Background
Methods
Eligibility criteria
Types of report
Participants
Intervention and comparison groups
Outcome measures
Search strategy and study selection
Data extraction and analysis
Risk of bias
Sub-group analysis
Results
Description of trials with follow-up reports
Location | Trial | Randomisation scheme | Pregnant women allocated (MMN and Fe60 Fol groups only) | Mean duration from LMP to beginning of supplementation and when supplementation stoppeda | Control content | Intervention contentb | Mean maternal BMI (kg/m2) | Main results from original trial paper (intervention effect relative to comparison group) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bangladesh JiVitA | West et al. [26] | Cluster | 127,282 women under pregnancy surveillance; 44,567 pregnancies recruited in 596 clusters | Median at enrolment 9 weeks until 12 weeks after birth | Iron 27 mg, folic acid 600 μg | Vit A, thiamine, riboflavin, vit B3, vit B6, folic acid, B12, vit C, vit D, vit E, copper, iodine, iron, selenium, zinc | Mean BMI unknown; proportion < 18.5 40 % | Birthweight, + 54 g (95 % CI, 41–66 g) SGA RR, 0.98 (95 % CI, 0.96–1.01) Gestation, 0.30 weeks (95 % CI, 0.21–0.40 weeks) Neonatal mortality RR, 0.98 (95 % CI, 0.88–1.20) |
Bangladesh MINIMat | Persson et al. [27] | Individual | 1478 | 102 days until birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg and “usual” food supplementation | UNIMMAP and “usual” food supplementation | 20.3 | Birthweight in MMN, 2710 g (95 % CI, 2675–2745 g) Birthweight in control, 2665 g (95 % CI, 2631–2699 g) Gestation in MMN, 39.1 weeks (95 % CI, 38.9–39.3 weeks); gestation in control, 38.8 weeks (95 % CI, 38.6–39.0 weeks) Perinatal mortality RR, 0.95 (95 % CI, 0.59–1.5) Neonatal mortality RR, 1.1 (95 % CI, 0.64–2.0) |
Burkina Faso | Roberfroid et al. [23] | Individual | 1428 | 125 days until 3 months after birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg | UNIMMAP; also randomly assigned to receive either chloroquine 300 mg weekly or sulfadoxine 1500 mg and pyrimethamine 75 mg once in 2nd and 3rd trimesters as malaria chemoprophylaxis | 20.9 | Birthweight, + 41 g (95 % CI, –11 to 94 g), adjusted for malaria prevention and health centre SGA, 0.83 (95 % CI, 0.65–1.07), adjusted for malaria prevention and health centre Gestation, –0.04 weeks (95 % CI, –0.38 to 0.29 weeks), adjusted for malaria prevention and health centre Perinatal mortality OR, 1.78 (95 % CI, 0.95–3.32) Neonatal mortality OR, 2.1 (95 % CI, 0.78–5.64) |
China | Zeng et al. [28] | Cluster | 3811 women in 104 clusters | 96 days until birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg | UNIMMAP | 20.9 | Birthweight in MMN, 3198 g; birthweight in control, 3174 g SGA in MMN, 16.9 %; SGA in control, 18.9 % Gestation in MMN, 39.8 weeks; gestation in control, 39.8 weeks PMR in MMN group, 50.9; PMR in control group, 36.9 NMR in MMN group, 12.4; NMR in control group, 10.7 |
Guinea Bissau | Kaestel et al. [24] | Individual | 1403 | 158 days until birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg | UNIMMAP; if haemoglobin concentration < 70 g/L, given additional iron 60 mg daily; all women received insecticide-treated bednets, weekly antimalarial prophylaxis and malaria treatment if needed | 23.3 | Birthweight, + 53.0 g (95 % CI, –19 to 125 g) Perinatal mortality OR, 0.82 (95 % CI, 0.53–1.26) Neonatal mortality OR, 1.18 (95 % CI, 0.66–2.11) |
Indonesia | Shankar et al. [29] | Cluster | 31,290 women, 262 randomly assigned midwives | 146 days until 90 days after birth | Iron 30 mg, folic acid 400 μg | UNIMMAP | Not recorded | Birthweight, + 21 g (95 % CI, –11 to 53 g) Perinatal mortality RR, 0.90 (95 % CI, 0.79–1.03) Neonatal mortality RR, 0.90 (95 % CI, 0.76–1.06) |
Mexico | Ramakrishnan et al. [25] | Individual | 873 children born in the trial were subsequently randomised to receive postnatal multiple micronutrients or iron and vitamin A supplements | 69 days until birth | Iron 60 mg; no supplements on Sundays | Vit A, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, vit B6, folic acid, vit B12, vit C, vit D3, vit E, iron, magnesium, zinc; no supplements taken on Sundays | 24.1 | Birthweight in MMN, 2981 g; birthweight in control, 2977 g SGA in MMN, 10.1 %; SGA in control, 11.8 % Gestation in MMN, 39.5 weeks; gestation in control, 39.6 weeks |
Nepal Janakpur | Osrin et al. [30] | Individual | 1200 | 112 days until birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg | UNIMMAP; if haemoglobin concentration < 70 g/L, given extra iron 60 mg daily and anthelminthic treatment; if symptoms of night-blindness, vitamin A 2000 μg | 19.9 | Birthweight, + 77 g (95 % CI, 24–130 g) Gestation, 0.2 weeks (95 % CI, –0.1 to 0.4 weeks) PMR in MMN, 49.0; PMR in control, 40.5 NMR in MMN, 30.6; NMR in control, 20.0 |
Nepal Sarlahi | Christian et al. [34] Christian et al. [31] | Cluster | 14,036 women under pregnancy surveillance; 2007 pregnancies recruited in 169 clusters | 80 days until 12 weeks after birth | Iron 60 mg, folic acid 400 μg, Vit A 1000 μg | Vit A, thiamine, riboflavin, vit B3, vit B6, folic acid, vit B12, vit C, vit D, vit E, vit K, copper, iron as ferrous fumerate, magnesium and zinc; albendazole was offered in 2nd and 3rd trimesters | 19.3 | Birthweight in MMN, 2659 g; birthweight in control, 2652 g SGA in MMN, 53.8 %; SGA in control, 51.7 % PMR in MMN group, 87.1; PMR in control group, 62.4 NMR in MMN group, 54.0; NMR in control group, 36.3 |
Follow-up reports
Location | Follow-up study | Age at follow- up | Eligibility/exclusion criteria for follow-up | Risk of bias in loss to follow-up | % follow-up in control groupa | % follow-up in intervention groupa | Outcome measures |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bangladesh JiVitA | West et al. [26] | 6 months | None reported | 5 infants lost to follow-up; assumed to be alive at 180 days | 100 % | 100 % | Mortality assessed at 1, 3 and 6 months |
Bangladesh MINIMat | Persson et al. [27] | 5 years | None reported | None | No reported losses | No reported losses | Mortality assessed at 5 years |
Khan et al. [42] | 54 months (monthly to 1 year 3 monthly to 2 years) | Singletons | None; imputation used for missing data points | 79.9 % of livebirths; 86.5 % of children with birth anthropometry | 78.3 % of livebirths; 87.9 % of children with birth anthropometry | Length or height, weight | |
Khan et al. [45] | 54 months | Singletons with birth anthropometry | Children lost more likely to be first born and have lower birthweight | 72.3 % children with birth anthropometry | 70.9 % children with birth anthropometry | Mid-upper arm circumference, skinfold thickness, body composition by bioelectrical impedance | |
Tofail et al. [48] | 7 months | Subgroup of singletons born May 2002 to December 2003 | Small but significant differences in children lost to follow-up; mothers had fewer children, higher haemoglobin and shorter gestation; no significant difference in these between allocation groups | Unable to calculate as the number of deaths is only provided for all allocation groups combined | Unable to calculate as the number of deaths is only provided for all allocation groups combined | Cognition (‘Support test’ and ‘Cover test’) Motor development (Psychomotor Developmental Index of Bayley Scales of Infant Development) Behaviour (modified Wolke in three domains: activity, emotion and vocalization) | |
Hawkesworth et al. [46] | 4 years (mean 4.6 years) | Singletons born at term with birth anthropometry | Children lost to follow-up more likely to have been firstborn and their mothers on average ~9 months younger with 6 months longer education | 69.1 % of livebirths; 73.6 % of children with birth anthropometry | 67.9 % of livebirths; 74.0 % of children with birth anthropometry | Blood pressure, kidney size by ultrasound (restricted to individuals born during the second half of MINIMat trial, June 2003 to June 2004), and glomerular filtration rate (restricted to individuals born during first y of MINIMat trial, June 2002 to June 2003) | |
Burkina Faso | Roberfroid et al. [35] | Monthly to 12 months and 30 months | Singletons | None | 97.8 % | 98.0 % | Length, weight, head, chest and mid-upper arm circumference |
China | Wang et al. [41] | 3 monthly to 12 months, 6 monthly to 30 months | Subgroup born in middle year of 3.5 years recruitment; congenital disease excluded (n = 3) | Not specified | 84.9 % of selected subgroup | 81.3 % of selected subgroup | Length, weight |
Li et al. [49] | 3 monthly to 1 year | Subgroup born in middle year of 3.5 years recruitment | Small difference in Apgar scores | 89.7 % of selected subgroup | 88.6 % of selected subgroup | Cognition Mental and Psychomotor development (Bayley Scales of Infant Development) | |
Li et al. [50] | 7–9 years | Singletons; children who moved away were excluded | None | 61.0 %b | 60.7 %b | Cognition Mental development (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children) | |
Guinea Bissau | Andersen et al. [36] | 0–2 years | None reported | Lost to follow-up different for maternal weight, age, height and parity; no difference between trial groups | 77.1 % | 77.8 % | Mortality by routine surveillance every 3 months up to 1 year and every 6 months after 1 year |
Indonesia | Prado et al. [37] | 42 months | 2369 of 41,839 women enrolled randomly assigned to blood tests; children of 549 of these women who gave birth in a 6 month period | None reported | 94.5 % of selected subgroup | 92.8 % of selected subgroup | Cognition Adapted, validated tests for motor, language, visual attention/spatial, executive and socio-emotional function; adjusted analyses presented: confounders included ‘home observation and measurement of environment’ inventory score, child haemoglobin, mother’s mid-upper arm circumference, birth weight, MMN adherence |
Mexico | Ramakrishnan et al. [38] | 3 months 24 months | Singletons; children from antenatal trial subsequently randomised to receive MMN or iron + Vit A | Lost to follow-up younger mothers, more educated and less parous | 24.9 % of livebirths in childhood randomisation control group; 69.3 % of children randomised in childhood control | 26.2 % of livebirths in the childhood randomisation MMN group; 74.2 % of children randomised in childhood control | Height, weight, head circumference |
Nepal Janakpur | Vaidya et al. [43] | 2–3 years | None reported | Difference in lost to follow-up in maternal education, urban/rural residence and main household occupation | 85.8 % | 86.5 % | Height, weight, head, chest, waist, hip and mid-upper arm circumferences, skinfold thickness, blood pressure |
Devakumar et al. [39] | 7–9 years | None reported | Small difference in lost to follow-up in maternal education and urban/rural residence | 80.5 % | 79.2 % | Height, weight, body composition by bioelectrical impedance, skinfold thickness, head, chest, waist, hip, mid-upper arm and upper leg circumferences, kidney dimensions, blood pressure | |
Devakumar et al. [52] | 7–9 years | None reported | Small difference in lost to follow-up in maternal education and urban/rural residence; small number (n = 5) with learning difficulties unable to complete spirometry | 80.5 % | 79.2 % | Spirometry, respiratory illness, asthma | |
Nepal Sarlahi | Stewart et al. [44] | 6–8 years | 3669 also in subsequent childhood trial of iron, folic acid and zinc | Lost to follow-up more likely to be of Pahadi (hill) ethnicity, have a literate mother and own a radio, and less likely to own cattle | 89.2 % | 91.2 % | Height, weight, mid-upper arm circumference, waist circumference, skinfold thickness |
Stewart et al. [47] | 6–8 years | 3673 also in subsequent childhood trial of iron, folic acid and zinc | Loss to follow-up did not differ between groups; large number did not complete all tests; children with missing data less likely to be of Pahadi ethnicity or to have had any schooling, and had slightly lower BMI | Overall 84.1 %; number of participants varied for each test or measurement | Overall 85.1 %; number of participants varied for each test or measurement | Metabolic syndrome BMI, waist circumference, blood pressure, HbA1c, urine microalbumin:creatinine, cholesterol, glucose, insulin, homeostasis model assessment | |
Christian et al. [51] | 7–9 years | In control group of subsequent iron and zinc pre-school trial; children followed up in this study represent 23 % of live births in relevant allocation groups in the original trial | Main loss to follow-up was exclusion of children taking part in postnatal supplementation trial; children lost more likely to be of Pahadi ethnicity, literate mother, own a radio and less likely to own cattle | 75.2 % of subgroup | 84.2 % of subgroup | Cognition Universal Non-verbal Intelligence Test Movement Assessment Battery for Children Finger-tapping test Executive Function (Stroop Numbers Test, backward digit span, go/no-go) Environment (Middle Childhood Home Observation for the Measurement of the Environment inventory) Maternal intelligence (Raven Coloured Progressive Matrices) | |
Christian et al. [40] | 6–8 years | None reported | None reported | 96.1 % | 96.0 % | Mortality |
Mortality
Location | Follow-up study | Deaths in control groupa | Livebirths in control group | Deaths in intervention groupa | Livebirths in MMN group | Mortality differencea MMN – control, per 1000 livebirths (95 % CI) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bangladesh, JiVitA | West et al. [26] | 764 625 neonatal 139 at 29–180 days | 14,142 | 741 626 neonatal 115 at 29–180 days | 14,374 | –2.5 (–8.1 to 3.1)b |
Bangladesh, MINIMat | Persson et al. [27] | 33 23 neonatal 10 post-neonatal to 5 years | 612 | 34 25 neonatal 9 post-neonatal to 5 years | 595 | 3.2 (–22.6 to 29.0) |
Burkina Faso | Roberfroid et al. [35] | 45 7 neonatal 38 post-neonatal to 30 months | 644 | 55 11 neonatal 44 post-neonatal to 30 months | 650 | 14.7 (–14.3 to 43.8) |
Chinac | Wang et al. [41] | 16 16 neonatal 0 in children born in 2004 | 1499 | 20 18 neonatal 2 in children born in 2004 | 1469 | 6.10 (–3.9 to 17.3)b |
Guinea Bissau | Andersen et al. [36] | 57 25 neonatal 9 at 29–91 days 10 at 92–365 days 13 at 366–730 days | 519 | 65 29 neonatal 6 at 29–91 days 21 at 92–365 days 9 at 366–730 days | 528 | 13.3 (–25.8 to 52.4) |
Indonesiac | Prado et al. [37] | 580 infant 17 in subsample | 14,053 | 490 infant 12 in subsample | 14,373 | –13.2 (–33.4 to 7.1)b |
Mexicoc | Ramakrishnan et al. [38] | 7 6 early deaths 1 in control group of childhood randomisation | 460 | 4 4 early deaths | 456 | –10.30 (–29.30 to 6.60) |
Nepal Janakpur | Devakumar et al. [39] | 22 12 neonatal 6 post-neonatal 4 at 1–8 years | 564 | 23 17 neonatal 4 post-neonatal 2 at 1–8 years | 567 | 1.6 (–21.2 to 24.3) |
Nepal Sarlahi | Christian et al. [40] | 54 34 before 91 days 20 at 91 days to 7 years | 773 | 81 52 before 91 days 29 at 91 days to 7 years | 872 | 23.0 (–5.2 to 51.3)b |
Anthropometry
Follow-up study | Weight difference (z scores) | % Underweight (< –2 z scores) | Height difference (z scores) | % Stunted (< –2 z scores) | Weight-for-height/length or BMI for age | % Wasted or low BMI (< –2 z scores) | Body composition and skin fold thickness | Body circumferences | Blood pressure | Other | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bangladesh MINIMat | Khan et al. [42] Anthroa | Calculated difference: 0 (–0.114 to 0.114) | Calculated difference: –0.01 (–0.13 to 0.11) | 4.8 % (0.8–8.9) more stunting across all measurements | Calculated difference: Wt-for-ht z score, 0.01 (–0.09 to 0.11) | ||||||
Khan et al. [45] Body compa | Lean mass, 0.000 kg (–0.123 to 0.125 kg); fat mass, 0.001 kg (–0.058 to 0.061 kg); no difference in biceps, triceps, subscap or suprailiac skinfold thicknesses | Calculated difference: head, 0.02 cm (–0.20 to 0.24) MUAC, 0.11 cm (–0.04 to 0.26 cm) | |||||||||
Hawkesworth et al. [46] | Compared to 30 mg iron control adjusted for iron intervention dummy and food intervention variables: Systolic, 0.05 (–0.71 to 0.81); Diastolic, 0.55 (–0.10 to 1.20) | No difference in kidney volumes compared to 30 mg iron | |||||||||
Burkina Faso | Roberfroid et al. [35] | 0.13 (–0.01 to 0.27)b | Hazard ratio in 1st year of life 0.84 (0.70, 1.02) c | –0.02 (–0.18 to 0.14)b Length for age was significantly higher in the first year, but this disappeared by 30 months | Hazard ratio in 1st year of life, 0.73 (0.60–0.87)c | 0.20 (0.06–0.34)b Wt-for-ht was lower initially but higher in MMN from ≥ 10 months | Hazard ratio in 1st year of life, 1.10 (0.90–1.35)c | MUAC for age z, 0.18 (–2.93 to 3.29)b | |||
China | Wang et al. [41] | Pooled (1–30 months) adjusted difference: 0.03 (–0.05 to 0.10)d | Pooled (1-30 months) adjusted. OR 0.95 (0.71, 1.29) d | Pooled (1–30 months) adjusted difference, 0.02 (–0.07 to 0.10)d | Pooled (1–30 months) adjusted; OR, 0.82 (0.63–1.07)d | Pooled wt-for-length (1–30 months) adjusted difference, 0.03 (–0.05 to 0.11)d | Pooled wt-for-length (1–30 months) adjusted; OR, 0.89 (0.58–1.36)d | ||||
Mexico | Ramakrishnan et al. [38] | Calculated difference: –0.1 (–0.34 to 0.14) | Calculated difference: 0.2 (–0.08 to 0.48) | Calculated difference: Wt-for-ht –0.2 (–0.42 to 0.02) | Calculated difference: head, 0.2 cm (–0.42 to 0.82) | ||||||
Nepal Janakpur | Vaidya et al. [43] | 0.14 (0.00–0.27) | 37.8 % in control, 36.6 % in MMN | 0.08 (–0.06 to 0.22) | 60 % in control, 56.7 % in MMN | Wt-for-ht 0.12 (–0.02 to 0.26) | 5.5 % in control, 6.3 % in MMN | Triceps, 0.20 mm (0.00–0.40 mm) | Head, 0.24 cm (0.06–0.43 cm); MUAC, 0.24 cm (0.11–0.37 cm) | Systolic, –2.5 mmHg (0.47–4.55 mmHg); Diastolic, –1.5 mmHg (–3.1 to 0.4 mmHg) | |
Devakumar et al. [39] | 0.05 (–0.09 to 0.19) | Not recorded by trial group | 0.02 (–0.10 to 0.15) | Not recorded by trial group | BMI for age 0.04 (–0.09 to 0.18) | Not recorded by trial group | Lean mass, –0.05 kg (–0.43 to 0.34 kg); fat mass, –0.07 kg (–0.32 to 0.18 kg); no difference in biceps, triceps, subscapular and suprailiac skinfold thicknesses | Head, 0.18 cm (–0.02 to 0.38); MUAC, 0.04 (–0.15 to 0.23 cm) | Systolic, 0.02 mmHg (–1.02 to 1.05 mmHg); Diastolic, 0.13 mmHg (–0.93 to 1.19 mmHg) | No difference in kidney dimensions; exclusion of children with chronic or major illness made no difference | |
Nepal Sarlahi | Stewart et al. [44] | Calculated difference: –0.04 (95 % CI, –0.15 to 0.07)e | Calculated difference: 0.3 % (95 % CI, –5.4 to 6.0)e | Calculated difference: –0.02 (–0.13 to 0.09)e | Calculated difference: 3.7 % (–2.0–9.4)e | BMI for age calculated difference: –0.04 (–0.14 to 0.06)e | Triceps: FeFol + vit A, 5.84 mm; MMN, 5.9 mm; Subscap: MMN, 4.81 mm; FeFol + vit A 4.75 mm | MUAC: FeFol + vit A, 15.4 cm; MMN, 15.4 cm | |||
Stewart et al. [47] | Waist: FeFol + vita A, 51.27 cm; MMN, 51.22 cm | Systolic: FeFol + vit A, 95.2 mmHg; MMN, 95.5 mmHg; calculated difference, 0.29 mmHg (95 % CI, –0.65 to 1.23)d Diastolic: FeFol + vit A, 63.9 mmHg; MMN, 64.4 mmHg; calculated difference, 0.56 mmHg (95 % CI, –0.38 to 1.50)d | Non-fasting glucose: FeFol + vit A, 3.91 mmol/L; MMN, 3.86 mmol/L; LDL: FeFol + vit A, 1.89 mmol/L; MMN, 1.84 mmol/L; HDL: FeFol + vit A, 0.72 mmol/L; MMN, 0.70 mmol/L; at risk for metabolic syndrome: FeFol + vit A, 12.2 %; MMN, 11.9 % |