Background
Methods
Realist evaluation
Organisation Type: Community Anchor Organisation (Voluntary sector) |
Location: Inner-city area of high socioeconomic deprivation in a city in the north of England |
Referral type: General Practitioners and other services refer direct to the organisation. Self-referral is also possible. Triage worker signposts to the most appropriate service, based on the client’s personal goals rather than the doctor’s determination of the problem. In 2018, there was a total of 1372 referrals; 813 from General Practitioners, 207 self-referrals, 315 from other sources (e.g. housing, community mental health teams) and 37 whose referral status was not recorded. The number of clients with a mental health condition is not recorded; however, in 2018, 56 clients enrolled on the coping and self-management programme and 59 enrolled on the emotional well-being programme |
Services provided: Advice and services around health, employment and training. For the purposes of this study, we only considered the health section: this includes health training (e.g. weight loss or health eating advice, alcohol or cigarette reduction and exercise advice), social café’s, benefits and housing advice, and volunteer work. There is no set pathway through the service. Clients can access different services at different times in whatever order meets their needs. The service has no time limit |
Staff team: Paid health trainers, health activity workers and advocacy workers (primarily giving benefits and housing advice) and unpaid volunteers. Any of the paid workers could be a link worker, this would be decided based on client goals. Clients with predominantly health goals would have a health trainer as a link worker. Once these goals were met, the client may be referred to other colleagues if needed, for example for benefits advice. The person acting as link worker would change |
Care pathway: New clients are screened by the in-house triage service to ensure the client is seen by the right part of the service to meet their goals. It is possible to move from one service to another or see multiple workers at one time depending on the nature of the client’s personal goals. The service also includes social café’s, which can take referrals or clients can drop in. You can attend the social café concurrently with other one to one services |
Data collection
Phase 1: interviews
Phase 2: stakeholder workshop
Analysis
The realist methodology uses the following approaches judiciously and in combination: |
---|
• Organizing and collating primary data and producing preliminary thematic summaries of these |
• Repeated writing and rewriting of fragments of the case study |
• Presenting, defending, and negotiating particular interpretations of actions and events both within the research team and also to the stakeholders themselves |
• Testing these interpretations by explicitly seeking disconfirming or contradictory data |
• Considering other interpretations that might account for the same findings |
• Using cross-case comparisons to determine how the same or submechanism plays out in different contexts and produces different outcomes, thereby allowing inferences about the generative causality of different contexts |
From Greenhalgh, T., Humphrey, C., MacFarlane, F., Bulter, C., & Pawson, R. (2009) |
Results
Participants
Interviews | |
Referrers | N = 6 (general practitioners, practice nurse, 2 male, 4 female) |
Staff | N = 13 (1 manager, 4 health trainers, 3 advisors, 3 volunteer coordinators 2 triage, 6 males, 6 females, one preferred not to say) |
Clients | N = 15 (12 clients, 3 clients who also volunteer, 5 males, 9 females, 1 preferred not to say) |
Focus group | |
Referrers | N = 5 (community mental health team, housing, social work) |
Staff | N = 7 (2 managers, health trainers, advisors) |
Clients | N = 3 (2 male and 1 female) |
Modification of the IPT
Non-stigmatising environments
SP [organisations] are there for people with low confidence (C) so they’re not going to look down on you (M). Client 1Chatting to people (M), you know you’re not on your own (M). You know you’re not the only person who’s had problems (C/M). Client 3
Person-centred care
When someone is new to the service (C), it’s crucial that we do it in an approached manner (M) that we can do it at their speed, (M) feeling comfortable about it (O), giving confidence that they can do it (M), and allowing that to flourish (O) and say ‘come on, we can move forward’ (M). So, it’s empowered them (O), they’ve got to make that choice (M) and they’ve got to make those decisions but it’s about being supportive isn’t it (M), to doing it. And that’s what I see my role, is supporting people and moving them on to next… every individual has structured management plan (O), speaks for itself. Every one’s different. It’s not my plan. It’s their plan (M). Staff 11
Social isolation
It’s building my confidence up great (C/O). I’m making loads of friends (O). I mean, I’m in a craft group but I don’t really do much crafting when I’m It’s more chatting (M) and helping the others (M), so it’s lovely, and they’re just so friendly(M). Client 14Instead of once a fortnight, they’re going to somewhere twice a week now (O) so there’s, there’s always something for them to do (M) and it brings them together (M), I mean they say to me, things like oh, if I didn’t come here I’d have nowhere else to go (O), I’d be sat, four walls (C), I don’t know what I’d do if I didn’t have this group, and that type of thing. Staff 7
Wider determinants of health
We can even do a home visit (Intervention), because even asking someone to come and see us here for the first time is daunting (C). so I think with us, slotting in with them (M), I see it as like a jigsaw, so it just all slots in because they see us and we look at the barriers to health and put them steps in first and work through them with them (M), and then it’s just giving them that bit of self-belief that they can do something and show them how they can make small changes that that’s leads to bigger things so by us being there, they can then move on to volunteering (O) and then move on to employment advocacy (O), if they are on [employment and support allowance] they can help them sort out the benefits and what have you but then they can refer back into us again, to say well actually they are on ESA but they are looking at wanting to return to work but they have got no confidence (C), you know, so we sort of can keep seeing them (M). Staff 9
Poor interagency communication
I think that would make a huge difference, because if a [General Practitioner] was to log in and see that they're working with social prescribers and they're going to groups and this has happened and that has happened, then we can work and keep encouraging them to go, you know those sort of things. General Practitioner 2Very often there’ll be interruptions in claims, benefits will get suspended. If I could talk to [the Council] at that time when the client’s here I could stop that happening, whereas now… the letters’ll be god knows where… and in the meantime you know the benefit might get suspended… If I could talk to them I could solve a lot of problems because I can put in a nutshell what the client might struggle to sort of want to put across. Staff 3