Toll-like receptor 9polymorphisms are associated with severity variables in a cohort of meningococcal meningitis survivors

The susceptibility, severity and prognosis of infectious diseases depend on the ability of the host immune system to respond to pathogens. Genetic variation of immune response genes is associated with susceptibility to and severity of infectious diseases [1]. Bacterial meningitis (BM) is a serious and life-threatening infectious disease of the central nervous system (CNS). Despite adequate antibiotic treatment and immunization strategies, mortality remains high, especially in developing countries [2, 3]. Neisseria (N.) meningitidis is a common causing pathogen of BM, both in the Western world as in developing countries. The clinical course of meningococcal meningitis (MM) is highly diverse and depends both on pathogen characteristics as on the individual immune response of the affected patient. Host-bacteria interactions are crucial in defense against MM [4]. Acquisition of N. meningitidis may lead to bacterial colonization in one patient and to fatal MM or meningococcal septic shock in the other. Survivors of BM have a high risk to develop neurological sequelae, ranging from subtle learning and behavioral disorders to deafness, paresis, and severe encephalopathy [5‐7]. Innate immunity is of particular importance as first line of defense since it quickly senses pathogen invasion by pattern recognition and subsequently initiates the immune response. Toll-like receptors (TLRs) are a class of pathogen recognition receptors (PRRs) that are key players of innate immunity. It becomes increasingly clear that TLR mediated meningeal inflammation is a pivotal factor for meningitis associated tissue damage [8]. TLR9 is an intracellular PRR which recognizes unmethylated Cytosine-phosphate-Guanine (CpG) motives in pathogen DNA [9]. Meningococcal CpG DNA enters TLR9 expressing cells by endocytosis and then binds to TLR9. A cascade of intracellular receptor signaling via myeloid differentiation protein 88 (MyD88) induces activation of transcription of nuclear factor kappa B (NFkB) resulting in the production of cytokines and chemokines [10]. TLR9 is present in phagocytosing microglia and antigen presenting astrocytes inside the CNS, cells responsible for adequate immune responses in this compartment [11]. In a previous study we demonstrated that the TLR9 +2848 SNP is associated with a decreased susceptibility to MM [12]. Recent studies showed that carriage of the TLR9 -1237 C variant allele creates a potential nuclear factor kappa B (NFκB) binding site that increases the transcriptional activity of TLR9 and enhances cellular production of pro-inflammatory cytokines [13].

The purpose of this study is to compare the genotype distributions of TLR9 -1237 and TLR9 +2848 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) between thirteen clinical severity variables in order to identify patients at risk for severe disease and sequelae.

The study population consists of 390 Dutch Caucasian children who survived MM. These patients were identified by the Dutch Reference Laboratory for Bacterial Meningitis. The diagnosis of MM was based on a positive cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) culture with N. meningitidis or meningococcal antigens in the CSF. A total of 560 children were asked to participate in the study and to return a sterile swab after collecting their buccal DNA, of whom 390 patients (70%) returned a buccal swab and informed consent form. Patients were diagnosed between January 1990 and December 1995 and this cohort was previously described in detail by Koomen et al.[6, 7]. A similar validation cohort of 76 children developed BM between 1997 and 2001 [14]. Data for our study were collected in the period from 2006 till 2010. Median age at infection was 2,5 (range 0.1 – 9.5) years, 46.5% were female, 53.5% were male. Data on medical history, physical examination, clinical course during hospitalization, and laboratory results were gathered from the medical records of all patients.

Children with ‘complex onset’ of meningitis (defined as meningitis secondary to immune deficiency states, cranial trauma, CNS surgery, and CSF shunt infections), relapsing meningitis, or meningitis in the neonatal period were excluded.

The Medical Ethical Committee of the VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands approved this study.

TLR9 -1237 (rs5743836) and TLR9 +2848 (rs352140) SNPs were analyzed in buccal DNA by TaqMan analysis using the standard TaqMan protocol. The AbiPrism® 7000 Sequence Detection System (Applied Biosystems, UK) was used to obtain data. Primers and probes we used have been described previously [12]. The two TLR9 SNPs were chosen based on a study by Lazarus et al. In three ethnic groups they found 20 TLR9 SNPs. A set of four frequent TLR9 SNPs (TLR9 -1486, TLR9 -1237, TLR9 +1174 and TLR9 +2848) accounted for more than 75% of all chromosomes in all three populations. Genotyping of both TLR9 -1237 T > C and TLR9 +2848 G > A allows all four locus haplotypes to be distinguished [15].

We performed a literature search to identify severity variables. We used clinical variables: duration of clinical illness before admission, rectal temperature, convulsions, level of consciousness at admission, ICU admission, main clinical diagnosis at discharge (meningitis or meningitis with sepsis), and post meningitis hearing loss. Convulsions were defined as convulsions reported before or at admission or during hospitalization. Post meningitis hearing loss was defined as > 25 dB perceptive hearing loss that was not present before meningitis occurred. Laboratory variables at admission included: blood culture results, CSF leukocyte numbers, CSF/blood glucose ratios, CSF protein concentrations, blood leukocyte numbers, and C-reactive protein (CRP) concentrations in serum. The selected variables were in accordance with a recent systematic review summarizing the evidence regarding prognostic factors predicting death or sequelae after BM in children [16]. We distinguish continuous and dichotomous variables. Continuous variables were dichotomized according to clinical relevant cut off points known from the literature i.e. duration of clinical illness before admission > 2 days, rectal temperature ≥ 38°C, CSF leukocyte numbers > 600 and > 1000 [17, 18], CSF blood/glucose ratio ≤ 0.4, CSF protein concentration > 0.7 g/L, blood leukocytes > 20x10^9 g/L, and serum CRP concentration > 100 mg/L [16].

Within selected severity groups, we compared the distribution of TLR9 -1237 and +2848 genotypes. For statistical analysis, SPSS for Windows 17.0 and Graphpad Prism 5 were used. Genotype distributions were checked for deviations of the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE). Recessive and dominant models were used to model the relations between genotype distributions and clinical variables. Histograms were used to assess normality of the clinical variables. T-tests, Mann–Whitney U tests, and χ² test or Fisher’s exact tests were used where appropriate. Outliers (< 4%) were excluded by the Grubbs’ test (p < 0.01) before continuous testing. P values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

Table 1 shows the distribution and characteristics of the severity variables in the study population. Differences in numbers of patients are due to missing or non-determined data in patient records.

Continuous variables i.e. duration of clinical illness, rectal temperature, CSF leukocyte numbers, CSF/blood glucose ratios, CSF protein concentrations, blood leukocytes, and serum CRP concentrations were compared between carriers of wild type (WT) alleles and mutant alleles in MM patients for TLR9 -1237 and TLR9 +2848 respectively. Figure 1A shows that CSF leukocyte numbers were significantly higher in MM patients carrying the TLR9 -1237 TC or CC genotypes compared to carriers of the TT WT genotype (median 2117, interquartile range (IQR) 4987 versus median 955, IQR 3938).

CSF/blood glucose ratios were significantly lower in TLR9 -1237 TC or CC carriers than in carriers of the TT WT (p = 0.017, median 0.20, IQR 0.4 versus median 0.35, IQR 0.5) (Figure 1B). CSF leukocytes/μL were significantly higher in patients carrying the TLR9 +2848 AA mutant compared to children with genotype GG or GA. (p = 0.0067, median 1907, IQR 5221 versus median 891, IQR 3952) (Figure 1C). There was no significant difference in CSF/blood glucose ratios for TLR9 +2848 genotypes (results not shown).

No significant differences in genotype distributions of −1237 and +2848 SNPs were found for the other continuous variables (data not shown).

Dichotomous variables, i.e. blood culture, convulsions in patient history, level of consciousness at admission, ICU admission, sepsis and hearing loss and the dichotomized continuous variables (as described above) were compared between WT carriers and mutant carriers. TLR9 -1237 TC or CC mutant carriers were compared to the TT WT carriers. Significant associations are shown in Table 2. The TLR9 -1237 TC and CC genotypes were associated with a decreased incidence of a positive blood culture for N. meningitidis (p = 0.014, odds ratio (OR) 0.5, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.3 – 0.9). These genotypes were also associated with CSF leukocyte levels > 1000 per μL (p = 0.029, OR 1.7, 95% CI 1.1 – 2.8), and with a CSF/blood glucose ratio ≤ 0.4 (p = 0.015, OR 2.0; 95% CI 1.1 – 3.6).

TLR9 +2848 mutant carriers were compared with WT carriers. Significant associations are shown in Table 3. TLR9 +2848 AA was associated with a decreased incidence of a positive blood culture (p = 0.017, OR 0.6, 95% CI 0.3 – 0.9). The TLR9 +2848 AA mutant was also significantly more present in children with > 600 and > 1000 leukocytes per μL (p = 0.028, OR 1.7, 95% CI 1.1 – 2.9 and p = 0.005, OR 2.0, 95% CI 1.2 – 3.2 respectively).

Table 4 shows that TLR9 haplotype I was very significantly associated with blood cultures positive for N. meningitidis (p = 0.001, OR 1.5, 95% CI 1.1 – 2.0). Haplotype I was also significantly associated with decreased CSF leukocytes (less than 1000/μL: p = 0.03; OR 0.7 95% CI 0.5–1.0). No significant differences in haplotype distribution were observed for other severity variables (data not shown).

We demonstrate that the TLR9 -1237 and +2848 SNPs are associated with severity variables in a cohort of MM survivors. In order to assess the biological consequence of this statistical association we focus on the essential steps in BM pathogenesis and the recognition of N. meningitidis by TLR9. Meningococci colonize the nasopharynx and may penetrate the mucosal barrier of the upper respiratory tract by transcellular passage of epithelial cells [19]. During this process meningococci are recognized by intracellular TLR9 of sinonasal epithelial cells [20]. After passage of this epithelial barrier meningococci are able to pass directly from the nasopharynx to meninges through the olfactory nerve system but more frequently they will enter the bloodstream [21]. Survival of bacteria within the circulation is a prerequisite for meningeal invasion. Complement-mediated opsonophagocytosis of N. meningitidis leads to activation of phagocytosing cells via TLR9 [22]. Upon survival in the bloodstream meningococci may attach to and traverse the blood–brain barrier by endocytosis, they will multiply in the subarachnoidal space and are recognized by astrocytes and microglia, dendritic cells and macrophages of the brain respectively and in direct contact with the CSF [23]. After being phagocytosed, meningococcal DNA motifs activate endosomal TLR9 and subsequent signal transduction occurs, stimulating the production of cytokines inside the CNS and chemokines leading to leukocyte recruitment towards the CNS [24, 25].

We associated TLR9 SNPs with protection against meningococcemia, a prerequisite for meningeal invasion, and with elevated CSF leukocyte levels during MM. A decreased incidence of positive blood cultures in children carrying TLR9 -1237 C allele and TLR9 +2848 AA genotypes may represent a reduction in the occurrence of secondary bacteremia due to more pronounced host immune response in the CSF. A possible mechanistic explanation and biological consequence is increased NFκB binding to the TLR9 promotor region, leading to increased transcriptional regulation of TLR9[13]. We confirmed this mechanism in our study population using a novel in silico regulatory SNP detection method as described by McIntyre et al.[26]: The TLR9 -1237 “C” variant was associated with significantly increased binding of NFκB, avian reticuloendotheliosis viral oncogene homolog A (RelA) and signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT3) to the TLR9 -1237 C variant (Figure 2). According to these predictions, the TLR9 -1237 C allele creates an increased affinity for NFκB which in its turn increases the transcriptional activity of the gene, leading to enhanced production of cytokines and chemokines. This effect was present in stimulated cells, but not under basal conditions, which may explain an association of TLR9-1237 with severity, but not susceptibility to MM. Carvalho et al. reported that the C allele of TLR9-1237 introduced a new IL-6-dependent transcription factor binding site in the TLR9 promoter. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) harbouring the TC genotype show higher expression of both TLR9 and IL-6 and increased B-cell proliferation in response to CpG [27]. Another study showed higher serum Interferon gamma levels in children carrying the TLR9-1237-C allele with cerebral malaria, indicating that enhanced TLR9 mediated immune responses are also relevant inside the CNS [28]. The +2848 SNP does neither result in an amino acid change nor to the modification of a regulatory site, implying linkage of a functional relevant SNP in the vicinity of this SNP.

In a mouse meningococcal bacteremia model the role of TLR9 in preventing bacteremia was also confirmed. TLR9 KO mice displayed reduced survival and elevated levels of bacteremia compared to WT mice [22]. We associated TLR9 polymorphisms with prevention of bacteremia and higher levels of leukocytes in the CSF. The link between systemic inflammation and pleocytosis was previously studied. Intravenous injection of LPS prior to intracisternal LPS injection in rabbits led to impaired pleocytosis, reduced levels of TNF-α, and impaired leukocyte influx into the CNS reflecting an impaired inflammatory response in the CNS [29].

Clinical studies show that the most severely affected patients with MM or septic shock with a rapidly evolving septic shock associated with high mortality have significant lower levels of pleocytosis [30]. Although we found an association of TLR9 SNPs with bacteremia, no association was found with clinical sepsis. We propose that TLR9 -1237 and +2848 polymorphisms have a beneficial effect on preventing bacteremia and increase the leukocyte influx in the CNS, reflecting an enhanced immune response inside the CNS.

Although CNS inflammation is necessary to guarantee sterility of the CNS, its injurious properties are also evident. An adequate but balanced inflammatory response inside the CNS is essential in limiting adverse outcome of disease. We concluded that TLR9 polymorphisms have a small but possibly important contribution to warrant balance between beneficiary and injurious effects of inflammation in the CNS. For exact consequences of these SNPs, future studies focussing on TLR9 SNPs and long term consequences of BM should be performed.

This study does have certain aspects that limit the interpretations. Survivors of MM were retrospectively included in our study. DNA from children with fatal meningitis were not a focus of our study because including survivors of MM allows us to obtain detailed information on follow-up and long term consequences of the disease which are of particular clinical relevance. In addition, the number of patients with fatal meningitis is very low in The Netherlands. The effect of treatment of BM was not incorporated in this study. This effect may not be of great influence since comparable protocols for treatment of BM were used nationwide in the period these children have been admitted to Dutch hospitals, and timing of treatment is divided equally between groups and independent of genotype distribution.

Multidisciplinary efforts are needed in order to bundle and translate genetic studies into beneficial interventions (personalized medicine, risk profiling, disease treatments with better specificity and innovative drug therapies) enforced by the field called Public Health Genomics [31].

We have performed several statistical analyses and therefore also performed corrections for multiple testing. Using the rough false discovery rate (rFDR) would shift the threshold for statistical significance from <0.05 to <0.026, reducing the number of significant associations described in this paper. Using the more conservative Holm-Bonferroni corrections, shifts the threshold to <0.002, resulting in one remaining significant association (TLR9 haplotype I and N. meningitidis). Although the multiple testing corrections reduce the number of statistically significant associations of the exploratory study, the trends that remain give indications for potential roles of the studied variables in the severity of bacterial meninigitis.

In this study, TLR9 -1237 and TLR9 +2824 mutant genotypes were associated with protection against meningococcemia, an essential prerequisite for meningeal invasion. We also associated these SNPs with enhanced local inflammatory responses inside the CNS. Carriers of the TLR9 + 2848 mutant genotype have a lower chance of developing meningitis when colonized with N. meningitidis. When they eventually do so, they will have more efficient bacterial killing inside the CNS but may also result in a higher chance of developing neurological sequelae.