Nutritional status of tuberculosis patients, a comparative cross-sectional study

Underweight is a malnutrition stage in which the body mass index (BMI) of adult scores less than 18.5 KG/M² cuts-points [1, 2]. It results from an imbalance between the supply of food and the body demands for the nutrients. Conditions like genetics, metabolism disorders, medication side effects, eating disorders, and tuberculosis predispose to underweight [3, 4].

Tuberculosis (TB) is an infectious disease caused by mycobacterium TB species. According to the world health organization (WHO), tuberculosis attacks 10 million people and kills 1.3 million people every year [5]. The association between TB and malnutrition is bi-directional, TB predisposes the patient to malnutrition and malnutrition increases the risk of developing active TB by 6 to 10 folds [6‐11]. One-quarter of TB in the world was as a result of malnutrition, improving the nutritional status of the individual decreases the risk of TB [12]. Additionally, malnutrition increases TB relapse and mortality [13‐20].

The treatment outcomes of TB patients can be improved by studying their nutritional status [13, 20]. Incorporating nutritional support during directly observed treatment strategy (DOTS) increases the probability of favorable treatment outcomes [16, 19, 21‐27].

The prevalence of malnutrition in the South American continent range from 20 - 50% [28, 29], in the Asian continent malnutrition among TB patient ranges from 68.6 - 87% [11, 20] and in the United Kingdom, the body mass index of TB patients was 13% lower than the general community [18]. On the African continent, 29 - 61% of TB patients were malnourished [14, 24, 30‐33].

The tuberculosis treatment guideline neglects the nutritional supplementation part of an intervention. Priority was not given by decision-makers as a result of evidence scarcity. This study will generate baseline information to give priority to the nutritional intervention part of TB treatment.

The objectives of this research were to estimate and compare the proportion of underweight and their determinants among the TB patients in a resource-limited setting.

A comparative cross-sectional study design was implemented. This study was conducted in Amhara regional state of Ethiopia. The region contains 25,000,000 population and every year more than 25,000 tuberculosis cases are reported from the health facilities. The target population was TB patients receiving the DOTS in the health centers of the Amhara region. New TB patients diagnosed during the data collection method were included. TB patients not willing to participate during the study and TB patients unable to communicate properly were excluded. The nutritional status of TB patients was compared with TB free residents. The sample size was calculated using Epi-info software version 7 assuming 95% CI, 90% power, the proportion of malnutrition in TB patients 50%, TB patients to TB free resident ratio of 3, the design effect of 2 and a 5% non-response rate [6, 34]. Finally, the estimated sample size was 1806 TB patients and 3612 TB free residents. The systematic random sampling technique was used to select TB patients from the selected governmental health facilities. Ethiopia adopts the tree health tier system; primary level health care (including the health center and district hospital and expected to serve up to 100,000 population), secondary level health care (includes the general hospital and expected to serve up to 1.5 million population) and the tertiary level health care (includes the specialized referral hospitals and expected to serve up to 5 million people). TB free residents were selected randomly from the community from the nearby house of the TB patients. The data were collected from July 2015–May 2018.

The data were collected using patient interview, measuring anthropometric indicators and collecting the stool and blood samples. The stool samples were collected to adjust for the effect of intestinal parasites on nutritional status because, in resource-limited settings like Ethiopia, intestinal parasites are the main predictor’s malnutrition. The blood samples were collected to see the effect of anemia on underweight because literature reports their relationship. For the patient interview part, the questionnaire was prepared in English then translated to Amharic (local language) then back to English to keep its consistency. The interview was conducted by 30 diploma nurse professionals and supervised by 8 degree holder health professionals. Weight and height of each study participant were measured by clinical nurses. Digital weight scale was used to measure the weight of each study participant and weight was measured to the nearest 0.1 kg. Height was measured using the vertical measuring rod to the nearest 0.1 cm. The participants’ shoes, hair clips, and braids were removed during the measurement. Participants were positioned feet together, feet flat on the ground, heels touching the backplate of the measuring instrument, legs straight, buttocks against the backboard, scapula against the backboard and arms were loosely at their side [1, 35].

The blood and stool samples were collected by 13-degree holder laboratory technologists and supervised by second-degree holder laboratory technologists. For each study participant, one gram stool sample was collected in 10 ml SAF (sodium acetate-acetic acid-formalin solution) and transported with a preservative to the regional laboratory. A concentration technique was used. The stool samples were well mixed and filtered using a funnel with gauze, then centrifuged for one minute at 2000 RPM (revolution per minute) and the supernatant was discarded. 7 ML (Milliliter) normal saline was added, mixed with a wooden stick, 3 ML ether was added and mixed well then centrifuged for 5 min at 2000 RPM. Finally, the supernatant was discarded and the whole sediment was examined for parasites. 5 ML blood sample was collected from a study participant following standard operating procedures to measure the hemoglobin concentration and the red cell indices of patients using Mindray hematology analyzer [36]. CAGE tool was used to assess the problematic alcohol use. Study participants unable to read and wrote were labeled as illiterate.

To maintain the quality of the data pretest was conducted, training was given for data collectors and supervisors. The whole data collection processes were closely supervised by the investigators and supervisors.

The data were entered in the computer using Epi-info software transferred into SPSS software version 20 and WHO Anthro-plus software for the analysis. Descriptive statistics were used to identify the proportion of malnutrition. Binary logistic regression was used to identify the determinants of malnutrition. Variables with a p-value less than 0.05 were declared as predictors of malnutrition. Body mass index (BMI) was used to assess nutritional status. BMI was computed as = weight (in kilogram)/ (height in meter) ². BMI less than 18.5 KG/M² was considered underweight [1].

Ethical clearance was obtained from the University of Bahir Dar ethical review committee. Formal permission was obtained from the Amhara National Regional State Health Bureau ethics committee and the respective authorities. Written informed consent was obtained from each study participant. The confidentiality of the data was kept at all steps. Study participants the right to withdraw from the study at any points were respected. Study participants with intestinal parasites or low hemoglobin concentration were linked to the nearby health facility.

A total of 5045 study participants was included giving for the response rate of 93.1%, 286 study participants did not volunteer to participate and 87 study participants were excluded due to incomplete data. The mean age of the study participants was 28 years (standard deviation [SD] ±14 years), 18 year was the youngest age of study participants, 1681 of the study participants was TB patients and 3364 of the study participants were TB free residents. Female constitute 53.9% (2721) of the study participants, 26% of the study participants were from the urban area, 90% of the study participants were Amhara by ethnicity and 96.7% of the study participants were Orthodox Christian believers.

The prevalence of underweight among TB patients was 57.17%; the prevalence of underweight among TB free residents was 23.37%. This proportion was statistically significant (X² 565.8, P-value < 0.01). This finding indicates that 33.8% of excess malnutrition was observed as a result of TB. This is because TB infection increases the anabolic process and consumes additional energy [37], additionally, TB infection manifests with a reduction in appetite, nutrient malabsorption, finally increasing the risk of underweight [34].

The prevalence of anemia among TB patients was 88.52%; the prevalence of anemia among TB free residents was 51.78%. TB patients had a 36.74% excess burden of anemia as compared to the residents. This result was statistically significant at X² 656.7 p-value < 0.01. This is due to the effect of TB on red blood cell production like decreasing the erythrocyte lifespan, poor erythrocyte iron incorporation, and decreased sensitivity to our supply of erythropoietin [38].

The odds of malnutrition among extra-pulmonary TB patients were 47% higher than pulmonary TB patients. This finding was in line with finding from Nepal [39]. This is due to the reason that the diagnosis of extra-pulmonary TB is not easy as compared to pulmonary TB and patients were not early detected for the intervention [40]. The odds of malnutrition were 2.5 times higher in female TB patients than male TB patients. This finding agrees with finding from Ghana [20]. This is due to the reason that the severity of TB was more virulent in female [41]. Additionally, Male could have better access to food compared to the female who might need to prioritize their families, especially their children.

The odds of malnutrition among TB patients were 3.84 folds higher in the urban areas than the rural. This finding disagrees with finding from India [42]. This is due to the reason that most urban residents in Ethiopia were living in the overcrowded condition [43].

The odds of malnutrition were 7 folds higher among intestinal parasites infected TB patients than intestinal free TB patients. This finding agrees with finding from Butajira [44]. This is because intestinal parasites decrease the food intake, interfere with the absorption of nutrients and they share the host nutrients [45].

TB patients with problematic alcohol use had 1.52 fold higher risk of becoming malnourished than non-alcoholic TB patients. This finding agrees with research finding from Tanzania [46]. This is due to the reason that alcoholic patients eat poorly, had poor digestion, storage, use, and excretion of nutrients [47].

The odds of malnutrition among anemic TB patients were 3.23 folds higher than non-anemic TB patients. This finding agrees with finding from Brazil [48]. This is due to the effect of red blood cells in the transportation of nutrients and minerals [49].

The odds of malnutrition were 3.23 folds higher among TB patients whose age was greater than 25 years. This finding agrees with finding from Ghana [33]. This is due to the reason that the risks of co-morbid illness like non-communicable diseases were higher in old age [50].

The odds of malnutrition were 1.96 folds higher among HIV positive TB patients than HIV negative TB patients. This finding agrees with finding from Tanzania [46]. This is due to the reason that HIV positive patients were not economically productive so that they can’t get the access to the different variety of foods [51], HIV positive patients have a poor appetite, poor absorption of nutrients [52, 53].

The odds of malnutrition were 15.75 folds higher among TB patients with family size greater than 4. This finding agrees with finding from India [20]. This is because high family size decreases the household income leading to the low dietary intake of household members [54].

Believe in avoiding a certain type of foods (mostly animal products) increase the odds of malnutrition by 3.19 folds. This finding was in line with finding from Ghana [55]. This is due to the reason that patients will not take important nutrients due to their behavior of avoiding that type of food [56].

Family size and believe in avoiding a certain type of food were not the predictors of malnutrition among the tuberculosis-free residents, but these variables were the predictors of malnutrition among TB patients. These show that TB patients are very susceptible to malnutrition even the very distal reason for malnutrition in the community became a proximal reason for TB patients.

The limitation of the study might be related to the cross-sectional nature of the study, which makes difficult to find whether the exposure precedes the outcome. However, this limitation works only for modifiable variables thought time. Since we used patient interview methods, recall bias might occur, however, we included only newly diagnosed TB patients which significantly drop the recall bias.

A very high proportion of TB patients were malnourished. TB patients were highly susceptible to malnutrition and even a very distal factor for malnutrition became proximal for TB patients. The nutritional status of TB patients was affected by the site of infection, sex, residence, intestinal parasite infection, alcohol.