Introduction
TNF-α Mechanism of Action
Types and Mechanism of Action of TNF-α Blockers
Clinical Uses of TNF-α Blockers
Anti-TNF-α Blockers’ Trials for Multiple Sclerosis
Side Effects of TNF-α Blockers
TNF-α Effect on Demyelination
Theories About the Mechanism of Action of Anti-TNF-α Therapy in CNS Demyelination
Reviewed Cases
CASE REPORTS | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
citation | Sex/age | Family history of MS | diagnosis | Previous treatments | antiTNFa | Exposure time (m) | Type of demyelination | MRI lesion | OCB | Anti-TNF-a cessation | Therapy | Recovery | Disease progression | Total followup (m) |
50 | F/33 | No | RA | NR | ETN | 24 | MS | Brain, CSC gd + | NR | Yes | none | Partial (4 m) | MRI progression (+gd) | 12 |
51 | F/47 | Yes | PsA | MTX, LEFL, folic acid | IFX | 7 | MS | Brain, SC gd+ | Yes | Yes | Pulse MP | partial | After 1y new relapse steroids = IVIG no improvement. Therapy MITO | 12 |
57 | F/40 | No | RA | MTX | ADM | 2 | MDE | Brain + SC gd+ | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | No | 14 |
62 | F/45 | NR | CD | NR | IFX | 10 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (3 m) | No | 3 |
62 | F/55 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 13 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (3w) | no | 0,75 |
62 | M/54 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 3 | ON bilateral | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | NR | NR |
62 | F/62 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 3 | ON bilateral | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | NR | NR |
62 | M/54 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 2 | ON bilateral | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | NR | NR |
62 | F/50 | NR | CD | NR | IFX | NR | ON | NR | NR | Yes | None | Complete (1,5 m) | no | 1,5 |
62 | F/45 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 11 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (3 m) | no | 3 |
62 | F/12 | NR | JIA | NR | ETN | 2,5 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (3 m) | no | 18 |
62 | F/17 | NR | JIA | NR | ETN | 8 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (2 m) | no | 20 |
62 | F/21 | NR | JIA | NR | ETN | 18 | ON bilateral | NR | NR | No – ETA | Pulse steroids | No | no | 6 |
62 | M/18 | NR | JSpA | NR | ETN | 11 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (1w) | no | 14 |
62 | F/31 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 4 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (1 m) | no | 12 |
62 | M/55 | NR | RA | NR | ETN | 3 | ON bilateral | Brain gd- | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (1w) | no | 12 |
62 | M/55 | NR | PsA | NR | ADM | 4 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (1w) | no | 12 |
62 | M/40 | NR | RA | NR | ADM | 12 | ON | Brain + SC gd- | NR | No –ADA | None | Partial | 4 | |
63 | M/48 | NR | CD | MTX, SUL, LEFL, PREDN | ADM | 12 | ON | Brain ON | NR | Oral steroids | Complete (1 m) | No | 12 | |
64 | F/48 | NR | RA | NR | ETN | 42 | TM + PM | Brain nm | No | 4 m after | Oral steroids + amitriptyline | No | No | 6 |
65 | M/66 | NR | RA | LEFL, HCQ, MTX | ADM, MTX | 3 | leukoencephalopathy | Brain gd- | No | 2 m after | Oral steroids + meloxicam | Partial | No | 1,67 |
66 | F/66 | NR | RA | DMARDs | ETN | 24 | MDE | Brain + CSC gd+ | No | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | No | 1 |
67 | F/32 | NR | RA | MTX | ADM | 23 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Partial | MRI progression After 3 m gd+, MS diagnosis | 3 |
68 | F/68 | No | RA | GST, D-P, Buc, Sal MTX, PREDN, NSAIDs | ADM | 23 | MS | Brain | NR | 3w prior | None | Complete recovery | 2w after MRI + gd | 12 |
69 | M/56 | NR | RA | PREDN, MTX, Buc | IFX, MTX, PREDN | 2,5 | MDE | Brain, CSC gd + | No | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | no | 9,5 |
69 | F/66 | No | RA | PREDN, MTX | IFX, MTX, PREDN | 4 | MDE | Brain, SC gd+ | No | Yes | Oral PREDN | Partial | no | 3 |
70 | F/58 | NR | RA | MTX | ETN | >12 | MDE | CSC gd- | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete 3w | no | 12 |
71 | F/41 (ON 9y before) | NR | AS | Indomethacin, PREDN | ETN | 6 | MS | Brain gd- | Yes | Yes | none | Complete | no | 3 |
72 | F/5 | NR | Still | Naproxen, MTX, steroids | ETN | 12 | MDE | Brain gd + | No | Yes | NR | NR | NR | 6 |
73 | M/43 | No | RA | NR | IFX | 24 | MDE | Brain gd - | No | Yes | None | Complete 1 m | RA worsened | 16 |
73 | F/47 | No | RA | PREDN, MTX | ADM | 48 | MDE | Brain gd- | Yes | 5 m later | None | No | No | 2 |
73 | F/49 | No | RA | MTX | ETN | 11 | MDE | Brain gd+ | Yes | 1 m later | none | No | RA progression (MTX, HCQ). New MS relapses (INFb1a) MS diagnosis | 18 |
74 | F/42 | NR | CIAU | MTX, mycophenolate mofetil | ADM | 0,75 | MS | Brain gd+ | Yes | Yes | Pulse MP | Complete (<1 m) | immunomodulatory therapy | 6 |
75 | F/53 | No | RA | PREDN, MTX, SULF, LEFL | IFX | 1,5 | ON | NR | NR | NR | Pulse steroids | Complete | NR | NR |
76 | M/53 | No | PsA | PREDN, MTX, NSAIDs | ETN,MTX | 6 | MDE | Brain, SC gd- | Yes | Yes | INFb 3times/w + baclofen | Partial | Symptom progression., MS diagnosis Steroids and INFb1a | 24 |
76 | M/42 | No | PsA | MTX, steroids, SULF | ETN | 21 | MDE | CSC gd+ | No | Yes | MTX + daily steroids | RA poorly controlled, symptom progression MS diagnosis | 36 | |
76 | F/51 | NR | AS HLAB27+ | MTX, PREDN, NSAIDs | ETN | 18 | MS | Brain, SC gd+ | No | Yes | None | partial | No | 24 |
77 | F/36 | No | PsA | MTX, PREDN | ETN | 4 | ON | Brain gd- | No | Yes | Pulse MP | Partial 1w | After 6 m peripheral facial palsy and MRI progression | 6,5 |
78 | F/35 | Yes | UC | SULF, PREDN, 6-MP, CYC | IFX | 18 | MS | Brain, SC gd + | Yes | Yes | None | NR | NR | NR |
79 | F/32 | NR | JRA | NR | ETN | 2 | Autoimmune leukencephalopathy | Brain gd- | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids, PLEX, IVIG, CYC, AZA, PREDN | partial | No | 12 |
79 | F/51 | NR | CD | NR | IFX, ADM | IFX 12, ADM 24 | TM | Brain gd- | NR | Yes | None | No | No | 10 |
79 | F/61 | NR | RA | NR | ETN | 48 | ON | Brain gd + | NR | Yes | None | Partial | No | 6 |
79 | F/42 | NR | PsA | NR | ETN, ADM | ETN 48, ADM 4 | ON bilateral | Brain, SC gd+ | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | partial | No | 8 |
79 | F/27 | NR | CD | NR | IFX, ADM | IFX 36, ADM 6 | Polycranial neuritis, rhombencephalitis, | Brain gd+ | Yes | Yes | None | Partial | No | 6 |
79 | F/61 | NR | NLD | NR | IFX | 9 | TM | Brain,SC gd+ | No | Yes | Pulse steroids | Partial | No | 6 |
79 | F/61 | NR | Ps | NR | ETN | 72 | TM | Brain, SC, gd - | NR | Yes | Glatiramir acetate, INFb-1a | No | Progressive symptoms, MS diagnosis | 36 |
79 | F/44 | NR | AS, Graves | NR | IFX | 7 | TM | SC gd- | - | Yes | Pulse steroids | partial | No | 18 |
79 | F/69 | NR | RA | NR | IFX | 7 | TM | SC gd- | - | Yes | Pulse steroids | partial | No | 18 |
80 | M/55 | NR | PsA | MP | ETN | 26 | MDE | Brain, SC gd - | + | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | LEFL | 3 |
80 | M/44 | NR | AS HLAb27+, Ps, UC | NR | ADM | 16 | ON bilateral | Brain gd- | - | 1 month later | None | NR | NR | NR |
81 | F/26 | No | CD | 6-MP, steroids | IFX ADM | IFX 6 ADM 4 | MS | Brain gd - | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | New MRI lesions at 6w = PLEX | 48 |
82 | M/57 | NR | RA | NR | IFX, MTX, PREDN | 4 | MDE | Brain gd - | No | Yes | Pulse MP, PLEX | DIED | - | - |
83 | M/69 | NR | RA | CYC, HCQ, steroids, | IFX | NR | PML | Brain gd - | NR | Yes | None | DIED | - | - |
84 | M/72 | NR | RA | PREDN, HCQ, MTX | IFX, MTX, PREDN | 60 | PML | Brain gd- | NR JC - | 2,5 m later | Supportive therapy | No | No | NR |
85 | F/23 | NR | SLE, RA | PREDN, HXQ | ETN | 48 | PML | Brain gd - | NR JC+ | Yes | Cytosine arabinoside | DIED | - | - |
86 | M/44 | NR | AS HLAB27+ | MTX, LEFL | ETN | 11 | Tumefactive demyelinating lesions | Brain gd + | No | Yes | PLEX, craniectomy | No | No | 6 |
87 | M/34 | NR | AS HLAB27+ | NSAIDs | ETN | 30 | MDE | Brain, CSC gd- | NR | Yes | None | No | New gd + lesion in 10 m, MS diagnosis | 10 |
88 | M/32 | NR | CD, HLAb27- bilateral sacroilitis | AZA, MES, oral steroids | IFX, oral steroids | 1,5 | MS | Brain, SC gd- | Yes | INFb, AZA, PREDN | Complete | No | 6 | |
89 | M/55 | No | CD | AZA, MES | IFX | 10 | ON | NR | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Partial | No | 2 |
90 | F/39 | NR | RA | NR | IFX, MTX | 0,1 | ON | Brain gd+ | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Partial | No | 5 |
91 | F/51 | NR | UC | MES, PREDN, AZA | IFX | 17 | ON | Brain gd+ | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | No | 1 |
92 | M/68 | NR | CD | NR | IFX | 1,5 | ON bilateral | Brain nm | No | Yes | Pulse steroids | No | No | 5 |
93 | F/44 | NR | PsA | NR | Golimumab + LEFL | Tumefactive lesions | Brain gd + | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Partial | Later MS diagnosis and therapy with dimethyl fumarate | 16 | |
94 | M/35 | NR | PsA | NR | ETN, IFX | IFX 8 | MDE, peroneal palsy | Brain, CSC gd- | NR | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete (2 m) | NR | 2 |
94 | F/45 | NR | RA | NR | ADM | 6 | ON | Brain nm | NR | Yes | None | Complete (2 m) | Flare of RA – restarted ADM – second ON | 4 |
Index case 1 | M/17 | No | PsA | NR | ETN | 8 | MS | Brain, SC gd+ | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | MRI progression, MS relapses, PsA progression (CYC) | 48 |
Index case 2 | M/27 | Yes | AS | NSAIDs | ADM | 36 | MS | Brain, CSC gd + | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | MRI progression, AS progression (no treatment) | 48 |
Index case 3 | F/46 | No | PsA | NR | ETN | 48 | MDE | Brain, CSC gd - | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | No PsA progresson -HCQ | 48 |
Index case 4 | F/57 | No | AS | NR | ETN | 72 | MS | Brain, CSC gd+ | Yes | Yes | Pulse steroids | Complete | No | 36 |
REVIEWS | ||||||||||||||
citation | N | Sex (n) | Mean age in years (SD) | Diagnosis (n) | antiTNFa agent (n) | Mean exposure time (months) | Type of demyelination (n) | Therapy | Recovery | Mean follow-up (months) | ||||
30 | 20 | F12/M 8 | 43,5 (9,27) | RA (11), PsA (4), JRA (2), other (3) | IFX (2), ETN (18) | 5 | MS (4), ON (7), MDE (10), other (4) | Pulse streroids (4), oral steroids (4), IVIG (2), PLEX (1), lfuoxetine (1), INFb-glatiramer acetate (1), NR (8) | Complete (4), partial (6), no (4), NR (5) | 4 | ||||
95 | BIOBADASER | 14 | F 9/ M 5 | 51 (11) | RA (9), AS (2), PsA (3) | IFX (8), ETN (5), ADM (1) | 17 | MS (1), ON (4), MDE (9) | Steroids (3), none (3), INFb (1) | Complete (5), partial (1), no (7), NR (1) | NR | |||
95 | FEDRA | 19 | F 10/ M 9 | NR | RA (10), AS (3), PsA (4), other (2) | IFX (11), ETN (6), ADM (2) | 12 | MS (9), ON (8), MDE (2) | NR | Complete (7), no (8), NR (4) | NR |