We investigated the prevalence and characteristics of defective mismatch repair (dMMR) in colorectal cancer (CRC) patients who would potentially benefit from anti-programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1) immunotherapy. Medical records were obtained and reviewed for 1147 patients who underwent surgical resection of stage I–IV CRC, in whom universal screening for Lynch syndrome using immunohistochemistry for MMR proteins had been undertaken. The molecular characteristics of dMMR CRCs were also investigated. Defective MMR accounted for 5.2% of stage I–IV CRC patients, including 12 (1.0% of all CRC patients) who had stage IV disease or recurrence after curative resection (n = 6 each). These 12 patients included patients with LS (n = 3) and Lynch-like syndrome (n = 1). Defective MMR tumors were predominantly located in the right-sided colon (P < 0.01). Approximately 1% of stage I–IV CRC patients could potentially benefit from anti-PD-1 immunotherapy, while one-third would require genetic counseling and/or MMR gene testing.