Erschienen in:
01.04.2010 | Letter
Relatives' evaluation in older patient's quality of life
verfasst von:
Jean-Pierre Tourtier, Ghislain Edjo Nkilly, Karim Tazarourte
Erschienen in:
Critical Care
|
Ausgabe 2/2010
Einloggen, um Zugang zu erhalten
Excerpt
We would like to congratulate Tabah and colleagues for their study concerning the quality of life (QOL) after intensive care unit (ICU) discharge in older patients [
1]. One could assume that obtaining information from the patient at ICU admission was rarely possible (due to critical illness or decreased consciousness) and that mostly family members provided responses. On the contrary, QOL 1 year after ICU discharge was evaluated directly from the patient. This change in evaluators, however, could be identified as a potential weakness. The tendency of relatives to underestimate the mental health of older patients has been observed [
2]. Scales and colleagues found agreement between acute respiratory distress syndrome survivors and their substitute decision-makers to be poor for all the domains of the Short Form-36 [
3]. Rothman and colleagues concluded that the agreement of relatives was so poor in the psychosocial aspects of patients' QOL they could not be used as reliable proxies [
4]. …