Introduction
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a slowly progressive destructive lung disease induced primarily by cigarette smoking in developed countries [
1]. Although COPD is associated with significant abnormalities in local immunity, the precise roles of inflammation, and the distinct roles of innate and acquired immune cells in the pathogenesis of COPD remain incompletely characterized [
2]. Among the immune cell types infiltrating the COPD airways, the extent of CD8 T cell, and small airway dendritic cell infiltration correlate with COPD severity as determined by lung function testing, suggesting that these immune cells play important roles in the pathogenesis [
3].
Dendritic cells are rare but critical immune cells that are distributed in sub-epithelial, interstitial and pleural compartments, where they usually exist as immature antigen presenting cells [
4]. At least three major phenotypic and functional subsets have been described; classic or conventional myeloid dendritic cells, epithelial-associated CD1a positive dendritic cells (analogous to epithelial associated Langerhans cells in the skin), and plasmacytoid dendritic cells [
4,
5]. The effect of smoking on dendritic cell profusion and activation in COPD is somewhat controversial with recent studies showing conflicting findings [
3,
6,
7]. Demedts and colleagues reported that the accumulation of CD207-positive dendritic cells (Langerhans cells) in the epithelium and adventitia of small airways in COPD was greater than that occurring in never-smokers or smokers without COPD [
3]. Demedts et al also reported that the number of Langerhans cells in the small airways of COPD patients increase in proportion with disease severity, suggesting that these abnormally accumulated Langerhans cells may directly participate in the pathogenesis of COPD [
3]. In contrast, another study reported no difference in the numbers of Langerhans cells in the airway biopsies of smokers with COPD when compared to ex-smokers or non-smokers without COPD [
6].
The current study was designed to determine whether COPD is associated with increased numbers of Langerhans-type dendritic cells (defined by surface expression of CD1a, or the presence of transcripts for the Langerhans cell restricted gene CD207), or matured dendritic cells (defined by surface CD83 expression), utilizing human COPD lung tissue procured through the Lung Tissue Research Consortium (LTRC). In addition, complimentary studies were conducted using relevant in vitro human and in vivo murine models to determine mechanisms by which cigarette smoke constituents promote dendritic cell persistence in the lung. Specifically, we sought to determine whether cigarette smoke promotes dendritic cell retention in the lung by promoting dendritic cell survival. In addition, we sought to determine the effect of cigarette smoke constituents on key migratory chemokine expression and migratory capacity of dendritic cells.
Discussion
Recent studies have demonstrated abnormalities in adaptive immunity against specific antigens in COPD patients [
26], and rekindled interest in the role of autoimmunity as a central mechanism in the pathogenesis of COPD [
2]. Relatively little is know about the roles of dendritic cells in the pathogenesis of cigarette smoke-induced COPD. In the current study we utilized human COPD tissue specimens and other experimental models to provide evidence consistent with recently published studies reporting increased dendritic cell numbers in COPD [
3]. We expand the observations reported in that study by showing that COPD is associated with a significant increase in the total number of CD83+ dendritic cells. We demonstrate that COPD lung tissue contains increased levels of the Langerhans cell restricted gene CD207, and that there is correlation between osteopontin and CD207 gene levels. The current study shows that CSE and cigarette smoke enhance human and murine dendritic cell survival respectively, and that CSE induces endogenous dendritic cell pro-survival factors. This study also shows that although activated dendritic cells conditioned with CSE have diminished migratory CCR7 expression - an effect induced by oxidative constituents in CSE - migration of CSE-conditioned activated dendritic cells towards the CCR7 ligand CCL21 is not impaired, implying that retention of activated dendritic cells due to impaired CCR7-dependent migration is unlikely to be an important mechanism for the increased dendritic cell numbers in COPD.
Virtually all lung compartments (conducting airways, interstitial and alveolar spaces, vascular structures, and pleura) contain dendritic cells [
4]. Whereas, in mice, the integrin CD11c is a reasonable marker to identify murine dendritic cells, human lung dendritic cells are more challenging to characterize [
4,
27]. The trachea and large conducting airways have a well-developed network of intraepithelial dendritic cells which share many properties with skin Langerhans' cells, and express intracellular CD207 and surface CD1a [
4]. Although some studies have suggested that cigarette smoke exposure is associated with a reduction in murine lung conventional dendritic cell populations [
28,
29], the majority of studies (including our own [
30]) report expansion of murine lung dendritic cell numbers following chronic (generally defined as 4 weeks or greater) cigarette smoke exposure [
30‐
35]. Increased numbers of lung dendritic cells were also reported to occur in SCID mice exposed to chronic cigarette smoke exposure [
36]. Cigarette smoke also increases the number of lung dendritic cells following allergen challenge in murine lungs [
31]. The current study provides additional evidence that COPD is associated with increased numbers of matured dendritic cells identifiable by the marker CD83. Our data are consistent with a recent report by Freeman et al, in which CD80 and CD83 expression on isolated lung dendritic cells were reported to increase with severity of COPD [
37]. A limitation of the current study is a lack of a non-smoking group as a control, as all patients from whom lung tissue was procured where either current or former smokers at the time of lung biopsy. Nevertheless, the current study shows that in smokers (either current or former) with COPD, increased numbers of CD83+ cells and CD207 mRNA occurs, which cannot be explained simply by chronic exposure to tobacco since the cumulative exposure to tobacco in the two groups was not different. Another limitation of our study is that is does not definitively show that COPD is associated with increased numbers of either Langerhans type dendritic cells or matured myeloid dendritic cells, as it may be argued that an alternative explanation to our findings is that COPD is associated with altered expression of these receptors or dendritic cell markers, rather than an increase in the respective dendritic cell populations
per se.
It is well recognized that cigarette smoke modulates immunity by altering the function of several immune cells, including dendritic cells [
11,
25,
30,
33,
38]. Cigarette smoke constituents known to having immune altering effects include nicotine [
39‐
43], carbon monoxide [
44], acrolein [
45], reactive oxidant species [
46], peroxynitrites [
47], and possibly others. In the current study we did not identify a specific cigarette smoke constituent responsible for altered dendritic cell viability or induction of pro-survival cellular proteins. The current study implicates reactive oxidative species [
47,
48], a term which broadly refers to a wide collection of chemicals present in cigarette smoke that have the capacity to increase cellular oxidative stress. In addition to oxidative stress, other cigarette smoke constituents may also be responsible for altered dendritic cell viability and retention in COPD. Although our data suggests that nicotine is not primarily responsible for enhanced dendritic cell survival
in vitro, or augmentation of dendritic cell survival proteins, it does not completely rule out the possibility that nicotine may have additive or synergistic effects with other chemicals in cigarette smoke (including those that induce cellular oxidative stress) that may have a significant effect on dendritic cell survival and retention in the COPD lung.
Our findings differ with a recent report that showed a reduction in CD83+ dendritic cells in COPD tissues compared to controls [
6]. In that study, mature dendritic cells defined as CD83+ cells, were identified by immunohistochemistry on 41 lung tissue samples from individuals with COPD [
6]. In contrast to the findings described in the current report, those authors observed fewer numbers of CD83+ cells in the small airways of COPD tissue compared with control smokers without COPD and non-smoker controls [
6]. The reasons for the discrepant findings are not clear. In the study by Tsoumakidou et al [
6], all subjects had primary lung carcinoma. In the current study, 20 out of the 24 subjects (5 of the 8 controls and 17 of the 18 COPD samples) used in the immunohistochemical determination of CD83 had a diagnosis of either non-small cell (15) or small cell carcinoma (5). Although cancer itself is known to be associated with reduced numbers of mature dendritic cells, this is not likely to have been a source of bias, since our study showed greater CD83 staining in COPD tissue (virtually all of which had coexistent lung carcinoma) compared to controls. Another potential source of bias in our study is the lack of information regarding corticosteroid therapy in COPD patients included in the current analysis. However, this is highly unlikely to have significantly altered the conclusions of the study, since corticosteroid therapy has been associated with a reduction - rather than an increase - in a number of dendritic cells functions, including maturation [
49‐
51].
The mechanisms by which smoking promotes dendritic cell recruitment or retention in the lung are not fully elucidated. The current study demonstrates that cigarette smoke components activate endogenous dendritic cell survival pathways. In this report, we focused on two key intermediary molecules that have previously been reported to have important roles in protecting cells from death by apoptosis [
19]. We used an
in vitro approach with CSE as a stimulant to determine whether cigarette smoke induces pro-survival factors in dendritic cells. This approach was utilized in favor of direct determination of protein levels in lung tissue dendritic cells. Dendritic cells are a rare population of cells, and quantitative determination of cellular protein levels in human lung tissue is extremely difficult to accomplish. Bcl-xL is a member of the Bcl-2 family of apoptosis regulators that control apoptotic cellular response to oxidants and other stressors [
20,
21]. Heme-oxygenase-1 is a cellular stress response protein shown to be induced by a variety of cellular stressors including cigarette smoke [
52‐
55]. Incubation of human dendritic cells with CSE resulted in induction of HO-1 and Bcl-xL protein levels, and suggests that induction of pro-survival factors by CSE may be an important mechanism by which CSE promotes dendritic cell survival
in vitro. Our data do not provide direct evidence that CSE-induced HO-1 or Bcl-xL promote dendritic cell survival. This proved impossible to test, as many of the techniques used to abrogate upregulation of these proteins (including siRNA or pharmacologic inhibitors), also resulted in diminished cellular survival due to cell toxicity or other non-specific effects.
Abnormalities in chemokine expression may also be responsible for excessive influx and delayed trafficking of dendritic cells. Demedts and colleagues identified CCR6 expression on dendritic cells and elevated CCL20 levels in sputum samples from COPD patients suggesting a potential interaction between dendritic cell CCR6 and epithelial CCL20 expression as a potential mechanism explaining the enhanced Langerhans cell numbers seen in COPD patients in their study [
3]. Concordant with that observation, Brattke and colleagues showed that myeloid dendritic cells obtained by BAL from smokers expressed lower levels of surface CCR7, a chemokine receptor expressed by activated dendritic cells and required for migration out of the lung and homing to lymph nodes [
25]. Those studies suggest the possibility that enhanced dendritic cell retention occurs in COPD due to epithelial-dendritic cell interactions and endogenous abnormalities in dendritic cell chemokine receptor expression. Our findings expand on those observations. We demonstrate that relative osteopontin gene transcript levels correlate highly with CD207 gene levels. Osteopontin is a secreted phosphoprotein potently induced in epithelial cells by CSE [
13], that regulates a variety of dendritic cell functions ranging from survival, maturation, and migration. While our data does not prove any direct association between induction of the osteopontin gene and dendritic cell infiltration in COPD, it does indicate parallel induction of the osteopontin and CD207 genes occurs in smokers with COPD, and suggests the possibility that cigarette smoke-induced osteopontin levels in the lung may be involved in recruitment or formation of Langerhans type dendritic cells in smokers with COPD. In support of this contention is a recent study that reported an increase in pulmonary Langerhans cells and macrophages in murine lungs that over-expressed osteopontin following delivery of the human osteopontin gene by an adenoviral vector [
16]. In the current report we also sought to determine whether the reduced CCR7 expression described to occur in human dendritic cells isolated by BAL from smokers [
25], or observed in human dendritic cells conditioned by CSE
in vitro [
11], is associated with reduced migration. We initially hypothesized that CSE-conditioned dendritic cells would have diminished migration towards a CCR7 ligand. The current report demonstrates that although CSE suppresses CCR7 expression
in vitro, there is no limitation in dendritic cell migration towards CCR7 ligands. Although contrary to our original hypothesis, this data is consistent with the report by Robbins et al that found no difference in the migration of ovalbumin-loaded lung dendritic cells - achieved by intra-tracheal delivery of FITC-tagged ovalbumin - to the regional lymph nodes in mice chronically exposed to cigarette smoke [
29]. In addition to migration, the CCR7 receptor is responsible for a number of non-migratory dendritic cell functions that may be relevant to COPD pathogenesis. Thus, it is conceivable that although migration towards CCR7 ligands is intact in dendritic cells conditioned by CSE, other CCR7-dependent non-migratory dendritic cell functions in smokers may be significantly altered.
In conclusion, we have used a number of complimentary approaches using human COPD lung tissue, in vitro and in vivo murine models to demonstrate that COPD is associated with increased numbers of cells bearing the CD83 receptor and CD207, and that CSE and cigarette smoke enhance dendritic cell survival. Enhanced osteopontin levels and augmented dendritic cell pro-survival factors are potential mechanisms that mediate the increased dendritic cell numbers. Our data do not support reduced emigration due to suppressed CCR7 expression as a mechanism for dendritic cell retention in the lungs of smokers. Elucidating the roles of dendritic cells in COPD will be essential in the quest for understanding the pathogenesis and ultimately therapy of this frustrating disease.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
RV obtained funding for experiments on murine and human dendritic cells, conducted experiments, analyzed data, generated figures, and wrote the manuscript. PRW designed and performed the murine and human dendritic cell experiments; collected and analyzed data. JL conducted all the experiments using human COPD tissue. TJK performed the PCR experiments described. ESY assisted with morphologic interpretation and immunohistochemical analysis. AHL obtaining funding for immunohistochemical tissue analysis, provided input on data analysis and interpretation, and helped prepare the final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.