In this report, we elucidate the origin of the enrichment and subsequent expansion of NK cells from human PBMCs using
3a-G1 phosphonate-capped dendrimers [
22]. Therefore, we focused our analysis on the first two weeks of culture although the expansion procedure requires 4 weeks to provide suitable amounts of cells for clinical purposes. Such amplified NK cells are perfectly cytotoxic against the K562 cell line but also a broad range of other tumor cell line. Although this has not been checked systematically, we did found that mid-term amplified NK are also cytotoxic against the K562 cell line and that
3a-G1 doesn't affect their cytotoxicity when compared with untreated cells [see Additional file
1]. Contrary to expectation, we could not demonstrate any significant activation of proliferation of pure NK cells exposed to
3a-G1. Conversely, we showed that during the first week of culture,
3a-G1 mainly acts by inhibiting CD4
+ T cell proliferation without affecting NK cells. In terms of cell expansion, we found that NK cells are normally competing with CD4
+ T cells when PBMCs are exposed to interleukin-2 and that
3a-G1 cancels this competition. Therefore, the decreased CD4
+ T cell representation results in more nutrients and cytokines for the expansion of NK cells. We propose that the higher proliferation status of NK cells when PBMCs are exposed to
3a-G1 (Fig.
1) is mainly due to an increase in the availability of IL-2 that has not been consumed by proliferating T cells. Supporting our hypothesis, other investigators have described the use of anti-CD3 antibodies and IL-2 as a method for the
in vitro expansion of human NK cells from PBMCs [
27]. No clues were provided about the origin of this process but it suggests that targeting T cells to some extent sustains the expansion of NK cells from PBMCs. Interestingly; we demonstrated that like such antibodies,
3a-G1 dendrimers specifically interacts with CD4
+ T cells. We believe that this interaction might drive the inhibition of CD4
+ T cell proliferation observed not only among PBMCs but also when pure CD4
+ T cells were stimulated with anti-CD3/CD28 coated beads. Molecular determinants are still needed regarding the mode of action of
3a-G1 but given its structural features, it is tempting to speculate that
3a-G1 could act by triggering Sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P) receptors. Indeed, there is some evidence that S1P regulates T cell proliferation [
28]. Interestingly, the phosphate moiety was shown to be important for this effect. To address that point, we are now concentrating our effort in the synthesis of a biotin analogue of
3a-G1 to perform pull-down experiment on CD4
+ T cell protein extracts with the aim of identifying by proteomics the molecular determinants of
3a-G1 regulatory activity. Furthermore, Miller and colleagues have described the importance of monocytes in the expansion of human NK cells from IL-2 treated PBMCs [
29]. We have shown that depleting monocytes from PBMCs prevents CD4
+ T cell proliferation. In agreement with Miller's report, we also found that NK cells are less able to proliferate when monocytes are depleted from PBMCs. Therefore, monocytes are supporting the
ex-vivo expansion of both cell types. Interestingly, we showed that monocytes rapidly engulfed phosphorus-containing dendrimers and consequently become activated [
19,
20]. We have addressed the particular mode of activation of these monocytes highlighting an immune-suppressive phenotype on mixed leukocyte reaction [
21] that could sustain the inhibition of T cell proliferation although we have shown here, using anti-CD3/CD28 microbeads, that monocytes are not required for regulatory activity of phosphonate-capped dendrimers. Again, Miller and colleagues showed that CD5
+ and CD8
+ cell depletion led to higher NK cell expansion yield providing support that T cells constitute a barrier for the expansion of NK cells. IL-2 stimulation of PBMCs was shown to elicit absolute expansion of NK cells and CD56
+ T cells, e.g. NK-T cells, γδ T cells and some αβ/CD8
+ T cells [
30]. The combination of IL-2 and
3a-G1 in our hands also led to a generally slightly higher representation of γδ-T cells (data not shown) but we were never able to detect any NKT (Vα 24
+) cell or CD8
+ T cell expansion under our conditions. In contrast, we found that a proportion of CD4
+ T cells that became activated under IL-2 stimulation were presenting a regulatory T cell phenotype e.g. CD25
+/FoxP3
+/CD127
low
, the best up to date combination to characterise regulatory T cells [
26]. Such in vitro induction of T regulatory activity by stimulated human CD4
+/CD25
- has already been described [
31].
In vivo, regulatory T cells play an important role in maintaining peripheral tolerance and preventing auto-immunity but they could also affect anti-tumor immunity by notably acting on NK cell activity [
23,
24]. Then, the presence of regulatory T cells during the process of NK cell expansion by
3a-G1 would have had a highly detrimental effect. Interestingly, the inhibition of CD4
+ T cell activation by
3a-G1 is global and also affects the accumulation of these phenotypically related regulatory T cells. Although it can't be excluded that the presence of few remaining regulatory T cells could have a detrimental effect for the activity of infused NK cells
in vivo, it does not affect the cytotoxic property of the expanded NK cells
in vitro against classical tumor cell lines [
22].