nach oben

Journal of Medicine and the Person

Erschienen in:

01.12.2014 | Original Article

Pediatric euthanasia in Belgium: some ethical considerations

verfasst von: Francesca Giglio, Antonio G. Spagnolo

Erschienen in: Journal of Medicine and the Person | Ausgabe 3/2014

Einloggen, um Zugang zu erhalten

Abstract

On February 2014, the Belgian Parliament approved the first law on children euthanasia stating that also young children can make the autonomous choice to have their lives terminated. This article reviews the ethical objections to the law. These include the impossibility to gauge the competence of children and their vulnerability, and the fact that euthanasia itself implies that some lives are not worthy of living. The denial of life as a “bonum onticum” reneges the very principles on which civil laws and medical ethics are founded.

Even though the law does not ratify a right to die but only decriminalizes euthanasia, de facto medical service is supplied that patients can require legitimately, establishing, therefore, an obligation by the society.

There is a difference between a “logical” version and an “empirical” version of the slippery slope argument. The first version is not valid in a logical moral reasoning: the abuse of a right principle cannot determine the unlawfulness of the same principle. We use the slippery slope argument only in the empirical or psycho-social version.

This is the meaning of decriminalize euthanasia and not ratify a right to die.

The Belgian Act on Euthanasia of May 28^th, 2002, Ch 1, Section 2

Chambre des Représentants de Belgique. Project de Loi modifiant la loi du 28 mai 2002 relative à l’euthanasie en vue de létendre aux mineurs. Art. 2

Termination of Life on Request and assisted Suicide (Review procedures) Act, Nederlands, April 1th 2001, Ch. 1, Session 1

Dan B, Fonteyne C, de Cl, d SC (2014) Self-requested euthanasia for children in Belgium. Lancet 383(9918):671–672PubMedCrossRef

Pousset G, Mortier F, Bilsen J, Cohen J, Deliens L (2011) Attitudes and practices of physicians regarding physician-assisted dying in minors. Arch Dis Child 96(10):948–953PubMedCrossRef

Pediatricians’ Open Letter to all Belgian Political Party Presidents. http://www.euthanasiestop.be/article-en/pediatricians-open-letter-to-all-belgian-political-party-presidents-292. Accessed 17 Sept 2014

Friedel M (2014) Does the Belgian law legalizing euthanasia for minors really address the need of life-limited children? International Journal of Palliative Nursing 20(6):265–267PubMedCrossRef

European Association for Palliative Care (2011) Palliative Care Development in Countries with a Euthanasia Law. http://bit.ly/1lcAYV8. Accessed 17 Sept 2014

von Lützau P, Otto M, Hechler T et al (2012) Children dying from cancer: parents’ perspectives on symptoms, quality of life, characteristics of death, and end-of-life decisions. J Palliat Care 28(4):274

10.

Mendelson D (2014) Minor’s decision making capacity to refuse life-saving and life-sustaining treatment: legal and psychiatric perspectives. J Law Med 21(4):762–773PubMed

11.

Siegel AM, Sisti DA, Caplan AL (2014) Pediatric Euthanasia in Belgium. Disturbing Developments. JAMA 311(19):1963–1964CrossRef

12.

Sgreccia E (2012) Personalist Bioethics: Foundations and Applications. National Catholic Bioethics Center, 1th ed

13.

Spagnolo AG (2008) Quality of life and ethical decisions in medical practice. J Med Person 6(3):118–122

14.

Shannon TA, Walter JJ (2007) The PVS patient and the forgoing/withdrawing of medical nutrition and Hydration. In: Hamel RP, Walters JJ (eds) Artificial nutrition and hydration and the permanently unconscious patient. Georgetown University Press, Washington D.C., pp 143–170

15.

Balducci L (2012) Interview with Kathy Foley. J Med Person 3:126–128CrossRef

16.

Hoven AD (2014) State mandates for physician participation in capital punishment violates medical ethics. http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/news/news/2014/2014-05-02-state-mandates-capital-punishment.page

17.

Spagnolo AG (2008) Deliberate termination of life of newborns with spina bifida. Childs Nerv Syst 24:37–38CrossRef

18.

Special Supplement. The Goals of Medicine: Setting New Priorities. The Hastings Center Report 1996; 26 (Suppl) (6): 1-27

19.

Van der Burg W (1991) The Slippery Slope Argument. Ethics 102(1):42–65CrossRef

20.

European Institute of Bioethics (2012) Euthanasia in Belgium: 10 years on. Dossier. http://www.ieb-eib.org/fr/pdf/20121208-dossier-euthanasia-in-belgium-10-years.pdf. Accessed 20 July 2014

21.

Vincent JL, Schetz M, De Waele JJ et al (2014) “Piece” of mind: end of life in the intensive care unit. Statement of the Belgian Society of Intensive Care Medicine. J Crit Care 29(1):174–175PubMedCrossRef

22.

International Children’s Palliative Care Network (2014) Euthanasia is not part of palliative care. Declaration at the end of ICPCN Conference. Mumbai, India 10-12 February. http://www.icpcn.org/icpcn-mumbai-declaration-2014/. Accessed 20 July 2014

23.

Montero E (2013) Cita con la muerte. 10 aňos de eutanasia legal in Bélgica. Madrid, Rialp

Titel: Pediatric euthanasia in Belgium: some ethical considerations
verfasst von: Francesca Giglio
Antonio G. Spagnolo
Publikationsdatum: 01.12.2014
Verlag: Springer Milan
Erschienen in: Journal of Medicine and the Person / Ausgabe 3/2014
Print ISSN: 2035-9411
Elektronische ISSN: 2036-3877
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12682-014-0189-y

Springer Medizin

Abstract

Bitte loggen Sie sich ein, um Zugang zu diesem Inhalt zu erhalten

Weitere Artikel der Ausgabe 3/2014

A penile prosthesis for a sex offender

Trisomy 21: research for a cure and rediscovery of the thought of Jérôme Lejeune

Practice guidelines that may kill

We are all angels: acting, reclaiming and moving beyond survivorship

Recipe for cancer education: a novel integrated cooking and nutrition education curriculum for medical students and physicians in dietary preventive and supplemental treatment for pancreatic cancer

Complicated and complex: the management of older cancer patients, a frame of reference to approach clinical complexity