indicator to measure actual use. |
2. |
"Bottles ready-to-drink"
Proportion of weeks during which SODIS bottles were ready-to-drink (as observed by community-based staff) | Households regularly disinfecting water with SODIS usually have bottles of SODIS-treated water ready-to-drink available in-house. Considered to be a more reliable indicator for actual use than "bottles exposed to sunlight" |
3. |
"Classified user"
Proportion of weeks during which a family was classified as SODIS-user (judgement of community-based staff after observing the family for at least 4 weeks). | Considered the most reliable indicator for actual use. Staff living in the community bases their judgement on daily observations of correct application, placing bottles in plain sunlight and/or getting drinking water from a SODIS-bottle when asked for. |
4. |
"Behavioural change"
Regression coefficient of a logistic regression of the occurrence of bottles exposed to the sunlight (yes/no in a given week) versus time. | Indicates behavioural change over time. Coefficient reflects an increase (high values), decrease (low values) or constancy of exposing bottles to sun throughout monitoring time. Note: a coefficient of B = 0 indicates constant SODIS-use at high or low levels |
Monitoring indicators
| ||
5. |
"Time in Study - Bottles sun-exposed"
Total number of weeks during which "Bottles exposed to sunlight" was recorded | Discriminates and identifies households with few weeks observed. |
6. |
"Time in Study - Classified user"
Total number of weeks during which "Classified user" was recorded | Discriminates and identifies households with few weeks observed to classify as SODIS-user. |
Statistical analysis
Ethics
Results
Intervention activities and compliance
SODIS-user group classification
Factors influencing SODIS adoption
Groups based on SODIS-use behaviour
| ||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total
| Group 1
('non-adopters')
| Group 2
('minimal-adopters')
| Group 3
('declining-adopters')
| Group 4
('emerging-adopters')
| ||||||||||||
n = 216
| n = 60
| n = 68
| n = 21
| n = 42
| P- values*
| |||||||||||
Demography | ||||||||||||||||
Number of household members
| 216
| 6.0
| (5;9)
| 60
| 6.0
| (5;8.5)
| 68
| 6.0
| (4;9)
| 21
| 6.0
| (5;7)
| 42
| 7.0
| (5;9)
| 0.24
|
Age of household members
| 216
| 15.8
| (13;18.1)
| 60
| 15.5
| (13.7;17.6)
| 68
| 15.9
| (13.3;18.7)
| 21
| 15.9
| (13;17.8)
| 42
| 16.0
| (12.1;18.4)
| 0.88
|
Number of females
| 216
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 60
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 68
| 3.0
| (2;5)
| 21
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 42
| 4.0
| (3;6)
| 0.04
|
Pregnant women at start of campaign
| 216
| 0.0
| (0;0)
| 60
| 0.0
| (0;0)
| 68
| 0.0
| (0;0)
| 21
| 0.0
| (0;0)
| 42
| 0.0
| (0;0)
| 0.09
|
Children aged < 5
| 216
| 1.0
| (1;2)
| 60
| 1.0
| (1;2)
| 68
| 2.0
| (1;2)
| 21
| 1.0
| (1;2)
| 42
| 2.0
| (1;2)
| 0.06
|
Children aged 5-9
| 216
| 1.0
| (0;2)
| 60
| 2.0
| (0;2)
| 68
| 1.0
| (0;2)
| 21
| 1.0
| (0;2)
| 42
| 1.0
| (1;2)
| 0.60
|
Children aged 10-14
| 216
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 60
| 0.0
| (0;2)
| 68
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 21
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 42
| 0.0
| (0;2)
| 0.80
|
Members aged 15-19
| 216
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 60
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 68
| 1.0
| (0;1)
| 21
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 42
| 0.0
| (0;1)
| 0.95
|
Members aged > = 20
| 216
| 2.0
| (2;2)
| 60
| 2.0
| (2;2)
| 68
| 2.0
| (2;2.5)
| 21
| 2.0
| (2;2)
| 42
| 2.0
| (2;2)
| 0.17
|
Caregivers' age
| 208
| 28.0
| (23;36)
| 58
| 28.8
| (23;35)
| 67
| 29.0
| (23;37)
| 19
| 30.0
| (22;36)
| 41
| 28.0
| (23;40)
| 0.87
|
Socioeconomic characteristics
| ||||||||||||||||
Years of household heads' schooling
| 155
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 43
| 4.0
| (2;5)
| 52
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 14
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 28
| 4.0
| (2.5;5)
| 0.38
|
Monthly household income in US$
| 120
| 16.9
| (0;37.5)
| 35
| 12.5
| (0;25)
| 37
| 12.5
| (0;31.3)
| 7
| 25.0
| (12.5;37.5)
| 24
| 31.3
| (0;47.5)
| 0.25
|
Bicycle: n (%)
| 192
| 107
| (55.7)
| 49
| 25
| (51)
| 65
| 40
| (61.5)
| 18
| 14.0
| (77.8)
| 39
| 17.0
| (43.6)
| 0.07
|
Radio: n (%)
| 192
| 158
| (82.3)
| 49
| 41
| (83.7)
| 65
| 55
| (84.6)
| 18
| 13
| (72.2)
| 39
| 30
| (76.9)
| 0.53
|
Gas cooker: n (%)
| 181
| 32
| (17.7)
| 53
| 9
| (17)
| 66
| 16
| (24.2)
| 20
| 3
| (15)
| 42
| 4
| (9.5)
| 0.28
|
Number of rooms
| 192
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 49
| 2.0
| (2;3)
| 65
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 18
| 3.0
| (2;3)
| 39
| 3.0
| (2;4)
| 0.29
|
Latrine: n (%)
| 192
| 34
| (17.7)
| 49
| 4
| (8.2)
| 65
| 5
| (7.7)
| 18
| 10
| (55.6)
| 39
| 10
| (25.6)
| >0.001
|
Electricity: n (%)
| 192
| 36
| (18.8)
| 49
| 11
| (22.5)
| 65
| 16
| (24.6)
| 18
| 1
| (5.6)
| 39
| 3
| (7.7)
| 0.06
|
Solar panel: n (%)
| 130
| 30
| (23)
| 29
| 9
| (31)
| 50
| 8
| (16)
| 12
| 3
| (25)
| 25
| 5
| (20)
| 0.44
|
Tiled roof: n (%)
| 181
| 57
| (31.5)
| 53
| 19
| (35.9)
| 66
| 18
| (27.3)
| 20
| 8
| (40)
| 42
| 12
| (28.6)
| 0.60
|
Environmental housing factors
| ||||||||||||||||
Use of improved water source: n (%)**
| 192
| 149
| (77.6)
| 49
| 36
| (73.5)
| 65
| 53
| (81.5)
| 18
| 15
| (83.3)
| 39
| 29
| (74.4)
| 0.69
|
Use of unimproved water source: n (%)***
| 192
| 133
| (69.3)
| 49
| 37
| (75.5)
| 65
| 48
| (73.9)
| 18
| 10
| (55.6)
| 39
| 24
| (61.5)
| 0.23
|
Distance to water source in metres.
| 192
| 22.5
| (5;50)
| 49
| 100.0
| (10;200)
| 65
| 30.0
| (7;100)
| 18
| 5.0
| (4;30)
| 39
| 10.0
| (5;200)
| 0.03
|
Turbidity of source water (NTU)
| 101
| 5.0
| (5;20)
| 30
| 5.0
| (5;40)
| 34
| 5.0
| (5;20)
| 7
| 5.0
| (5;40)
| 19
| 5.0
| (5;15)
| 0.79
|
Faecal contamination of housing environment: n (%)
| 185
| 106
| (57.3)
| 50
| 31
| (62)
| 62
| 34
| (54.8)
| 16
| 9
| (56.3)
| 36
| 16
| (44.4)
| 0.46
|
Animals present in the kitchen: n (%)
| 168
| 45
| (26.8)
| 42
| 15
| (35.7)
| 57
| 13
| (22.8)
| 15
| 3
| (20)
| 33
| 6
| (18.2)
| 0.32
|
Soap, detergent present in the kitchen: n (%)
| 166
| 29
| (17.5)
| 41
| 6
| (14.6)
| 56
| 12
| (21.4)
| 15
| 3
| (20)
| 33
| 4
| (12.1)
| 0.68
|
Household members health status
| ||||||||||||||||
Households with at least one stunted child < 5: n (%)
| 167
| 62
| (37.1)
| 43
| 12
| (27.9)
| 53
| 19
| (35.9)
| 17
| 8
| (47.1)
| 35
| 16
| (45.7)
| 0.33
|
Households with at least one wasted child < 5: n (%)
| 167
| 85
| (50.9)
| 43
| 17
| (39.5)
| 53
| 25
| (47.2)
| 17
| 11
| (64.7)
| 35
| 23
| (65.7)
| 0.08
|
Diarrhoea incidence in children < 5 before start of intervention
| 216
| 3.0
| (0;7)
| 60
| 3.0
| (0;5)
| 68
| 3.0
| (1;7)
| 21
| 6.0
| (1;12)
| 42
| 3.0
| (0;6)
| 0.22
|
Diarrhoea prevalence (%) in children < 5 before start of intervention
| 216
| 7.0
| (1;14)
| 60
| 5.0
| (0;12)
| 68
| 8.0
| (2;14)
| 21
| 7.0
| (2;32)
| 42
| 6.0
| (0;17)
| 0.26
|
Cough prevalence (%) in children < 5 before start of intervention
| 216
| 8.0
| (0;20)
| 60
| 5.0
| (0;17)
| 68
| 8.0
| (2;21)
| 21
| 1.0
| (0;17)
| 42
| 10.0
| (0;24)
| 0.72
|
Fever prevalence (%) in children < 5 before start of intervention
| 216
| 7.0
| (2;15)
| 60
| 6.0
| (0;16)
| 68
| 5.0
| (1;11)
| 21
| 6.0
| (2;19)
| 42
| 7.0
| (2;22)
| 0.58
|
Hand-washing behaviour
| ||||||||||||||||
Hand-washing per day of children > 5 and adults
| 169
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 44
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 57
| 3.0
| (3;5)
| 15
| 3.0
| (3;5)
| 33
| 4.0
| (3;5)
| 0.27
|
Hand-washing per day of children < 5
| 192
| 2.6
| (2;3)
| 49
| 2.5
| (2;3)
| 65
| 2.5
| (2;3)
| 18
| 3.0
| (2;3)
| 39
| 2.7
| (2;3)
| 0.96
|
Household water management
| ||||||||||||||||
Safe storage: n (%)
| 155
| 19
| (12.3)
| 34
| 4
| (11.8)
| 57
| 5
| (8.8)
| 14
| 5
| (37.5)
| 30
| 2
| (6.7)
| 0.06
|
Water disinfection: n (%)
| 192
| 42
| (21.9)
| 49
| 12
| (4.5)
| 65
| 13
| (20)
| 18
| 5
| (27.8)
| 39
| 9
| (23.1)
| 0.86
|
Household water consumption [l/household day]
| 189
| 40
| (20;50)
| 58
| 35
| (20;50)
| 67
| 40
| (20;60)
| 21
| 50
| (20;60)
| 41
| 30
| (20;60)
| 0.81
|
Satisfied with quality of drinking water: n (%)
| 201
| 190
| (94.5)
| 54
| 51
| (94.4)
| 64
| 59
| (92.2)
| 19
| 19
| (94.7)
| 40
| 39
| (97.5)
| 0.76
|
Groups based on SODIS-use behaviour
| ||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total
| Group 1
('non-adopters')
| Group 2
('minimal-adopters')
| Group 3
('declining-adopters')
| Group 4
('emerging-adopters')
| ||||||||||||
n = 216
| n = 60
| n = 68
| n = 21
| n = 42
| P- values*
| |||||||||||
Household exposure to SODIS campaign | ||||||||||||||||
Different events visited by at least one household member (n)
| 213
| 10.0
| (6;13)
| 58
| 7.5
| (6;12)
| 68
| 10.0
| (6;12)
| 21
| 13.0
| (9;17)
| 42
| 12.0
| (7;14)
| 0.002
|
Events visited by at least one household member (n)
| 213
| 11.0
| (6;15)
| 58
| 8.5
| (6;14)
| 68
| 11.0
| (6;15)
| 21
| 16.0
| (11;22)
| 42
| 14.0
| (10;18)
| 0.004
|
Proportion of possible events per community visited (%)
| 213
| 62.0
| (39;83)
| 58
| 50.0
| (32;80)
| 68
| 62.0
| (44;81)
| 21
| 78.0
| (57;100)
| 42
| 71.0
| (48;94)
| 0.017
|
Events visited by most active household member (n)
| 213
| 6.0
| (4;8)
| 58
| 5.0
| (3;8)
| 68
| 5.5
| (4;8)
| 21
| 9.0
| (6;11)
| 42
| 6.0
| (4;9)
| 0.002
|
Community events visited by at least one household member (n)
| 213
| 5.0
| (3;7)
| 58
| 5.0
| (3;7)
| 68
| 5.0
| (3;9)
| 21
| 5.0
| (3;6)
| 42
| 7.0
| (5;9)
| 0.019
|
Women events visited by at least one household member (n)
| 213
| 2.0
| (1;4)
| 58
| 2.0
| (1;3)
| 68
| 2.0
| (1;4)
| 21
| 7.0
| (2;8)
| 42
| 3.0
| (1;4)
| 0.003
|
School events visited by at least one household member (n)
| 213
| 0.0
| (0;2)
| 58
| 0.0
| (0;2)
| 68
| 0.0
| (0;2)
| 21
| 0.0
| (0;3)
| 42
| 0.0
| (0;3)
| 0.515
|
Household visits by promoting NGO (n)
| 213
| 12.0
| (8;18)
| 57
| 10.0
| (6;19)
| 68
| 13.0
| (9;18)
| 21
| 16.0
| (12;21)
| 42
| 12.5
| (9;18)
| 0.224
|
SODIS campaign at community level
| ||||||||||||||||
Events taken place per community (n)
| 216
| 18.0
| (16;21)
| 60
| 19.0
| (15.5;21)
| 68
| 18.0
| (16.5;21)
| 21
| 21.0
| (17;23)
| 42
| 17.5
| (16;21)
| 0.037
|
Average number of participants per event per community
| 216
| 29.6
| (23.2;40.4)
| 60
| 29.4
| (20.1;40.4)
| 68
| 30.1
| (24.0;48.8)
| 21
| 27.1
| (27.1;30.1)
| 42
| 30.1
| (27.1;40.4)
| 0.071
|
Average duration of events per community (hrs)
| 216
| 3.3
| (2.9;3.8)
| 60
| 3.1
| (2.8;3.6)
| 68
| 3.2
| (2.8;3.7)
| 21
| 3.8
| (3.4;3.8)
| 42
| 3.4
| (3.1;3.8)
| 0.018
|
Predictor | Univariable model (n = 189) (SODIS implementation factor only) | ||
---|---|---|---|
OR | 95% CI* | P value | |
Total no. of events visited by at least one household member | 1.07 | 1.01-1.13 |
0.02
|
Multivariable model (n = 146)
| |||
OR
|
95% CI* |
P value
| |
Total no. of events visited by at least one household member | 1.04 | 0.98-1.11 | 0.15 |
Nr of females per household | 1.18 | 1.07-1.30 |
0.001
|
Household with pregnant women at start of campaign | 1.33 | 0.67-2.64 | 0.41 |
Bicycle ownership | 0.75 | 0.35-1.64 | 0.48 |
Latrine | 3.38 | 1.07-10.70 |
0.04
|
Distance (meters) to water source (log of) | 0.94 | 0.73-1.22 | 0.65 |
Households with at least one wasted child under 5 | 2.17 | 1.34-3.49 |
0.001
|