Rationale
Methods
Search strategy
Eligibility criteria
-
Published in English with a publication date of 1990 forward.
-
Patients with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases.
-
Fully-published primary studies (all study designs for primary data collection included; e.g., RCT, non-randomized trials, cohort studies, case–control studies or case series).
-
Any study evaluating the use of WBRT, SRS, surgical excision, or chemotherapy alone or in combination.
-
Number of study participants with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases >5 per study arm for comparative studies and >5 overall for non-comparative studies.
-
For studies evaluating interventions exclusively in patients with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases, baseline characteristics of study participants are provided by treatment group for comparative designs and overall for non-comparative studies. For studies with mixed populations (i.e., includes participants with conditions other than recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases), baseline characteristics are provided for the sub-group of participants with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases, and stratified by treatment group for comparative studies.
-
Published in English with a publication date of 1990 forward.
-
Patients with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases.
-
Fully-published peer-reviewed primary studies (all study designs for primary data collection included; e.g., RCT, non-randomized trials, cohort studies, case–control studies or case series).
-
Any study evaluating the outcome(s) of WBRT by tumor histopathology (or primary tumor type).
-
Number of study participants with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases >5 per study arm for comparative studies and >5 overall for non-comparative studies.
-
For studies evaluating the outcome(s) of WBRT by histopathology (or primary tumor type) exclusively in patients with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases, baseline characteristics are presented and stratified by histologic/primary tumor group. For studies with mixed populations (i.e., includes participants with conditions other than recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases), baseline characteristics are presented and stratified by histologic/primary tumor group for the sub-group of participants with recurrent and/or progressive brain metastases.
Study selection and quality assessment
Evidence classification and recommendation levels
Guideline development process
Scientific foundation
First author (Year) | Study design/evidence class | Intervention (# pts) | Population/previous treatment | Median survival | # Pts with recurrence/progression after retreatmenta
| Median time to recurrence/progression after retreatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cooper [5] (1990) | Case series | WBRT (n = 52) | Recurrent/progressive BM | Median: NR | NR | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Mean survival: 22.4 weeks | ||||||
Initial treatment: WBRT | ||||||
Sadikov [6] (2007) | Case series | WBRT (n = 72) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 4.1 months | NR | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial treatment: WBRT | ||||||
Wong [7] (1997) | Case series | WBRT (n = 86) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 4.0 months | NR | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial treatment: WBRT |
First author (Year) | Study design/evidence class | Intervention (# pts) | Population/previous treatment | Median survival | # Pts with recurrence/progression after retreatmenta
| Median time to recurrence/progression after retreatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arbit [8] (1995) | Case series | Surgery (n = 32) | Recurrent BM from NSCLC | 10 months | NR | NR |
Evidence class III | Initial treatment included surgical resection | |||||
Bindal [9] (1995) | Case series | Surgery (n = 48) | Recurrent BM | 11.5 months | At original site only: 18/48 (38%) | Overall in brain: 7.7 months |
Initial treatment: surgical resection ± WBRT | ||||||
Evidence class III | At distant brain site only: 3/48 (6%) | |||||
At original + distant sites: 5/48 (10%) | ||||||
Overall in brain: 26/48 (54%) | ||||||
Truong [10] (2006) | Case series | Surgery (n = 32) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 8.9 months | At original site: 9/32 (28%) | At original site: 6.2 months |
Evidence class III | BM had been previously treated with SRS (either as initial or salvage treatment) | |||||
Vecil[11] (2005) | Case series | Surgery (n = 61) | Recurrent/progressive ≤3 BM | 11.1 months | At original site only: 4/61 (7%) | Overall in brain: 5 months |
Evidence class III | At distant brain site only: 19/61 (31%) | At distant sites in brain: 8.4 months | ||||
Initial treatment: SRS | ||||||
At original + distant sites: 9/61 (15%) | At original site: Median: could not be estimated |
First author (Year) | Study design/evidence class | Intervention (# pts) | Population/previous treatment | Median survival | # Pts with recurrence/progression after retreatmenta
| Median time to recurrence/progression after retreatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Akyurek [12] (2007) | Case series | SRS (n = 15) | Recurrent/progressive BM from breast cancer | 14 months | At original site: 1 year local | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Control rate: 77% | ||||||
At distant brain sites: 1 year distant control rate: 57% | ||||||
Initial BM treatment: WBRT | ||||||
Chen [13] (2000) | Case series | SRS (n = 45) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 28 weeks | Local control (by lesion for 84% of lesions with data): 90% | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included SRS ± WBRT | ||||||
1 year freedom from tumor progression: 94% | ||||||
Combs [14] (2004) | Case series [For the recurrent group (G3) only] | SRS for recurrent BM (n = 39) | Recurrent/progressive BM from breast cancer | 19 months | NR | At original sites: 9 months |
At distant brain sites: 7 months | ||||||
Evidence class III | Initial BM treatment: WBRT | |||||
Davey [15] (2007) | Retrospective cohort study with historical controls | G1: SRS (n = 35) | Recurrent/progressive BM | G1: 16 weeks | NR | NR |
G2: Fractionated SRS (2 fractions) (n = 69) | G2: 30 weeks (Survival curves: log-normal; univariate p = 0.0155) | |||||
Initial BM treatment included WBRT | ||||||
Evidence class III | ||||||
Davey [16] (1994) | Prospective single arm phase I/II trial | SRS (n = 12 pts) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 6 months | # pts with local recurrence: 9/12 (75%) | NR |
Initial BM treatment: WBRT | Radiological response at 4 weeks (by lesion): Complete response 3/19 (16%) | |||||
Evidence class III | ||||||
Partial response 6/19 (32%) | ||||||
No change 10/19 (53%) | ||||||
Progression 0/19 | ||||||
Hoffman [17] (2001) | Case series [For the recurrent group (G3) only] | SRS for recurrent BM (n = 53) | Recurrent/progressive BM from lung cancer | 10.0 months | 1 year freedom from LR rate: 36% | At original site: 9.2 months |
At distant site: 16.5 months | ||||||
1 year freedom from DR rate: 55% | ||||||
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment: WBRT | ||||||
Overall in brain: 5.8 months | ||||||
1 year freedom from any intracranial recurrence: 27% | ||||||
Kwon [18] (2007) | Case series | SRS (n = 43) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 32 weeks | 6 month local control rate: 91% | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included SRS | 6 month overall brain control rate: 86% | |||||
Loeffler [19] (1990) | Case series | SRS (n = 18) | Recurrent/progressive BM | NR | At original site: # of lesions that decreased or stabilized: 21/21 (100%) | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment: WBRT ± surgery (except in 1 pt who refused WBRT) | ||||||
Noel [20] (2003) | Case series [For the recurrent group (G3) only] | SRS for recurrent group(n = 36) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 8 months | 1 year local control rate: 86% | Overall in brain: Median: not reached |
Initial BM treatment: WBRT | ||||||
Evidence class III | ||||||
Noel [21] (2001) | Case series | SRS (n = 54) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 7.8 months | 1 year local control rate (by lesion): 91% | Median time to development of new BM or leptomeningeal carcinomatosis: 24.5 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment: WBRT | 1 year overall brain control rate: 65% | |||||
Sheehan [22] (2005) | Case series | SRS (n = 27) | Recurrent/progressive BM from SCLC | 4.5 months | Local tumor control (Of 21 lesions in 14 pts with data): 17/21 (81%) lesions; 12/14 (86%) pts | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included WBRT | ||||||
Shuto [23] (2004) | Case series | SRS (n = 16) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 22.4 months (from 1st SRS treatment) | Tumor response:[Of 173/242 (72%) lesions with data]: Complete response 121/173 (70%) | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included SRS | ||||||
Partial response or no change 47/173 (27%) | ||||||
Progression 5/173 (3%) | ||||||
Yamanaka [24] (1999) | Case series | SRS (n = 41) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 15 months (from first SRS treatment) | Overall local control rate after 2nd SRS (by lesion): 93% | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included SRS | ||||||
Response after 2nd SRS [Of 61 lesions evaluable]: Disappeared 16/61 (26%) | ||||||
Decreased 40/61 (66%) | ||||||
Unchanged 1/61 (2%) | ||||||
Increased 4/61 (7%) |
First author (Year) | Study design/evidence class | Intervention (# pts) | Population/previous treatment | Median survival | # Pts with recurrence/progression after retreatmenta
| Median time to recurrence/progression after retreatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abrey [25] (2001) | Prospective single arm phase II trial | TMZ (n = 41) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 6.6 months | Response in brain: Complete response 0/41 (0%) | Overall in brain: 1.97 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment varied (all received WBRT ± other modalities) | ||||||
Partial response 2/41 (5%) | ||||||
Stable disease 15/41 (37%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 17/41 (42%) | ||||||
Not assessed 7/41 (17%) | ||||||
Bröcker [26] (1996) | Prospective single arm study | WBRT + fotemustine (n = 13) | Progressive multiple BM from melanoma | Overall: Not reported | Response in brain: (12 evaluable pts) | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Pts with partial response/stable disease: 6 months | Complete response: 0/13 (0%) | |||||
Partial response 4/13 (31%) | ||||||
Stable disease 3/13 (23%) | ||||||
Other pts: 2 months | ||||||
Progressive disease 6/13 (46%) | ||||||
Not assessable: 1/13 (8%) | ||||||
Christodoulou [27] (2005) | Prospective single arm phase II trial | TMZ + cisplatin (n = 32) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 5.5 months | Response both in brain + extra-cranial sites: Complete response 1/32 (3%) | Median time to progression for all pts: 2.9 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Partial response 8/32 (25%) | ||||||
Partial response in brain only 1/32 (3%) | ||||||
Stable disease 5/32 (16%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 6/32 (19%) | ||||||
Not evaluable 11/32 (34%) | ||||||
Feun [28] (1990) | Case series | Intracarotid cisplatin-based chemotherapy (n = 23) | Recurrent/progressive BM from melanoma | Median: Not reported | Objective improvement by CT scan 7/23 (30%) | Median time to progression in responding pts: 20 weeks |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Range: 1 to 65 weeks | ||||||
Initial BM treatment included WBRT in 22/23 pts | Stable disease 3/23 (13%) | |||||
Failed to respond 13/23 (57%) | ||||||
Giorgio [29] (2005) | Prospective single arm phase II trial | TMZ (n = 30) | Recurrent or progressive BM from NSCLC | 6 months | Response in brain: Complete response 2/30 (7%) | Median time to progression of brain metastases in all pts: 3.6 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Previous BM treatment: WBRT and chemotherapy for BM | ||||||
Partial response 1/30 (3%) | ||||||
Stable disease 3/30 (10%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 24/30 (80%) | ||||||
Groen [30] (1993) | Prospective single arm study | Carboplatin (n = 20) | Recurrent/progressive BM from SCLC | 15 weeks | Response in brain: Complete response 2/20 (10%) | Median duration of response: 8 weeks |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM with teniposide, reinduction combination chemotherapy or cranial irradiation | ||||||
Partial response 6/20 (30%) | ||||||
Stable disease 4/20 (20%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 4/20 (20%) | ||||||
Clinically determined progressive disease 4/20 (20%) | ||||||
Hwu [31] (2005) | Prospective single arm phase II trial | TMZ + thalidomide (n = 26) | Recurrent/progressive BM from melanoma | 5 months | Response in brain: Complete response 2/26 (8%) | Median duration of response or stable disease in brain: 4 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment varied | ||||||
Chemotherapy-naive patients | Partial response 1/26 (4%) | |||||
Minor response/stable: 7/26 (27%) | ||||||
Progressive disease: 4/26 (15%) | ||||||
Unknown 1/26 (4%) | ||||||
Not assessable 11/26 (42%) | ||||||
Iwamoto [32] (2008) | Prospective single arm phase II study | TMZ + vinorelbine (n = 38) | Recurrent/refractory BM | 5 months | Response in brain: Objective response 5% (CR 1/38; minor response 1/38) | Median progression free survival: 1.9 months |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment varied | ||||||
Stable disease 5/38 (13%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 29/38 (76%) | ||||||
Not evaluable 2/38 (5%) | ||||||
Kaba [33] (1997) | Prospective single arm study | TPDC-FuHu (n = 97 assessable/115 enrolled) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 25 weeks | Response in brain: Complete response 4/97 (4%) | Median time to progression for all pts: 12 weeks |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment: surgery and/or radiation therapy | ||||||
Partial response 14/97 (14%) | ||||||
Minor response 9/97 (9%) | ||||||
Stable disease 25/97 (26%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 45/97 (46%) | ||||||
Omuro [34] (2006) | Prospective single arm phase I trial | TMZ + vinorelbine (n = 21) | Recurrent/progressive BM | 17 weeks | Response in brain: (Of 18 evaluable pts) | NR |
Evidence class III | ||||||
Initial BM treatment varied | ||||||
Partial response 1/18 (6%) | ||||||
Minor response 1/18 (6%) | ||||||
Stable disease 6/18 (33%) | ||||||
Progressive disease 10/18 (56%) |