Introduction
Heterogeneity type | Background information and examples |
---|---|
Spatial | Understanding relevant spatial heterogeneities underlies our ability to map host risk of pathogen exposure. Predictions of disease importation or emergence are limited by our ability to distinguish disease-specific hotspots from continuous risk surfaces. Spatial variation in risk is defined by the specific biology of each host-pathogen relationship. Epidemiologically relevant spatial heterogeneities can be highly specific to each infection and must be correctly identified within the proper context of the ecology and landscape of each host-pathogen relationship. Spatial heterogeneities that impact risk profiles for exposure to a pathogen include large-scale environmental factors, such as temperature, access to water, and rainfall abundance, which can affect host susceptibility (e.g. within the African meningitis belt [4]), host exposure (e.g. proximity to malaria vector habitats [5]), and pathogen viability (e.g. cholera survival in the environment [6]). Within a population, the transmission events of infections drive the spatial progression of an outbreak after the initial exposure to the pathogen has already taken place. Transmission events are rarely observed and risk profiles must be constructed using proxies for transmission, again highlighting characteristics specific to each host-pathogen relationship. Risk profiles for directly transmitted diseases focus on host contacts between infectious and susceptible individuals. Important components of these contacts are host density, susceptibility, and mobility. Each of these factors can also be defined across spatial scales, from within household contact patterns to settlement-level risk factors. Urban and rural residence can be thought of as a basic (yet dichotomized) spatial heterogeneity that is closely associated with density and landscape, but typically urbanization has not been defined in spatial terms. Similarly, transmission of vector-mediated infections is impacted by spatial heterogeneities at the household and community level determined by host density, prevention measures, vector mobility and vector abundance. Spatial patterns of environmentally mediated infections will also be determined by the host-pathogen relationship. |
Temporal | Epidemiologically important temporal heterogeneities will also be specific to each infection. For emerging infections, long-term changes in host settlements, habitat loss, and changing levels of interactions between humans and animal species interactions can define the risk of disease emergence over time [7] (e.g. ebola, SARS, monkeypox, HIV, H1N1 and H5N1 influenza). In other situations, seasonal and environmental factors may determine the population level risk of pathogen exposure (e.g. malaria vector habitats, hyperendemic areas of meningitis). Short-term risk of infection, or transmission of a pathogen within a population, is determined by the biology of the relationships between the host, pathogen and vector. These relationships establish the host susceptibility and infectious periods, and therefore the risk of transmission events. Population level susceptibility profiles (natural or derived) vary across temporal scales with respect to prior exposure and preventative measures. Temporal likelihood of transmission will be determined by length of exposure, and changes in abundance and susceptibility of the host and vector. Exposure and contact rates (density, migration) over the course of a day (as in commuter patterns for influenza [8]) are additional examples of temporal heterogeneities in transmission likelihood and risk across temporal scales. |
Demographic and Socioeconomic | Susceptibility and transmissibility of infectious disease vary across differing demographic and socioeconomic groups due to differences in immunity, mobility, contact patterns and health status. Small-scale variations in socioeconomic and demographic factors can have a large influence on the geographical variation of infections compared to environmental factors. Age represents one of the most significant factors, with risk of morbidity and mortality of many diseases varying substantially across age groups. These include large variations in mortality and morbidity by age for malaria [9] and for clinical attack risk for dengue [10]. Heterogeneities in susceptibility and transmissibility also exist between the sexes, and especially during childbearing age for women, when pregnancy increases the risks of death for both the mother and fetus, and are important for diseases such as congenital rubella syndrome (CRS) [11]. At a population scale, differences in vital rates such as birth rates create heterogeneities in disease risk across space and time, as evidenced by rotavirus in the US [12]. For macro-parasite infections, such as helminths, in addition to environmental risk factors, the population at risk often depends on socioeconomic profiles and access to key infrastructure (housing quality, adequate sanitation and drinking water). For micro-parasite infections with human-to-human transmission, risk is again associated with individual socioeconomic attributes, but also with community/neighborhood attributes. In other words, the concentration of poverty or poor sanitation services increase risk, as evidenced by cholera outbreaks [13]. Finally, in addition to information on poverty status, knowledge of nutritional status is important; malnutrition can increase (i) susceptibility to many infectious diseases, (ii) the period of infectiousness (by reducing immune function and delaying recovery) and (iii) disease associated mortality [14]. |
Usages of spatial demographic data in epidemiology
Improving estimates of children under 5 years at risk of Plasmodium falciparummalaria
Transmission Class | U5PAR1: UN Nationwide adjusted | U5PAR2: Census unit adjustments | Percentage change from U5PAR1 to U5PAR2 |
---|---|---|---|
PfPR < 5% | 770547 | 650174 | −15.62175961 |
PfPR = 5–40% | 4315638 | 3383040 | −21.6097365 |
PfPR > 40% | 773992 | 630518 | −18.5368841 |
Spatial demographic data to meet needs
Data (standard survey name)/source | Time intervals | Typical spatial coverage | Typical strata | Relevant variables |
---|---|---|---|---|
Census | ||||
National Statistical Offices | Typically 10 years | Census enumerator area or courser level | Urban/rural, race or ethnic groups (often) | Sex, age, education, migration status, household and dwelling characteristics |
Census Microdata | ||||
Typically 10 years | Admin 1-3 | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, migration status, children ever born, children surviving | |
DHS (Demographic and Health Survey) | ||||
Household, women 15–49, men 15–59, children born in the last five years | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 5 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for most recent surveys (last 15 years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, maternal and child health, fertility and full birth history, family planning, domestic violence, biomarkers, nutrition | |
MICS (Multi-indicator cluster survey) | ||||
UNICEF (Round 2, 1999–2001; round 3 2005–2007; round 4 is in the field 2009–present) | National, Admin 1 | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, status, maternal and child health, child labor, domestic violence, summary birth history, anthropometry | |
LSMS (Living Standard Measure Survey) | ||||
(Integrated Household Budget Survey and many others that are locally adapted) | ||||
Irregular | National, Admin 1, some GPS coordinates | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, migration status,consumption, expenditures, income, nutrition,anthropometry, summary birth history | |
MIS (Malaria Indicator Survey) | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 3 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for some surveys (last five years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, biomarkers | |
AIS (AIDS Indicator Survey) | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 3 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for some surveys (last eight years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, biomarkers | |
DHS (Demographic and Health Survey) | ||||
Household, women 15–49, men 15–59, children born in the last five years | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 5 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for most recent surveys (last 15 years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, maternal and child health, fertility and full birth history, family planning, domestic violence, biomarkers, nutrition | |
MICS (Multi-indicator cluster survey) | ||||
UNICEF (Round 2, 1999–2001; round 3 2005–2007; round 4 is in the field 2009-present) | National, Admin 1 | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, status, maternal and child health, child labor, domestic violence, summary birth history, anthropometry | |
LSMS (Living Standard Measure Survey) | ||||
(Integrated Household Budget Survey and many others that are locally adapted) | ||||
Irregular | National, Admin 1, some GPS coordinates | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, migration status, consumption, expenditures, income, nutrition, anthropometry, summary birth history | |
MIS (Malaria Indicator Survey) | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 3 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for some surveys (last five years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, biomarkers | |
AIS (AIDS Indicator Survey) | ||||
Varies by country, typically every 3 years | National, Admin 1/region, GPS coordinates of cluster locations for some surveys (last eight years) | Urban/rural | Household and dwelling characteristics, sex, age, education, biomarkers |
Designing a spatial demographic database
Feature | Example dataset | Example dataset source |
---|---|---|
National boundaries | SALB | |
Administrative boundaries | GADM | |
DHS boundaries | MEASURE DHS | |
Coastlines | GBWD | |
Water bodies | SWDB | |
Land cover | GlobCover | |
Protected areas | WDBPA | |
Urban extents | MODIS | |
Settlement locations | NGA Geonames | |
Elevation and slope | SRTM | |
Infrastructure | gRoads |